federal reserve conspiracy!!!

The gain is realized at the exact point when the new money is exchanged for goods and services. As to the question of which creators are responsible, the number of layers of abstraction in the process doesn't change the fundamental nature of the process. Using the counterfeiting analogy, in a counterfeiting ring who is guilty of the crime of counterfeiting? The ringleader? The person who supplied the laser printers, paper, and ink? The person who initiated the print function? Or the person or people who spent the new money into the economy?

Except this isn't analogous either. When money is created under the current Reserve system it eventually enters general circulation, it isn't placed in the private accounts of the board members or anything. If you wish to argue it really is somehow, then you'll need to provide some evidence of this.

As for the creation of money and retiring to a nice tropical island, I can't prove it doesn't happen, and given human nature am inclined to believe it happens all the time.

You could, however, try to prove it does happen, which would be far more helpful than speculating about it. I'm only willing to go so far as to say it could happen without evidence it actually does.

Most of the NY money center bank loans to the so-called developing nations have low or non-existent reserve requirements, and are secured at US taxpayer expense through the IMF/World Bank. It's likely that most of that money winds up in kickbacks and in the coffers of tin-pot African dictators. Meanwhile the African people end up paying the interest in a never-ending cycle of debt with their labor and natural resources.

The best thing about this is that if you can find proof of some of these accusations, you can probably bring legal action against the participants (specifically if they are receiving kickbacks). If you have some solid evidence, I probably wouldn't be the only person interested in it. This is also straying a bit far afield of the Federal Reserve. I know it's connected somewhat, but you're starting to get away from domestic monetary policy and into international loans.

I don't think fiat money itself represents theft. I think when the supply of money is governed by human beings as opposed to economic scarcity that theft becomes practically inevitable. The only notable historical exception was the Byzantine empire which imposed harsh penalties for coin-clipping.

I think theft is a possibility under all economic systems, you have to take steps to prevent it or mitigate the damage done by it. Scarcity doesn't make theft less of a possibility, although it does certainly make it more profitable and potentially damaging.

As for the profitability of debauching your own currency, just think of aggregate money supply as a pie chart, of which you own a slice. As you inflate, your slice of the pie increases, as does the size of the pie itself. The purchasing power of each unit in the pie decreases, but your relative share increases. In addition, those who inflate know when they're doing it. They can convert their monetary holdings into real assets, leaving all the other money holders with the bag.

Except that theory doesn't make any sense. If you hold your money entirely in currency (or a deposit in currency at a bank, for example), then inflating the money supply decreases the overall worth of your holdings. The situation you propose only sort-of works if, like you say, you hold real assets.

However, it still doesn't make your purchasing power increase. If you buy real assets and then inflate the money supply, your real assets may be worth more total dollars, but their purchasing power will remain the same, as the overall market will correct for the new money supply.

Finally, if you hold some of your wealth in the form of debts owed to you (as, say, a bank or credit card company), then inflation is death to your debt-wealth. As the purchasing power of the dollar declines, the loan owed to you also becomes less valuable. Similarly, because wages tend to increase with inflation (and because obtaining dollars in an inflated money supply is easier), the consumers become more able to pay off the debt, losing you money earned in interest.

I suppose you could increase your real wealth by buying real assets, inflating the currency supply drastically and immediately, selling your assets before the market corrects, and then buying more real assets.

But we don't see this kind of radical inflation in the US, so it seems unlikely that someone is trying to play that game.

It's not like the Fed has sole control over inflation anyway - there are various checks involved on the issuance of new currency. While not foolproof, they prevent one person from simply flooding the market with tons of currency.

There is another factor which helps ensure the circulation of fiat money - Gresham's_Law. This law essentially states that bad money drives out good.

That has more to do with consumer behavior than anything else, and will work with counterfeit non-fiat currency as well.

As far as the trade deficit with China, I would say that it is philosophically a good deal for us that we give them paper, and they give us real goods and services. There are consequences to this, they wield exorbitant influence over the US Dollar. I don't think monetary reform would solve these kinds of problems specifically because other countries are free to use fiat money/fractional reserve banking regimes. Only fiscal reform would prevent this. If we were to abolish the Federal Reserve tomorrow, there are a hundred other central banks that Congress would continue borrowing from in order to fund its deficits.

Deficit budgets are a whole other topic, true.

I think monetary reform is the biggest issue nobody cares about, and I think Jefferson was right when he said

I think most consumers are happy as long as the system works. Ultimately, we're all spinning a lot of plates here... as long as most of them stay up, I think we're doing all right. If you have serious suggestions to improve things, that's always welcome.

I think the money illusion is real and I don't think people grasp the magnitude of how inflation destroys their savings and wealth over time, much how many people don't understand compound interest.

That depends on how they hold their wealth. I think more people understand the way inflation erodes currency-based wealth than you might think.

I think inflation is the cause of many economic problems for which the blame is placed elsewhere (usually on capitalism). I don't think economic growth or employment are dependent on fiat money/fractional reserve banking regimes, nor would be harmed by needed reforms.

I think we need to separate fractional reserve from fiat money, because the two are vastly different processes.

What, in principle, is wrong with fractional reserve? Nobody forces you to invest in a bank that uses it, and it provides a means by which potential capitalists can obtain startup money. So what? You can convert all your money to gold and hold onto it if you want - as can anyone else.

How is fractional reserve itself harming the larger economy?

Inflation isn't a cause of growth or employment, but it does tend to be a result of it. I know the Phillips curve tends to collapse in the long run, but there is still the wage/price cycle to consider. I suppose without fiat money to easily expand the system, we could curb inflation to some degree by halting that cycle. That would protect those that want to hold currency, sure, as well as loaning institutions.

I also think the money system is the supreme cause of the Wealth Condensation Effect.

I don't. I think it's ultimately something you'll find in any system that allows individuals to continue to hold private wealth and invest it elsewhere. It can happen under any economic system that doesn't forcibly confiscate wealth from the wealthy and give it to everyone else.

Now, I don't think that's a good idea at all, but wealth condensation will occur to some degree in a free market system. It's one of those tradeoffs we all have to make.

There is a fiat money scheme called the Monetary Reform Act which was endorsed by Milton Friedman. I don't necessarily support it but it makes for interesting reading. I think fractional reserve banking is the biggest problem and is the primary cause of the business cycle, hence monetary reform should begin with this.

How? Do you agree with the MRA's approach? If not, what specifically do you propose?


Tippit, I like you a lot better than TruthSeeker. He didn't really want to talk about anything, he just wanted to push his agenda (he's done this before in other threads), but you seem willing to have an actual discussion. That's refreshing.
 
I don't think economic growth or employment are dependent on fiat money/fractional reserve banking regimes, nor would be harmed by needed reforms.

I wonder why Tippit associates fractional reserve banking with fiat currency? I can easily conceive a bank being required to keep 10% of all deposits in its reserves when using pork bellies as a currency.

Tippit, you say growth is not dependent on fiat currency, which is true, but tell me something: how is the economy going to grow at its desired pace if the money supply is restricted by the finite nature of the commodity being used as money?
 
Except this isn't analogous either. When money is created under the current Reserve system it eventually enters general circulation, it isn't placed in the private accounts of the board members or anything. If you wish to argue it really is somehow, then you'll need to provide some evidence of this.
Do we agree that when new money is created, it represents a transfer of wealth from the existing holders of that money? I'm not sure what you think I'm arguing. To the extent that inflationary high-powered money is lent into existence to fund congress, it benefits congress and the special interests who obtain government contracts. To the extent it is lent into existence to fund private banks, it benefits private bankers. I'm not claiming the Fed governors are electronically crediting their own bank accounts. There are a lot of abstractions in between. In the case of Congress I think it is wrong because this is in essence a surreptitious form of taxation. In the case of private banks it is wrong, because not everyone has access to borrow funds at the discount rate, nor treat liabilities as assets as only banks can under fractional reserve banking.

I think theft is a possibility under all economic systems, you have to take steps to prevent it or mitigate the damage done by it. Scarcity doesn't make theft less of a possibility, although it does certainly make it more profitable and potentially damaging.

Scarcity of money is a natural check on a government, central bank, or counterfeiter's ability to debase money. Fortunately for them, electronic and paper money isn't scarce.

Except that theory doesn't make any sense. If you hold your money entirely in currency (or a deposit in currency at a bank, for example), then inflating the money supply decreases the overall worth of your holdings. The situation you propose only sort-of works if, like you say, you hold real assets.

It makes perfect sense. Assuming I am the beneficiary of new money I create, there is a net profit resulting from my increased share of money less the lost purchasing power of my existing money. Is the counterfeiter unwilling to print $100 bills because he has $100 tucked under his mattress? Of course not. If you're arguing that the institutional counterfeiters don't benefit directly from money creation and, assuming you agree that there is a transfer of wealth during the money creation process, then who does benefit?

However, it still doesn't make your purchasing power increase. If you buy real assets and then inflate the money supply, your real assets may be worth more total dollars, but their purchasing power will remain the same, as the overall market will correct for the new money supply.

Again, I'm assuming that you benefit directly from the inflation, i.e. either all or part of those new dollars find their way to you in some way. I presume that central bankers are rewarded similar to politicians in the form of kickbacks or delayed compensation, perhaps with cushy jobs and golden parachutes. For every $600 government toilet seat that is bought by "mistake", there is someone in the private sector selling $600 toilet seats. This kind of systemic corruption may be difficult to prove to someone who is disinclined to believe it could happen in the first place, but certainly the fact that politicians spend millions of dollars campaigning for an office that pays a salary of $165,000/yr might be construed as evidence.

Finally, if you hold some of your wealth in the form of debts owed to you (as, say, a bank or credit card company), then inflation is death to your debt-wealth. As the purchasing power of the dollar declines, the loan owed to you also becomes less valuable. Similarly, because wages tend to increase with inflation (and because obtaining dollars in an inflated money supply is easier), the consumers become more able to pay off the debt, losing you money earned in interest.

Yes, inflation hurts creditors and helps debtors, this is a good point. But it also hurts those not in debt and living on fixed income the most. How is inflationary monetary policy fair to creditors who don't benefit from the new money? Why should creditors or debtors receive any kind of preference? In fact, inflation hurts anyone who cannot afford to offset its ravaging effects by buying real or capital assets, namely the poor. Take the Africans again, who suffer an endless cycle of debt, bailout, and default. The fact that their debts are being devalued is offset by the fact that they are constantly being replaced with new debts. A similar but less draconian example are the debt consolidation companies that operate in the US.

I suppose you could increase your real wealth by buying real assets, inflating the currency supply drastically and immediately, selling your assets before the market corrects, and then buying more real assets.

But we don't see this kind of radical inflation in the US, so it seems unlikely that someone is trying to play that game.

It's not like the Fed has sole control over inflation anyway - there are various checks involved on the issuance of new currency. While not foolproof, they prevent one person from simply flooding the market with tons of currency.

That depends on your definition of radical. Since the Fed's inception in 1913 they have debauched the dollar by roughly 96-99% of its original value, and presided over two stock market crashes, one great depression, and several recessions. Milton Friedman blames the Fed for the great depression, but thinks it was accidental. I think it was done intentionally and with malice. But proving this is akin to proving that a driver in control of a car intentionally caused a car accident. We would have to believe that Benjamin Strong of the NY Fed didn't know what would happen when he contracted the money supply by nearly one-third. This would indicate some level of credulity in the believer.

At best, the Federal Reserve has failed to prevent what it was ostensibly designed to prevent. At worst it has been the cause.

I think we need to separate fractional reserve from fiat money, because the two are vastly different processes.

What, in principle, is wrong with fractional reserve? Nobody forces you to invest in a bank that uses it, and it provides a means by which potential capitalists can obtain startup money. So what? You can convert all your money to gold and hold onto it if you want - as can anyone else.

How is fractional reserve itself harming the larger economy?

Fractional Reserve Banking is wrong because no sector of the economy should have the exclusive right to create money out of nothing, which is precisely what FRB grants them. Banks are the only entities who under GAAP (Generally Accepted Accounting Principles) are allowed to treat liabilities as assets on the balance sheet. As a student of equity valuation I can confirm this. Why should they be exceptional? You or I don't have the right to treat our liabilities as assets, neither should they. The idea that capitalists couldn't obtain financing without FRB is wrong. They could obtain financing from banks that used their own paid-in capital instead, and this process would be self-regulating by the limited supply of credit. FRB is the sole cause of bank runs, and the Kontradieff (business) cycle, two of the rationalizations for why the Federal Reserve needs to exist in the first place! It is harming the economy because it results in the necessary condensation of wealth and a two-tiered society composed of bankers, and non-bankers.

As for the convertibility of gold, how do you explain and justify Executive Order 6102? FDR in 1933 expropriated the presumably harmless inert metal gold from US Citizens, and this was not reversed until December of 1974%2
 
Last edited:
This thread is still going on? I thought I had the last word. Boobies! Boobies was the last word. Let's depart for other threads. I hear there's one about circumcision.
 
I was trying to edit my previous post and had an error while saving so it got corrupted. I saved the original and the balance follows here:

As for the convertibility of gold, how do you explain and justify Executive Order 6102? FDR in 1933 expropriated the presumably harmless inert metal gold from US Citizens, and this was not reversed until December of 1974! Is this consistent with a "free market" or a free country? What possible legitimate reason could there have been for this?

jonnyfive said:
Inflation isn't a cause of growth or employment, but it does tend to be a result of it. I know the Phillips curve tends to collapse in the long run, but there is still the wage/price cycle to consider. I suppose without fiat money to easily expand the system, we could curb inflation to some degree by halting that cycle. That would protect those that want to hold currency, sure, as well as loaning institutions.

No, inflation doesn't tend to be the result of growth or employment. It is the result of either a) an increase in the supply of money relative to the supply of goods and services or b) a decrease in the supply of goods and services relative to the supply of money. The idea that economic growth is caused by or results in inflation is one of the biggest lies taught in contemporary economics, and repeated ad nauseum by pundits and TV talking heads. In fact, the exact opposite is true. Given a static supply of money, economic growth results in disinflation. As the same amount of money chases an increased number of goods and services, the prices of those goods and services decline and the purchasing power for each unit of currency is increased. Wages fall, but more things can be bought with each dollar of wages. There is no legitimate economic theory which seeks to optimize for nominal prices, or final demand. We don't need a central bank to manipulate the value of our currency under the premise of fighting inflation, when they are the primary cause of it.

I don't. I think it's ultimately something you'll find in any system that allows individuals to continue to hold private wealth and invest it elsewhere. It can happen under any economic system that doesn't forcibly confiscate wealth from the wealthy and give it to everyone else.

Now, I don't think that's a good idea at all, but wealth condensation will occur to some degree in a free market system. It's one of those tradeoffs we all have to make.

I have already argued that our current monetary system is ultimately based on force, and I believe it. It is also based on subterfuge, ignorance, and misinformation. As a proponent of capitalism I find it important to distinguish between meritorious value-producing wealth accumulation, and monetary fraud, because it seems that all of the blame for the current inequities of wealth distribution in the world find their way into anti-capitalist sentiment. As this anti-capitalist sentiment is realized, it makes things a lot worse and exacerbates the gap between rich and poor, which is why I'm beating the drum for reform now. Capitalism is no more reflected by monetary fraud and manipulation than it is by armed robbery or grand larceny.

How? Do you agree with the MRA's approach? If not, what specifically do you propose?

I don't like fiat money, even if its supply is theoretically limited by statute. In essence, I'm skeptical of government's ability to restrain itself. On the other hand, this does represent a viable solution, and if it is the best we can do then I'm all for it. Unfortunately support for this is about the same as interest in this subject - nil.

Tippit, I like you a lot better than TruthSeeker. He didn't really want to talk about anything, he just wanted to push his agenda (he's done this before in other threads), but you seem willing to have an actual discussion. That's refreshing.

I read his posts here and I agree with most of what he said, with the big exception of the idea that we should return to a fiduciary gold standard. That's been done before, and it doesn't work. Other than that I share his agenda where it leads to monetary reform. I too appreciate an honest discussion. This is often perceived as a complex and boring subject, best left to the arcane dominion of central bankers. I couldn't disagree more. I think it is the biggest and most important story in the last four hundred years. Once it is simplified, the incredible scope of the problem becomes apparent, having implications over every aspect of human behavior.
 
Do we agree that when new money is created, it represents a transfer of wealth from the existing holders of that money?

I'll be the first to admit I'm not an economist, but I fail to see how the act of creating something can also be an act of transfering the same thing. Either it already existed and was transfered or it didn't exist and was created. It can't be both.
 
I'll be the first to admit I'm not an economist, but I fail to see how the act of creating something can also be an act of transfering the same thing. Either it already existed and was transfered or it didn't exist and was created. It can't be both.

Then could you explain the moral and legal justification for counterfeiting laws, and describe who the victims are, if any?

Back to square one.
 
Do we agree that when new money is created, it represents a transfer of wealth from the existing holders of that money?

I suppose you could argue it represents a transfer of wealth from the holders of the currency into nothingness, but I don't agree that anyone actually particularly benefits from the creation of the new money, except those with high levels of debt.

It makes perfect sense. Assuming I am the beneficiary of new money I create, there is a net profit resulting from my increased share of money less the lost purchasing power of my existing money.

Except that the market will adjust to the new money created because the money is released openly into the market. Moreover, a lot of the direct inflation created by the Fed is not due to the issue of new currency, but to the changing of the reserve rates.

Is the counterfeiter unwilling to print $100 bills because he has $100 tucked under his mattress? Of course not. If you're arguing that the institutional counterfeiters don't benefit directly from money creation and, assuming you agree that there is a transfer of wealth during the money creation process, then who does benefit?

You are conflating legitimate creation of currency with counterfeiting. I understand you don't like fiat money, and consider it little better than theft, but consider the nuance involved. A counterfeiter profits by concealing the existence of the additional currency long before any market correction could be made to compensate for their product's existence. Additionally, the counterfeit currency will eventually be removed from circulation, thus the use of the counterfeit currency to pay for a good represents real, uncompensated theft from a retailer.

The creation of new currency and the existence of inflation is something that can be, and is, corrected for constantly on the market. Prices and wages are adjusted to match it, unlike with counterfeiting.

The scales are different, as are the levels of disclosure and its role on the market.

Again, I'm assuming that you benefit directly from the inflation, i.e. either all or part of those new dollars find their way to you in some way. I presume that central bankers are rewarded similar to politicians in the form of kickbacks or delayed compensation, perhaps with cushy jobs and golden parachutes.

If you wish to bolster your theories with this kind of claim, you really need to show evidence of it. You're moving beyond economic theory and into talking about evidence of corruption. If you have such evidence, please present it.

For every $600 government toilet seat that is bought by "mistake", there is someone in the private sector selling $600 toilet seats. This kind of systemic corruption may be difficult to prove to someone who is disinclined to believe it could happen in the first place, but certainly the fact that politicians spend millions of dollars campaigning for an office that pays a salary of $165,000/yr might be construed as evidence.

Political power and influence are worth something too, you know.

But you're talking about congressional politicians now. Perhaps you could address the bankers and Fed staff instead? Do you have some evidence of systematic corruption in the Fed?

Remember that the Fed is separate from Congress for this very reason - so that their behavior is not corrupted by legislative issues.

Yes, inflation hurts creditors and helps debtors, this is a good point. But it also hurts those not in debt and living on fixed income the most.

Assuredly. I have never said that inflation causes no problems.

How is inflationary monetary policy fair to creditors who don't benefit from the new money? Why should creditors or debtors receive any kind of preference?

They don't, this is simply a result of the economic calculations involved. Deflation has its own set of side effects.

In fact, inflation hurts anyone who cannot afford to offset its ravaging effects by buying real or capital assets, namely the poor.
All negative economic effects impact the poor more than anyone else. They are also hurt by collapsing salaries and lost jobs in deflationary cycles. They are also hurt most by wide market swings.

That depends on your definition of radical. Since the Fed's inception in 1913 they have debauched the dollar by roughly 96-99% of its original value, and presided over two stock market crashes, one great depression, and several recessions. Milton Friedman blames the Fed for the great depression, but thinks it was accidental. I think it was done intentionally and with malice.

Well, how about providing evidence that it was done intentionally.

But proving this is akin to proving that a driver in control of a car intentionally caused a car accident. We would have to believe that Benjamin Strong of the NY Fed didn't know what would happen when he contracted the money supply by nearly one-third. This would indicate some level of credulity in the believer.

The Great Depression is more complicated than simply contracting the money supply.

Fractional Reserve Banking is wrong because no sector of the economy should have the exclusive right to create money out of nothing, which is precisely what FRB grants them.

No, that is a gross misstatement of what FRB does. FRB has nothing to do with creating money, simply with how existing money is loaned. Remember that any money loaned under FRB is owed back, ultimately, to the original holder of the money, with interest. Those taking the loans will use that capital to produce something, gain capital, and pay back the loans.

All of this can work without fiat money or a flexible currency supply.

Banks are the only entities who under GAAP (Generally Accepted Accounting Principles) are allowed to treat liabilities as assets on the balance sheet.

Isn't that because the loans outstanding are considered assets, ultimately, because the debtors are legally obligated to pay them back? That is a matter of accounting convention, in any case.

As a student of equity valuation I can confirm this. Why should they be exceptional? You or I don't have the right to treat our liabilities as assets, neither should they.

You or I are not generally in the business of making loans, nor are we large financial institutions. Again, you're talking about accounting conventions, not economic theory.

The idea that capitalists couldn't obtain financing without FRB is wrong. They could obtain financing from banks that used their own paid-in capital instead, and this process would be self-regulating by the limited supply of credit.

But why shouldn't the banks be allowed to practice FRB if they want? They are constrained in the extent they can do it by the government, who can determine statistically how much they should hold in reserve. Moreover, the customers are free to choose to take their business elsewhere.

FRB is the sole cause of bank runs,

You mean it is the reason that a bank run could potentially be damaging. But we could (and do) set up a situation where the likelihood of a bank run is mathematically insignificant.

...and the Kontradieff (business) cycle, two of the rationalizations for why the Federal Reserve needs to exist in the first place! It is harming the economy because it results in the necessary condensation of wealth and a two-tiered society composed of bankers, and non-bankers.

Wealth condensation is ultimately a function of capitalism, banks or no banks. This idea of a tier of "bankers" and "non-bankers" is somewhat misleading. "Bankers" are salaried employees responsible for dealing with banking transactions.

I suppose you mean the "wealthy bankers" in the sense of the bank owners. That these "wealthy bankers" are increasingly corporations with stockholders I suppose is ultimately unimportant to your point.

How about a two-tiered society of "those wealthy enough not to have to give a rat's ass about inflation or anything like that" and "everyone else?"

As for the convertibility of gold, how do you explain and justify Executive Order 6102? FDR in 1933 expropriated the presumably harmless inert metal gold from US Citizens, and this was not reversed until December of 1974%2

I don't. It was a stupid idea, and it's good that it was reppealed. Why would I support everything the government does because I don't agree that the Fed, in principle, needs to be abolished?

I think the ability of private citizens to hold their wealth in whatever form they want is a pillar of workable capitalism.
 
No, inflation doesn't tend to be the result of growth or employment.

So you don't agree with the wage/price cycle? Despite that it both follows economic theory and can be observed in reality?

Whether or not you like it, the increasing of wages and prices in response to each other is ultimately an inflationary trend.

It is the result of either a) an increase in the supply of money relative to the supply of goods and services

Which is why the wage/price cycle is inflationary.

or b) a decrease in the supply of goods and services relative to the supply of money. The idea that economic growth is caused by or results in inflation is one of the biggest lies taught in contemporary economics, and repeated ad nauseum by pundits and TV talking heads. In fact, the exact opposite is true. Given a static supply of money, economic growth results in disinflation.

Yes, given a static supply of money. But we don't have a static supply of money. Given a completely static supply of money, the wage/price cycle tends not to exist, and the growth is in fact deflationary.

As the same amount of money chases an increased number of goods and services, the prices of those goods and services decline and the purchasing power for each unit of currency is increased. Wages fall, but more things can be bought with each dollar of wages.

That's the theory, yes. Unfortunately, in practice the wages and prices don't always rise and fall the way they should. Given a fast enough rate of deflation, wages may tend to remain sticky enough that firms choose to fire employees to reduce costs, thus raising unemployment. It will adjust in the long run, usually, but it can hurt the economy severely in the short run. The damn Phillips Curve and all that.

There is no legitimate economic theory which seeks to optimize for nominal prices, or final demand. We don't need a central bank to manipulate the value of our currency under the premise of fighting inflation, when they are the primary cause of it.

Actually, the central bank doesn't pretend to fight inflation. They are designed to stabilize the currency, preventing radical inflation or deflation and preserving the short term stability of inflation and unemployment.

I have already argued that our current monetary system is ultimately based on force, and I believe it.

And who, precisely, forces you to hold your wealth in fiat dollars? (Please don't say it's a law that you can't refuse dollars, because it isn't true according to the US Treasury.)

It is also based on subterfuge, ignorance, and misinformation. As a proponent of capitalism I find it important to distinguish between meritorious value-producing wealth accumulation, and monetary fraud, because it seems that all of the blame for the current inequities of wealth distribution in the world find their way into anti-capitalist sentiment. As this anti-capitalist sentiment is realized, it makes things a lot worse and exacerbates the gap between rich and poor, which is why I'm beating the drum for reform now. Capitalism is no more reflected by monetary fraud and manipulation than it is by armed robbery or grand larceny.



I don't like fiat money, even if its supply is theoretically limited by statute. In essence, I'm skeptical of government's ability to restrain itself.

Which is why it's important to check the system. Thus we have a central bank that is not beholden to Congress, but that follows a specific mandate of monetary policy.

On the other hand, this does represent a viable solution, and if it is the best we can do then I'm all for it. Unfortunately support for this is about the same as interest in this subject - nil.

I would venture that the reason there is no interest in the subject is because most people see the system as working pretty well for them.

I read his posts here and I agree with most of what he said, with the big exception of the idea that we should return to a fiduciary gold standard. That's been done before, and it doesn't work. Other than that I share his agenda where it leads to monetary reform.

But what monetary reform would you actually propose? All you've really said (that I remember, sorry if I missed something) is you don't want to return to the gold standard and you don't want the Fed around anymore (and no fractional reserve banking). But what would you set up? Bimetallic standard? Fixed currency issue? No currency? Much more regulated Fed?

I too appreciate an honest discussion. This is often perceived as a complex and boring subject, best left to the arcane dominion of central bankers. I couldn't disagree more. I think it is the biggest and most important story in the last four hundred years. Once it is simplified, the incredible scope of the problem becomes apparent, having implications over every aspect of human behavior.

I'm not so sure it's the biggest and most important story in the past 400 years (atomic energy, modern computing, vaccines, and antiseptics would beat it for sure), but it'd probably make the top ten, maybe even top five.
 
No, inflation doesn't tend to be the result of growth or employment.

Let's setup a basic supply and demand model:

S = -3 + 5p
D = 5 - 5P

For the sake of simplicity let's assume the economy is on equilibrium (S=D, in case Tippit doesn't know what that means) so equilibrium price is P= 0.8 and quantity is Q = 1. What happens if demand raises by 2? New equilibrium price will be P = 0.87 and eq. quantity Q ~ 1.3. Wee see clearly that while the economy grew there was also a change in the price level.

About employment, just look at the Phillips curve.

This is basic macroeconomics Tippit, grab a book someday.
 
Let's setup a basic supply and demand model:

S = -3 + 5p
D = 5 - 5P

For the sake of simplicity let's assume the economy is on equilibrium (S=D, in case Tippit doesn't know what that means) so equilibrium price is P= 0.8 and quantity is Q = 1. What happens if demand raises by 2? New equilibrium price will be P = 0.87 and eq. quantity Q ~ 1.3. Wee see clearly that while the economy grew there was also a change in the price level.

About employment, just look at the Phillips curve.

This is basic macroeconomics Tippit, grab a book someday.

To be fair to Tippit, if the money supply was truly completely static - with no mining of new metals, no production of x objects of currency, and no printing of new money at all - then the wage/price cycle would likely not exist.

Mostly because you'd just be shuffling the same amount of objects of currency around in the economy (I'm also assuming that no one ever holds this currency in reserve, thus making it completely static).

Of course, that scenario doesn't represent real life. Inflation fluctuates not only from printing or removing money, but from holding and releasing savings or reserves, or exploiting new currency-like resources (such as gold, silver, or platinum).

Also, the Phillips curve doesn't hold in the long run, but it is a very real factor in the short run. Also, it's something I haven't seen Tippit address. I'd like to know if he has any thoughts on it.
 
I suppose you could argue it represents a transfer of wealth from the holders of the currency into nothingness, but I don't agree that anyone actually particularly benefits from the creation of the new money, except those with high levels of debt.

This is a sticking point, and I don't think we can progress further unless we're clearly agreed. We may have to agree to disagree. If I counterfeit new money into existence and spend it at your hypothetical restaurant, I have exchanged practically nothing for something. I printed some figures on a piece of paper, and you gave me real food and real service in exchange for it. Now you could argue that since you accepted them as authentic that others likely would as well, thus they have spendable value and function much the same as all of the other tokens we use for money, and I would agree. In any case, I have willfully increased the aggregate supply of tokens, and by doing so have debauched each token proportionally. If we're playing a standard-edition game of Monopoly at your house with an aggregate money supply of $15,140, and I decide to bring $1,514 from my own set to purchase assets on the board, then I have willfully increased the supply of monopoly dollars by 10%, thereby debasing each token by 1/10th. That I have exchanged tokens for wealth is obvious to me. Why isn't it obvious to anyone else here? You might say that I was cheating. If I were the Federal Reserve, you would probably say that I'm just doing my job. Coincidentally, this is the answer to the question I have asked at least twice now, i.e. "What is the moral and legal basis for the existence of counterfeiting laws?" You can add as many layers of abstraction to the process as you want, but that doesn't change the fact that there are beneficiaries, and losers. The beneficiaries are the ones closest to the creation of the money. The losers are the last to receive it. Nor does the ascribed legitimacy to the process change anything. You can call counterfeiting illegal, and praise what the Federal Reserve does legally, but there is no other difference. Institutionalized crime is nevertheless crime.

Except that the market will adjust to the new money created because the money is released openly into the market. Moreover, a lot of the direct inflation created by the Fed is not due to the issue of new currency, but to the changing of the reserve rates.

Incorrect. Any money the Fed lends to its member banks is inflationary due to the issuance of new currency. It is referred to as "high powered money" or the "monetary base", because when it is injected it becomes the apex of a pyramid, becoming the basis for multiple rounds of new bank deposits, thanks to the fractional reserve system. When the fed raises the discount rate, the higher cost of borrowing discourages member banks from borrowing and limits the supply of new money in this fashion. When it lowers the rate, assuming there is demand for new credit, the reverse is true.

The "adjustment" you wrote about is the market bidding up prices with the newly created money. This is the period when the wealth is actually transferred from the holders of old tokens to the creators of new tokens.

You are conflating legitimate creation of currency with counterfeiting. I understand you don't like fiat money, and consider it little better than theft, but consider the nuance involved. A counterfeiter profits by concealing the existence of the additional currency long before any market correction could be made to compensate for their product's existence. Additionally, the counterfeit currency will eventually be removed from circulation, thus the use of the counterfeit currency to pay for a good represents real, uncompensated theft from a retailer.

I fail to see any substantive difference between counterfeiters and central bankers, other than the relative legal status of their activities. I also don't see why counterfeit currency would necessarily be removed from circulation. I suppose that would depend on the quality of the counterfeiting.

But you're talking about congressional politicians now. Perhaps you could address the bankers and Fed staff instead? Do you have some evidence of systematic corruption in the Fed?

Remember that the Fed is separate from Congress for this very reason - so that their behavior is not corrupted by legislative issues.

My evidence is the fact that the Fed's codifying principles are logically and morally corrupt, and its existence alone is systematically corrupt.

Even if I did presume that the supply of money needed to be actively managed by men, reason would dictate that such a dangerous task be fully politically accountable. The idea that politicians are more or less corruptible than "independent" bankers strikes me as credulous.

All negative economic effects impact the poor more than anyone else. They are also hurt by collapsing salaries and lost jobs in deflationary cycles. They are also hurt most by wide market swings.

No, that isn't true. Many "negative" economic effects can be described as more or less progressive. For instance, Congress is mulling over legislation that will tax private equity and limited partnerships as if they were private corporations. You could use a supply-side argument and say that the poor will be negatively affected by this, but I have a difficult time seeing how this will hurt the poor relatively the same or more than private equity.

Well, how about providing evidence that it was done intentionally.

The Great Depression is more complicated than simply contracting the money supply.

The evidence is that central bankers should have known what would happen if you contract a nation's money supply by one-third, and yet they did it anyway. It's akin to a murder defense that amounts to "I didn't know what would happen if i aimed that pistol and pointed the trigger, your honor!"

The Great Depression and the Roaring Twenties were both entirely monetary phenomenons, and a pristine example of what Thomas Jefferson warned against. It's worth repeating in context:

Thomas Jefferson said:
"If the American people ever allow private banks to control the issuance of their currency, first by inflation and then by deflation, the banks and corporations that will grow up around them will deprive the people of all their property until their children will wake up homeless on the continent their fathers conquered."

In case you haven't been following what has been going on in credit markets recently, the doomed are repeating history.

No, that is a gross misstatement of what FRB does. FRB has nothing to do with creating money, simply with how existing money is loaned. Remember that any money loaned under FRB is owed back, ultimately, to the original holder of the money, with interest. Those taking the loans will use that capital to produce something, gain capital, and pay back the loans.

All of this can work without fiat money or a flexible currency supply.



Isn't that because the loans outstanding are considered assets, ultimately, because the debtors are legally obligated to pay them back? That is a matter of accounting convention, in any case.

FRB has everything to do with money creation. If the fed creates $100B in high powered money, that translates into roughly $1 trillion in the FRS. When demand deposits are treated simultaneously as assets and liabilities, this is de facto money creation. In contrast to the Fed whose money creation is virtually costless, at least banks have to pay their depositors a token amount. The fact that bankers can profit by this spread on money they have created out of nothing gives them an unfair advantage over every other business in existence. If you, I, or business X want to make a loan, we have to loan our own paid-in capital or savings. If Public Storage Inc. ran their business similar to banks, the owners would be jailed. If you want to make a time deposit with your bank, that's fine. But lets end the FRS on demand deposits. Promising two different sets of people money at the same time is the sole cause of bank runs. Instead of creating the Federal Reserve System, why don't we just solve the real problem?

The special GAAP rules for banks are an exception to law, not a "convention".

You or I are not generally in the business of making loans, nor are we large financial institutions. Again, you're talking about accounting conventions, not economic theory.

No, we're not. But this justifies the unfair advantage that banks have how?

But why shouldn't the banks be allowed to practice FRB if they want? They are constrained in the extent they can do it by the government, who can determine statistically how much they should hold in reserve. Moreover, the customers are free to choose to take their business elsewhere.

For the same reason that plantation owners shouldn't be allowed to own slaves. It's immoral.

You mean it is the reason that a bank run could potentially be damaging. But we could (and do) set up a situation where the likelihood of a bank run is mathematically insignificant.

Or, more accurately, the bankers have set up a system whereby the risk of bank runs is socialized, while exceptionally gained bank profits are privatized.

Wealth condensation is ultimately a function of capitalism, banks or no banks. This idea of a tier of "bankers" and "non-bankers" is somewhat misleading. "Bankers" are salaried employees responsible for dealing with banking transactions.

I suppose you mean the "wealthy bankers" in the sense of the bank owners. That these "wealthy bankers" are increasingly corporations with stockholders I suppose is ultimately unimportant to your point.

How about a two-tiered society of "those wealthy enough not to have to give a rat's ass about inflation or anything like that" and "everyone else?"

Most real capitalists have to get by on creating new wealth by manufacturing goods or providing services, rather than the manipulation of monetary tokens. I as a full-fledged capitalist pig object to our banker overlords who have created a class of paper-pushing do-nothings, typified by that remora-like pinnacle of idleness, the "daytrader". Of course, the sharks themselves reside in London and Wall Street.

I don't. It was a stupid idea, and it's good that it was reppealed. Why would I support everything the government does because I don't agree that the Fed, in principle, needs to be abolished?

I think the ability of private citizens to hold their wealth in whatever form they want is a pillar of workable capitalism.

There sure is a lot of stupidity going around. But unlike FDR in 1933, we're not stupid. Could you elaborate on all of the possible motives you think might exist for E.O. 6102, other than stupidity? I would appreciate this, because on the one hand I'm told by many that this funny little inert metal known as gold is just a barbaric relic that only a fool would value, and yet on the other we see clearly that ownership of said inert metal was banned for forty-one years. Is this just a false dilemma?
 
Incorrect. Any money the Fed lends to its member banks is inflationary due to the issuance of new currency. It is referred to as "high powered money" or the "monetary base", because when it is injected it becomes the apex of a pyramid, becoming the basis for multiple rounds of new bank deposits, thanks to the fractional reserve system.

It’s quite funny to see you starting your post with “incorrect” just to follow that with a barrage of incorrect assertions. First of all the monetary base is not “any money the Fed lends to its member banks”, what economists refer to as the “monetary base” is to the narrowest definition you can think of money in an economy: money in the hands of the public and reserves in the Central Bank from the private banks. It is called “high powered” money because it is the most liquid form of money, not because it is inflationary or is the apex of any pyramid (in fact, it is the base of the monetary aggregates pyramid). Loans taken by the commercial banks are just part of the monetary base.

Will you ever grab a book Tippit?

My evidence is the fact that the Fed's codifying principles are logically and morally corrupt, and its existence alone is systematically corrupt.

The only evidence you have shown so far demonstrated that The Fed financed less than 1% of the government expenditures on 2003 ... why do you think The Fed is so corrupt when the data contradicts your accusation? Ignorance or just pure dishonesty? Why do you keep repeating the same lies after the data you brought here showed that in 2003 bonds bought by The Fed to the government represented 0.25% of the U.S. GDP?

I won't say you are dishonest, you are just ignorant.

I fail to see any substantive difference between counterfeiters and central bankers, other than the relative legal status of their activities.

And that concludes my participation in this discussion. When you (Tippit) grab a monetary theory book and get some formal education, then we can carry on this discussion.

Now i know why you hold such incorrect views. As i said before, clueless would be an understatement.
 
Last edited:
To be fair to Tippit, if the money supply was truly completely static - with no mining of new metals, no production of x objects of currency, and no printing of new money at all - then the wage/price cycle would likely not exist.

Mostly because you'd just be shuffling the same amount of objects of currency around in the economy (I'm also assuming that no one ever holds this currency in reserve, thus making it completely static).

Of course, that scenario doesn't represent real life. Inflation fluctuates not only from printing or removing money, but from holding and releasing savings or reserves, or exploiting new currency-like resources (such as gold, silver, or platinum).

Also, the Phillips curve doesn't hold in the long run, but it is a very real factor in the short run. Also, it's something I haven't seen Tippit address. I'd like to know if he has any thoughts on it.

Even if the money supply is fixed, unless supply grows at the same rate as demand there will be inflation.

The Philips curve does hold in the long run, it is just not the same curve you would have in the short run since in the long run you only have one NAIRU. But basically you are correct, there is no tradeoff in the long run.
 
So you don't agree with the wage/price cycle? Despite that it both follows economic theory and can be observed in reality?

Whether or not you like it, the increasing of wages and prices in response to each other is ultimately an inflationary trend.

Which is why the wage/price cycle is inflationary.

I don't agree that the general price level is dependent upon the price of labor more than the price of anything else, over the long run. This would be mistaking correlation for cause. You could probably study the prices of many things during an inflation and find many correlations, for instance, the price of oil.

The increase of wages and general prices in response to each other is ultimately just a symptom of either more money chasing the same or fewer goods (monetary inflation), or an economic slowdown resulting in the same or more money chasing fewer goods (stagflation). Either way since prices are defined in monetary units it stands to obvious reason that the principle causative factor of inflation or deflation is the supply of money relative to the supply of goods. The prices of some goods and services will influence each other, but they will not influence the general price level over the long run.

Yes, given a static supply of money. But we don't have a static supply of money. Given a completely static supply of money, the wage/price cycle tends not to exist, and the growth is in fact deflationary.

You've just demonstrated why the original claim that rising wages cause higher prices is false. If we isolate the variable prices of labor and a general price index by keeping the money supply constant, then the wage/price cycle tends not to exist, thereby disqualifying it as a cause of inflation altogether. The price of labor rises along with many other prices under inflationary conditions. Happy to have you on board!

That's the theory, yes. Unfortunately, in practice the wages and prices don't always rise and fall the way they should. Given a fast enough rate of deflation, wages may tend to remain sticky enough that firms choose to fire employees to reduce costs, thus raising unemployment. It will adjust in the long run, usually, but it can hurt the economy severely in the short run. The damn Phillips Curve and all that.

My explanation for the Phillips curve was given earlier in the thread. I think it is a short term condition from informational asymmetries that arise due to the money illusion whereby employers are more sensitive to real vs. nominal wages and use this knowledge to hire more workers at lower real cost. Voila, we now have higher wages and lower unemployment to blame for the rise in general prices. Meanwhile, central bankers snicker. Damn those greedy wage earners.

Actually, the central bank doesn't pretend to fight inflation. They are designed to stabilize the currency, preventing radical inflation or deflation and preserving the short term stability of inflation and unemployment.

You could have fooled me. But I won't debate what central banks pretend to do. On the other hand, maybe you could tell me exactly why our currency and employment rates should be "stabilized", and how a 99% debasing of the US dollar since the Fed's inception in 1913 qualifies as "stable"?

And who, precisely, forces you to hold your wealth in fiat dollars? (Please don't say it's a law that you can't refuse dollars, because it isn't true according to the US Treasury.)

The same people who force me to submit an income tax return, pay income taxes, and use Federal Reserve notes to pay debts. And yes, if a debtor offers you legal tender to satisfy a debt, you are legally obliged to accept it or the debt is void. The only exception to this are debts which arise at the same time as your offer to pay. Which is why vending machines don't have to accept your $100 bill, but restaurants do.

This raises another question as to the moral problem with contemporary money systems. Even if that for some definition of "force" we are not forced to hold a currency that is perpetually debased by bankers, what moral right do they have to debase them? Does the fact that most people are ignorant of the vagaries of monetary policy exempt bankers from their monetary plunder and raping of most people? You might think so, but I don't. If you're not smart enough to lock your front door, that doesn't justify me walking into your house and stealing everything. If you're not smart enough to use a proper deadbolt, that doesn't justify me picking the lock.

Which is why it's important to check the system. Thus we have a central bank that is not beholden to Congress, but that follows a specific mandate of monetary policy.

Which makes no sense at all. The arguments for central bank "independence" are about as bankrupt as they get. Lets take control of the most important aspect of any economy - the supply of money - move it outside the realm of political accountability and give it to benignly disinterested and inordinately altruistic bankers, while simultaneously lauding the virtues of "independence". Is there a specific gene sequence in bankers that makes them less corruptible than politicians? Your "check" to the system is no check at all.

I would venture that the reason there is no interest in the subject is because most people see the system as working pretty well for them.

For some selective definition of "most people" that doesn't include the 3,000,000,000 people who live on less than $2 per day, and the 1,000,000,000 children living in poverty. The reason there is no interest in the subject is because people have been systematically dumbed-down and distracted, or, they either are or perceive themselves as being beneficiaries of the system. If you consider yourself one of the latter, then maybe that perception will change over time, as US borders and our standard of living are eroded to converge with the third world. By then it will be too late.

But what monetary reform would you actually propose? All you've really said (that I remember, sorry if I missed something) is you don't want to return to the gold standard and you don't want the Fed around anymore (and no fractional reserve banking). But what would you set up? Bimetallic standard? Fixed currency issue? No currency? Much more regulated Fed?

Abolish the Fed, abolish the Federal Income Tax, abolish the practice of fractional reserve banking, abolish fiat money in favor of commodity (not fiduciary) money, place statutory limitations on government borrowing, return government to its constitutional role.

That's a start. If it seems outlandishly far-fetched or ridiculous to you, then I submit that this is exactly how far we've come.
 
Abolish the Fed, abolish the Federal Income Tax

Sure, deprive the government from more than 50% of its revenues. Roads, bridges, schools, hospitals, social security ... etc. grow in trees, right Tippit?

This thread became a comedy.
 
You can add as many layers of abstraction to the process as you want, but that doesn't change the fact that there are beneficiaries, and losers. The beneficiaries are the ones closest to the creation of the money. The losers are the last to receive it. Nor does the ascribed legitimacy to the process change anything. You can call counterfeiting illegal, and praise what the Federal Reserve does legally, but there is no other difference. Institutionalized crime is nevertheless crime.

But it's NOT a crime. And second, the difference has been explained to you. The new money printed by the government is not hidden, and is immediately put into circulation. So tell me, who benefits from it ? And who loses ? Aside from the aforemention indebted ?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom