federal reserve conspiracy!!!

Abby, I did so address "unexpected inflation", and so does Rothbard. On the free market, all inflation is unexpected, for the reasons given. If you want to explain why you think some inflation is expected and some not, and how that relates to fiat money being theft, or not, go ahead.

No it isn't. Not at all. Good grief, your Mr. Baker addresses inflation in EXPECTED TERMS. He even argues that when inflation is expected, people spend now.

Re: expected vs. unexpected inflation:
http://www.sparknotes.com/economics/macro/measuring2/section1.html

Scroll to the bottom.

This is another, basic, basic concept.
 
I'll tell you what, Abby. For the sake of the thread, and trying to get an actual discussion of the wealth redistribution inherent in central banking, I will offer the following concession:

You, Abby Scott, know far more than I do about mainstream economics. I bow down to your vastly superior knowledge of mainstream economics.

You will admit, I hope, that I know far more about the so-called Austrian school of economics. You will say that it is all wrong, a fringe theory, whatever. Fine with me. Accepted for the sake of argument.

Using your vastly superior knowledge of mainstream economics, which is the correct thesis in your view, what is the error in my Austrian theory that fiat money creation redistributes wealth, away from late-receivers of new money, to early receivers of new money, and especially to the creators of new money?

Please Abby, don't hold back. Go for it. Lay your Galbraith on me. Your Samuelson. Or some Chicago Friedmanite monetarism. Whatever. Give it up. Please explain how it could possibly be that fiat money is created, yet real wealth not redistributed.
 
Last edited:
Well Ace, if you think that paper money is worthless, you can send it to me, I'll happily take all that worthless paper off of your hands.
 
Well Ace, if you think that paper money is worthless, you can send it to me, I'll happily take all that worthless paper off of your hands.

Have I got a deal for you. I'll give you $40 in paper dollars, for every $20 gold piece you give me. You will double your money. Deal?
 
Corsair and Abby. Both long on trolling, short on substance.
I'm still waiting for you to explain how the media of other nations are part of the 9/11 cover up. I would be interested to know, as a Canadian, that the CBC, CTV, and Global television networks were part of some conspiracy to hide the truth.

I'm still waiting to hear if you've tried contacting the aforementioned three networks to see what 9/11 news reports they might have archived.

I'm still waiting to hear if you've finally done some reading on the origin and background of special visual effects and if you've gained some knowledge as to how various techniques are done and how they've changed over the years.


Normally, I wouldn't have taken a shot at you like I did, as I do prize civility, but frankly, you've worn out my patience. So I fired a round across your bow to get your attention.
 
Why is it that people act like inflation never happened pre Fed Reserve?
Or that price inflation contributed largely to the demise of Spain (c 17th Century) coupled with an aggressive adherence to a precious metal standard?
 
Corsair and Abby. Both long on trolling, short on substance.
[/URL].

Pretty arrogant for a guy who's been caught flat-footed and unable to even know the terms of what he's talking about.

Even I don't know squat about economics and I could see this is a losing proposition.
 
I'm still waiting for you to explain how the media of other nations are part of the 9/11 cover up. I would be interested to know, as a Canadian, that the CBC, CTV, and Global television networks were part of some conspiracy to hide the truth.

I don't know if or to what extent the Canadian media are in on it. Good research subject. On 9/11, they were simply fed the same videos and information that everyone else was. Since then, I don't know.

I'm still waiting to hear if you've tried contacting the aforementioned three networks to see what 9/11 news reports they might have archived.

The Canadian networks? No. I'd be happy to though. Perhaps you could give me some contact info.

I'm still waiting to hear if you've finally done some reading on the origin and background of special visual effects and if you've gained some knowledge as to how various techniques are done and how they've changed over the years.

I discuss this in my paper. Had you actually read it, you'd know this. You should try comprehending that which you criticize. It will actually make your argument stronger.

Normally, I wouldn't have taken a shot at you like I did, as I do prize civility, but frankly, you've worn out my patience. So I fired a round across your bow to get your attention.

I've gotten a lot of people's attention. I have produced a robust proof of video fakery on 9/11. If you'd like to cease your distractions and contribute some substance, perhaps you could bump the appropriate thread.
 
Pretty arrogant for a guy who's been caught flat-footed and unable to even know the terms of what he's talking about.

Even I don't know squat about economics and I could see this is a losing proposition.

Go back and re-read the thread. I know perfectly well what Abby's beloved multipliers are - both the Keynesian multiplier, and the money multiplier. I just happen to think they are both fiction. Historically, I don't see where mainstream economics has predicted or explained anything. It is a failed pursuit. I'm not real interested in belaboring a discussion of fictional constructs.

Austrian economics explains much. Would you like to know the cause of the boom/bust business cycle? Would you like to know the cause of price inflation?

I am interested in discussing the Federal Reserve System, and the creation of fiat money.

I am still waiting for anyone to even attempt to refute what I have said.

Fiat money = Theft.
 
No it isn't. Not at all. Good grief, your Mr. Baker addresses inflation in EXPECTED TERMS. He even argues that when inflation is expected, people spend now.

Re: expected vs. unexpected inflation:
http://www.sparknotes.com/economics/macro/measuring2/section1.html

Scroll to the bottom.

This is another, basic, basic concept.

The page you link is revealing of your mindset. The page defines inflation as a rise in prices, and attempts to categorize inflation as "expected" and "unexpected". It's not very interesting. What is interesting is to wonder:

What causes inflation?

That is not discussed on your sparknotes page, Abby.

The Austrians have an elegant and scholarly explanation for the cause of price inflation. According to Austrian theory, the only possible explanation for a sustained, general rise in prices is an increase in the quantity of money, relative to the amount of goods and services.

That is why the Austrians define inflation as the increase in money supply, and say that rising prices are a symptom of inflation.

Naming ill-defined categories of things is boring to me. Understanding causation is stimulating. Perhaps that's just the difference between me and you.
 
Last edited:
I don't know if or to what extent the Canadian media are in on it. Good research subject. On 9/11, they were simply fed the same videos and information that everyone else was.
They also had their own reporters there, covering various stories. A number of Canadians worked in the WTC towers; 24 were killed in the attacks that day.

The Canadian networks? No. I'd be happy to though. Perhaps you could give me some contact info.
Google should easily supply such info.

I discuss this in my paper. Had you actually read it, you'd know this.
No, I haven't read it. Why? I'll be blunt: anyone who's starting position is that ALL the video footage shot on 9/11 of the aircraft impacts (all 40+ angles worth) are fakes is someone who is divorced from reality and living in a fantasy world. As a result, I'm not much interested in reading their paper.

Considering my own eyes watched much of the same footage when it was originally aired and in broadcast quality and which was repeated several times, and given just how good these eyes of mine are at spotting special effects and which saw absolutely NOTHING wrong in any of the footage, I am content that what I saw was real. Add to this all the other supporting evidence (many eyewitness testimonies, aircraft debris, still photos, etc.), and I am sure your assertions are utterly incorrect and utterly false.

By the way, I'm still waiting for you to address all the still photographs of the 9/11 impact events. You're going to have to prove all those pictures which were shown on newspapers around the world are faked too.

I have produced a robust proof of video fakery on 9/11.
You may have for folks who don't know much about the subject of visual effects, or who don't have a good eye for spotting them, but for everyone else, no, your proof is not robust (leaving aside all the other corroborating evidence that jetliners impacted the WTC towers which makes your case even weaker than it was initially).

One more time I mention this:

To determine if a video is faked, you do NOT need to do some frame-by-frame Photoshop analysis. Faked images can be detected merely by watching the footage at normal speed several times. If your eyes are any good, normal speed viewing should reveal the problems, and from there you can go into details. But if you can't spot the problems at normal speed, then your eyes are no good for spotting effects.

If you'd like to cease your distractions and contribute some substance, perhaps you could bump the appropriate thread.
You're the one who has abandoned your own thread on the subject.

I'm still waiting for you to tell me what, if anything, you think looks odd about the way the full-size powerloader moved in the movie Aliens. That is a litmus test for determining whether you are any good or not at spotting subtle issues with the way things move. If your eyes find nothing out of the ordinary, then I know beyond any doubt that my eyes are superior to yours when it comes to determining special effects.
 
Last edited:
That is why the Austrians define inflation as the increase in money supply, and say that rising prices are a symptom of inflation.
The "Austrians" play an interesting little shell game, TS1234. They acknowledge the need for the concentration of capital useful for technological application (canals, railways, highways, motorcars, steamships, port facilities, industrial buildings, banks, airplanes, airports, and so on). But this requires a liquidity and portability of money that gold and silver simply cannot keep up with, nor can private banking concerns.

Not only that, but capitalism coupled with a precious metal exchange currency is a recipe for price inflation. You have to increase the local money supply (concentration of capital). That used to mean ridiculous demands on local banking facilities, runaway price inflation, and moreover stripped other places of their ability to employ the same technologies.

These days of central banking, that doesn't happen any longer unless the local authority loots the cash register and opens up a bank account in Zurich. Maybe you're afraid that's going to happen in your country. I can't see why, though. They certainly had their opportunity about eighty years ago and decided instead to play fair.

Maybe you live in a gold-producing area or something and you think you'll reap "benefits" of some sort of neo-mercantilist scheme. Or perhaps you're deeply indebted to others and feel you were coerced into your situation. But most people accept that "fiat" currency doesn't mean "fake money" and don't need to know much about economic history to realise that they're far better off than their ancestors were.

The nineteenth century saw a plethora of "Austrian" solutions and they resulted in bank panics, widespread poverty in the West, and dissolution of markets and trade. Shall we raise the banner of Tariff yet again Mr Truth Seeker?
 
Have I got a deal for you. I'll give you $40 in paper dollars, for every $20 gold piece you give me. You will double your money. Deal?
Can I take you up on that deal? I'll trade you my Krugerrands 1 oz legal tender gold coins @ $1,330 each for your fiat money
 
@TruthSeeker1234

First, I'm asking for criticism of this concept:

The creation of fiat money is theft. It necessarily transfers real wealth away from the late receivers of new money, and into the hands of the early receivers, and especially into the hands of the money creators.

That could be the case in a scenario where the Central Bank is an active agent of the economy, where it has the ability to spend the money it creates. In the case of the Federal Reserve the “money creators” receive no transfer of wealth.

The bit about the “late receivers” and “early receivers” makes no sense in the context of a Central Bank that manages the growth of the money supply according to the changes in the demand. A stable and predictable rate of inflation does away with your argument about the transfer of wealth from the “late receivers” to the “early receivers”.
 
Prior to the existence of gold money, there was a demand for gold as a commodity.

Yea, but when's the last time people used currency MADE OUT OF gold ?

Something which was not valuable could not function as money

Of course, and that's why paper money works.

In 1913, refusal to accept paper money was made a felony.

It's a good thing that the local supermarked can't ask for 6 goats in exhange for that new television set I want...
 
If what you say is true, government would not have had to use force to impose fiat money.

Actually, they would.

Paper money is THE SAME THING as any other kind of money, expect it's more practical, because there's never any less of it after a few million marriages.

Gold money evolved through free choice. When given the freedom to choose, people chose to accept commodities as money, especially precious metals, and gold above all others.

Yes. Same thing with paper money. What's your point ?

Fiat money did not evolve through free choice. When given the freedom to choose, people did not choose to accept unbacked paper money, ever.

And yet the world economy works fine with it. Your theory fails in practice.

4. I need to get stuff from other people.
5. If I offer them [unbacked] paper money, they'll tell me to go fly a kite.

Of course NOT. You are completely ignorant of these things, apparently.

If OTHER people use paper money as a currency, then it has economic value even if it has no real value.

So who cares ? "Diablo II" players used damn "Stones of Jordan" items as a currency... instead of ACTUAL gold in the game that they could use to buy stuff with. So why did they use that ? <shrugs> Because they agreed to use it as currency, that's all. They were cheating, but that's besides the point.

The creation of fiat money is theft.

That's your conclusion. So far you've failed miserably at demonstrating it.

It necessarily transfers real wealth away from the late receivers of new money

And THAT is why you fail. [/Yoda]

"Real wealth" is an illusion. You only have "real" wealth so long as the wealth you have is CONSIDERED wealth.
 
Of all the stupid conspiracytheories, this gold-crap really taks the pie...
Are these people unable to understand concepts like inflation? Or that there isn't gold enough in the world, to cover the value of money in the United States, let alone in the world?

Having Krugerrands and other "real" gold currencies is just stupid, let alone a bad investment. Gold prices are up right now, but not nearly as high as they were. And if the price of gold falls, which it very might well, and which it has done before, guess what, your precious Krugerrands will lose value as well. Unlike the money I have invested in bonds and the stock market...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom