The gain is realized at the exact point when the new money is exchanged for goods and services. As to the question of which creators are responsible, the number of layers of abstraction in the process doesn't change the fundamental nature of the process. Using the counterfeiting analogy, in a counterfeiting ring who is guilty of the crime of counterfeiting? The ringleader? The person who supplied the laser printers, paper, and ink? The person who initiated the print function? Or the person or people who spent the new money into the economy?
Except this isn't analogous either. When money is created under the current Reserve system it eventually enters general circulation, it isn't placed in the private accounts of the board members or anything. If you wish to argue it really is somehow, then you'll need to provide some evidence of this.
As for the creation of money and retiring to a nice tropical island, I can't prove it doesn't happen, and given human nature am inclined to believe it happens all the time.
You could, however, try to prove it does happen, which would be far more helpful than speculating about it. I'm only willing to go so far as to say it could happen without evidence it actually does.
Most of the NY money center bank loans to the so-called developing nations have low or non-existent reserve requirements, and are secured at US taxpayer expense through the IMF/World Bank. It's likely that most of that money winds up in kickbacks and in the coffers of tin-pot African dictators. Meanwhile the African people end up paying the interest in a never-ending cycle of debt with their labor and natural resources.
The best thing about this is that if you can find proof of some of these accusations, you can probably bring legal action against the participants (specifically if they are receiving kickbacks). If you have some solid evidence, I probably wouldn't be the only person interested in it. This is also straying a bit far afield of the Federal Reserve. I know it's connected somewhat, but you're starting to get away from domestic monetary policy and into international loans.
I don't think fiat money itself represents theft. I think when the supply of money is governed by human beings as opposed to economic scarcity that theft becomes practically inevitable. The only notable historical exception was the Byzantine empire which imposed harsh penalties for coin-clipping.
I think theft is a possibility under all economic systems, you have to take steps to prevent it or mitigate the damage done by it. Scarcity doesn't make theft less of a possibility, although it does certainly make it more profitable and potentially damaging.
As for the profitability of debauching your own currency, just think of aggregate money supply as a pie chart, of which you own a slice. As you inflate, your slice of the pie increases, as does the size of the pie itself. The purchasing power of each unit in the pie decreases, but your relative share increases. In addition, those who inflate know when they're doing it. They can convert their monetary holdings into real assets, leaving all the other money holders with the bag.
Except that theory doesn't make any sense. If you hold your money entirely in currency (or a deposit in currency at a bank, for example), then inflating the money supply decreases the overall worth of your holdings. The situation you propose only sort-of works if, like you say, you hold real assets.
However, it still doesn't make your purchasing power increase. If you buy real assets and then inflate the money supply, your real assets may be worth more total dollars, but their purchasing power will remain the same, as the overall market will correct for the new money supply.
Finally, if you hold some of your wealth in the form of debts owed to you (as, say, a bank or credit card company), then inflation is death to your debt-wealth. As the purchasing power of the dollar declines, the loan owed to you also becomes less valuable. Similarly, because wages tend to increase with inflation (and because obtaining dollars in an inflated money supply is easier), the consumers become more able to pay off the debt, losing you money earned in interest.
I suppose you could increase your real wealth by buying real assets, inflating the currency supply drastically and immediately, selling your assets before the market corrects, and then buying more real assets.
But we don't see this kind of radical inflation in the US, so it seems unlikely that someone is trying to play that game.
It's not like the Fed has sole control over inflation anyway - there are various checks involved on the issuance of new currency. While not foolproof, they prevent one person from simply flooding the market with tons of currency.
There is another factor which helps ensure the circulation of fiat money - Gresham's_Law. This law essentially states that bad money drives out good.
That has more to do with consumer behavior than anything else, and will work with counterfeit non-fiat currency as well.
As far as the trade deficit with China, I would say that it is philosophically a good deal for us that we give them paper, and they give us real goods and services. There are consequences to this, they wield exorbitant influence over the US Dollar. I don't think monetary reform would solve these kinds of problems specifically because other countries are free to use fiat money/fractional reserve banking regimes. Only fiscal reform would prevent this. If we were to abolish the Federal Reserve tomorrow, there are a hundred other central banks that Congress would continue borrowing from in order to fund its deficits.
Deficit budgets are a whole other topic, true.
I think monetary reform is the biggest issue nobody cares about, and I think Jefferson was right when he said
I think most consumers are happy as long as the system works. Ultimately, we're all spinning a lot of plates here... as long as most of them stay up, I think we're doing all right. If you have serious suggestions to improve things, that's always welcome.
I think the money illusion is real and I don't think people grasp the magnitude of how inflation destroys their savings and wealth over time, much how many people don't understand compound interest.
That depends on how they hold their wealth. I think more people understand the way inflation erodes currency-based wealth than you might think.
I think inflation is the cause of many economic problems for which the blame is placed elsewhere (usually on capitalism). I don't think economic growth or employment are dependent on fiat money/fractional reserve banking regimes, nor would be harmed by needed reforms.
I think we need to separate fractional reserve from fiat money, because the two are vastly different processes.
What, in principle, is wrong with fractional reserve? Nobody forces you to invest in a bank that uses it, and it provides a means by which potential capitalists can obtain startup money. So what? You can convert all your money to gold and hold onto it if you want - as can anyone else.
How is fractional reserve itself harming the larger economy?
Inflation isn't a cause of growth or employment, but it does tend to be a result of it. I know the Phillips curve tends to collapse in the long run, but there is still the wage/price cycle to consider. I suppose without fiat money to easily expand the system, we could curb inflation to some degree by halting that cycle. That would protect those that want to hold currency, sure, as well as loaning institutions.
I also think the money system is the supreme cause of the Wealth Condensation Effect.
I don't. I think it's ultimately something you'll find in any system that allows individuals to continue to hold private wealth and invest it elsewhere. It can happen under any economic system that doesn't forcibly confiscate wealth from the wealthy and give it to everyone else.
Now, I don't think that's a good idea at all, but wealth condensation will occur to some degree in a free market system. It's one of those tradeoffs we all have to make.
There is a fiat money scheme called the Monetary Reform Act which was endorsed by Milton Friedman. I don't necessarily support it but it makes for interesting reading. I think fractional reserve banking is the biggest problem and is the primary cause of the business cycle, hence monetary reform should begin with this.
How? Do you agree with the MRA's approach? If not, what specifically do you propose?
Tippit, I like you a lot better than TruthSeeker. He didn't really want to talk about anything, he just wanted to push his agenda (he's done this before in other threads), but you seem willing to have an actual discussion. That's refreshing.