federal reserve conspiracy!!!

Alas, it is not clear enough for me to determine exactly who you think is stealing from whom.

The purchasing power of everyone who saves or holds the money in question is stolen by the money issuer, or counterfeiter. The proportion by which the issuer increases the total money supply is the same proportion by which each individual unit is debauched.

If you're questioning whether or not this really qualifies as theft, is it any less theft to steal one penny from one hundred different people than to steal one dollar from one person? If you think so, then would you explain what you think the moral and legal rationalizations behind counterfeiting laws are? Is counterfeiting a victim-less crime, in your estimation? Is legal institutionalized theft somehow different than illegal theft, other than the obvious?
 
Last edited:
This may be a dumb question, but is all currency that is in circulation borrowed from the Federal Reserve.

Theoretically it is all borrowed, yes. Consider this 1941 exchange between then Fed Chairman Marriner Eccles and Congressman Wright Patman in Eccles' testimony to the House Banking Committee:

MR. PATMAN: How did you get the money to buy those two billion dollars worth of Government securities in 1933?

ECCLES: We created it.

MR. PATMAN: Out of what?

ECCLES: Out of the right to issue credit money.

MR. PATMAN: And there is nothing behind it, is there, except our Government’s credit?

ECCLES: That is what our money system is. If there were no debts in our money system, there wouldn’t be any money.

According to the Fed its open market activity is limited to the purchase and sale of US government obligations, but I'm aware of no regulation that prevents them from purchasing any asset that they deem necessary. If in fact they were to purchase real assets, then that high-powered money wouldn't be encumbered by debt. As far as I know this has never happend.
 
TruthSeeker1234 in your analogy you assume that the entity holding the monopoly power over money creation takes active part in the economy, that is: buys goods and services with the money being issued. In the real world economists advocate for an independent central bank (the Federal Reserve and Chile's Central Bank are good examples) with the very purpose of avoiding the analogy you are trying to make.

By the way, can you please point to Von Mises' argument against fiat money?

Monetizing government debt more than qualifies as "taking an active role in the economy". The Fed's job is to make sure that Congress gets all of the money that it could possibly want to spend. To the extent that the supply of US government IOUs goes unmet by the demand of US investors, and foreign creditors, the Fed stands ready as "lender of last resort" to monetize those IOUs and provide congress with the money it needs to deficit spend. The difference between foreign and US investors and the Fed is, the Fed has the ability to create money out of "thin-air" by crediting the account of a Wall Street bond broker. This is known as "high-powered money", and is also highly inflationary, reducing the purchasing power of all pre-existing Federal Reserve Notes. The Fed, far from being a valiant warrior in the fight against inflation, is actually the primary cause of inflation.

The argument that central banks should be "independent" is dangerous. The idea that control over the single most important aspect of our economy - our money - should be delegated to bankers is wrong, it should fall firmly within the realm of political accountability, or, left to the market entirely.
 
Uhh, no they don't. The Fed is not a for profit organization. It is regulated by Congress. Any money they make in excess of their expenses is paid by to the Treasury, last year it was something like $29 billion. The Fed also does not "create" money. All they do is buy up and sell treasuries (which they are not responsible for creating in the first place) to keep the money supply in check. The Fed also does not print currency, the treasury does.

But other than being factually incorrect on every count, I have no problem with your post.

Actually, you're incorrect. The Fed is a quasi-public organization, which means it enjoys certain public and private benefits where they apply. Member banks of the Fed own restricted stock that pays dividends, disqualifying it as a non-profit. They are not regulated by Congress, and their only accountability to Congress is in the form of Congressional testimony before the House and Senate Banking Committees. The Fed certainly does create and destroy money, that is its express purpose. Did you think their open market operations were funded by paid-in capital? When they purchase securities in the open market, they are funded by a bookkeeping entry on a computer which reflects a credit to the account of the bond dealer's bank. When they make a sale, a debit is recorded in the same way. If they used paid-in capital, they would be merely another bond investor, not an instrument of monetary policy.
 
Oh, wait, you forgot to mention that it's pretty and shiny.

Now, here's a question for you. If gold is so great, and actual dollars are just rubbish, then why don't, y'know, businessmen ... capitalists ... entrepreneurs ... people like that ... insist on dealing in gold rather than these bits of green paper?

Bit of a puzzler, no?

That's a good question. Legal tender laws require the acceptance of Federal Reserve Notes for all debts, public and private. The kicker here is that you must remit your Federal Income taxes in Federal Reserve Notes. This creates an artificial demand for the notes, which is ultimately based on coercion. Perhaps it's no coincidence that the Federal Reserve and Federal Income Tax acts were both passed in 1913.

Obviously, dollars aren't "rubbish", or worthless. The problem is that since the inception of the Federal Reserve, they have been continuously debauched such that they are always being made worth less. The result is a continuous, surreptitious transfer of wealth from the saver to the money issuer.
 
(1) Why do you want to stop inflation?

Why would you want to start, or continue inflation? According to economist John Maynard Keynes in The Economic Consequences of the Peace:

"By a continuing process of inflation, governments can confiscate, secretly and unobserved, an important part of the wealth of their citizens. By this method they not only confiscate, but they confiscate arbitrarily; and, while the process impoverishes many, it actually enriches some. The sight of this arbitrary rearrangement of riches strikes not only at security, but at confidence in the equity of the existing distribution of wealth."

Keynes goes on to say:

"Lenin was certainly right. There is no subtler, no surer means of overturning the existing basis of society than to debauch the currency. The process engages all the hidden forces of economic law on the side of destruction, and does it in a manner which not one man in a million is able to diagnose."

I would substitute "bankers" for "government" here. But regardless of your political persuasion, can we agree that tax policy shouldn't be surreptitious but fair and non-regressive, and that tax revenue should accrue to governments, and not private bankers?

(2) Do you have the faintest idea what the gold standard did to the American economy?

Do you? When analyzing the systemic problems of any monetary system past or present, it is important to take a holistic view. To indict the gold standard for past economic problems is to take a rather myopic view of history, and indulges the anti-gold propaganda that has been unleashed by the banking establishment over contemporary history. It also ignores the vastly more significant problem of fractional reserve banking, which is a problem independent of whether we use commodity, fiduciary, or fiat money systems.
 
My english is just fine and I've lived in Europe for just 30 years. :D

Ace I'll add history and economics to the ever expanding list of "Stuff Ace knows diddle squat about". The 20s crash was caused by several reasons, but essentially the stock market was phenomenally over valued. Similar to the web stock boom in the 90s. People were buying stock on the assumption that it would automatically rise. It was a bubble and it burst.

The "roaring twenties" including the bull stock market at the time were the direct result of the Federal Reserve's expansionary monetary policy, as was the crash and the subsequent Great Depression the result of it's contraction of the money supply by nearly one-third. There is little debate among economists anymore over this, and it's been confirmed by the likes of Milton Friedman. Even one of today's most vehement apologists for the Federal Reserve System, Dr. Edward Flaherty, concedes that this was true. You can find his "debunking" of Fed theories using google.

This is the most achingly thunder headed maddeningly stupid argument I've ever seen proposed, since, well, the last time Ace spoke. There's no point even arguing with someone who is so spectacularly wrong. We just need to pick our jaws up off the floor, shake our heads, walk away and wonder, "Millions of sperm, and he was the fastest?"



Oh and BTW. ABBY RULEZ!
 
When analyzing the systemic problems of any monetary system past or present, it is important to take a holistic view.


Welcome to the forum, Tippit. Glad to see a new face. And I must say that you are off to what I think is a record-breaking start: six posts in a row and not a single word right.


ETA: Seven! While I was typing, you got in another one! Good for you.
 
Also, there is a poor notion here that inflation in itself is inherantly evil. Look up the Phillip's curve for a refutation of this.

You want no inflation at all? Or unnaturally low inflation? Then welcome high unemployment.

The Philips curve was discredited in the seventies. In the long run, there is no meaningful relationship between unemployment, and inflation. In the short run, employees suffering from money illusion are willing to accept higher nominal wages and lower real wages, but this condition is temporary and ends when workers obtain a more realistic expectation of inflationary trends.

in·fla·tion (n-flshn)
n.
1. The act of inflating or the state of being inflated.
2. A persistent increase in the level of consumer prices or a persistent decline in the purchasing power of money, caused by an increase in available currency and credit beyond the proportion of available goods and services.

Inflation is caused by expansion of the money supply, a reduction in goods and services, or some combination of both (stagflation). When inflation is the result of monetary manipulation, which is surely the vast majority of the time, it is "evil" and represents theft, as surely as when a pickpocket steals money from your wallet.
 
Is there anyone who can offer a critique of the notion that fiat money is theft?

I would critique that notion. Technically, fiat money itself is not theft. If we all agree to use token money, such as at the beginning of a game of Monopoly, there is no inherent theft. Milton Friedman et al. posited a Monetary Reform Act which would in effect abolish the Federal Reserve banking cartel and restore the control of money to Congress. It would, limited by statute, create enough credit-based fiat money to pay down the national debt, while gradually increasing the bank reserve requirement ratio to 100%, so as to offset the hyperinflation that would otherwise occur. If i recall correctly, it would increase the stock of money at 3% per annum, strictly limited by statute, ostensibly to prevent disinflation.

Practically, fiat money and fractional reserve banking have always resulted in theft, and are the root cause of poverty, war, and injustice in the world. They are also the root cause of the wealth condensation effect. It is likely that given human nature, all fiat money regimes even ones which seek to limit the supply of money by statute will fall to human corruption ultimately. When the banker in that game of Monopoly cheats and allocates the bank tokens for himself in order to buy up all of the real property on the board, there is theft.
 
I would critique that notion. Technically, fiat money itself is not theft. If we all agree to use token money, such as at the beginning of a game of Monopoly, there is no inherent theft. Milton Friedman et al. posited a Monetary Reform Act which would in effect abolish the Federal Reserve banking cartel and restore the control of money to Congress. It would, limited by statute, create enough credit-based fiat money to pay down the national debt, while gradually increasing the bank reserve requirement ratio to 100%, so as to offset the hyperinflation that would otherwise occur. If i recall correctly, it would increase the stock of money at 3% per annum, strictly limited by statute, ostensibly to prevent disinflation.

Practically, fiat money and fractional reserve banking have always resulted in theft, and are the root cause of poverty, war, and injustice in the world. They are also the root cause of the wealth condensation effect. It is likely that given human nature, all fiat money regimes even ones which seek to limit the supply of money by statute will fall to human corruption ultimately. When the banker in that game of Monopoly cheats and allocates the bank tokens for himself in order to buy up all of the real property on the board, there is theft.

So none of these things existed before fiat money... interesting.
 
I never made any such claim. It was the market which selected gold as the best functioning money, not me. The market, as in the combined subjective decisions of billions of people over thousands of years. That this occurred is an objective fact. There is nothing magical about it.

It seems that the market has selected a wide variety of fiat currencies as the best functioning money today.

This thread has rambled a bit since I stopped following it because my son was born, but how again would, say, mining more gold not create inflation? If the amount of currency medium on the market increases, the value of it in exchange tends to decrease. How is that not true of gold, especially as it has little utility except as a medium of exchange or a means of ornamentation?
 
It seems that the market has selected a wide variety of fiat currencies as the best functioning money today.

This thread has rambled a bit since I stopped following it because my son was born,

Well that deserves a mazal tov!
 
Fleshpie ?

Clearly! :)

Mmmm... savoury pie with savoury ingredients....

So, what happened here while I was gone? I saw something about TS misreading someone's reference to marginal utility and claiming to have "owned" them prematurely... or something. Has this discussion made any progress?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom