federal reserve conspiracy!!!

The same people who force me to submit an income tax return, pay income taxes, and use Federal Reserve notes to pay debts. And yes, if a debtor offers you legal tender to satisfy a debt, you are legally obliged to accept it or the debt is void. The only exception to this are debts which arise at the same time as your offer to pay. Which is why vending machines don't have to accept your $100 bill, but restaurants do.

This is the key to this misunderstanding. In no case, according to the US Treasury, is a private business obligated to accept Fed Notes. Thus, if you sell someone something, you are free to demand payment however you want.

The exception, according to the government and the court's interpretation of the matter, is with credit extended in the currency at hand. Thus, if I loan you $1,000 in USD, I can't suddenly decide I will refuse repayment in USD.

However, this applies to creditors only, not to businesses in general. If you are extending someone credit in dollars (loaning them USD), you are essentially drawing up a specific contract which, among other things, stipulates that repayment can be made in the original form of issue.

If you were to draw up a contract exchanging $1,000 for the future repayment of x ounces of gold, that would also be legally binding. An old-style gold certificate, something worth either x dollars or y amount of gold, is illegal. A contract of the sort I described is not.

To suggest that this law has broad implications on private transactions is misleading. If you do not wish to be obligated to accept dollars as repayment, then do not issue credit in such a manner. IMHO, to issue credit in dollars and then refuse to accept dollars as repayment without prior contractual stipulations would be extremely dishonest... somewhat like lending you my stereo and asking for your TV back instead because I happen to think it more valuable.

The pertinent US Treasury FAQ can be found here: http://www.ustreas.gov/education/faq/currency/legal-tender.shtml
 
You've just demonstrated why the original claim that rising wages cause higher prices is false. If we isolate the variable prices of labor and a general price index by keeping the money supply constant, then the wage/price cycle tends not to exist, thereby disqualifying it as a cause of inflation altogether. The price of labor rises along with many other prices under inflationary conditions. Happy to have you on board!

You celebrate victory prematurely, I fear.

The problem is that you cannot simply detach the concept of inflation from the currency system that exists in the real world. Inflation doesn't simply have one cause.

Not only that, but you can still have wage/price driven inflation with a fixed currency supply. If you allow for unemployment and technological improvement, you can have a situation where the workforce is reduced in order to raise profits (the lost workforce offset by increased efficiency or technology), prices are increased to respond to the lost profits from having fewer active consumers, wages are increased to respond to the higher prices and worker demands (due to higher prices), and so on.

The problem is that these things are very closely linked. Sure, inflation can drive wages up as well as prices, but those both tend to feed back into inflation. If you can really fix the currency supply, you can remove part of that feedback loop, but it's still possible for it to pop up in other ways.

That actually fixing the currency supply is a ridiculous simpification is beside the point. Fiat money isn't the only way that the currency supply fluctuates. Again, probably beside the point from a modeling perspective.
 
Incorrect. Any money the Fed lends to its member banks is inflationary due to the issuance of new currency. It is referred to as "high powered money" or the "monetary base", because when it is injected it becomes the apex of a pyramid, becoming the basis for multiple rounds of new bank deposits, thanks to the fractional reserve system. When the fed raises the discount rate, the higher cost of borrowing discourages member banks from borrowing and limits the supply of new money in this fashion. When it lowers the rate, assuming there is demand for new credit, the reverse is true.

Fed loans to member banks are short-term loans, not frequently used, and the discount rate has less of a direct impact on inflation than you might think. As I said, reserve requirements are a far more direct impact.

I fail to see any substantive difference between counterfeiters and central bankers, other than the relative legal status of their activities. I also don't see why counterfeit currency would necessarily be removed from circulation. I suppose that would depend on the quality of the counterfeiting.

If discovered, it will be removed from circulation.

You really cannot see a substantive difference between transactions carried out in plain sight with no intention of deceiving the participants of the mechanics involved and transactions carried out with the intent of concealing all knowledge of the activities involved, with knowledge limited to the counterfeiters only?

My evidence is the fact that the Fed's codifying principles are logically and morally corrupt, and its existence alone is systematically corrupt.

That is not evidence, that is your opinion.

Even if I did presume that the supply of money needed to be actively managed by men, reason would dictate that such a dangerous task be fully politically accountable. The idea that politicians are more or less corruptible than "independent" bankers strikes me as credulous.

Actually, the issue is that the politicians involved are responsible for obtaining funding for various projects. That interest tends to conflict with responsible money management.

No, that isn't true. Many "negative" economic effects can be described as more or less progressive. For instance, Congress is mulling over legislation that will tax private equity and limited partnerships as if they were private corporations. You could use a supply-side argument and say that the poor will be negatively affected by this, but I have a difficult time seeing how this will hurt the poor relatively the same or more than private equity.

From an overall economic standpoint, then, those wouldn't be negative outcomes. I'm talking about things that hurt overall purchasing power, economic growth, employment, etc. Those with less money are less able to bear the brunt of those effects.

FRB has everything to do with money creation. If the fed creates $100B in high powered money, that translates into roughly $1 trillion in the FRS. When demand deposits are treated simultaneously as assets and liabilities, this is de facto money creation. In contrast to the Fed whose money creation is virtually costless, at least banks have to pay their depositors a token amount. The fact that bankers can profit by this spread on money they have created out of nothing gives them an unfair advantage over every other business in existence. If you, I, or business X want to make a loan, we have to loan our own paid-in capital or savings. If Public Storage Inc. ran their business similar to banks, the owners would be jailed. If you want to make a time deposit with your bank, that's fine. But lets end the FRS on demand deposits. Promising two different sets of people money at the same time is the sole cause of bank runs. Instead of creating the Federal Reserve System, why don't we just solve the real problem?

The banks not only have to pay a "token amount," they owe their depositors the full amount deposited plus interest for whatever period the loan was made.

The disadvantage to FRB is that in order to satisfy all demand deposits, the loans outstanding must be called in to obtain the required capital. This takes some time to do, but does not mean that the desposits are unavailable, only that they are not immediately available.

It's still perfectly possible to use FRB in an environment without any fiat currency system. Hell, I could draw up a private, legally binding contract between you and I that would basically amount to FRB on a personal level.

It increases the money supply in that the bank releases the money from reserve holding, but that's a somewhat deceptive thing to say, especially if talking to someone unfamiliar with how the money supply is calculated. In colloquial terms, it doesn't create new currency so much as shuffle existing currency around and in and out of reserves. The money isn't "created out of nothing" as you imply, but is loaned on behalf of the customer as part of their agreement with the bank when they become a depositor.

The special GAAP rules for banks are an exception to law, not a "convention".

The GAAP are, in fact, conventions, whether or not you believe this to be the case. The GAAP conventions, though required to be followed by the SEC for their filings, are no codified in the law. There are several different conventions and filing requirements for different SEC-regulation entities. How does this provide an "exception to the law?"

No, we're not. But this justifies the unfair advantage that banks have how?

Unfair advantage? How, precisely? Because they can list their issued loans as a liability on their balance sheets?

Oddly, this doesn't seem to be harming the various successful non-banks too much.

For the same reason that plantation owners shouldn't be allowed to own slaves. It's immoral.

How is fractional reserve banking comparable to slavery? This smacks of a blatant appeal to emotion rather than a reasoned belief. The customer is aware that the bank will lend a portion of their deposit, generally in exchange for some interest payment (or for not charging a fee for the bank's various services). Nothing forces the consumer to choose the bank - they are free to invest their money where they see fit, or bury in a hole if they would like.

How this compares to the forcible abduction and enslavement of human beings who have no choice in the matter at any point, I can't quite fathom.

Or, more accurately, the bankers have set up a system whereby the risk of bank runs is socialized, while exceptionally gained bank profits are privatized.

The risk of bank runs exists as a risk to the customers of those banks. Ironically, it is also a function of the behavior of those customers. Also, the profits gained by those banks are realized to the consumer in the form of no-cost bank services and interest payments.

I as a full-fledged capitalist pig object to our banker overlords who have created a class of paper-pushing do-nothings, typified by that remora-like pinnacle of idleness, the "daytrader". Of course, the sharks themselves reside in London and Wall Street.

Don't day traders just buy and sell financial instruments for a living? How are they "remora-like?" Isn't that like claiming you're "remora-like" if you decide to invest on the stock market?
 
Simply creating money for the sake of money would crash the economy and would not benefit anyone. This notion that money should be based on an object who's value is determined by people, is not much of an improvement over directly putting a value on the money itself. It's pretty pointless.
 
Last edited:
Jonnyclueless you have to understand the basis of Tippit's point: ignorance. For him The Fed just hands out money to the government (he keeps thinking this even after the data contradicted his views) and handles the money supply using a personal criteria. In reality a central bank like The Fed follows a "simple" equation:

(M/P) = L(Y,r). That is: real balances equal the demand for money.

How can people like Tippit keep repeating the same lies? They don't know any better. If their claims were true the inflation rate would be pretty high, yet i would like them to point out when was the last time the U.S. experienced a two digits inflation rate.
 
And btw, fixing the money supply has two immediate effects:

It will restrict economic growth (hooray!!)

It will put pressure on the price level since credit will become more expensive and producers will have to raise their prices in order to pay for their obligations. (yaaaay!!)

At least we can rest assured that these things won't happen since, unlike Tippit and TS1234, the people in charge of these things do get a formal education on the subject.
 
abolish the practice of fractional reserve banking


I don't have the economics background of some of the posters here, but my study of history has led me to this conclusion: The establishment of the concept of fractional reserve banking is one of the most important in the history of civilization. It allowed growth and capital investment without first creating new wealth. That investment, in turn, made society more productive and repaid us with far, far more wealth than we could ever have acheived otherwise.

It is not an understatement to say that every road, bridge, school, factory and farm in the United States owes its existence to the concept of fractional reserve banking.

Abolishing the practice would destroy any hope of capital investment and almost completely freeze us in place at our level of technology and production forever.

I can think of no idea more certain to destroy the very fabric of civilization that does not have the words "bomb" and "nuclear" in it.
 
Tippit said:
My evidence is the fact that the Fed's codifying principles are logically and morally corrupt, and its existence alone is systematically corrupt.

Somebody forgot to tell you that stuff you make up isn't considered evidence.
 
I don't have the economics background of some of the posters here, but my study of history has led me to this conclusion: The establishment of the concept of fractional reserve banking is one of the most important in the history of civilization. It allowed growth and capital investment without first creating new wealth.

Ah, but to malcontents, it's theft.
 
This is the key to this misunderstanding. In no case, according to the US Treasury, is a private business obligated to accept Fed Notes. Thus, if you sell someone something, you are free to demand payment however you want.

The exception, according to the government and the court's interpretation of the matter, is with credit extended in the currency at hand. Thus, if I loan you $1,000 in USD, I can't suddenly decide I will refuse repayment in USD.

However, this applies to creditors only, not to businesses in general. If you are extending someone credit in dollars (loaning them USD), you are essentially drawing up a specific contract which, among other things, stipulates that repayment can be made in the original form of issue.

That is what I just said, there is no misunderstanding as we are in agreement. Legal tender laws apply to debts public and private that are not originated contemporaneously with an offer to pay.

If you were to draw up a contract exchanging $1,000 for the future repayment of x ounces of gold, that would also be legally binding. An old-style gold certificate, something worth either x dollars or y amount of gold, is illegal. A contract of the sort I described is not.

Why should the government favor a debt obligation denominated in fiat money over commodity money, such as gold or silver? Legal tender law creates a demand for fiat money. What is debatable is the extent of the demand it creates. As I specified before, the demand for fiat money is generated by a number of things, not limited to legal tender, income tax remittance, Gresham's Law, and lest we forget, convention.

If you're trying to argue that people actually want dollars, they don't. They want what dollars can buy. And none of this changes the fact that the dollar the Federal Reserve started with in 1913 is now worth only $.01. Money is supposed to be a medium of exchange, and a store of value, and with respect to the latter the Federal Reserve is a miserable failure, and I think we both understand how.

To suggest that this law has broad implications on private transactions is misleading. If you do not wish to be obligated to accept dollars as repayment, then do not issue credit in such a manner. IMHO, to issue credit in dollars and then refuse to accept dollars as repayment without prior contractual stipulations would be extremely dishonest... somewhat like lending you my stereo and asking for your TV back instead because I happen to think it more valuable.

Nowhere did I suggest rescinding or rewording contracts ex-post facto was honorable.
 
You celebrate victory prematurely, I fear.

The problem is that you cannot simply detach the concept of inflation from the currency system that exists in the real world. Inflation doesn't simply have one cause.

Inflation, as defined by a long term rise in the general price level, only has two causes, and both relate to the supply of money relative to goods and services. In reality, it typically has one cause, and that is the creation of new money for the vast profits of seigniorage.

Not only that, but you can still have wage/price driven inflation with a fixed currency supply. If you allow for unemployment and technological improvement, you can have a situation where the workforce is reduced in order to raise profits (the lost workforce offset by increased efficiency or technology), prices are increased to respond to the lost profits from having fewer active consumers, wages are increased to respond to the higher prices and worker demands (due to higher prices), and so on.

Layoffs result in temporarily less demand. Less demand is disinflationary, and leaves producers with a surplus. Producers with a surplus condition must lower prices such that supply meets the lower demand, and the equilibrium price is reached. Therefore, the statement "prices are increased to respond to the lost profits from having fewer active consumers" is untrue. Producers with a surplus have no pricing power at all.

My contention is that if prices are rising in one sector of the economy, whether it is wages, the price of oil, the price of wheat, or anything else, they will be generally offset by corresponding decreases in prices of other sectors, when the money is constant. It is not, of course, a zero-sum game. Price spirals are not positive but negative feedback loops, and are ultimately regulated by demand.

An example of non-monetary inflation would be increases in the price of oil. Since the demand for oil is relatively inelastic because there are few substitutes, and oil is a fundamental cost of doing business, increases in the oil price results in higher marginal costs across the board. Rational producers whose marginal costs begin to exceed market prices will cut production, and supply is thereby reduced. The cause of inflation hasn't changed, we still have too much money chasing fewer goods and services. This is actually worse than monetary inflation, because it affects real GDP. Exacerbating this problem would be a Fed that decided that in order to stabilize nominal prices, and "fight inflation" it had to tighten monetary policy. This would be an obvious disaster, akin to when the Fed tightened in mid 1929 and caused the Stock Market crash and the subsequent Great Depression.

The moral of the story is, prices can and do fluctuate, and shouldn't be managed. There is no long run inflation without new money, and in fact absent war or other wealth-destroying calamities, and given a constant supply of money, the natural state of prices is disinflationary (not deflationary), and this is a good and normal thing.
 
Fed loans to member banks are short-term loans, not frequently used, and the discount rate has less of a direct impact on inflation than you might think. As I said, reserve requirements are a far more direct impact.

What? Can you tell me the last time the reserve requirement ratio was changed? The discount rate and open market operations are the primary tools of central bank policy. Altering the reserve requirement ratio could have a substantial impact if it were ever actually done on a routine basis. Member bank loans are made frequently enough for the US stock market to essentially go on pause as it waits for Lord Bernanke to make his proclamation from on high. The impact of reserve ratio policy has already been felt, and hasn't changed for a very long time.

You really cannot see a substantive difference between transactions carried out in plain sight with no intention of deceiving the participants of the mechanics involved and transactions carried out with the intent of concealing all knowledge of the activities involved, with knowledge limited to the counterfeiters only?

I really cannot. Wealth is transferred either way. You can put lipstick on the pig, but it nevertheless remains a pig.

Actually, the issue is that the politicians involved are responsible for obtaining funding for various projects. That interest tends to conflict with responsible money management.

The existence of the Fed, and all the other central banks in the world guarantee that the politicians get their money, even when they run out of legitimate lenders. So if you're arguing that the Fed should be "independent" because the politicians would crank up the printing press, well, I've got news for you, it's happening anyway.

Why don't we eliminate the Fed and it's several hundred million dollar/yr operating cost, and save the US taxpayer the 6% yield that goes to the private member banks who hold its restricted stock, if for no other reason? Why should taxpayers pay any interest at all for the use of their own money?

In fairness, the ability of Congress to borrow endlessly is a distinct problem which is separate from, but not unrelated to the problems with the Federal Reserve System itself. In reality, they are incestuous twins.

The banks not only have to pay a "token amount," they owe their depositors the full amount deposited plus interest for whatever period the loan was made.

Yes, they owe it "on demand". Tell that to angry depositors who rightfully wanted their money throughout any of the bank failures over history.

The disadvantage to FRB is that in order to satisfy all demand deposits, the loans outstanding must be called in to obtain the required capital. This takes some time to do, but does not mean that the desposits are unavailable, only that they are not immediately available.

Then we have fraud. If the money is not available "on demand", then it isn't a "demand deposit", and the bank has defrauded the depositor. That's why banks have things called time deposits, or CDs. How many depositors in the bank runs that preceded the Great Depression got their money back on demand, if at all?

It's still perfectly possible to use FRB in an environment without any fiat currency system. Hell, I could draw up a private, legally binding contract between you and I that would basically amount to FRB on a personal level.

I never suggested FRB was dependent upon fiat money. It's obvious that it isn't. FRB existed during the fiduciary gold standard. The only reason it works is because of the substitutability of money. If I give you temporary custody of my car to store it, I expect you to do just that. If you sell my car short or lease it out for joyrides, you have committed fraud, and you deserve to go to jail. Why should it be any different for money? It is a logical contradiction and morally reprehensible to sell a "demand" deposit which is anything but. The fact that I may, if I'm lucky, get someone else's money as a substitute for my own doesn't justify the fraud, or remove the contradiction.

It increases the money supply in that the bank releases the money from reserve holding, but that's a somewhat deceptive thing to say, especially if talking to someone unfamiliar with how the money supply is calculated. In colloquial terms, it doesn't create new currency so much as shuffle existing currency around and in and out of reserves. The money isn't "created out of nothing" as you imply, but is loaned on behalf of the customer as part of their agreement with the bank when they become a depositor.

When a deposit exists as both a promise to be paid on demand (a liability), and as a loan on the balance sheet (an asset), you have the de facto creation of money, and in fact this is fully reflected in the exceptional accounting rules for banks under GAAP, as I previously pointed out. I am not guilty of the deception here.

The GAAP are, in fact, conventions, whether or not you believe this to be the case. The GAAP conventions, though required to be followed by the SEC for their filings, are no codified in the law. There are several different conventions and filing requirements for different SEC-regulation entities. How does this provide an "exception to the law?"

Ok, I stand corrected, as they are "accounting principles" rather than accounting law. But the fact remains, it is "generally accepted" that banks have some exclusive right to record liabilities as assets, and that if you as an incorporated non-bank attempt to file a 10-K and record your liabilities in a similar fashion you will most definitely receive a knock on the door from the SEC.

Unfair advantage? How, precisely? Because they can list their issued loans as a liability on their balance sheets?

Oddly, this doesn't seem to be harming the various successful non-banks too much.

Because the profit stream that is based on the spread between what they pay depositors and what they receive in fractional loans is an exclusive one to bankers. Either abolish the practice, or liberalize it.

How is fractional reserve banking comparable to slavery? This smacks of a blatant appeal to emotion rather than a reasoned belief. The customer is aware that the bank will lend a portion of their deposit, generally in exchange for some interest payment (or for not charging a fee for the bank's various services). Nothing forces the consumer to choose the bank - they are free to invest their money where they see fit, or bury in a hole if they would like.

How this compares to the forcible abduction and enslavement of human beings who have no choice in the matter at any point, I can't quite fathom.

Because the banking system is cartelized, the financial barriers to bank entry are high, and this necessitates wealth condensation. It is commonly referred to as "capital" rather than "chattel" slavery, and it is quite real, whether you can fathom it or not. It's the reason why more than half the world's 6.6B population live in abject poverty.

The risk of bank runs exists as a risk to the customers of those banks. Ironically, it is also a function of the behavior of those customers. Also, the profits gained by those banks are realized to the consumer in the form of no-cost bank services and interest payments.

Of course, the implication being that depositors themselves are to blame for bank runs.

Don't day traders just buy and sell financial instruments for a living? How are they "remora-like?" Isn't that like claiming you're "remora-like" if you decide to invest on the stock market?

It certainly is, and I am a big beneficiary of the capital markets. Of course, there is nothing inherently wrong with equity markets. The problem again goes back to monetary manipulation that has resulted in a class of idle-rich who are entirely parasitical and contribute little-to-no value to society at large, and the inflation of capital and real estate markets. Perhaps more importantly, it has created a super-class of immensely wealthy people who are at the top of the monetary pyramid, and who wield inordinate influence over everything.
 
I really hate to necro this thread after a month, but I've been taking a course on money & banking this semester, and learned some additional information about credit issuance that some others might find interesting.

Banks are not, in fact, special in how they report credit as an asset. In any situation where an SSU (surplus spending unit) loans money to a DSU (deficit spending unit) the issuance of credit ultimately results in two marks on the asset column of the SSU, one mark on the asset column of the DSU, and one mark on the liability column for the DSU.

The SSU marks the money given to the DSU as a negative on their asset column, and puts in a positive entry for the claim they have against the DSU for repayment.

Likewise, the DSU marks the money received as an asset, and the corresponding liability to repay the SSU as a liability (duh, I suppose).

This is the case for all SSUs, including private individuals. The money loaned to the DSU is a negative asset (not a liability), and the direct claim against the DSU is the corresponding positive asset. The DSU then picks up the asset of the money and the liability of the direct claim.

When a financial intermediary is involved, the situation simply gains another step. The SSU (the person investing) lends to the FI (financial intermediary - the bank), who lend in turn to the DSU. The SSU marks their payment as a negative asset and their claim against the FI as a positive asset. The FI marks the money from the SSU as a + asset and the money to the DSU as a - asset, along with the direct claim against the DSU as a + asset. The FI also has the liability of the claim the SSU holds against the loan to the FI. Finally, the DSU has the + asset of the money from the FI, and the liability of the direct claim the FI has on their loan.

They are not, in fact, recording their own liabilities as assets. If that was what was being implied, then there is an issue of confusing negative assets for liabilities, or possibly confusing liabilities to the SSU with the direct claim against the DSU (which is a + asset). They are not the same thing, and to suggest otherwise is to be very careless with the accounting involved.

And no, it does not appear that banks are special in how they record this information. The GAAP may have particular conventions for recording bank transactions due to the nature of the transactions involved, but this in no way confers on the banks some special ability to record their own liabilities as assets.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom