federal reserve conspiracy!!!

Solerno explains marginalism with a desert island example. Say a guy has 6 identical bushels of wheat. He has earmarked many different uses for the wheat, which he can rank in order of importance to him.

The first bushel he needs just to survive.
The second bushel he needs to be strong and have lots of energy.
The third bushel he wants to feed to his chickens, so he can have eggs.
The fourth bushel is for trade.
The fifth bushel is to feed his pet monkey, for amusement.
The sixth bushel is to ferment into alcoholic beverage.

First, that can't be a desert island if there is someone or some place to trade with. But the real world does have other people or places in it.

This immediately calls into question the whole model and the basis for it. Why can't the guy trade away all his bushels of wheat instead? Maybe for a freezer full of steaks and a MLB franchise?

I think you genuinely don't understand what creates wealth (individual or national) or why a reliable money supply is vital to capitalism.
 
This explains how identical things can be valued differently, destroying Loss Leader's (archaic) notion that things have some underlying inherent value.


Um, it doesn't destroy my anything. All I said was that you were using the word "value" wrong while fully endorsing the concept of marginal utility which you had described but mislabled. If I sell a loaf of bread for $3.00, the loaf of bread and the $3.00 have the same value. They may, to the actors, have different marginal utilities.

Nowhere did I claim that the bread has an "inherent" value of anything. However, by making the trade, the bread took on a value at that moment of exactly $3.00. The actors set the value, I didn't.
 
Easy.

Perhaps when the two are stranded, they both have high hopes of being rescued very soon, and taken back to the larger society where lots of people still value the kind of money they have. The use of money on an island is not "completely superfluous". Money is a medium of exchange. That is its function.

In the absence of pre-existing money, the two guys would likely adopt a new medium of exchange, perhaps coconuts, or flashlight batteries. It would have to be something both guys valued. Money must originate as a commodity of value.

I was talking specifically about the pre-existing money which you gave the mysterious value to in the minds of our castaways. I thought that was obvious. You're basically just repeating what I already said:

[the preexisting money]'s only real value would be determined solely by how likely either person considered the possibility of rescue: a sort of gamble based on a number of contingencies left unspecified in your hypothetical.

And as far as adopting a new currency that they can use on the island such as batteries or whatever: sure, that's a possibility. They wouldn't necessarily need it, as a market of only two people on a desert island really doesn't need to be that complicated. But so what if they did? What does any of this prove?

TruthSeeker1234 said:
As the days pass by, perhaps one of the castaways becomes more pessimistic about being rescued, while the other remains hopeful, and adopts a strategy of selling all his goods for the money. Perhaps he ends up with millions of "dollars" while the other guy ends up with goods that would only be worth a few thousand dollars back in the larger society.

You see, perhaps both guys rationally thought they were getting the better end of the deal. The future is always uncertain, and different people can and do make different judgments about what the future may hold.

Of course people make different judgments about the future. If they happen to get rescued the next day, then the guy who traded all his pre-existing money for stuff that's mostly worthless off the island is screwed out of however much money he had on him when they were shipwrecked, and the other gets to go to Disneyland or something. So what?

TruthSeeker1234 said:
This is just one possible rational explanation for why the pre-existing money continued to have value to the two guys. It's not necessary to know exactly why, because it is logically evident from the hypothetical that they did value it, for some reason, because they were willing to accept it in trade.

That doesn't cut it. You cannot just say the money has value to these people without giving a reason why. If the premises are unsound then the hypothetical does not correspond to the real world and thus has no explanatory power and is essentially useless. If all you're trying to say is that money has no inherent value, just say that. It's not something particularly deep and doesn't require a convoluted hypothetical like the one you made to demonstrate it. Of course there's always risk and if the U.S. government were overthrown tomorrow by a bunch of Ace Baker clones, yeah, people would lose faith in the value of the dollar and it would undergo hyperinflation and we'd all be screwed. But if you're trying to make it out like the precarious situation the two castaways found themselves in is reflective of the circumstances of the real world today in terms of the dollar's value, I dispute that.
 
Oh yes there is. The money must have had pre-existing value to both guys, or they never would have been able to spend it on the island.

Depends. They could just as easily decide that cocoa nuts are their new currency, now.

Incidently I'd like to ask you a question about the gold thing:

Assuming you have a country with 50 million people, and a gold reserve used as money. Assuming you don't mine any more gold, and in a century that population blooms to 500 million, what happens ?
 
I did not introduce one element into the hypothetical that could not be derived logically.

Again, typical truther claptrap. You just make stuff up as you go and call it "logic". When making a hypothetical, you can't alter the rules of the game just because you realise that something was missing.

Perhaps when the two are stranded, they both have high hopes of being rescued very soon

There you go. Adding stuff again.

You may wish that you were the great negotiator, but you have revealed yourself to be the moron. You are the one who stubbornly cannot tell the difference between money and wealth.

There is NO difference between money and wealth because both depend on whether or not someone wants what you have.

Whenever two people trade, they value the objects being traded in the opposite order. When you buy a loaf of bread from the store, you are saying that you value the loaf of bread more than you value the $3 it costs.

Actually, equal to or more than. And you don't necessarily trade for something you value. You could trade for something someone ELSE values because you have future trades in mind.

Fiat money cannot exist on the free market.

That's funny. That means there was never a free market.
 
In theory, any commodity could function on the market as money. In practice, the market chose precious metals as the best-functioning money

Why ? Metals aren't "precious" unless people want them a lot. Same thing with any other type of money. Currency is, basically, a social agreement to use an abstract form of goods instead of bartering.
 
This explains how identical things can be valued differently, destroying Loss Leader's (archaic) notion that things have some underlying inherent value.

Things only have the value that we place on them. Gold is a thing, yet you claim it magically has inherent value. Do you see how you just contradicted yourself?
 
Things only have the value that we place on them. Gold is a thing, yet you claim it magically has inherent value. Do you see how you just contradicted yourself?

I never made any such claim. It was the market which selected gold as the best functioning money, not me. The market, as in the combined subjective decisions of billions of people over thousands of years. That this occurred is an objective fact. There is nothing magical about it.
 
I never made any such claim. It was the market which selected gold as the best functioning money, not me. The market, as in the combined subjective decisions of billions of people over thousands of years. That this occurred is an objective fact. There is nothing magical about it.

Yes at one time the market choose gold. Now the market has switched to fiat money because the gold standard was no longer able to suffice. That is the beauty of the market, it is the unstoppable force. If the market really demanded the gold standard it would get it.
 


There are tremendous "so what" answers. Ludwig von Mises wrote a masterpiece called "Human Action". It presents an entire theory of economics and politics. It includes money, inflation, the business cycle, unemployment, why socialism can't work, etc. etc. It is completely derived by proceeding logically from a few very basic, a priori starting points. His assumptions were basically, "Humans exist" and "Humans act purposefully".

In contrast, the so-called mainstream economists have proceeded by attempting to understand macro phenomena from the top down, by employing calculus and "econometrics". It sounds fancy, but the problem is, this approach has never actually understood anything. It has no predictive value that I am aware of. In other words, it is BS.

Ideas such as "When two people agree to trade, they value the items in reverse order" are well worth arguing over. The next step from there is to understand that voluntary trade is always a net plus for the world. Two people are made better off, and no one is made worse off.

Coerced trade, that is "theft", is not a net plus for the world. One person is made better off, and one is made worse off.

Does this give you some insight about "So What"?
 
Truthseeker1234, can’t you get anything right?

If I have two loaves of bread, I value each one less than if I only had one loaf of bread.

You get a lesser amount of utility for each additional unit you consume. You already derived utility from the goods you consumed so it makes no sense to state that an additional unit of a good makes you derive less utility from the goods you already consumed.

Utility depends on consumption, not on what you hold or depart with. I get the impression that you are confusing hoarding with consumption because your particular analysis is based on what the individuals depart with and what they hoard, instead of what they consume (Cobb-Douglas, for example).

Formally a consumption function would be expressed like: U(x,y) where x and y are the amount of units consumed of each good. Marginal utility is just the first derivative of this function respect to which good's marginal utility we’re interested on; that is dU/dx and dU/dy for x and y respectively.

Can you show us a formal definition of your bread “model”? I am very curious about how you will make hoarding and trading, which are the basis of your “model”, part of a utility function. What kind of utility function can be defined like this?

This is what Adam Smith could not figure out, with his value paradox.

It is quite funny that after making such an absurd description of the marginal utility concept you would have the arrogance to say something like this. Ignorance is bliss.

Alan, stop it. I never said anything about "the one I bought before it". If I have two loaves of bread, I value each one less than if I only had one loaf of bread. I might give away my second-to-the last loaf of bread. I would never give away my last loaf of bread, for I would starve.

Seeing how clueless you are about anything related to economics, who knows you tried to say? We do have your actual words: I said I would value my last loaf of bread more than I would value my second-to-the-last loaf.

The fact that a demand function usually has a negative slope is enough to prove this thing you are saying is just nonsense. Grab a book someday and quit making stuff up.

This explains how identical things can be valued differently, destroying Loss Leader's (archaic) notion that things have some underlying inherent value.

Your explanation is absurd, the only thing it explains is how much you need to read about basic microeconomic theory.
 
The example I used to describe marginal utility is taken from Carl Menger. Carl Menger is the person who discovered it. It's like arguing about the structure of the double helix with Crick and Watson.
 
Yes at one time the market choose gold. Now the market has switched to fiat money because the gold standard was no longer able to suffice. That is the beauty of the market, it is the unstoppable force. If the market really demanded the gold standard it would get it.

Obviously we must have radically different definitions of the market. I define the market as that situation which occurs under purely voluntary exchange. How do you define it?
 
Obviously we must have radically different definitions of the market. I define the market as that situation which occurs under purely voluntary exchange. How do you define it?



Nothing occurs under purely voluntary exchange.

How many battleships have been built by neighbors taking up a collection for their common defense? How many prison inmates voluntarily exchanged their freedom for the goods and services available in jail? How many potholes have been filled?

The concept that there is some libertarian utopia waiting for us just as soon as the government releases its evil grip is as intellectually poor as ... well ... as the concept that the World Trade Center was destroyed by that very same government.
 
Obviously we must have radically different definitions of the market. I define the market as that situation which occurs under purely voluntary exchange. How do you define it?
This is quite ridiculous.

You may be suggesting (and your models have confirmed it) that the only reason for a trade of goods or services is a surplus of mean commodities. This is entirely false. Singapore nor Hong Kong would either exist or flourish under your assumptions.

Those entities produce little in the way of mean commodities. They are built only on the essentials of trade.

The United Kingdom is not far off that example. And, were it not for its spectacular blessings of arable land, minerals, and an educated population, the United States would be just another big empty place with nothing happening.

Why do you suppose that trade flourishes when currency is sound and flounders when it isn't? Why did Imperial Spain collapse, in spite of regular shipments of precious metals, while Republican Venice, with no intrinsic source of precious metals, thrived? Do you know anything about the regulation of currency in Venice during the Renaissance?

I also agree fully with some of the other participants that you keep on adding complexities to your "simple" desert island example. Why do you do this? Is the original example faulty? How?
 
well damn, hawaii has nothing to offer and the main "source" of revenue is tourism . we no longer export alot of things including produce because you can grow pineapples, bannanas and other such produce cheaply in signapore and thailand. we import everything; from toilet paper to the lumber to build our homes.

so please tell us how there can be an "excess" of something when the state has to import nearly every little thing into it; and we exactly can't export out tourism
 
The example I used to describe marginal utility is taken from Carl Menger. Carl Menger is the person who discovered it. It's like arguing about the structure of the double helix with Crick and Watson.

Misquoting someone does not absolve you from making sense Truthseeker1234. What you said made no sense and could not come from an economist. Quit making stuff up, ok?
 
Obviously we must have radically different definitions of the market. I define the market as that situation which occurs under purely voluntary exchange. How do you define it?

So you are saying that all the governments that switched from the gold standard to fiat money were forced by someone? Who has the power to make countries to what he wants? Individuals do not make monetary policy, governments do. They voluntararily made the switch.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom