Stop it Johnny. My reasoning is in no way circular. Prior to the existence of gold money, there was a demand for gold as a commodity. That is, people valued it. Commodity monies emerged in response to the problems of barter. Additional demand for gold thus arose, the original demand for gold, plus the new demand for gold as a medium of exchange. The additional demand will make gold more highly valued.
Something which was not valuable could not function as money, because people would not accept it in exchange. Therefore, to function as money, a commodity must have a high pre-existing market exchange value. None of this is circular reasoning.
Not sure what high value has gold other than as a medium of trade - which is equivalent to currency, but I'll drop the complaint as its trivial to the point of stupidity anyway. I apologize for misunderstanding what you were getting at.
Where on earth have I ever said the gold standard emerged suddenly? I said it emerged spontaneously. The spontaneous emergence of the gold standard took place over thousands of years.
Well, that was a simple misreading.
But technically, it wasn't spontaneous either. You even gave various reasons that gold was selected - making it a logical choice over time, and hardly spontaneous. Spontaneous implies arising
without cause, but there
are reasons to choose to select gold as a medium of currency. Also, numerous other mediums were tried, before gold was selected as one of the primary standards, along with silver to a lesser extent, in many civilizations.
In 1913, refusal to accept paper money was made a felony.
Incorrect, according to the Treasury:
http://www.treas.gov/education/faq/currency/legal-tender.shtml#q1
Private businesses are perfectly free to not accept cash. Do you have evidence that such a law existed and is still in effect?
As far as I can tell, there are no laws that force any private business from conducting business as it sees fit. They are perfectly free not to take paper money, as they are free not to take credit cards, or to refuse to accept payment in, say, gold.
In 1933, all the monetary gold was confiscated by the government, and its possession was made a felony. Making gold a felony tends to discourage its use, wouldn't you say?
This is highly misleading. What the US actually did was remove from circulation all the
gold certificates that were used as currency. This, in
absolutely no way prevents you from trading in gold. Gold is bought and sold on the open market, and if you can convince someone to take it in trade for something, there is
no law that prevents you from doing so.
Possession of the original
gold certificates is, in fact, illegal. They also have no value. However, this does not mean "gold" (as in, actual possession of
gold, not a
gold certificate in the old sense)
Your first sentence, which refers to
monetary gold, I assume refers to the gold certificates issued by the US government. But then you switch to just saying "gold," which leads the reader to believe that using gold itself as a medium of exchange is illegal. This is false. You are quite free to try to persuade a business to accept gold as payment. They probably won't, but no law stops you. I think you have been misled about the US laws governing private exchange.
Any money supply is optimal. If this were false, then you could not explain why there is even one poor country. All any country would need to do is create more money, and be rich. Money is a medium of exchange, prices will adjust to any supply of money.
Like I said, this is true only in theory. However, you neglect to factor in the fact that both prices and wages are "sticky" relative to other economic factors - they tend to change more slowly. If the money supply is changing very quickly, then prices/wages may not change quickly enough to adjust for the money supply.
Obviously, the theory is that the money supply will always self-adapt. If there is only $100 instead of 100 billion in the whole economy (obviously absurd), then your wages might drop to 1 billionth of what they were, but so will prices. That is the theory, anyway. But, like I said, the prices and wages take time to adjust, and the economy takes time to reorganize.
There is also the issue of fixed debt. While the wages and prices may adjust to the money supply eventually, the debt amounts may not, and that may cause issues with repayment if the money supply is shrinking.
If you honestly believe the money supply always adjust perfectly, then why do you have such a problem with the Fed? After all, any changes they make must be optimal by definition, correct?
Sorry, must have missed your history lesson. Link it.
http://www.answers.com/topic/panic-of-1873
The central issue was that Grant refused to expand the money supply by moving off the gold standard. As additional background, there was pressure from the
bankers to stay on the gold standard, and pressure from the
debtors to move off it. Any idea why?
If you want additional sources, might I suggest the excellent "American Pageant, volume II" by Thomas A. Bailey et. al.
Again, my apologies for misunderstanding you, I was reading more into what you said than I should have.