federal reserve conspiracy!!!

Whenever two people trade, they value the objects being traded in the opposite order. When you buy a loaf of bread from the store, you are saying that you value the loaf of bread more than you value the $3 it costs. The owner of the store is disagreeing with you. He values the $3 more than the loaf of bread.
Wrong. The owner of the store added value to the loaf of bread by bringing it to a convenient place (his store) for people to purchase it. The store owner is then able to realize profit by selling the bread at a premium over what he paid for it.
 
Why are the two unhappy castaways using the money at all? Considering that the money has absolutely no utilitarian value (except maybe as kindling), and there's no wider market to use it in, why would any rational person value it enough to trade something useful for it in the first place? The person who had less money to begin with would never desire more of it from the other person, since it has no practical value for his survival.
I disagree. I once saw a documentary about a group of people whe were shipwrecked on a desert island. One of them had a lot of money with him, and was able to pay the first mate to do chores for him with the money he had brought with him. I think it was called "Gilligan's Island"... :D
 
Noone has consumed anything yet. Usually when you eat bread, it happens to dissapear.
In your example, Govt, Latey and Early just buy and sell for some unkown reason without consuming untill you reach a situation that you think proves your point. Only problem is that you chose your example this badly that it actually proves you wrong.

Latey and Early have the same amount of bread, they both haven't eaten anything and Latey has more money. Any reasonal human being would know who is in the better position.

You are engaging in fraudulent bookkeeping. With Early, you are reporting both sides of the ledger, sales and expenditures, with Latey, you are only reporting sales. In order for the very simple model to make any sense, each actor must go though the same number of transactions.

Ideally, you would attempt to hold either goods constant, to see what happens to the money distribution, or you would hold money constant, to see what happens to the goods distribution, as I did.

If you want to continue having Latey sell all his goods for money, and never purchase anything, he will end up with only money, and the others will end up with the goods. Latey will starve to death.
 
Wrong. The owner of the store added value to the loaf of bread by bringing it to a convenient place (his store) for people to purchase it. The store owner is then able to realize profit by selling the bread at a premium over what he paid for it.

Non sequitur. Of course the store owner adds value by bringing the bread to market. That was earlier.

At the exact moment of the agreement to trade, the two parties value the money and the bread in the reverse order. The buyer values the bread more, the store owner values the money more. Otherwise, they would not agree to trade.

This principle applies to every voluntary trade. When two parties agree to trade, they both benefit. This is one of the most important principles in economics, and you cannot go any further in my class until you recognize and appreciate this.
 
In order for the very simple model to make any sense, each actor must go though the same number of transactions.

So your "model" only makes sense in a very specific situation. And you want to use it as some sort of prove of your assertion? Wow.

Keep pretending you are not reading my posts, just don't repeat the same "nobody have refuted my point" thing anymore ... ok little Hayek?
 
At the exact moment of the agreement to trade, the two parties value the money and the bread in the reverse order. The buyer values the bread more, the store owner values the money more. Otherwise, they would not agree to trade.


Yeah, the phrase you're looking for is "marginal utility." The word "value" doesn't have a precise enough meaning for this situation. Both the bread and the money have exactly the same value: three dollars. But the bread and the money have different amounts of marginal utility to the actors.

That is basic economics. See, in my class we first learn what the words mean and only then do we use them in sentences.


I don't really have a class. Neither does TS1234. The difference is that I know I don't.
 
You are engaging in fraudulent bookkeeping. With Early, you are reporting both sides of the ledger, sales and expenditures, with Latey, you are only reporting sales. In order for the very simple model to make any sense, each actor must go though the same number of transactions.

Ideally, you would attempt to hold either goods constant, to see what happens to the money distribution, or you would hold money constant, to see what happens to the goods distribution, as I did.

If you want to continue having Latey sell all his goods for money, and never purchase anything, he will end up with only money, and the others will end up with the goods. Latey will starve to death.
In the beginning, Mr. Early and Mr. Latey each have 10 loaves of bread, and each has $10. They each like to keep a cash balance on hand of $10. The government has no money and no bread. The current market price of bread is $1 per loaf.

The fed prints up a brand new $10 dollars, and gives it to the government. The government buys 8 loaves from Mr. Early for $1 each.

Govt. now has $2, and 8 loaves.
Early now has $18, and 2 loaves.
Latey still has $10, and 10 loaves.

This chases the price of bread up to $2 per loaf.

Latey buys 4 loaves of bread from Govt. for $2 per loaf.

Govt. now has $10, and 4 loaves.
Early still has $18 and 2 loaves.
Latey now has $2 and 14 loaves.

This chases the price of bread up to $4 per loaf.

Early buys 2 loaves from Latey at $4 per loaf.

Govt. still has $10, and 4 loaves.
Early now has $10 and 4 loaves.
Latey now has $10 and 12 loaves.

All actors made the same number of transactions: 2. They bought and sold one time.
 
This model of TS's completely ignores the demand for money itself. In his example there isn't much of a demand for it. If anything, that closed system would result in almost a daily devaluation of money and an increase in the value of the bread.

This happens in real life, too.

If a commodity becomes important enough and portable enough, it becomes money. Anyone familiar with a first-year economics course would recognise the example of the "six-pack economy" in Angola.

Maybe TS is opposed to the actual "control" (more like supervision) of the money supply exerted by central banks. That would put him squarely in the camp of the regional and local bankers. They were the ones in charge of the money supply before the introduction of central banking. They were also the ones responsible for the (roughly) seven-year regular cycle of bank panics and economic depressions that wracked the US economy during the nineteenth century.
 
Last edited:
Yeah, the phrase you're looking for is "marginal utility." The word "value" doesn't have a precise enough meaning for this situation. Both the bread and the money have exactly the same value: three dollars. But the bread and the money have different amounts of marginal utility to the actors.

That is basic economics. See, in my class we first learn what the words mean and only then do we use them in sentences.

No, you're wrong. You're falling into the same mistake that centuries of economists also fell into, in thinking that an object must have some underlying, objective value. It doesn't. Value is a purely subjective human emotion.

Ten different people could all look at the same loaf of bread, and have ten different opinions on how much they would pay for it.

We employ marginalist thinking to explain why identical objects can be valued differently. My last loaf of bread is worth more to me than my second-to-last loaf. By the way, it was Carl Menger in the 1870's who discovered the concept of marginalism, starting the marginalist revolution, and founding what later became known as "the Austrian School".

You are absolutely wrong in thinking objects have an objective value. And you are wrong about the use of the word "value". The examples so far have not required marginalism. I can take you through that also, with another desert island example.

But first, we all need to agree that when two parties agree to trade, each values the traded items in reverse order. It is fundamental to economic analysis, and if you persist in your error, you can get no farther than Adam Smith got.
 
In the beginning, Mr. Early and Mr. Latey each have 10 loaves of bread, and each has $10. They each like to keep a cash balance on hand of $10. The government has no money and no bread. The current market price of bread is $1 per loaf.

The fed prints up a brand new $10 dollars, and gives it to the government.

The government buys 5 loaves from Mr. Early for $1 each.

Govt. now has $5, and 5 loaves.
Early now has $15, and 5 loaves.
Latey still has $10, and 10 loaves.

The government gives two loaves to the poor, loses a loaf behind the sofa, and enacts a loaf tax of 20%. Early and Latey each eat a loaf. The loaves, now being stale, are worth only 50 cents. Bob the baker shows up with ten new loaves at $1 each.

Govt. now has $8, and 2 loaves.
Early now has $14, and 4 loaves.
Latey still has $10, and 9 loaves.
Bob has $0 and 10 loaves.

Latey sells his loaves to Fred the Farmer as cattle feed, buys a new loaf, and eats it, all the while wondering what the hell he was doing with 10 loaves in the first place. Early eats a stale loaf and gives the rest to the Salvation Army. Carol, Ted, Dick and Jane buy a loaf each, and Alice buys three loaves for her restaurant. The government awards Fred a biofuel grant of $5 and gives its remaining loaves to the Dominican Republic. Alice takes out a loan to buy a cow from Fred.

Govt. has $3 and 0 loaves.
Early has $14 and 0 loaves.
Latey has $13.50 and 0 loaves.
Carol has $9 and 1 loaf.
Ted has $9 and 1 loaf.
Dick has $9 and 1 loaf.
Jane has $9 and 1 loaf.
Alice has $7 in cash and $10 in debt, three loaves and a cow.
Fred has $20.50 and 1 cow.
Bob has $8 and 2 loaves.

Alice chops up the cow and starts selling steak sandwiches at $2 each. Early, Latey, Carol, Ted, Dick, Jane and Fred, all sick of eating plain bread, buy two steak sandwiches apiece. Bob bakes ten new loaves and makes the two stale loaves into bread pudding, and sells it to Alice for $3. Alice divides it up into portions, and Early, Latey, Carol, Ted and Jane each pay $1 for dessert. The government imposes a 20% sales tax on prepared food. Fred's remaining cow develops TB, and the government orders it slaughtered, paying him $12 in compensation. Dick loses all his cash to a Nigerian spammer. Carol trades her Velvet Elvis collection to Alice for a 15% stake in the restaurant. Jane takes a position with the newly formed Federal Department of Baked Goods, and orders an inquiry into bread prices. The government finds the loaf from behind the sofa and hands it over to Carol at the NIH, who develops a new vaccine for bovine tuberculosis from the bread mould. Ted posts a blog entry about about it, gets linked by Slashdot, and the traffic spike nets him a $15 bill for excess bandwidth from Bob's Patisserie and Web, but also gets him a job interview at Dick's PR firm. Fred sells the farm, marries Carol, and they found a pharmaceutical company with the aid of an angel investor. Early and Latey retire to New Zealand to raise kiwis.
 
Last edited:
@Truthseeker1234

We employ marginalist thinking to explain why identical objects can be valued differently. My last loaf of bread is worth more to me than my second-to-last loaf.

Can't you get anything right? You just contradicted the concept (some call it a "law") of diminishing marginal utility, which is one of the explanations for the negative slope of the demand curve. You do know that a demand curve usually has a negative slope, right?

What you are implying with your latest absurdity is that a person would be willing to pay more for the last loaf of bread than for the first loaf of bread which means a demand curve with a positive slope. Can you tell me which type of goods exhibit such a demand curve? Is bread one of these types?

Where are you getting all this garbage from? Seems like you are inventing your own economic "theories" here. Do you follow this same approach when you seek for the "truth" ?
 
In the beginning, Mr. Early and Mr. Latey each have 10 loaves of bread, and each has $10. They each like to keep a cash balance on hand of $10. The government has no money and no bread. The current market price of bread is $1 per loaf.

The fed prints up a brand new $10 dollars, and gives it to the government. The government buys 8 loaves from Mr. Early for $1 each.

Govt. now has $2, and 8 loaves.
Early now has $18, and 2 loaves.
Latey still has $10, and 10 loaves.

This chases the price of bread up to $2 per loaf.

Latey buys 4 loaves of bread from Govt. for $2 per loaf.

Govt. now has $10, and 4 loaves.
Early still has $18 and 2 loaves.
Latey now has $2 and 14 loaves.

This chases the price of bread up to $4 per loaf.

Early buys 2 loaves from Latey at $4 per loaf.

Govt. still has $10, and 4 loaves.
Early now has $10 and 4 loaves.
Latey now has $10 and 12 loaves.

All actors made the same number of transactions: 2. They bought and sold one time.

You simply had "Latey" complete his transactions before "Early". Duh. It doesn't matter what their names are, it matters where their transactions occur in time. In your version, the person who completed trading last, "Early", is the big loser.

Let's not forget that Govt. has produced nothing, yet ends up with goods.

In any case, you have again shown the most important feature: Money creation redistributes wealth. In the model, no wealth is created or destroyed. Simply by creating new money, wealth becomes redistributed. Thus there must be winners and losers. Winners are called "thieves" and losers are called "victims".

On the free market, including commodity based money, there are only winners. All transactions are voluntary, and voluntary transactions benefit both parties. Fiat money cannot exist on the free market.
 
Fiat money cannot exist on the free market.

On a free market anything can be used as money as long as the agents agree. You talk about a free market yet you restrict what that market should use as a medium of exchange. Wow.
 
@Truthseeker1234



Can't you get anything right? You just contradicted the concept (some call it a "law") of diminishing marginal utility, which is one of the explanations for the negative slope of the demand curve. You do know that a demand curve usually has a negative slope, right?

What you are implying with your latest absurdity is that a person would be willing to pay more for the last loaf of bread than for the first loaf of bread which means a demand curve with a positive slope. Can you tell me which type of goods exhibit such a demand curve? Is bread one of these types?

Where are you getting all this garbage from? Seems like you are inventing your own economic "theories" here. Do you follow this same approach when you seek for the "truth" ?

Your reading comprehension is poor. I said I would value my last loaf of bread more than I would value my second-to-the-last loaf. The more I have of something, the less I value each unit.

I am not making anything up Alan, and the economics I present here are not original with me at all. I present so-called Austrian theory. Credit for these concepts goes to Menger, Mises, Hayek, Rothbard, and all the current guys - Hoppe, Reismann, Solerno, Block, et al.

Here is the Mises Institute homepage

http://www.mises.org/

There is a treasure trove of great lectures, books, articles there. I recommend them.

If you really want to argue mainstream econ/politics against the Austro-libertarianism, you'll need to present public goods theory. I say the Austrians have demolished public goods theory, but it does make an interesting argument.
 
On a free market anything can be used as money as long as the agents agree. You talk about a free market yet you restrict what that market should use as a medium of exchange. Wow.

In theory, any commodity could function on the market as money. In practice, the market chose precious metals as the best-functioning money, after centuries of experimentation and competition between all sorts of different commodities. In theory and in practice, fiat money cannot and did not function on the free market as money.

If you will review how money comes into existence, you will see why this is true.
 
Last edited:
@Truthseeker1234

Your reading comprehension is poor. I said I would value my last loaf of bread more than I would value my second-to-the-last loaf. The more I have of something, the less I value each unit.

The last sentence contradicts the one before it. The problem is not my reading comprehension, is the fact that you don't know anything about what are discussing. If you say that you value your last loaf of bread more than the one you bought before it, then you can't possibly say that the more you have of something the less you value each additional unit. But hey, at least you read what the concept of diminishing marginal utility means.

I am not making anything up Alan, and the economics I present here are not original with me at all.

Actually you've made up quite a bunch of silly things in this some sort of conversation, the latest one was the contradiction of the diminishing marginal utility concept by stating that you would assign a higher value to the last unit of bread you consumed than to the one you consumed before that.

After you actually read what this concept means you were able finally make a correct statement ... even if it contradicted what you said in the previous one. But hey, one thing at a time ... right?
 
In theory and in practice, fiat money cannot and did not function on the free market as money.

You keep saying that, yet you have not presented any evidence to backup such claim. Not a surprise tho, i asked you to provide evidence of your claim about The Fed "printing money out of thin air and giving it to the government" and i am still waiting.

You see, when we have all of the world's biggest economies using a fiat currency when they have the choice to use precious metals, a claim such as yours can become silly pretty fast.
 
In theory, any commodity could function on the market as money. In practice, the market chose precious metals as the best-functioning money, after centuries of experimentation and competition between all sorts of different commodities. In theory and in practice, fiat money cannot and did not function on the free market as money.

If you will review how money comes into existence, you will see why this is true.
Not "in theory" to your first point. In practice, any commodity or unit of exchange may function as money. We've had salt as money. Silver as money. Gold as money. Six-packs of beer as money. Fiat currency as money.

Are you suggesting that Roman commerce based on the exchange of salt was freer than the one you participate in?

Fiat currency creates a freer market economy than metal-based currency does. Bankers just love metal-based currency. It solidifies their control over the issuance of credit. They despise central banking because it liberalises credit and the exchange of goods.

If JP Morgan were alive today he'd be spinning in his grave at how much the banking industry gave up to allow commerce to flourish.
 
@Truthseeker1234



The last sentence contradicts the one before it. The problem is not my reading comprehension, is the fact that you don't know anything about what are discussing. If you say that you value your last loaf of bread more than the one you bought before it, then you can't possibly say that the more you have of something the less you value each additional unit. But hey, at least you read what the concept of diminishing marginal utility means.



Actually you've made up quite a bunch of silly things in this some sort of conversation, the latest one was the contradiction of the diminishing marginal utility concept by stating that you would assign a higher value to the last unit of bread you consumed than to the one you consumed before that.

After you actually read what this concept means you were able finally make a correct statement ... even if it contradicted what you said in the previous one. But hey, one thing at a time ... right?


Alan, stop it. I never said anything about "the one I bought before it". If I have two loaves of bread, I value each one less than if I only had one loaf of bread. I might give away my second-to-the last loaf of bread. I would never give away my last loaf of bread, for I would starve.

Solerno explains marginalism with a desert island example. Say a guy has 6 identical bushels of wheat. He has earmarked many different uses for the wheat, which he can rank in order of importance to him.

The first bushel he needs just to survive.
The second bushel he needs to be strong and have lots of energy.
The third bushel he wants to feed to his chickens, so he can have eggs.
The fourth bushel is for trade.
The fifth bushel is to feed his pet monkey, for amusement.
The sixth bushel is to ferment into alcoholic beverage.

Suppose a weasel comes in the night and steals his first and second bushels of wheat. Does this mean he will starve to death, since those were the two bushels earmarked for survival?

No.

Likely it is the monkey feeding and alcohol fermenting that will go unmet.

The fifth and sixth bushels of wheat had less marginal utility than did the others. The more and more of a good he has, the less he values each unit. This is why we must consider the margin. Marginal utility, not just utility. Transactions take place, "on the margin".

This is what Adam Smith could not figure out, with his value paradox. How cold people value diamonds more than bread? If we were faced with a choice of having to lose all of the bread in world, or all of the diamonds, we have to lose the diamonds and keep the bread.

But the point is, we are not faced with that choice. We are faced with the choices on the margin. If I already have a thousand loaves of bread in my pantry, I might very well be willing to trade 500 of them for a diamond, just to look at. This is because those loaves of bread have less marginal utility to me. I would never trade my last 500 loaves of bread for a diamond, because I would starve. Thus, those loaves, even though they are identical, have a greater marginal utility.


This explains how identical things can be valued differently, destroying Loss Leader's (archaic) notion that things have some underlying inherent value.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom