federal reserve conspiracy!!!

It seems that the market has selected a wide variety of fiat currencies as the best functioning money today.

This thread has rambled a bit since I stopped following it because my son was born, but how again would, say, mining more gold not create inflation? If the amount of currency medium on the market increases, the value of it in exchange tends to decrease. How is that not true of gold, especially as it has little utility except as a medium of exchange or a means of ornamentation?

Congratulations on your son. Mining gold is inflationary to the extent it is used as money, and the annual rate is somewhere between two and three percent. Production has decreased somewhat, and last year the rate was about 1.5%. In addition, since production doesn't scale with the aggregate, the rate of gold inflation is generally on the decline, sometimes offset by technology and productivity gains.
 
Congratulations on your son. Mining gold is inflationary to the extent it is used as money, and the annual rate is somewhere between two and three percent. Production has decreased somewhat, and last year the rate was about 1.5%. In addition, since production doesn't scale with the aggregate, the rate of gold inflation is generally on the decline, sometimes offset by technology and productivity gains.

Thank you.

My comment was specifically directed at TruthSeeker, who said before I left this discussion that mining gold was not inflationary because it created additional wealth.

Quite true. Additionally, there is a physical limit to the amount of gold in the world, thus ultimately limiting inflation of gold in the market.

There is also the possibility of shorter-term inflation (or deflation) created by the introduction of gold into the market from private reserves, or the purchase and holding of gold in reserve. I haven't studied the market for gold enough to know how much of a factor either of those things are, but in theory they would have a similar impact on the gold supply as bank reserve rates have on the money supply for non-gold currencies.
 
Monetizing government debt more than qualifies as "taking an active role in the economy". The Fed's job is to make sure that Congress gets all of the money that it could possibly want to spend. To the extent that the supply of US government IOUs goes unmet by the demand of US investors, and foreign creditors, the Fed stands ready as "lender of last resort" to monetize those IOUs and provide congress with the money it needs to deficit spend. The difference between foreign and US investors and the Fed is, the Fed has the ability to create money out of "thin-air" by crediting the account of a Wall Street bond broker. This is known as "high-powered money", and is also highly inflationary, reducing the purchasing power of all pre-existing Federal Reserve Notes. The Fed, far from being a valiant warrior in the fight against inflation, is actually the primary cause of inflation.

The argument that central banks should be "independent" is dangerous. The idea that control over the single most important aspect of our economy - our money - should be delegated to bankers is wrong, it should fall firmly within the realm of political accountability, or, left to the market entirely.

And we are supposed to take your word for it? How much from the government expenditures are being financed in this way? What percentage of the GDP this monetized debt represents?

I hope you do a better job than Truthseeker at backing up your claims with publicly available data.
 
Quite true. Additionally, there is a physical limit to the amount of gold in the world, thus ultimately limiting inflation of gold in the market.

This finite nature is also an indirect cause of inflation. When the demand for credit goes up, the only thing banks can do is raise the interest raise which makes credit more expensive. Producers have to raise their prices to compensate for the erosion of the benefits caused by the payments of their obligations.
 
Thank you.

My comment was specifically directed at TruthSeeker, who said before I left this discussion that mining gold was not inflationary because it created additional wealth.
I would disagree with his assertion. When gold is money, gold mining is inflationary, and gold miners obtain a monetary gain when the price of gold exceeds their cost to mine it. Similarly, the creators of fiat money experience a monetary gain when they spend or lend new money into existence. One could argue that the former is more legitimate than the latter, since presumably anyone is free to mine gold at relatively high cost, yet the supply of the latter is negligibly cheap, is monopolized and protected by counterfeiting laws, and the demand ensured by legal tender laws and the necessity to remit Federal income taxes.

Quite true. Additionally, there is a physical limit to the amount of gold in the world, thus ultimately limiting inflation of gold in the market.

There is also the possibility of shorter-term inflation (or deflation) created by the introduction of gold into the market from private reserves, or the purchase and holding of gold in reserve. I haven't studied the market for gold enough to know how much of a factor either of those things are, but in theory they would have a similar impact on the gold supply as bank reserve rates have on the money supply for non-gold currencies.

Yes, but the potential for these supply shocks exist for all forms of money, and even more so with fiat money. For instance, the value of the US dollar right now depends not only on the Fed's monetary policy, but on China's dollar policy, as they have been financing our trade deficit for years. If China decides to start liquidating its massive stock of dollars, the dollar will not so much implode as evaporate.

I think it's important to point out that ever since money has existed, groups have tried to manipulate its value for their own gain, and gold was no exception. Another poster in this thread referred to William Jennings Bryan and his famous "Cross of Gold" speech. In this speech Bryan was not calling to abolish gold as money, but rather advocating a bi-metallic standard introducing silver convertible at 16:1. This was in order to relieve his main street constituents, who were suffering under the Wall Street banker's oligopoly on gold. I don't think gold itself is to blame for why the bankers obtained an oligopoly on it, but rather the fractional reserve banking system.

I am wary of calls to return to a gold standard, because no one owns more gold than the central banks themselves, and it could be a disaster. However, this is in no way a defense of the Federal Reserve, fiat money, or the fractional reserve banking system, which are evolving disasters, and they all need to be abolished.
 
And we are supposed to take your word for it? How much from the government expenditures are being financed in this way? What percentage of the GDP this monetized debt represents?

I hope you do a better job than Truthseeker at backing up your claims with publicly available data.

You're supposed to know how the Fed works already, having taken the moniker of a former Fed Chairman. I hope you take this opportunity to drop your condescending attitude and possibly learn something.

According to the US Treasury's Financial Management Service Ownership of Federal Securities table OFS-1, as of March 2007 the Federal Reserve holds $777.348 billion dollars worth of US Government obligations.

(source: www-fms-treas-gov/bulletin/b2007-2ofs.doc)

According to FMS table FD-1.—Summary of Federal Debt, as of March 2007 the total outstanding Federal Debt is $8.873 trillion dollars.

(source: www-fms-treas-gov/bulletin/b2007-2fd.doc)

Thus the Fed holds about 8.8% of the outstanding national debt, all of this portion being inflationary. In addition roughly $2.2T is held by foreigners of which the lion's share is owned by foreign central banks, all with their own inflationary fiat money regimes that operate in a similar fashion. You are free to do the budget and GDP calculations yourself.

The story doesn't end here, however. In fact, most of the action is in the private sector. Open market operations are only one of the three basic tools of monetary policy. The other two are the discount rate, which is the rate the Fed charges its member banks for loans, and the reserve requirement ratio, which is the rate banks are required to keep on reserve. The latter is 10% for liabilities in excess of $45.8M, and hasn't changed much since the Great Depression.

(source www-federalreserve-gov/monetarypolicy/reservereq.htm)

Just like its open market operations, when the Fed lends money to a member bank it merely credits the bank's account with the fed by an electronic bookkeeping entry. The Fed controls the demand for these loans by manipulating the discount rate. When the loans are repaid the debt is simply canceled and the money extinguished.

The simple money multiplier is defined as the reciprocal of the reserve requirement ratio. For most bank liabilities, this is 10%, giving us a multiplier of 10. If we focus merely on the Fed's cumulative open market activity as documented above, the inflationary effect is roughly one order of magnitude higher then the value of their outstanding debt, or about $7.8 trillion dollars. That's a lot of lost purchasing power, and it doesn't even consider their loans to member banks.

Where did it all go?
 
Tippit:

Government expenditures is a flow variable, so is the the percentage of these expenditures that is financed with debt with the Central Bank. The total stock of debt is a stock variable. The fact that you replied with a stock variable when i asked for a flow variable makes me think you are not very familiar with economic literature. But hey, at least you did more than Truthseeker1234.

According to the US Treasury's Financial Management Service Ownership of Federal Securities table OFS-1, as of March 2007 the Federal Reserve holds $777.348 billion dollars worth of US Government obligations.

Inflation is a flow variable, why are you using the total stock of debt held by the Central Bank in your analysis? In case you did not know, a stock variable can't affect a flow variable.

Let's find our flow variable then, according to the table you brought up the stock of debt for years 2002 and 2003 was 628,414 and 654,593 million dollars respectively. The difference between these amounts is the amount of government expenditures financed by The Fed for the year 2003. That is: 26,179 million dollars. Government expenditures for the same year were 3,410.5 billion dollars according to the white house.. With a simple glance anyone can realize that The Fed financed a very small part of the government expenditures, approximately only 0.8%. How can you claim that The Fed is a primary cause of inflation when it financed less than 1% of total government expenditures on 2003? You obviously don't know a thing about what you are saying here.

Thus the Fed holds about 8.8% of the outstanding national debt, all of this portion being inflationary.

Inflation is a flow variable, total debt is a stock variable. If you ever get some formal education on this subject you'll learn that a stock variable does not affect a flow variable.

Or perhaps you made an innovating model that describes how the total stock of debt owed by the government to the Central Bank affects the price level.

You are free to do the budget and GDP calculations yourself.

At the beginning of this post i already calculated the share of the government expenditures The Fed financed during the year 2003 ... even if it was you who should have done it, since you are the one claiming that The Fed's monetary poolicy is a primary cause of inflation.

Using the same data we used for the expenditures share, let's find the ratio of the GDP represented by these 26,179 million dollars The Fed lent to the government. GDP for the year 2003 was 10,400 billion, so that means that the share of government expenditures financed by The Fed represented approx. a mere 0.25% of the GDP.

The story doesn't end here, however. In fact, most of the action is in the private sector. Open market operations are only one of the three basic tools of monetary policy. The other two are the discount rate, which is the rate the Fed charges its member banks for loans, and the reserve requirement ratio, which is the rate banks are required to keep on reserve. The latter is 10% for liabilities in excess of $45.8M, and hasn't changed much since the Great Depression.

(source www-federalreserve-gov/monetarypolicy/reservereq.htm)

Just like its open market operations, when the Fed lends money to a member bank it merely credits the bank's account with the fed by an electronic bookkeeping entry. The Fed controls the demand for these loans by manipulating the discount rate. When the loans are repaid the debt is simply canceled and the money extinguished.

And why exactly is this a bad thing?

The simple money multiplier is defined as the reciprocal of the reserve requirement ratio.

Where on earth did you get that definition? The money multiplier is the ratio between M1 and M0. This definition comes from a simple math operation:

M1 = μM0
μ = M1/M0

Since the rest of your comment was based on this absurd definition you came up with, there is no need to even address it ... although one might think it is impossible, the second part makes even less sense.

Where did it all go?

Nowhere, the number you reached was based on an absurd definition of the money multiplier.

I hope you take this opportunity to drop your condescending attitude and possibly learn something.

Yes, thank you for the opportunity to learn that even when there is access to the information, people like you will still be making absurd and uninformed claims.
 
Tippit:

Government expenditures is a flow variable, so is the the percentage of these expenditures that is financed with debt with the Central Bank. The total stock of debt is a stock variable. The fact that you replied with a stock variable when i asked for a flow variable makes me think you are not very familiar with economic literature. But hey, at least you did more than Truthseeker1234.



Inflation is a flow variable, why are you using the total stock of debt held by the Central Bank in your analysis? In case you did not know, a stock variable can't affect a flow variable.

Now you're just being dishonest in a pathetic attempt to save face, with the implication that I can't tell the difference between an income statement and a balance sheet. I used the total stock of debt held by the Fed because it answers a far more relevant question by showing what the cumulative inflationary effect of the Fed's open market activity has been. I even told you that you could do the budget and GDP calculations yourself.

Let's find our flow variable then, according to the table you brought up the stock of debt for years 2002 and 2003 was 628,414 and 654,593 million dollars respectively. The difference between these amounts is the amount of government expenditures financed by The Fed for the year 2003. That is: 26,179 million dollars. Government expenditures for the same year were 3,410.5 billion dollars according to the white house.. With a simple glance anyone can realize that The Fed financed a very small part of the government expenditures, approximately only 0.8%. How can you claim that The Fed is a primary cause of inflation when it financed less than 1% of total government expenditures on 2003? You obviously don't know a thing about what you are saying here.



Inflation is a flow variable, total debt is a stock variable. If you ever get some formal education on this subject you'll learn that a stock variable does not affect a flow variable.

Or perhaps you made an innovating model that describes how the total stock of debt owed by the government to the Central Bank affects the price level.

Considering that you weren't aware that the Federal Reserve is a bank of issue, and that its open market purchases and lendings to member banks are additive to the money stock, I find it ironic that you would question my education when it is yours that is in question. After I analyzed the Fed and the US Government's balance sheet while instructing you to do your own budget (flow) and GDP (flow) analysis, you took the opportunity to waste time with a windy and condescending post about nothing substantial.

At the beginning of this post i already calculated the share of the government expenditures The Fed financed during the year 2003 ... even if it was you who should have done it, since you are the one claiming that The Fed's monetary poolicy is a primary cause of inflation.

I just showed how the cumulative Fed Open Market policy has resulted in approximately ~$7.8 trillion worth of inflationary dollars.

Using the same data we used for the expenditures share, let's find the ratio of the GDP represented by these 26,179 million dollars The Fed lent to the government. GDP for the year 2003 was 10,400 billion, so that means that the share of government expenditures financed by The Fed represented approx. a mere 0.25% of the GDP.




And why exactly is this a bad thing?

Since you weren't even aware the Fed is a bank of issue, it's not surprising that you're totally ignorant of such concepts as "high powered money" and the "simple money multiplier". So in your ignorance you manage in the calculation above to totally understate the Fed's impact, and then you manage to ask why stealing $26.2 billion from dollar holders in 2003 (when the actual amount is much higher) is a "bad thing". We haven't even touched on the Fed's lending to member banks yet.

Where on earth did you get that definition? The money multiplier is the ratio between M1 and M0. This definition comes from a simple math operation:

M1 = μM0
μ = M1/M0

Since the rest of your comment was based on this absurd definition you came up with, there is no need to even address it ... although one might think it is impossible, the second part makes even less sense.

Where on earth did you get such poor reading comprehension? I wrote "simple money multiplier, and I meant "simple money multiplier", not "money multiplier". Once again, the simple money multiplier is 1/R where R is the reserve requirement ratio. Any first year econ major knows this. Why are you so dishonest?

Nowhere, the number you reached was based on an absurd definition of the money multiplier.

It's not "my definition" nor is it "absurd". You might try googling for "simple money multiplier", if all else fails. Then you can apologize.

Yes, thank you for the opportunity to learn that even when there is access to the information, people like you will still be making absurd and uninformed claims.

Lets review. First you go from disbelief and insult to implicit acceptance on the point of whether or not the Fed actually creates money out of nothing, without so much as an apology. Then you create two strawmen in one post, with the flows vs. stock (income vs. balance) herring and the simple vs. money multiplier in a vain effort to make yourself look less ignorant than you really are.

So first I'd like you to admit once and for all that you were wrong, and that the Fed really is a bank of issue. Then, I'd like you to admit that there is a thing called the "simple money multiplier". Then, after you apologize for being a dishonest troll, we can address the more interesting question of applying the money multiplier (simple or not) to the 2003 $26.2B figure you quoted above.
 
Last edited:
You are clueless. The sad part, is that you think your "analysis" is correct. Inflation is flow variable, a stock variable (as the total stock of government debt owed to The Fed) has no effect over a flow variable. There is no "cumulative effect" and the total stock of government bonds held by Central Bank by itself offers no relevant information regarding inflation, you used that data because you didn't know any better.

For you to identify government expenditures financed by The Fed as a main determinant of inflation it's only logical that you use the the amount of bonds The Fed purchased from the government in that specific period since inflation is measured for specific periods.
I used the total stock of debt held by the Fed because it answers a far more relevant question by showing what the cumulative inflationary effect of the Fed's open market activity has been.

That total stock of debt you quoted is government issued debt, open market activities are conducted with the general public and member banks. Seems like you don't even understand the data you brought here.

Considering that you weren't aware that the Federal Reserve is a bank of issue, and that its open market purchases and lendings to member banks are additive to the money stock

Funny, i remember detailing the instruments of monetary policy to Truthseeker1234 earlier in the thread. I wonder how did you conclude i ignored them? I think you are confusing me with someone else.

After I analyzed the Fed and the US Government's balance sheet while instructing you to do your own budget (flow) and GDP (flow) analysis, you took the opportunity to waste time with a windy and condescending post about nothing substantial.

The only time i wasted was when i read your "analysis".

I just showed how the cumulative Fed Open Market policy has resulted in approximately ~$7.8 trillion worth of inflationary dollars.

You sure are clueless. You do know the underlying assumptions of the basic money multiplier, right? Is that the case of the United States economy? No, and since these assumption do not apply to the United States you did not demonstrate anything. What you said what just absurd, plain and simple.

p.s.: since you are pretending that you didn't read this question, i'll ask it again: How can you claim that The Fed is a primary cause of inflation when it financed less than 1% of total government expenditures on 2003? Remember that i am using the data you brought here to backup your point.
 
I'm not clueless. You on the other hand, are hopelessly dishonest. You ignored my request to admit that you were wrong about the Fed being a bank of issue. You created a strawman about flow and stock variables vis-a-vis inflation. You tried to spin your ignorance of the SMM as if I were ignorant of the MM. You're even ignorant of what the word "cumulative" means. All you're left with are insults, and you're as ignorant about the Fed as when you joined this thread. I'm afraid your continuing education will have to progress without me. Feel free to have the last word.
 
You say you are not clueless, yet you believe that the difference between a stock variable and a flow variable is a logical fallacy. Tippit if you are going to analyze the determinants of inflation, you should use the variables for the period you are analyzing. It is of no use to to look at the total stock of debt owed by the govt. to The Fed when you are trying to analyze how big of a role did the seigniorage play. You claim that The Fed is creating money and giving it to the government, yet the data shows that for a given year The Fed only financed less than 1% of the government expenditures.

Why did you choose to present the total stock of debt instead? Because it was a higher number and you did not know any better. Even if it did not present a shred of relevant information by itself, you concluded this data was some sort of proof of your point. Even worse, you replied with that data when i asked for two flow variables. But no, you are not clueless.

And then you moved on to the simple money multiplier. I apologize, i misread what you said. I am not used to using the simple money multiplier in an economy where people do prefer to hold cash. I am also used to using the money multiplier when looking at transactions, not a stock of debt. Applying the money multiplier to a stock of debt is just absurd. You are right, you are not clueless ... saying that would be a huge understatement.

But the funniest thing? It is this aspect of discussing certain subjects with pseudo-academics: even after the data contradicted your claims, you came up with distorted and absurd interpretations of one or various theories and simply everything you said was incorrect ... you still believe you are right and actually educated the other person.
 
You ignored my request to admit that you were wrong about the Fed being a bank of issue.

Why would i admit that? You seem to be confusing me with someone else.

Can you quote what exactly did i say that you think it was "wrong"? I don't use the term "bank of issue", i believe it to be a deprecated term in this context. But perhaps i misused it somewhere, so if you please quote this i will be more than glad to admit i was mistaken.
 
I would disagree with his assertion. When gold is money, gold mining is inflationary, and gold miners obtain a monetary gain when the price of gold exceeds their cost to mine it. Similarly, the creators of fiat money experience a monetary gain when they spend or lend new money into existence.

Certainly, as the gold miners are directly selling the product on the market. But how is that analogous to the creators of a fiat currency? Which creators, anyway? The entities that print the currency? The entities that put the money into circulation? The board members of the reserve bank? The member banks?

How is the monetary gain realized? If this is the case, why don't those with the ability to create money simply print a whole lot of it and retire to a nice island somewhere?

The claim has been made several times in this thread that fiat money is theft, or that its creation benefits the "money makers," so to speak. How exactly is that the case? How do the people in control of the supply ultimately benefit, in your opinion, from the creation of additional currency, or from inflation?

I'm having trouble seeing this conceptually. It seems that those with some level of investment in, say, loans (e.g. banks) would prefer that the currency retain as much value per unit as possible, and thus would want inflation to be controlled.

One could argue that the former is more legitimate than the latter, since presumably anyone is free to mine gold at relatively high cost, yet the supply of the latter is negligibly cheap, is monopolized and protected by counterfeiting laws, and the demand ensured by legal tender laws and the necessity to remit Federal income taxes.

It seems that the demand isn't really ensured at all. The fact that inflation exists at all would suggest that the demand for fiat currency is highly variable.

I suppose Federal taxes ensure there is always some baseline demand in the sense of someone wanting the money. Still, that's not to say that the currency itself will retain a high level of demand on the market that ensures any kind of value.

Yes, but the potential for these supply shocks exist for all forms of money, and even more so with fiat money.

Sure, I wasn't questioning that.

For instance, the value of the US dollar right now depends not only on the Fed's monetary policy, but on China's dollar policy, as they have been financing our trade deficit for years. If China decides to start liquidating its massive stock of dollars, the dollar will not so much implode as evaporate.

Yes, that could potentially become an issue. Any idea what we could do about it?

ETA: I say "potentially" because the trade deficit - a sign that other countries are investing in our own - is not necessarily a bad thing.

I think it's important to point out that ever since money has existed, groups have tried to manipulate its value for their own gain, and gold was no exception.

No question.

Another poster in this thread referred to William Jennings Bryan and his famous "Cross of Gold" speech. In this speech Bryan was not calling to abolish gold as money, but rather advocating a bi-metallic standard introducing silver convertible at 16:1. This was in order to relieve his main street constituents, who were suffering under the Wall Street banker's oligopoly on gold. I don't think gold itself is to blame for why the bankers obtained an oligopoly on it, but rather the fractional reserve banking system.



I am wary of calls to return to a gold standard, because no one owns more gold than the central banks themselves, and it could be a disaster. However, this is in no way a defense of the Federal Reserve, fiat money, or the fractional reserve banking system, which are evolving disasters, and they all need to be abolished.

As another poster asked: What do you propose that we do instead?

People are currently free enough on the market that, if they had the will, they could effectively abolish those things. Stop putting money into banks, invest in commodities rather than holding fiat currency, and convert small amounts to currency in the short run only to pay taxes and bills. But I'm guessing you would prefer a more permanent solution, so what would you propose?

I don't think any money system is perfect, but the one we currently use seems to work fairly well, most of the time. We have inflation to contend with, but we also have a decent way of adjusting for economic expansion, and unemployment is quite low. Also, the current rate of inflation is fairly easy to manage.

If you have a suggestion that will increase overall purchasing power without seriously sacrificing economic growth or jacking up unemployment, I'd be very interested in hearing the details.
 
Last edited:
At least Tippit was not a complete waste of time, the data he/she brought here showed that in 2003 the U.S. government financed less than 1% of its expenditures with monetary emission. This is far, very far, from Truthseeker1234's assertion that The Fed is "creating money out of thin air and giving it to the government".

No wonder why Truthseeker1234 ignored all requests to show this data.
 
Certainly, as the gold miners are directly selling the product on the market. But how is that analogous to the creators of a fiat currency? Which creators, anyway? The entities that print the currency? The entities that put the money into circulation? The board members of the reserve bank? The member banks?

How is the monetary gain realized? If this is the case, why don't those with the ability to create money simply print a whole lot of it and retire to a nice island somewhere?

The gain is realized at the exact point when the new money is exchanged for goods and services. As to the question of which creators are responsible, the number of layers of abstraction in the process doesn't change the fundamental nature of the process. Using the counterfeiting analogy, in a counterfeiting ring who is guilty of the crime of counterfeiting? The ringleader? The person who supplied the laser printers, paper, and ink? The person who initiated the print function? Or the person or people who spent the new money into the economy?

As for the creation of money and retiring to a nice tropical island, I can't prove it doesn't happen, and given human nature am inclined to believe it happens all the time. Most of the NY money center bank loans to the so-called developing nations have low or non-existent reserve requirements, and are secured at US taxpayer expense through the IMF/World Bank. It's likely that most of that money winds up in kickbacks and in the coffers of tin-pot African dictators. Meanwhile the African people end up paying the interest in a never-ending cycle of debt with their labor and natural resources.

The claim has been made several times in this thread that fiat money is theft, or that its creation benefits the "money makers," so to speak. How exactly is that the case? How do the people in control of the supply ultimately benefit, in your opinion, from the creation of additional currency, or from inflation?

I'm having trouble seeing this conceptually. It seems that those with some level of investment in, say, loans (e.g. banks) would prefer that the currency retain as much value per unit as possible, and thus would want inflation to be controlled.

I don't think fiat money itself represents theft. I think when the supply of money is governed by human beings as opposed to economic scarcity that theft becomes practically inevitable. The only notable historical exception was the Byzantine empire which imposed harsh penalties for coin-clipping.

As for the profitability of debauching your own currency, just think of aggregate money supply as a pie chart, of which you own a slice. As you inflate, your slice of the pie increases, as does the size of the pie itself. The purchasing power of each unit in the pie decreases, but your relative share increases. In addition, those who inflate know when they're doing it. They can convert their monetary holdings into real assets, leaving all the other money holders with the bag.

It seems that the demand isn't really ensured at all. The fact that inflation exists at all would suggest that the demand for fiat currency is highly variable.

I suppose Federal taxes ensure there is always some baseline demand in the sense of someone wanting the money. Still, that's not to say that the currency itself will retain a high level of demand on the market that ensures any kind of value.

There is another factor which helps ensure the circulation of fiat money - Gresham's_Law. This law essentially states that bad money drives out good.

ETA: I say "potentially" because the trade deficit - a sign that other countries are investing in our own - is not necessarily a bad thing.

As far as the trade deficit with China, I would say that it is philosophically a good deal for us that we give them paper, and they give us real goods and services. There are consequences to this, they wield exorbitant influence over the US Dollar. I don't think monetary reform would solve these kinds of problems specifically because other countries are free to use fiat money/fractional reserve banking regimes. Only fiscal reform would prevent this. If we were to abolish the Federal Reserve tomorrow, there are a hundred other central banks that Congress would continue borrowing from in order to fund its deficits.

I don't think any money system is perfect, but the one we currently use seems to work fairly well, most of the time. We have inflation to contend with, but we also have a decent way of adjusting for economic expansion, and unemployment is quite low. Also, the current rate of inflation is fairly easy to manage.

If you have a suggestion that will increase overall purchasing power without seriously sacrificing economic growth or jacking up unemployment, I'd be very interested in hearing the details.

I think monetary reform is the biggest issue nobody cares about, and I think Jefferson was right when he said

"If the American people ever allow private banks to control the issue of their money, first by inflation and then by deflation, the banks and corporations that will grow up around them, will deprive the people of their property until their children will wake up homeless on the continent their fathers conquered."

I think the money illusion is real and I don't think people grasp the magnitude of how inflation destroys their savings and wealth over time, much how many people don't understand compound interest. I think inflation is the cause of many economic problems for which the blame is placed elsewhere (usually on capitalism). I don't think economic growth or employment are dependent on fiat money/fractional reserve banking regimes, nor would be harmed by needed reforms. I also think the money system is the supreme cause of the Wealth Condensation Effect.

There is a fiat money scheme called the Monetary Reform Act which was endorsed by Milton Friedman. I don't necessarily support it but it makes for interesting reading. I think fractional reserve banking is the biggest problem and is the primary cause of the business cycle, hence monetary reform should begin with this.
 
Last edited:
I think the money illusion is real and I don't think people grasp the magnitude of how inflation destroys their savings and wealth over time,

They just don't grasp it because their salaries increase proportionally...
 
There is a fiat money scheme called the Monetary Reform Act which was endorsed by Milton Friedman.

"Endorsed" is a bit misleading, the quote merely states: "I am entirely sympathetic with the objectives of your Monetary Reform Act". He's not endorsing anything there. And by the way, can you find this quote outside that "documentary" website?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom