federal reserve conspiracy!!!

Yes, Abby, I know what is meant by "the capital account".

Gone, eh. So the answer evidently is "No, Abby Scott cannot refute Ace Baker's (Austrian based) claim that fiat money is theft.

Anyone else?

No need to refute the nonsensical.

When push comes to shove, your only argument is "because I said so". Telling.

So far your argument pretty much hinges on the same reasoning, so I think we can call you the kettle, here.

I don't know if or to what extent the Canadian media are in on it.

Let me give you a hint: about as much as the American media.
 
Corsair and Abby. Both long on trolling, short on substance.

Abby, critique fiat = theft.

Corsair, critique this.

No, no, no. You gave me a "treatise" proving that fiat=theft. I've taken it apart. It's up to you to show me more proof.

You don't "know more about the Austrian school of Economics" than i do, because you don't know about the basic tools.
 
The page you link is revealing of your mindset. The page defines inflation as a rise in prices, and attempts to categorize inflation as "expected" and "unexpected". It's not very interesting. What is interesting is to wonder:

What causes inflation?

That is not discussed on your sparknotes page, Abby.

The Austrians have an elegant and scholarly explanation for the cause of price inflation. According to Austrian theory, the only possible explanation for a sustained, general rise in prices is an increase in the quantity of money, relative to the amount of goods and services.

That is why the Austrians define inflation as the increase in money supply, and say that rising prices are a symptom of inflation.

Naming ill-defined categories of things is boring to me. Understanding causation is stimulating. Perhaps that's just the difference between me and you.


You're moving the goal posts, big guy. Big time. You said there was no difference between unexpected and expected inflation.

Wanna know the problem with the quantity theory of money? The assumption that the Velocity of Money is fixed.
 
I came up with a simple scenario for the people who would like us to go back to the time when gold was used as currency. Let's start by reminding a very a very simple fact of real life: gold is a finite resource. With that in mind let's simplify life a bit and assume that a given country (let's name it Kookland) has 1000 gold coins running around in its economy. Kookland has a very fertile soil so they specialize in agriculture.

So, one day one of the farmers at Kookland sees he can duplicate his production for the next year if he can buy the necessary technology (a technology that does not exhibit constant returns to scale) ... problem is he can't pay for it in cash right now. The farmer goes to the financial market to see if anyone can lend him the money just to find out that the nation's money supply is already strained and there's a line of people who have the same trouble as he does. Since demand is higher than the finite supply there's only one thing to do: raise the interest rate, which means that credit is now more expensive and so the farmers will have to raise their prices in order to be able to pay their obligations. What is this? Inflation while using commodity money? But isn't this kind of money the panacea against inflation? Well, no it's not. Good monetary policy does not necessarily depend on what is being used as money, delete some of that information you got from "America from freedom to fascism" or "zeitgeist" and replace it with this tiny bit.
 
8. And thus, gold is now demanded for its exchange value, in addition to its pre-existing values.


It had no preexisting value. It's a soft and (until recently) fairly useless metal.


3. Other people [the market] do not put a value on [unbacked] paper money.


Um ... yes they do. They put quite a heavy value on it. Just today I was able to use some to convince a guy to bake me a bagel. I used more of it to convince the Campbell's Soup Company to grow eight vegetables, juice them, mix them together, bottle them and send them to the bagel guy for me to drink. So, your statement is false owing, I suspect, to your lack of comprehension of economics.


5. If I offer them [unbacked] paper money, they'll tell me to go fly a kite.


Wrong!

When I offered the bagel guy the unbacked paper money, he took it happily. He even told me to have a nice day. Did I mention the bagel had vegetable cream cheese on it? All in all, a lovely breakfast was had by me using unbacked paper money.

Do you have any examples of merchants in the US refusing to take unbacked paper money?

I didn't think you did. It's because you don't understand the issues.


6. Because I do not find [unbacked] paper money aesthetically pleasing, and because the market finds it essentially worthless, I do not wish to own [unbacked] paper money.


Send it all to me.

You won't, though, because you are lying. You do not find unbacked paper money essentially worthless. You covet it for its essential worth. You want more of it. So you're not even being honest about your own beliefs.


8. And thus, [unbacked] paper money is intrinsically worthless, and also worthless to free people as a medium of exchange.


Which would be true if it were at all the case. Unfortunately for you, I have just checked and my mortgage company will be happy to accept unbacked paper money for land. There's nothing more real than land and you can get some with unbacked paper money. Meanwhile, they will not sell me back my land for either bagels or V8.


3. Other people put a value on [redeemable] paper money, because they can readily exchange it for gold or silver.


You should pick up the very easy book Greenback by Jason Goodwin. He has some nice anecdotes from the 1800s about what happened when people tried to redeem their bank notes for gold. It was a pretty rare event. One bank manager told a customer that no one had ever made that request before and he would be happy if the man did not reveal to anyone else the location of the main bank branch that held the gold deposits.

There's a reason nobody cared when we left the gold standard: nobody could readily exchange their money for gold and almost nobody wanted to.


5. If I give them [redeemable] paper money, they'll give me stuff in exchange.


Really? Try buying a bagel and V8 with a note that says "IOU 0.006 oz. og gold." The truth is you could convert your money to gold today and you could issue gold certificates. Or you could skip that step and buy gold bonds directly. Then try to use them in trade. You can't. Guess why? People don't want them!


4. I need to get stuff from other people.
5. If I give them [unbacked] paper money, they'll go to jail if they refuse to accept it, so they are forced to give me stuff in exchange.
6. Even though I do not find [unbacked] paper money aesthetically pleasing, I wish to own [unbacked] paper money, because the government has left me with no choice, other than to revert to barter.
7. Thus, [unbacked] paper money has value to me.
8. And thus, [unbacked] paper money, though intrinsically worthless, and irredeemable, becomes valued as a medium of exchange.


I'm having difficulty seeing why this accurate representation of the world is in any way problematic.
 
Stop it Johnny. My reasoning is in no way circular. Prior to the existence of gold money, there was a demand for gold as a commodity. That is, people valued it. Commodity monies emerged in response to the problems of barter. Additional demand for gold thus arose, the original demand for gold, plus the new demand for gold as a medium of exchange. The additional demand will make gold more highly valued.

Something which was not valuable could not function as money, because people would not accept it in exchange. Therefore, to function as money, a commodity must have a high pre-existing market exchange value. None of this is circular reasoning.

Not sure what high value has gold other than as a medium of trade - which is equivalent to currency, but I'll drop the complaint as its trivial to the point of stupidity anyway. I apologize for misunderstanding what you were getting at.

Where on earth have I ever said the gold standard emerged suddenly? I said it emerged spontaneously. The spontaneous emergence of the gold standard took place over thousands of years.

Well, that was a simple misreading.

But technically, it wasn't spontaneous either. You even gave various reasons that gold was selected - making it a logical choice over time, and hardly spontaneous. Spontaneous implies arising without cause, but there are reasons to choose to select gold as a medium of currency. Also, numerous other mediums were tried, before gold was selected as one of the primary standards, along with silver to a lesser extent, in many civilizations.

In 1913, refusal to accept paper money was made a felony.

Incorrect, according to the Treasury:

http://www.treas.gov/education/faq/currency/legal-tender.shtml#q1

Private businesses are perfectly free to not accept cash. Do you have evidence that such a law existed and is still in effect?

As far as I can tell, there are no laws that force any private business from conducting business as it sees fit. They are perfectly free not to take paper money, as they are free not to take credit cards, or to refuse to accept payment in, say, gold.

In 1933, all the monetary gold was confiscated by the government, and its possession was made a felony. Making gold a felony tends to discourage its use, wouldn't you say?

This is highly misleading. What the US actually did was remove from circulation all the gold certificates that were used as currency. This, in absolutely no way prevents you from trading in gold. Gold is bought and sold on the open market, and if you can convince someone to take it in trade for something, there is no law that prevents you from doing so.

Possession of the original gold certificates is, in fact, illegal. They also have no value. However, this does not mean "gold" (as in, actual possession of gold, not a gold certificate in the old sense)

Your first sentence, which refers to monetary gold, I assume refers to the gold certificates issued by the US government. But then you switch to just saying "gold," which leads the reader to believe that using gold itself as a medium of exchange is illegal. This is false. You are quite free to try to persuade a business to accept gold as payment. They probably won't, but no law stops you. I think you have been misled about the US laws governing private exchange.

Any money supply is optimal. If this were false, then you could not explain why there is even one poor country. All any country would need to do is create more money, and be rich. Money is a medium of exchange, prices will adjust to any supply of money.

Like I said, this is true only in theory. However, you neglect to factor in the fact that both prices and wages are "sticky" relative to other economic factors - they tend to change more slowly. If the money supply is changing very quickly, then prices/wages may not change quickly enough to adjust for the money supply.

Obviously, the theory is that the money supply will always self-adapt. If there is only $100 instead of 100 billion in the whole economy (obviously absurd), then your wages might drop to 1 billionth of what they were, but so will prices. That is the theory, anyway. But, like I said, the prices and wages take time to adjust, and the economy takes time to reorganize.

There is also the issue of fixed debt. While the wages and prices may adjust to the money supply eventually, the debt amounts may not, and that may cause issues with repayment if the money supply is shrinking.

If you honestly believe the money supply always adjust perfectly, then why do you have such a problem with the Fed? After all, any changes they make must be optimal by definition, correct?

Sorry, must have missed your history lesson. Link it.

http://www.answers.com/topic/panic-of-1873

The central issue was that Grant refused to expand the money supply by moving off the gold standard. As additional background, there was pressure from the bankers to stay on the gold standard, and pressure from the debtors to move off it. Any idea why?

If you want additional sources, might I suggest the excellent "American Pageant, volume II" by Thomas A. Bailey et. al.


Again, my apologies for misunderstanding you, I was reading more into what you said than I should have.
 
Loss Leader said:
Which would be true if it were at all the case. Unfortunately for you, I have just checked and my mortgage company will be happy to accept unbacked paper money for land. There's nothing more real than land and you can get some with unbacked paper money.

Hey, Ace!! Listen to the lawyer man. Forget the gold. We should use LAND as money.

It's true. :)
 
Go back and re-read the thread. I know perfectly well what Abby's beloved multipliers are - both the Keynesian multiplier, and the money multiplier.

Well, that's not coming across.

I just happen to think they are both fiction.

That's one of the reasons. If I wrote "I know perfectly well who John F. Kennedy and Bobby Kennedy were, but I just happen to think they are both fiction," then I don't know.


I am still waiting for anyone to even attempt to refute what I have said.

Fiat money = Theft.

No. That's not what "theft" means. Refutation complete.
 
Have I got a deal for you. I'll give you $40 in paper dollars, for every $20 gold piece you give me. You will double your money. Deal?

"$20 gold piece" as in "$20 worth of gold at present market value" or "$20 gold piece from some time in the history of the US?"
 
Don't listen to them, TS. You and me and Billy Bryan know the truth. We will answer their demand for a gold standard by saying to them: You shall not press down upon the brow of labor this crown of thorns. You shall not crucify mankind upon a cross of gold.

Wait -- I guess it's just Billy Bryan and me. Never mind, TS. Go seek some truth or something.
 
You guys may well feel at home arguing angels on a pinhead - I notice that no one commented when I posted one from the horse's mouth - read it a weep gatekeepers:)



SIR JOSIAH STAMP (President of the Bank of England in the 1920's, then the second richest man in Britain)

"Banking was conceived in iniquity, and was born in sin. The Bankers own the Earth. Take it away from them, but leave them the power to create deposits, and with the flick of the pen, they will create enough deposits, to buy it back again. However, take it away from them, and all the great fortunes like mine will disappear, and they ought to disappear, for this would be a happier and better world to live in. But if you wish to remain the slaves of Bankers, and pay the cost of your own slavery, let them continue to create deposits."
 
Parmanides: there's nothing to comment on someone's personal opinion that you manage to catch while watching "Money Masters" or a similar video.
 
Don't listen to them, TS. You and me and Billy Bryan know the truth. We will answer their demand for a gold standard by saying to them: You shall not press down upon the brow of labor this crown of thorns. You shall not crucify mankind upon a cross of gold.

Wait -- I guess it's just Billy Bryan and me. Never mind, TS. Go seek some truth or something.

Ooh, nice reference!

You guys may well feel at home arguing angels on a pinhead - I notice that no one commented when I posted one from the horse's mouth - read it a weep gatekeepers:)

The "horse's mouth?" You mean the quote from the banker that's been dead for 66 years that you quoted without context or verification and expect comment on?

SIR JOSIAH STAMP (President of the Bank of England in the 1920's, then the second richest man in Britain)

"Banking was conceived in iniquity, and was born in sin. The Bankers own the Earth. Take it away from them, but leave them the power to create deposits, and with the flick of the pen, they will create enough deposits, to buy it back again. However, take it away from them, and all the great fortunes like mine will disappear, and they ought to disappear, for this would be a happier and better world to live in. But if you wish to remain the slaves of Bankers, and pay the cost of your own slavery, let them continue to create deposits."

Okay... so what? Posting this quote doesn't invalidate anything or make anything true. If you believe the Federal Reserve is somehow "enslaving" people, then you're welcome to make that argument using evidence.

Never mind that the "bankers" don't have the power to create money whenever they want, or simply use it to buy whatever they want. Who's the richest person in the world, parmanides?
 
Last edited:
You guys may well feel at home arguing angels on a pinhead - I notice that no one commented when I posted one from the horse's mouth - read it a weep gatekeepers:)



SIR JOSIAH STAMP (President of the Bank of England in the 1920's, then the second richest man in Britain)

"Banking was conceived in iniquity, and was born in sin. The Bankers own the Earth. Take it away from them, but leave them the power to create deposits, and with the flick of the pen, they will create enough deposits, to buy it back again. However, take it away from them, and all the great fortunes like mine will disappear, and they ought to disappear, for this would be a happier and better world to live in. But if you wish to remain the slaves of Bankers, and pay the cost of your own slavery, let them continue to create deposits."


May I assume that you have no savings account, credit cards or loans of any kind?
 
JohnyFive:

Long years ago, I heard an old recording of Bryan reading that speech; he'd deliver it if you asked him enough times -- once, say.

By god but I wish we had such orators today! He was wrong about almost everything, but the power of his wrongness would carry you along with him, like a boulder tumbling in a stream.

"There used to be a giant in that body, but he got lost looking for Billy Bryan." That's from Inherit the Wind, and it would make a good title for a biography: The Lost Giant.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom