federal reserve conspiracy!!!

Uhh, no they don't. The Fed is not a for profit organization. It is regulated by Congress. Any money they make in excess of their expenses is paid by to the Treasury, last year it was something like $29 billion. The Fed also does not "create" money. All they do is buy up and sell treasuries (which they are not responsible for creating in the first place) to keep the money supply in check. The Fed also does not print currency, the treasury does.

But other than being factually incorrect on every count, I have no problem with your post.

Part of the Feds expenses is 6% interest on all member deposits payed the the member banks. Not for profit, my batooti.

In order to increase the money supply, the Fed creates money to buy treasury bonds the money is allocated to the member accounts and then used to make the purchase. Alternatively, the newly allocated funds can be used in open market operations.

I never said the Fed prints money.

Go read something reliable about the Federal Reserve System and get back to me.
 
Part of the Feds expenses is 6% interest on all member deposits payed the the member banks. Not for profit, my batooti.

In order to increase the money supply, the Fed creates money to buy treasury bonds the money is allocated to the member accounts and then used to make the purchase. Alternatively, the newly allocated funds can be used in open market operations.

I never said the Fed prints money.

Go read something reliable about the Federal Reserve System and get back to me.

Yes... if people put money in the bank, they are entitled to some recompense. That's called a savings account.

Otherwise regarding profit: all of the profit from the Fed goes directly into the US treasury.

Also, again, though these people have stock (not talking about deposits here), they don't have the same control over the Fed that a commercial stockholder does.

And, what, since you've studied the Fed, are the other ways in which the Fed increases the money supply?

Why is it that people act like inflation never happened pre Fed Reserve?
 
Max Photon recommends: Antal Fekete > The 10 Pillars of Sound Money

---

OahuOahu,

For years I have been a student of synthetic currency, and the cloaking of the 1971 US default on its international gold obligations (a declaration of insolvency).

IMHO, you can do no better on the subject than the works of Antal E. Fekete

I recommend starting with the awesome short series:

The 10 Pillars of Sound Money

Here is the link to the webpage that has the links to the series.

http://www.shoemakerconsulting.com/GoldisFreedom/default.htm

(If you click on individual articles, and then look at the very bottom left, there is a button that shows the article with white background / black text - much easier to read.)

Here is a link to the first in the series:

http://www.shoemakerconsulting.com/GoldisFreedom/PVFfiles/firstpillarpvf.htm

Give his work a chance, and you are in for some serious clarity.

(He's also fun to read.)

Regards,

Max

---
 
---

OahuOahu,

For years I have been a student of synthetic currency, and the cloaking of the 1971 US default on its international gold obligations (a declaration of insolvency).

IMHO, you can do no better on the subject than the works of Antal E. Fekete

I recommend starting with the awesome short series:

The 10 Pillars of Sound Money

Here is the link to the webpage that has the links to the series.

http://www.shoemakerconsulting.com/GoldisFreedom/default.htm

(If you click on individual articles, and then look at the very bottom left, there is a button that shows the article with white background / black text - much easier to read.)

Here is a link to the first in the series:

http://www.shoemakerconsulting.com/GoldisFreedom/PVFfiles/firstpillarpvf.htm

Give his work a chance, and you are in for some serious clarity.

(He's also fun to read.)

Regards,

Max

---

Do you wear a superhero suit when you surf the net?
 
I think that most CT's see money and wealth as a static item and that there is only so much money in the world. Thus they reason that if someone else has a heap of money and they don't, then this is unfair and they the other person has their share. They don't seem to understand that money is expansionary and that by going and getting a job and working hard, one can make money quite successfully. Of course they could also try swiddling their fellow CT's, I hear that works pretty well.....
 
Yeah, but inflation is just not the same without bank panics, rare metal shortages, and coin recalls.

Ah, the good old days. Remember It's a Wonderful Life? Bank runs can lead to angel wings.


And by the way, that whole kookbreaker's day thread with the xmas bit? Still laugh at the thought of that months later.
 
Ah, the good old days. Remember It's a Wonderful Life? Bank runs can lead to angel wings.


And by the way, that whole kookbreaker's day thread with the xmas bit? Still laugh at the thought of that months later.

My humor is subtle, subversive and lasting. Like a five wheeled biodesiel Honda. :P

Glad you liked it. :)
 
Hi Abby.

Abby and I had an email conversation about economics. Abby is indoctrinated in the mainstream Neo Keynesian money multiplier nonsense that has so utterly failed to explain or predict anything.

I'll remind everyone that in the 1920's, when the price levels were stable, and the US economy was booming, it was Mises and Hayek who explained why this was a time of great inflation (Rapid money creation with the brand new Central Bank). Using Mises' "Theory of Money and Credit", they deduced the "Austrian Business Cycle Theory". They said that the artificially low interest rate was causing investors to over-invest in capital goods industries, and under-invest in consumer goods industries. Consumers were demanding more consumer goods, but the distorted price signals were causing investors to "mal-invest". The economy was being pulled in two directions at once. Mises and Hayed predicted the great depression. Repeatedly. For a couple of years straight.

Austrian Business Cycle Theory is correct. I invite you all to learn it, it's actually quite straightforward, and has tremendous explanatory power.

Fiat money is theft. I notice that nobody has even attempted to disagree with my explanation, which is taken directly from Mises, Rothbard, Riesmann, Hoppe, et al. Wealth is transferred from late receivers of new money, to early receivers of new money, and most of all to the monopolistic creators of new money.

The Fed and the Treasury are a partnership, they act in concert. Central banking is a government operation in every sense of the word. It is allowed to appear "private" on paper, so that there is a justification for its total secrecy.

We often refer to the "printing" of new money, without literally meaning printing currency. New money is created out of thin air by the issuance of new debt. The government creates an IOU called a treasury bond, which is purchased by the Fed with a check drawn on the Federal Reserve. The government can then write its own checks to buy what it desires, thus diverting resources away from the consumers who otherwise would have enjoyed them. These government checks end up in commercial banks, who then count that as additional reserves. For every checkbook dollar in additional reserves, the commercial bank can make six dollars in new loans. The money supply is now larger.

The real world methodology is complex, but the economic analysis really is the same if we imagine that the executive branch of the government has a printing press and simply prints bills of any denomination and spends them at will. It is theft. Theft is immoral. Thieves are bad guys. They should be stopped from thieving, and punished.
 
Last edited:
TruthSeeker1234 in your analogy you assume that the entity holding the monopoly power over money creation takes active part in the economy, that is: buys goods and services with the money being issued. In the real world economists advocate for an independent central bank (the Federal Reserve and Chile's Central Bank are good examples) with the very purpose of avoiding the analogy you are trying to make.

By the way, can you please point to Von Mises' argument against fiat money?

Absurd. The whole purpose of creating money is to spend it.

Here is a great paper on the Austrian theory of money, and includes Mises' regression analysis.

http://www.mises.org/rothbard/money.pdf
 
OK, so as I understand it, the FR hating nutters want the FR removed becuase it makes money that is not backed by gold. Even though there is nowhere near enough gold to back up the money in circulation today?

Now, their complaint is that money is only of value because we have a faith in it as currency. Wheras gold has value because....its shiny and somewhat rare?

Wrong all the way around. There is plenty of gold, because any money supply is optimal. Prices adjust. The free market will expand the supply of gold as demanded, the same way it expands the supply of anything else. If gold were to somehow become so scarce as to inhibit the function of money, the market would seek substitutes, as it does with any other commodity.

Gold spontaneously became the world standard money because of the market, not because of anyone's personal taste. It turns out that gold has the qualities that make for a well-functioning money. Had you read my article , you would know this now. The qualities are:

high demand
high value to weight ratio
durability
divisibility
interchangeability
 
As I said once before, I once ran for office under the banner of the Alberta Social Credit Party. It's been a long time since I was involved with this stuff, but I'm seeing alot of familiar terms being tossed about.

I'm curious, Ace. Could you explain to me what exactly is the difference. if there is any, between Von Mises theories and those of Clifford Hugh Douglas?
 
@GregoryUrich

Maybe the FR hating nutters want the FR removed because it is privately owned and helps a small number of very wealthy people to maintain their economic hegemony.


Well since you are so sure The Fed is "privately owned" i guess you'll have no difficulties listing the banks for which each of the members of the board of governors work for. The same goes for the chairman.

The Federal Reserve is not privately owned, its member banks are.


The FR charges interest on all loans (including new currency) and has an unfair advantage in other open market operations.


Why does it have an unfair advantage on open markets operations?

When the government needs to borrow money, tax payers end up paying with interest.


You do know that's what it happens with any financial institution, right? Just checking.


The interest ends up in the hands of private corporations which own stock in the FR.


Which private corporations are these?


If the FR purchases securities or other assets, these are bought on the open market except the FR has an unfair advantage because the FR can create money thus devaluing other private competitors assets.


The Fed creates money by purchasing securities or other assets, not by creating money to buy these financial instruments.


Part of the Feds expenses is 6% interest on all member deposits payed the the member banks. Not for profit, my batooti.


That makes no sense.


In order to increase the money supply, the Fed creates money to buy treasury bonds the money is allocated to the member accounts and then used to make the purchase.

Wrong, as i said earlier The Fed increases the money supply by purchasing financial instruments not by "creating money" to buy these instruments.


Go read something reliable about the Federal Reserve System and get back to me.


After quoting your previous assertion i have the feeling that it is you you has to do a lot of reading on the subject because you are completely clueless and very confused about it.
 
Last edited:
Absurd. The whole purpose of creating money is to spend it.

Sure it is "truthseeker" ... but not by the central bank as you incorrectly assumed in your previous "analysis". And please, can you quote Von Mises' argument rather than pointing to a file and saying "here it is"?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom