federal reserve conspiracy!!!

Another one: he mentions inflation but doesn't discuss unexpected inflation. That's a big problem.
 
I was explaining why gold is a good money, not why gold is valuable. You have attributed to me a statement which I did not make, then used that to accuse me of a logical fallacy. That is itself a logical fallacy on your part. I thought you were smarter/more intellectually honest than this.

All right, as I explained in my edit, I was pointing out that one of your "why gold is a good currency" arguments was circular. You clearly indicate that gold is a good currency because people consider it valuable. You have mentioned that it's primary value is as currency. You are, therefore, claiming gold is valuable because of its use as a currency, and by extension its good qualities as a currency contribute to its value because it is accepted as a currency on the market.

If you're going to claim gold's value is in its use as currency, you cannot separate its value from its function as a good money. The two are one and the same.

The value/weight relationship cannot have meaning without a priori or market value. Your arguments concerned the (as you claim) sudden emergence of gold as a currency standard.

To say that it is valuable as a currency, and was a good choice for currency because of its value/weight ratio is circular.

But that's just distracting from the real issues at hand. Claiming I am intellectually dishonest doesn't make you any more right.

What stops you from using gold as a currency right now? You keep talking about how people should be free, but they are - nothing stops you from buying and selling gold. You could hold all your money in gold, then sell only enough to pay expenses to those who won't accept gold but want, say, US dollars instead.

Also, you claim that any money supply is optimal. In a very base way, this tends to be theoretically true in an ideal, model market. However, this tends not to be the case in the real world. Even when the gold standard existed, there were issues related to the money supply. I already gave one historical example of money supply issues with a gold standard you haven't bothered to reply to yet.
 
our dollars are printed out of thin air. this is such an evil, vast, and dark conspiracy because our currency is not held under any type of gold standard to secure its value and stop inflation.

i know this is a worldwide conspiracy too, because almost every currency in the world is printed out of thin air and doesnät really adhere to some kind of gold stanard or metal standard.

Actually, it's printed from paper and ink.

Dollars are worth what people are willing to pay for them. It's just a very, very sophisticated form of barter.

It's always worked. What's wrong with it ?
 
There are always alternative uses for all commodities. How much milk should be made into cottage cheese, how much into ice cream, how much into butter, how much into yogurt? Only the market can decide this. Similarly, only the market can decide how much gold should be used to back money, and how much should be used for industrial and/or jewelry, etc.

You examples are invalid as they are renewable items. Gold does not strike as having the same development schedule as milk. If you are going to back our money, you have to back it all the way. There's just not enough precious metal in the world.

There are plenty of uses for gold, the most important of which is money.

These days there are plenty of uses. In older days the limit was money and decoration. Now why should modern industries suffer incredible raw materials price increases because we want to revert to an obselete system?

Correct! You have stumbled onto two of the key insights of economics, in one sentence!

1. All economic activity is directed at fulfilling the wants and needs of people.

2. All valuation is subjective.

So why is having our monetary system not based on gold such a bad thing?

A good money must be divisible into very small pieces, with the pieces still being valuable. Also it must be interchangeable, with one unit being the same value as another.

When you say divisible, you mean physically? As in 'Pieces of Eight'?

Sigh. The only way we can determine what sort of money works best is to allow the market to function. Fearing that the market would not supply enough gold is like fearing that it won't supply enough socks. When people demand more, the supply will be made to increase by those people in the business of producing it. Enforcing a monopoly in the production of money is evil, for the same reasons that any other monopoly is evil.

So far I have not seen anything really 'evil' about this alleged marketing, and I have read enough about the old days of metal money economies to know they have limitations that can cripple economies. In addition to other problems (price increases for raw materials i.e.). In short, I have yet to see why this system should be changed in favor of one that has had a very shakey past.
 
Please do post it. But just to make sure. Tell me what is the difference between the money multiplier and the keynesian multiplier.

Sure, Abby.

The Keynesian multiplier effect is the a fictional idea wherein it is claimed that government spending increases real wealth. Government creates fiat money, spends it, and this increases demand in that sector, which attracts investment and creates new jobs. In turn, the new dollars are respent, which again increases demand and employment. The repeated ("multiplied") spending of the new money thus is alleged to increase the production of goods and services.

What Keynes forgot was what Bastiat taught. He forgot to consider that the government spending diverts resources away from where they would have been put to use, had the government spending not occurred. Because of the distorted price signals, the new economic activity must be less efficient than the economic activity that would have taken place otherwise. Thus it must be a net loss in real wealth.


The so-called money multiplier is another fictional construct. The money supply does not only consist of currency, but also of checkbook money, and all sorts of financial instruments, etc. The money multiplier is an attempt to determine the overall supply of money, by multiplying the quantity of currency by some number.

Now your turn. What's wrong with the Austrian explanation of how fiat money is theft?
 
Last edited:
Now your turn. What's wrong with the Austrian explanation of how fiat money is theft?

See my comments above.

The so-called money multiplier is another fictional construct. The money supply does not only consist of currency, but also of checkbook money, and all sorts of financial instruments, etc. The money multiplier is an attempt to determine the overall supply of money, by multiplying the quantity of currency by some number.


No, that is not the money multiplier. Try again. The money multiplier is the amount that the total currency increases due to a specific injection in currency.

The Keynesian multiplier effect is the a fictional idea wherein it is claimed that government spending increases real wealth. Government creates fiat money, spends it, and this increases demand in that sector, which attracts investment and creates new jobs. In turn, the new dollars are respent, which again increases demand and employment. The repeated ("multiplied") spending of the new money thus is alleged to increase the production of goods and services.

Incorrect. In the case of the Keynesian multiplier, any component of the GDP is increased. Not just Government spending. And you are absolutely incorrect about where the funding for spending comes from. It does not come from the Fed. You've got fiscal action and monetary action. The two might work in tandem, but you do not need one for the other. Gov't spending does not necessarily include the increase of the monetary supply. That would defeat the purpose. Look up what is called the IS/LM graph.


Also, I've noticed you discuss a demand/supply for money. That does exist without the gold standard: see money demand, money supply curve. It measures the supply of money vs. the interest rate.


Edit to add: Yes, there have been many criticisms of Keynesian policies. Many from the Monetarism school of thought, which is also taught in standard econ classes. The Monetarists do not throw the baby out with the bathwater as you are doing.
 
Also, there is a poor notion here that inflation in itself is inherantly evil. Look up the Phillip's curve for a refutation of this.

You want no inflation at all? Or unnaturally low inflation? Then welcome high unemployment.
 
@GregoryUrich

No, i'm not the real Greenspan ... the real one is too busy drafting policies for the NWO.

The member banks own all of the stock in the Fed. Member banks are privately owned and sometimes publicly traded.

Owning stock options on The Fed is not the same as owning stock option on a private corporation.

By the way, i asked you a simple question that you chose to ignore: what corporation employs the current board of directors and the chairman of The Fed.

By just saying "see above" you failed to point why exactly you claim The Fed has an unfair advantage on open markets operations.

Newly created money is used by the central bank to buy in the open market a financial asset, such as government bonds, foreign currency, or gold.

There's a problem with this statement, The Fed can only "create" money by buying financial instruments or expanding/contracting the legal reserves ... so saying that it buys certificates so it can buy more certificates is just absurd. Picture this, The Fed wants to expand the money supply by purchasing 1 million in certificates ... you go to a member bank and sell your certificates and receive 1 million US$, money supply has effectively been increased by 1 million but the money is not in the hand of The Fed but rather in the hands of the agents who sold the certificates. Whoever wrote that part of the wikipedia entry should revise his/her monetary policy notes.

Wrong. See above.

Then i guess you can tell me another way for The Fed to expand the money supply other than expanding/contracting the legal reserves or incurring in open market operations.
 
Last edited:
GregoryUrich, the stock that the member banks hold in the Fed cannot be publically traded, it cannot be sold, and it cannot be used as collateral(thus, our own "Alan Greenspan" is quite correct). The idea that the stock is equivalent to normal stock is completely false.

The dividends are fixed, and the rate of return is fairly low by market standards (6% annually is approximately what one would get in a high-yield savings account, and is quite below the average rate of return on stocks, as well as various other investment products).

In case you want a source: http://www.frbsf.org/publications/federalreserve/fedinbrief/organize.html
(right down at the bottom)

If you'd like to know about procedural issues, you can just go to the Fed's web site. All the various codes and laws are a matter of public record, as are its policies and organizational structure. Unless you think the Fed is lying about its own organization on its web site (and all the assorted codes/laws are ignored or lies too), in which case you're perfectly welcome to present the evidence that this is the case.

...snip

Who said it's normal stock? The stock is still privately owned. It's a guaranteed, no-risk return on investment and includes the right to create money (collectively with the other members). Normal stock has risks, but you probably know that.
 
Who said it's normal stock? The stock is still privately owned. It's a guaranteed, no-risk return on investment and includes the right to create money (collectively with the other members). Normal stock has risks, but you probably know that.

You imply that it's normal stock by suggesting that the owners have the ultimate control over how much money is created. That is not the case.
 
TruthSeeker clearly likes gold very much, but I'd still really like to know what he thinks is stopping him from using it as a currency right now.

Gold is bought and sold on the open market, so he can freely buy gold or exchange it for any currency he wants, which can then be exchanged for other goods or exchanged for more gold.

Assuming TruthSeeker draws a salary from somewhere, he is free to buy gold with all the money he makes, then sell small quantities of gold to pay expenses to people who won't accept gold as direct payment.

He might even be able to convince some merchants to accept gold payments directly. They might not all want to, due to the hassle of converting it and storing it, but some might welcome it... perhaps they also feel as strongly about its value as a currency.

So, TS1234, what's stopping you from doing all this? You keep talking about freedom of currency, but what is forcing you to hold or use dollars? At the very worst, you would only need to hold dollars for a couple days in order to pay bills, or before you convert your salary into gold.
 
@GregoryUrich
There's a problem with this statement, The Fed can only "create" money by buying financial instruments or expanding/contracting the legal reserves ... so saying that it buys certificates so it can buy more certificates is just absurd. Picture this, The Fed wants to expand the money supply by purchasing 1 million in certificates ... you go to a member bank and sell your certificates and receive 1 million US$, money supply has effectively been increased by 1 million but the money is not in the hand of The Fed but rather in the hands of the agents who sold the certificates. Whoever wrote that part of the wikipedia entry should revise his/her monetary policy notes.

To increase the money supply, the Fed buy's financial instruments by crediting the sellers reserve account. No account is debited.

From the Fed site:

Purchasing securities or arranging a repurchase agreement increases the quantity of balances because the Federal Reserve creates balances when it credits the account of the seller’s depository institution at the Federal Reserve for the amount of the transaction; there is no corresponding offset in another institution’s account.
 
Who said it's normal stock? The stock is still privately owned. It's a guaranteed, no-risk return on investment and includes the right to create money (collectively with the other members). Normal stock has risks, but you probably know that.

I actually misread what you said here:

The member banks own all of the stock in the Fed. Member banks are privately owned and sometimes publicly traded.

As implying the stock could be de facto publically traded. My apologies if that doesn't reflect how you actually feel about this.

Technically, it isn't no risk, as there is always the risk of catastrophic collapse of the economy, but I know what you mean. Yes, it is an extremely low-risk investment, with returns equivalent to other similarly low-risk investments. It also prevents the members from doing much of what can be done with standard stock, such as selling it at a profit or using it to obtain a loan.

Also, if the bank becomes insolvent, it loses its stock in the Fed, which could very well be considered a risk, albeit a small one:

http://www.federalreserve.gov/generalinfo/fract/sect06.htm

You can, assuming you have enough to open the account, get a high-yield savings account with a bank that will net you around a 6% APR, or you can get a low-risk mutual fund with a similar ROI.

And they may get the right to "create money" in a loose kind of way, but it's hardly unregulated. You wanted a better source for the idea of pledging collateral for currency, IIRC:

http://www.newyorkfed.org/aboutthefed/fedpoint/fed01.html
 
Last edited:
You imply that it's normal stock by suggesting that the owners have the ultimate control over how much money is created. That is not the case.

The twisted spaghetti logic of your perceived implication must go something like this:

The owners of Fed stock can influence the creation of (effectively create) money. Since owners of normal stock can create money, the Fed stock must be normal stock.

I implied nothing. Duh!
 
The twisted spaghetti logic of your perceived implication must go something like this:

The owners of Fed stock can influence the creation of (effectively create) money. Since owners of normal stock can create money, the Fed stock must be normal stock.

I implied nothing. Duh!

No. This was your implication: The owners of stock can influence the money supply, as normal stock owners control the company in which they own stock.

This is not the case with the Fed. The owners of stock in the Fed DO NOT have ultimate control over the money supply, decrease or increase.

Edited to add: Duh. Always a good argument.
 
To increase the money supply, the Fed buy's financial instruments by crediting the sellers reserve account. No account is debited.

You quoted a passage from The Fed's publication The Federal Reserve System: Purposes and Functions, the rest of which reads:

Conversely, selling securities or conducting a reverse repurchase agreement decreases the quantity of Federal Reserve balances because the Federal Reserve extinguishes balances when it debits the account of the purchaser’s depository institution at the Federal Reserve; there is no corresponding increase in another institution’s account. In contrast, when financial institutions, business firms, or individuals buy or sell securities among themselves, the credit to the account of the seller’s depository institution is offset by the debit to the account of the purchas-er’s depository institution; so existing balances held at the Federal Reserve are redistributed from one depository institution to another without changing the total available.

I had to track back your discussion a bit, but you seemed to be saying that the Fed had some unfair advantage by being able to create money. That doesn't appear to be exactly correct.

One of the ways used to increase the total money supply is to buy securities, as this increases the available reserves for the bank to loan out, thus increasing the amount of money available to the total economy. Conversely, they sell securities to remove money from the reserves, and thus the economy at large.

Also, in order to actually create wholly new money, the Fed is required to pledge collateral. So how does this give them an "unfair advantage" in buying back government securities?

Presumably, your objection to all of this is the inflationary tendency created by, say, creating additional currency. However, do you have any particular reason to suspect that inflation is currently out of control, or inherently undesireable?
 
You quoted a passage from The Fed's publication The Federal Reserve System: Purposes and Functions, the rest of which reads:

I had to track back your discussion a bit, but you seemed to be saying that the Fed had some unfair advantage by being able to create money. That doesn't appear to be exactly correct.

One of the ways used to increase the total money supply is to buy securities, as this increases the available reserves for the bank to loan out, thus increasing the amount of money available to the total economy. Conversely, they sell securities to remove money from the reserves, and thus the economy at large.

Also, in order to actually create wholly new money, the Fed is required to pledge collateral. So how does this give them an "unfair advantage" in buying back government securities?

Presumably, your objection to all of this is the inflationary tendency created by, say, creating additional currency. However, do you have any particular reason to suspect that inflation is currently out of control, or inherently undesireable?

Your quote from the Fed deals with two separate issues:

The Fed:
Conversely, selling securities or conducting a reverse repurchase agreement decreases the quantity of Federal Reserve balances because the Federal Reserve extinguishes balances when it debits the account of the purchaser’s depository institution at the Federal Reserve; there is no corresponding increase in another institution’s account.

Everyone else:
In contrast, when financial institutions, business firms, or individuals buy or sell securities among themselves, the credit to the account of the seller’s depository institution is offset by the debit to the account of the purchas-er’s depository institution; so existing balances held at the Federal Reserve are redistributed from one depository institution to another without changing the total available.

To whom does the Fed pledge collateral when creating entirely new money?

Inflation doesn't worry me. A system that maintains the wealth and power of a small number of people at the expense of the rest of the people is not a fair system.
 
Your quote from the Fed deals with two separate issues:

Yes, and it clearly describes how the purchase or sale of securities affects the available money supply, as opposed to the private purchase which does not. Was that not sufficiently clear?

To whom does the Fed pledge collateral when creating entirely new money?

Technically, to the government of the United States. In the event that Congress dissolves the Fed, the US government assumes liability for the notes.

In essence, the notes are backed by the US economy. If it tanks, so does the currency of the US.

Inflation doesn't worry me. A system that maintains the wealth and power of a small number of people at the expense of the rest of the people is not a fair system.

And how do you figure that the current system does this, exactly?

ETA: Your first post on that topic mentions the private ownership of the Fed, but neglects to mention that the Fed is ultimately an agent of the US government chartered to act in the public interest. The fact that it is not directly controlled by, say, Congress, protects it from political pressure to make unsound monetary decisions in the interest of politics.

You said it protected the "economic hegemony" of a few individuals. How?

How does the Fed has an unfair advantage on the open market in terms of buying securities? Can they force people to sell them those securities?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom