federal reserve conspiracy!!!

In the beginning, Mr. Early and Mr. Latey each have 10 loaves of bread, and each has $10. They each like to keep a cash balance on hand of $10. The government has no money and no bread. The current market price of bread is $1 per loaf.

The fed prints up a brand new $10 dollars, and gives it to the government. The government buys 6 loaves from Mr. Early for $1 each.

Govt. now has $4, and 6 loaves.
Early now has $16, and 4 loaves.
Latey still has $10, and 10 loaves.

This chases the price of bread up to $2 per loaf.

Early buys 6 loaves of bread from Mr. Latey for $2 per loaf.

Govt. still has $4, and 6 loaves.
Early now has $4 and 10 loaves.
Latey now has $22 and 4 loaves.

This chases the price of bread up to $4 per loaf.

Latey buys 3 loaves from the government at $4 per.

Govt. now has $16, and 3 loaves.
Early still has $4 and 10 loaves.
Latey now has $10 and 7 loaves.

This chases the price of bread up to $6 per loaf.

The government buys 1 loaf of bread from Early for $6.

Final score:

Govt. has $10 and 4 loaves.
Early has $10 and 9 loaves.
Latey has $10 and 7 loaves.


Play with the numbers all you want. You could make it so that Latey ends up with the same amount of bread, but way less money. Anyway you slice it, the late receivers get screwed under the creation of fiat money. Whoever is given the power to create money can and must siphon real wealth away from others.
Why do you make it so complicated?
Why not level Latey and Early after step 1?
What is the logic behind the steps?
Why does an increase in the money supply of 50% lead to 600% inflation?

Leveling out after step 1 has the following result:

The fed prints up a brand new $10 dollars, and gives it to the government. The government buys 6 loaves from Mr. Early for $1 each.

Govt. now has $4, and 6 loaves.
Early now has $16, and 4 loaves.
Latey still has $10, and 10 loaves.

This chases the price of bread up to $2 per loaf.

Early buys 3 loaves of bread from Mr. Latey for $2 per loaf.

Govt. still has $4, and 6 loaves.
Early now has $10 and 7 loaves.
Latey now has $16 and 7 loaves.

So here the early receivers get screwed under the creation of fiat money.

Please explain..
 
Why do you make it so complicated?
Why not level Latey and Early after step 1?
What is the logic behind the steps?
Why does an increase in the money supply of 50% lead to 600% inflation?

Leveling out after step 1 has the following result:

The fed prints up a brand new $10 dollars, and gives it to the government. The government buys 6 loaves from Mr. Early for $1 each.

Govt. now has $4, and 6 loaves.
Early now has $16, and 4 loaves.
Latey still has $10, and 10 loaves.

This chases the price of bread up to $2 per loaf.

Early buys 3 loaves of bread from Mr. Latey for $2 per loaf.

Govt. still has $4, and 6 loaves.
Early now has $10 and 7 loaves.
Latey now has $16 and 7 loaves.

So here the early receivers get screwed under the creation of fiat money.

Please explain..

Sure. You stopped the model at a point when Govt. had bought but not sold, Early had bought and sold, and Latey had only sold. In other words, Govt. had been able to consume without producing anything, Early was able to consume after producing something, and Latey had to produce, but was not able to consume anything. If Latey wants to consume, he has to buy, using his even more devalued money. If you run your model one more step so that Latey can survive, you will see that he is again the big loser.

I only made the price inflation so huge so as to deal with easy, whole numbers. The principle is exactly the same with more realistic numbers.

Ultimately, money itself is not what you're after. You can't eat it, it won't keep you warm, etc. It is a medium of exchange. It is goods that constitute real wealth. That is why I ran my earlier example around until everyone had the same amount of money, to see how the goods were redistributed.

To illustrate, consider one of my favorite examples.

Imagine two people get stranded on a small island. With them, they have a bunch of stuff that would be very useful in trying to survive - fishing nets, camping equipment, tools, matches, flashlight, batteries, etc. They also each have pockets full of money.

As the months go buy, they undergo all sorts of trading with each other. They trade money for goods, goods for other goods, they borrow and payback, etc. etc. After awhile, one guy has all the money, and the other guy has all the stuff.

Which guy would you rather be?
 
Last edited:
What is the logic behind the steps?

None. These seem to be irrational agents with unusual utility functions. Now, this can't surprise anyone since the model was conceived by someone who has no knowledge in undergrad economics.
 
As the months go buy, they undergo all sorts of trading with each other. They trade money for goods, goods for other goods, they borrow and payback, etc. etc. After awhile, one guy has all the money, and the other guy has all the stuff.

Which guy would you rather be?


It doesn't matter which guy I am. In your example, money has value. The guys actually will trade each other stuff for money. I don't know why money has value on this island with two guys neither of whom has a comparative advantage over the other but that's not my problem. You created the hypothetical; you decided that to these two guys money has value.

So, it doesn't matter whether I have all the money and none of the stuff because I could trade my money for stuff. the other guy will take the money because apparantly money has value. If he won't take the money, you'd need to explain to me why your system just devalued all the money to zero when it wasn't zero a moment ago. There's certainly nothing built into your hypo that makes this necessarily true.
 
To illustrate, consider one of my favorite examples.

Imagine two people get stranded on a small island. With them, they have a bunch of stuff that would be very useful in trying to survive - fishing nets, camping equipment, tools, matches, flashlight, batteries, etc. They also each have pockets full of money.

As the months go buy, they undergo all sorts of trading with each other. They trade money for goods, goods for other goods, they borrow and payback, etc. etc. After awhile, one guy has all the money, and the other guy has all the stuff.

Which guy would you rather be?

I'd rather be the guy with all the goods, of course. Who wouldn't? Then, why would the guy with all the goods trade it for worthless cash? I know you said money had value, but, assuming they are there for awhile, that is not logical. Money is only good to buy things. But there is nothing to buy on your island except the finite goods that one guy just sold. I presume the guy who bought those goods would not be willing to sell them back. So what good is the money to the guy who just sold the goods?
 
It doesn't matter which guy I am. In your example, money has value. The guys actually will trade each other stuff for money. I don't know why money has value on this island with two guys neither of whom has a comparative advantage over the other but that's not my problem. You created the hypothetical; you decided that to these two guys money has value.

So, it doesn't matter whether I have all the money and none of the stuff because I could trade my money for stuff. the other guy will take the money because apparantly money has value. If he won't take the money, you'd need to explain to me why your system just devalued all the money to zero when it wasn't zero a moment ago. There's certainly nothing built into your hypo that makes this necessarily true.

Oh yes there is. The money must have had pre-existing value to both guys, or they never would have been able to spend it on the island. They valued it the day they were stranded, because they had valued it the day before, and the day before that.

However, there's nothing to say that money will have value tomorrow, just because it does today. Its value can go down, and can go down to zero, as 1920's Germany proved.

And, there's nothing to say that any 2 people are equally intelligent, nor that they will value things the same as one another. All valuation is a subjective human emotion. In the example, the guy who ended up with the goods decided in his mind that the goods were more valuable, and the guy who ended up with the money decided in his mind that the money was more valuable, as evidenced by their respective trading decisions.

The guy with the money will likely change his mind, once he realizes that the other guy doesn't value money any more. The guy with the goods was smarter, and figured it out sooner.
 
Last edited:
Just a reminder folks. GOLD...is valueless. It has no value. It is no more valuable then your average rock, pebble, or stone.

The only value that Gold has..and therefore money based on the value of Gold...is the value agreed upon by the world for Gold.

So whether our money's value is based on agreemants regarding the value of currency..or connected to the agreed upon value of Gold...its all man made and all based on agreemants between powerful people.

All you folks who think basing the value of the dollar on the value of Gold is somehow a magical thing...get over yourselves. Its all relative and based on man.
 
Oh yes there is. The money must have had pre-existing value to both guys, or they never would have been able to spend it on the island. They valued it the day they were stranded, because they had valued it the day before, and the day before that.

However, there's nothing to say that money will have value tomorrow, just because it does today. Its value can go down, and can go down to zero, as 1920's Germany proved.

And, there's nothing to say that any 2 people are equally intelligent, nor that they will value things the same as one another. All valuation is a subjective human emotion. In the example, the guy who ended up with the goods decided in his mind that the goods were more valuable, and the guy who ended up with the money decided in his mind that the money was more valuable, as evidenced by their respective trading decisions.

The guy with the money will likely change his mind, once he realizes that the other guy doesn't value money any more. The guy with the goods was smarter, and figured it out sooner.


So your hypothetical was just a lie. Imagine the very last trade. The one guy has most of the money and a fishing net, the other guy has all the stuff and ten bucks. Why would the guy with the net sell it for ten bucks? What you meant to say is:

"Two guys are stranded on an island with equal amounts of money and goods. One guy is a great negotiator who always maximizes his profits. The other guy is a moron. Which would you rather be?"

Once again, you've built your prejudices into your hypothetical. But they don't exist in real life. The money does not suddenly devalue to zero unless one guy never valued the money to begin with. But you didn't say that - you said they trade the money and goods back and forth freely.

So in your new, revised hypothetical, I'd rather be the guy who's not a moron. I'm sure you'd rather not be a moron as well. It's just ... harder for you.


ETA: You know, the more I think about it, the angrier I get that you're now introducing elements that were not in your original hypothetical. I might as well say I'd rather be the guy with all the money because the guy with all the stuff has an inoperable brain tumor and will die within twelve hours. After all, as you say: "There's nothing to say that any 2 people are equally intelligent." I might as well add: "There's nothing to say that any 2 people are equally healthy." It makes exactly the same sense as what you said.
 
Last edited:
Once again, you've built your prejudices into your hypothetical. But they don't exist in real life. The money does not suddenly devalue to zero...


I just love the gold brokers.

"The dollar is being devalued!!"

"Gold is the new standard!!"

"Buy our gold!!"


Wait a minute. If the dollar is being devalued and gold is now the new standard, why are you so willing to trade your gold for my dollars?
 
@Truthseeker1234

Are you going to reply to this post?

And by replying to it i don't mean quoting the first 3 lines as you already did. You do understand that's quite dishonest from you, right?

Imagine two people get stranded on a small island. With them, they have a bunch of stuff that would be very useful in trying to survive - fishing nets, camping equipment, tools, matches, flashlight, batteries, etc. They also each have pockets full of money.

As the months go buy, they undergo all sorts of trading with each other. They trade money for goods, goods for other goods, they borrow and payback, etc. etc. After awhile, one guy has all the money, and the other guy has all the stuff.

You have said some pretty stupid things, but this definitely takes the prize. Why would they be interested in trading goods for money if they can't use this money in a market to buy other goods? Did you forget your main assumption? There is no market.
 
The money must have had pre-existing value to both guys, or they never would have been able to spend it on the island. They valued it the day they were stranded, because they had valued it the day before, and the day before that.

And tell me? what would determine its current value in such a setup? The absence of toilet paper?
 
So your hypothetical was just a lie. Imagine the very last trade. The one guy has most of the money and a fishing net, the other guy has all the stuff and ten bucks. Why would the guy with the net sell it for ten bucks? What you meant to say is:

"Two guys are stranded on an island with equal amounts of money and goods. One guy is a great negotiator who always maximizes his profits. The other guy is a moron. Which would you rather be?"

Once again, you've built your prejudices into your hypothetical. But they don't exist in real life. The money does not suddenly devalue to zero unless one guy never valued the money to begin with. But you didn't say that - you said they trade the money and goods back and forth freely.

So in your new, revised hypothetical, I'd rather be the guy who's not a moron. I'm sure you'd rather not be a moron as well. It's just ... harder for you.


ETA: You know, the more I think about it, the angrier I get that you're now introducing elements that were not in your original hypothetical. I might as well say I'd rather be the guy with all the money because the guy with all the stuff has an inoperable brain tumor and will die within twelve hours. After all, as you say: "There's nothing to say that any 2 people are equally intelligent." I might as well add: "There's nothing to say that any 2 people are equally healthy." It makes exactly the same sense as what you said.

I did not introduce one element into the hypothetical that could not be derived logically.

You are quite correct about one thing in the hypothetical, one guy is a great negotiator, the other is a moron. You may wish that you were the great negotiator, but you have revealed yourself to be the moron. You are the one who stubbornly cannot tell the difference between money and wealth.

QED
 
Last edited:
There is an important concept worth mentioning.

Whenever two people trade, they value the objects being traded in the opposite order. When you buy a loaf of bread from the store, you are saying that you value the loaf of bread more than you value the $3 it costs. The owner of the store is disagreeing with you. He values the $3 more than the loaf of bread.

This is another great insight provided by the Austrian school. For centuries it was thought that a voluntary trade indicated that there was some underlying equality in value between the items being traded. But actually, value is subjective.
 
Last edited:
And tell me? what would determine its current value in such a setup? The absence of toilet paper?


LOL. Toilet paper. Good one.

All value is subjective. Who is to say why they still valued the money after they were stranded on the island? We know they did, because they voluntarily traded for it.
 
Sure. You stopped the model at a point when Govt. had bought but not sold, Early had bought and sold, and Latey had only sold. In other words, Govt. had been able to consume without producing anything, Early was able to consume after producing something, and Latey had to produce, but was not able to consume anything. If Latey wants to consume, he has to buy, using his even more devalued money. If you run your model one more step so that Latey can survive, you will see that he is again the big loser.

I only made the price inflation so huge so as to deal with easy, whole numbers. The principle is exactly the same with more realistic numbers.

Ultimately, money itself is not what you're after. You can't eat it, it won't keep you warm, etc. It is a medium of exchange. It is goods that constitute real wealth. That is why I ran my earlier example around until everyone had the same amount of money, to see how the goods were redistributed.

To illustrate, consider one of my favorite examples.

Imagine two people get stranded on a small island. With them, they have a bunch of stuff that would be very useful in trying to survive - fishing nets, camping equipment, tools, matches, flashlight, batteries, etc. They also each have pockets full of money.

As the months go buy, they undergo all sorts of trading with each other. They trade money for goods, goods for other goods, they borrow and payback, etc. etc. After awhile, one guy has all the money, and the other guy has all the stuff.

Which guy would you rather be?

Okay, I'm no economist (I've never even taken an economics course), but your hypothetical isn't making sense to me. Why are the two unhappy castaways using the money at all? Considering that the money has absolutely no utilitarian value (except maybe as kindling), and there's no wider market to use it in, why would any rational person value it enough to trade something useful for it in the first place? The person who had less money to begin with would never desire more of it from the other person, since it has no practical value for his survival. I'd expect any rational person to realize the money is worthless so long as he's stranded and to simply stow it away somewhere in the hopes that one day he'll be rescued; then if/when he returns to civilization he can resume using it. But that's of course assuming there is any possibility of rescue in the first place. Its only real value would be determined solely by how likely either person considered the possibility of rescue: a sort of gamble based on a number of contingencies left unspecified in your hypothetical. Otherwise what point is there in having a currency between two people? It's completely superfluous.
 
Last edited:
Oh yes there is. The money must have had pre-existing value to both guys, or they never would have been able to spend it on the island. They valued it the day they were stranded, because they had valued it the day before, and the day before that.

Don't you think being marooned on an island is a bit of change in circumstances that these two (I'm assuming rational) men would recognize? You can't just say they would continue to value the money for no reason. If they're stranded then the market for the currency is gone and it has no value, unless they expect to be rescued tomorrow.

However, there's nothing to say that money will have value tomorrow, just because it does today. Its value can go down, and can go down to zero, as 1920's Germany proved.

I would say that the expectation, by those who use and invest with the money, of stability and permanency in their society and government, and in its ability to enforce the rule of law, ultimately give the money its value. There were very real external factors which caused the devaluation of the German Mark in the 1920's, yes? Don't you think those had something to do with its fall? You're making it sound like the value of currency is completely arbitrary and it's not. I suppose if you think, as many "Truthers" do, that the US Gov. is likely to be overthrown in the near future, it would make sense to be very mistrustful of the value of today's currency. But I don't, so I'm not.

And, there's nothing to say that any 2 people are equally intelligent, nor that they will value things the same as one another. All valuation is a subjective human emotion. In the example, the guy who ended up with the goods decided in his mind that the goods were more valuable, and the guy who ended up with the money decided in his mind that the money was more valuable, as evidenced by their respective trading decisions.

The guy with the money will likely change his mind, once he realizes that the other guy doesn't value money any more. The guy with the goods was smarter, and figured it out sooner.

These people are extremely irrational and I would guess that their decisions don't well correspond with real market forces in a stable society.
 
Last edited:
Okay, I'm no economist (I've never even taken an economics course), but your hypothetical isn't making sense to me. Why are the two unhappy castaways using the money at all? Considering that the money has absolutely no utilitarian value (except maybe as kindling), and there's no wider market to use it in, why would any rational person value it enough to trade something useful for it in the first place? The person who had less money to begin with would never desire more of it from the other person, since it has no practical value for his survival. I'd expect any rational person to realize the money is worthless so long as he's stranded and to simply stow it away somewhere in the hopes that one day he'll be rescued; then if/when he returns to civilization he can resume using it. But that's of course assuming there is any possibility of rescue in the first place. Its only real value would be determined solely by how likely either person considered the possibility of rescue: a sort of gamble based on a number of contingencies left unspecified in your hypothetical. Otherwise what point is there in having a currency between two people? It's completely superfluous.

Easy.

Perhaps when the two are stranded, they both have high hopes of being rescued very soon, and taken back to the larger society where lots of people still value the kind of money they have. The use of money on an island is not "completely superfluous". Money is a medium of exchange. That is its function.

In the absence of pre-existing money, the two guys would likely adopt a new medium of exchange, perhaps coconuts, or flashlight batteries. It would have to be something both guys valued. Money must originate as a commodity of value.

As the days pass by, perhaps one of the castaways becomes more pessimistic about being rescued, while the other remains hopeful, and adopts a strategy of selling all his goods for the money. Perhaps he ends up with millions of "dollars" while the other guy ends up with goods that would only be worth a few thousand dollars back in the larger society.

You see, perhaps both guys rationally thought they were getting the better end of the deal. The future is always uncertain, and different people can and do make different judgments about what the future may hold.

This is just one possible rational explanation for why the pre-existing money continued to have value to the two guys. It's not necessary to know exactly why, because it is logically evident from the hypothetical that they did value it, for some reason, because they were willing to accept it in trade.
 
Last edited:
Tell me "Truthseeker" are you ever going to reply to this post? By replying i don't mean quoting the first line as you already did.


All value is subjective. Who is to say why they still valued the money after they were stranded on the island? We know they did, because they voluntarily traded for it.

So you just arbitrarily set a value for money in your initial "model" when there wasn't a market to trade this money for other goods and services. If you had ever been close to an economics book you'd understand how absurd is this you're saying. So again i ask, what determines the value of money in this economy with no market to trade the money for goods and services? And please don't come up with something like "they are the market" ... that would be too much even when coming from you.

LOL! Seeing Truthseeker1234 adding new elements to his absurd example is just hilarious. Man if it made no sense the first time, leave it at that and don't try to make it seem less absurd by adding new elements such as:

Perhaps when the two are stranded, they both have high hopes of being rescued very soon

You already established all the assumptions, the fact that you have to establish new ones after people pointed the lack of logic in your example says quite a lot. But hey keep doing it, i need a good laugh after a week in the office.
 
Last edited:
Sure. You stopped the model at a point when Govt. had bought but not sold, Early had bought and sold, and Latey had only sold. In other words, Govt. had been able to consume without producing anything, Early was able to consume after producing something, and Latey had to produce, but was not able to consume anything. If Latey wants to consume, he has to buy, using his even more devalued money. If you run your model one more step so that Latey can survive, you will see that he is again the big loser.
Noone has consumed anything yet. Usually when you eat bread, it happens to dissapear.
In your example, Govt, Latey and Early just buy and sell for some unkown reason without consuming untill you reach a situation that you think proves your point. Only problem is that you chose your example this badly that it actually proves you wrong.

Latey and Early have the same amount of bread, they both haven't eaten anything and Latey has more money. Any reasonal human being would know who is in the better position.
 
Early was able to consume after producing something, and Latey had to produce, but was not able to consume anything.

Truthseeker1234 if you ever do get some formal education come back and read the stuff you are saying. Your "model" started with an initial allocation of goods which you conveniently reassigned until you got the results you wanted. Nobody produced anything directly or indirectly, because for any of them to produce anything indirectly they would need to actually produce something and trade it for it.

And to think that all this ignorance comes from someone "very knowledgeable in undergrad econ".
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom