federal reserve conspiracy!!!

Gold spontaneously became the world standard money because of the market, not because of anyone's personal taste. It turns out that gold has the qualities that make for a well-functioning money. Had you read my article , you would know this now. The qualities are:

high demand
high value to weight ratio
durability
divisibility
interchangeability
Oh, wait, you forgot to mention that it's pretty and shiny.

Now, here's a question for you. If gold is so great, and actual dollars are just rubbish, then why don't, y'know, businessmen ... capitalists ... entrepreneurs ... people like that ... insist on dealing in gold rather than these bits of green paper?

Bit of a puzzler, no?
 
Last edited:
our dollars are printed out of thin air. this is such an evil, vast, and dark conspiracy because our currency is not held under any type of gold standard to secure its value and stop inflation.
(1) Why do you want to stop inflation?

(2) Do you have the faintest idea what the gold standard did to the American economy?
 
Tell me, how does one buy stock in the Federal Reserve?

One doesn't, member banks do by meeting the requirements for membership including depositing reserves in a Federal Reserve bank and holding some portion of reserves themselves.

The interest I was speaking of is more correctly called a dividend on the stock. The dividends are in lieu of interest on reserves.
 
This is barely English, let alone high finance.

What are you talking about?

Sorry, my english is deteriorating after living in Europe for 15 years. Member banks get stock dividends equivalent to guaranteed 6% interest on their reserves.
 
Sorry, my english is deteriorating after living in Europe for 15 years. Member banks get stock dividends equivalent to guaranteed 6% interest on their reserves.


My english is just fine and I've lived in Europe for just 30 years. :D

Ace I'll add history and economics to the ever expanding list of "Stuff Ace knows diddle squat about". The 20s crash was caused by several reasons, but essentially the stock market was phenomenally over valued. Similar to the web stock boom in the 90s. People were buying stock on the assumption that it would automatically rise. It was a bubble and it burst.

This is the most achingly thunder headed maddeningly stupid argument I've ever seen proposed, since, well, the last time Ace spoke. There's no point even arguing with someone who is so spectacularly wrong. We just need to pick our jaws up off the floor, shake our heads, walk away and wonder, "Millions of sperm, and he was the fastest?"



Oh and BTW. ABBY RULEZ!
 
@GregoryUrich

Is it really you Mr. Greenspan...we're not worthy!

Well since you are so sure The Fed is "privately owned" i guess you'll have no difficulties listing the banks for which each of the members of the board of governors work for. The same goes for the chairman.

The member banks own all of the stock in the Fed. Member banks are privately owned and sometimes publicly traded.

The Federal Reserve is not privately owned, its member banks are.

See above.

Why does it have an unfair advantage on open markets operations?

See below.

You do know that's what it happens with any financial institution, right? Just checking.

Which private corporations are these?

Member banks. Actually they get stock dividends in lieu of interest on reserves.

The Fed creates money by purchasing securities or other assets, not by creating money to buy these financial instruments.

from Wikipedia: Open Market Operations
Since most money is now in the form of electronic records, rather than paper records such as banknotes, open market operations are conducted simply by electronically increasing or decreasing the amount of money that a bank has, e.g., in its reserve account at the central bank, in exchange for the bank selling or buying a financial instrument. Newly created money is used by the central bank to buy in the open market a financial asset, such as government bonds, foreign currency, or gold. If the central bank sells these assets in the open market, the amount of money that the bank holds decreases, effectively destroying money.

Maybe Wikipedia is wrong. If so, do you have a better source?

That makes no sense.

The member banks get a guaranteed 6% stock dividend. That would be profit.


Wrong, as i said earlier The Fed increases the money supply by purchasing financial instruments not by "creating money" to buy these instruments.

Wrong. See above.

After quoting your previous assertion i have the feeling that it is you you has to do a lot of reading on the subject because you are completely clueless and very confused about it.

We are worthy. You can not be the real Alan Greenspan.
 
Last edited:
Stamp quote

SIR JOSIAH STAMP (President of the Bank of England in the 1920's, then the second richest man in Britain)

"Banking was conceived in iniquity, and was born in sin. The Bankers own the Earth. Take it away from them, but leave them the power to create deposits, and with the flick of the pen, they will create enough deposits, to buy it back again. However, take it away from them, and all the great fortunes like mine will disappear, and they ought to disappear, for this would be a happier and better world to live in. But if you wish to remain the slaves of Bankers, and pay the cost of your own slavery, let them continue to create deposits."

nobody told me there'd be days like these
 
GregoryUrich, the stock that the member banks hold in the Fed cannot be publically traded, it cannot be sold, and it cannot be used as collateral(thus, our own "Alan Greenspan" is quite correct). The idea that the stock is equivalent to normal stock is completely false.

The dividends are fixed, and the rate of return is fairly low by market standards (6% annually is approximately what one would get in a high-yield savings account, and is quite below the average rate of return on stocks, as well as various other investment products).

In case you want a source: http://www.frbsf.org/publications/federalreserve/fedinbrief/organize.html
(right down at the bottom)

If you'd like to know about procedural issues, you can just go to the Fed's web site. All the various codes and laws are a matter of public record, as are its policies and organizational structure. Unless you think the Fed is lying about its own organization on its web site (and all the assorted codes/laws are ignored or lies too), in which case you're perfectly welcome to present the evidence that this is the case.

TS1234, and other assorted proponents of the gold standard as a monetary cure-all, I would like you to consider something from the history of the US and tell me what you think:

Post-reconstruction, at the end of the 1800's (1870's specifically, under President Grant), there was a fairly serious economic situation in the US. In the hopes of massive profits, business owners and promoters began to aggressively expand their enterprises. However, the level of profit was insufficient to sustain this economic growth, and the borrowers were unable to repay their debts.

Given this situation, the debtors pushed the Federal Government to re-issue non-backed currency into the economy. At the same time, the bankers who had issued those loans in the first place pressured the government to remain on the gold standard.

To anyone who is currently pushing the borderline conspiratorial anti-Fed platform: do you have any idea why the bankers would want the US government to remain on the gold standard in those conditions?

I should have given you enough information to at least make an informed guess.





As I said in the Monopoly Men thread - I am not saying the gold standard is unworkable. If you want to argue for gold, that's not a problem.

What is a problem is when one makes simplistic assumptions about gold being a kind of economic magical elixir that will fix our problems and make everyone wealthy (I use hyperbole, but some of the claims aren't far off this mark). There are issues with gold too, and those issues can be seen with a fairly cursory study of economics and history.
 
Wrong all the way around. There is plenty of gold, because any money supply is optimal. Prices adjust. The free market will expand the supply of gold as demanded, the same way it expands the supply of anything else. If gold were to somehow become so scarce as to inhibit the function of money, the market would seek substitutes, as it does with any other commodity.

Either way you are removing precious metals from the market that could be used for other purposes.

Gold spontaneously became the world standard money because of the market, not because of anyone's personal taste. It turns out that gold has the qualities that make for a well-functioning money. Had you read my article , you would know this now. The qualities are:

high demand

Only because people like its shiny nature. There's only limited uses non-monetary/jewelry uses for it.

high value to weight ratio

Again, as determined by human subjective need.

durability

So are lots of things.

divisibility
interchangeability

Sounds like the list is being padded.

I admit to not knowing a lot about economics, but I do know when something won't work. There are trillions of dollars in our economy right now, and no matter how much you inflate the price of gold there still won't be enough. Worse, you will cause massive damage to the industries that use those metals as you make them scarce by stuffing them into Fort Knox for no good reason.
 
our dollars will always be at least as valuable as a piece of paper, and they will never be less valuable than that cause how could a piece of paper be less valuable than a piece of paper.


Actually, US dollars aren't made out of paper. They're made out of cotton and linen. So you didn't even get that right.
 
No, Truthseeker. You just had a hard time understanding the difference between the Keynesian multiplier and the money multiplier.
 
Is it me, or did TS1234 argue that one of the reasons gold is valuable is because of it's high value/weight ratio?

Good to know that gold is valuable because it's valuable. That kind of information is very helpful when understanding economics.
 
Actually, US dollars aren't made out of paper. They're made out of cotton and linen. So you didn't even get that right.

Not to nitpick your nitpick, but linen/cotton based paper is still paper.

Now if he had said that dollars were made of wood pulp....
 
No, Truthseeker. You just had a hard time understanding the difference between the Keynesian multiplier and the money multiplier.

No Abby, you got confused. I called you on it, and you never answered any of my questions. I could probably dig up the email archive and post it with your permission. But it's irrelevant, the exchange contains no argument at all from you, only complete avoidance. Perhaps you could put your econ training to work and explain what you think is wrong with my opinion that fiat money creation is theft.

Here is Rothbard's treatise on money, freely available on line.

If there is something wrong with it, perhaps you could point out some errors, or link to anyone, anywhere who has critiqued it. AFAIK, it stands.

I'd be happy to link you to a rigorous dismantling of Keynes.
 
Is it me, or did TS1234 argue that one of the reasons gold is valuable is because of it's high value/weight ratio?

Good to know that gold is valuable because it's valuable. That kind of information is very helpful when understanding economics.

I said the market chose gold as money because gold has the most "money-ish" qualities. It is the market which says gold is money, not me. It seems you are wrestling with what Adam Smith couldn't figure out - the value paradox. Why is a diamond worth more than a loaf of bread, when bread is the staff of life?

Carl Menger figured out the value paradox, ushered in the marginalist revolution, and founded the Austrian school.

In a sense, the tautology you present is instructive. Ultimately, it doesn't matter why people value what they value, as long as they do so freely. When freedom is allowed, gold is money.
 
I said the market chose gold as money because gold has the most "money-ish" qualities. It is the market which says gold is money, not me. It seems you are wrestling with what Adam Smith couldn't figure out - the value paradox. Why is a diamond worth more than a loaf of bread, when bread is the staff of life?

I was pointing out the fact that one of your "why gold is valuable" arguments was circular, that's all.

I'm quite familiar with the concept of value and the determination of value on the market.

ETA: For clarification, you said that one of the reasons gold was used as a market currency was its high "value to weight" ratio. However, your reason that it was chosen as a currency medium relates to it having some a priori value, which it does not. You apparently grasp the idea that the market ultimately assigns value to everything, but fail to understand the paradox of then saying that gold was chosen as a currency medium because of high "value to weight."

That "quality" you mention is assigned by the humans that make up the market, it is not innate to gold. You should've stuck with things like "doesn't corrode," "looks nice," "can be divided up easily," "can be shaped easily," "looks nice," "is rare enough to not be everywhere but common enough to actually find," etc.

There are other substances, incidentally, that have higher value/weight ratios in the current market. Ironically, several world currencies (including the US dollar) are among those substances.

Carl Menger figured out the value paradox, ushered in the marginalist revolution, and founded the Austrian school.

In a sense, the tautology you present is instructive. Ultimately, it doesn't matter why people value what they value, as long as they do so freely. When freedom is allowed, gold is money.

What stops you from using gold as money right now, TruthSeeker? Who prevents you from trading in gold and how?
 
Last edited:
Either way you are removing precious metals from the market that could be used for other purposes.

There are always alternative uses for all commodities. How much milk should be made into cottage cheese, how much into ice cream, how much into butter, how much into yogurt? Only the market can decide this. Similarly, only the market can decide how much gold should be used to back money, and how much should be used for industrial and/or jewelry, etc.



Only because people like its shiny nature. There's only limited uses non-monetary/jewelry uses for it.

There are plenty of uses for gold, the most important of which is money.

Again, as determined by human subjective need.
Correct! You have stumbled onto two of the key insights of economics, in one sentence!

1. All economic activity is directed at fulfilling the wants and needs of people.

2. All valuation is subjective.


Sounds like the list [of money-ish qualities] is being padded.
A good money must be divisible into very small pieces, with the pieces still being valuable. Also it must be interchangeable, with one unit being the same value as another.

I admit to not knowing a lot about economics, but I do know when something won't work. There are trillions of dollars in our economy right now, and no matter how much you inflate the price of gold there still won't be enough. Worse, you will cause massive damage to the industries that use those metals as you make them scarce by stuffing them into Fort Knox for no good reason.
Sigh. The only way we can determine what sort of money works best is to allow the market to function. Fearing that the market would not supply enough gold is like fearing that it won't supply enough socks. When people demand more, the supply will be made to increase by those people in the business of producing it. Enforcing a monopoly in the production of money is evil, for the same reasons that any other monopoly is evil.
 
I was pointing out the fact that one of your "why gold is valuable" arguments was circular, that's all.

I was explaining why gold is a good money, not why gold is valuable. You have attributed to me a statement which I did not make, then used that to accuse me of a logical fallacy. That is itself a logical fallacy on your part. I thought you were smarter/more intellectually honest than this.
 
No Abby, you got confused. I called you on it, and you never answered any of my questions. I could probably dig up the email archive and post it with your permission. But it's irrelevant, the exchange contains no argument at all from you, only complete avoidance. Perhaps you could put your econ training to work and explain what you think is wrong with my opinion that fiat money creation is theft.

QUOTE]

Please do post it. But just to make sure. Tell me what is the difference between the money multiplier and the keynesian multiplier.
 
And just at first glance at the "problems with fiat money" on that rothbard page: he doesn't mention the benefits of a depreciated dollar.

Yes, it hurts importers... but it helps exporters. And in the US we have a horrible trade deficit. A deflated dollar alleviates this problem.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom