Truthseeker1234, can’t you get anything right?
If I have two loaves of bread, I value each one less than if I only had one loaf of bread.
You get a lesser amount of utility for each additional unit you consume. You already derived utility from the goods you consumed so it makes no sense to state that an additional unit of a good makes you derive less utility from the goods you already consumed.
Utility depends on consumption, not on what you hold or depart with. I get the impression that you are confusing hoarding with consumption because your particular analysis is based on what the individuals depart with and what they hoard, instead of what they consume (Cobb-Douglas, for example).
Formally a consumption function would be expressed like: U(x,y) where x and y are the amount of units consumed of each good. Marginal utility is just the first derivative of this function respect to which good's marginal utility we’re interested on; that is dU/dx and dU/dy for x and y respectively.
Can you show us a formal definition of your bread “model”? I am very curious about how you will make hoarding and trading, which are the basis of your “model”, part of a utility function. What kind of utility function can be defined like this?
This is what Adam Smith could not figure out, with his value paradox.
It is quite funny that after making such an absurd description of the marginal utility concept you would have the arrogance to say something like this. Ignorance is bliss.
Alan, stop it. I never said anything about "the one I bought before it". If I have two loaves of bread, I value each one less than if I only had one loaf of bread. I might give away my second-to-the last loaf of bread. I would never give away my last loaf of bread, for I would starve.
Seeing how clueless you are about anything related to economics, who knows you tried to say? We do have your actual words:
I said I would value my last loaf of bread more than I would value my second-to-the-last loaf.
The fact that a demand function usually has a negative slope is enough to prove this thing you are saying is just nonsense. Grab a book someday and quit making stuff up.
This explains how identical things can be valued differently, destroying Loss Leader's (archaic) notion that things have some underlying inherent value.
Your explanation is absurd, the only thing it explains is how much you need to read about basic microeconomic theory.