I would disagree with his assertion. When gold is money, gold mining is inflationary, and gold miners obtain a monetary gain when the price of gold exceeds their cost to mine it. Similarly, the creators of fiat money experience a monetary gain when they spend or lend new money into existence.
Certainly, as the gold miners are directly selling the product on the market. But how is that analogous to the creators of a fiat currency? Which creators, anyway? The entities that print the currency? The entities that put the money into circulation? The board members of the reserve bank? The member banks?
How is the monetary gain realized? If this is the case, why don't those with the ability to create money simply print a whole lot of it and retire to a nice island somewhere?
The claim has been made several times in this thread that fiat money is theft, or that its creation benefits the "money makers," so to speak. How exactly is that the case? How do the people in control of the supply ultimately benefit, in your opinion, from the creation of additional currency, or from inflation?
I'm having trouble seeing this conceptually. It seems that those with some level of investment in, say, loans (e.g. banks) would prefer that the currency retain as much value per unit as possible, and thus would want inflation to be controlled.
One could argue that the former is more legitimate than the latter, since presumably anyone is free to mine gold at relatively high cost, yet the supply of the latter is negligibly cheap, is monopolized and protected by counterfeiting laws, and the demand ensured by legal tender laws and the necessity to remit Federal income taxes.
It seems that the demand isn't really ensured at all. The fact that inflation exists at all would suggest that the demand for fiat currency is highly variable.
I suppose Federal taxes ensure there is always some baseline demand in the sense of
someone wanting the money. Still, that's not to say that the currency itself will retain a high level of demand on the market that ensures any kind of value.
Yes, but the potential for these supply shocks exist for all forms of money, and even more so with fiat money.
Sure, I wasn't questioning that.
For instance, the value of the US dollar right now depends not only on the Fed's monetary policy, but on China's dollar policy, as they have been financing our trade deficit for years. If China decides to start liquidating its massive stock of dollars, the dollar will not so much implode as evaporate.
Yes, that could potentially become an issue. Any idea what we could do about it?
ETA: I say "potentially" because the trade deficit - a sign that other countries are investing in our own - is not necessarily a bad thing.
I think it's important to point out that ever since money has existed, groups have tried to manipulate its value for their own gain, and gold was no exception.
No question.
Another poster in this thread referred to William Jennings Bryan and his famous "Cross of Gold" speech. In this speech Bryan was not calling to abolish gold as money, but rather advocating a bi-metallic standard introducing silver convertible at 16:1. This was in order to relieve his main street constituents, who were suffering under the Wall Street banker's oligopoly on gold. I don't think gold itself is to blame for why the bankers obtained an oligopoly on it, but rather the fractional reserve banking system.
I am wary of calls to return to a gold standard, because no one owns more gold than the central banks themselves, and it could be a disaster. However, this is in no way a defense of the Federal Reserve, fiat money, or the fractional reserve banking system, which are evolving disasters, and they all need to be abolished.
As another poster asked: What do you propose that we do instead?
People are currently free enough on the market that, if they had the will, they could effectively abolish those things. Stop putting money into banks, invest in commodities rather than holding fiat currency, and convert small amounts to currency in the short run only to pay taxes and bills. But I'm guessing you would prefer a more permanent solution, so what would you propose?
I don't think any money system is perfect, but the one we currently use seems to work fairly well, most of the time. We have inflation to contend with, but we also have a decent way of adjusting for economic expansion, and unemployment is quite low. Also, the current rate of inflation is fairly easy to manage.
If you have a suggestion that will increase overall purchasing power without seriously sacrificing economic growth or jacking up unemployment, I'd be very interested in hearing the details.