Faith leads to evil.

Pathetic. I said he was atheist.

Bundy made the non-sequitor jump to conclusion that value-judgement is subjective, therefore there are no consequences to breaking the law. Obviously, he was wrong, he suffered the consequences.

So what was wrong was basically that he was caught? If he'd gotten away with it, as many people do, for a long time at least, then would his reasoning have been valid?
 
How can you have a logical conversation with people who want to believe that Bundy or Stalin committed evil due to their lack of belief-- while refusing to accept that Hitler was a Christian or that Al Quaeda did awful things in the name of their faith? Or that Andrea Yates killed her kids to send them to their heavenly eternity early?

When faith healing or refusal of a blood transfusion leads to death, the apologists blame everything but faith... their double standard is so glaring. And they use the worst semantic twisting of correlation with causation in order to relate any evil done by a non believer to be tied to the lack of belief. Lack of belief is NOT a motivator... it's the same as the lack of belief that theists have in other woo and other religions. It's a nothing. It is only a "something" in the minds of those brainwashed by theists to think that it is. Is Sagan's greatness due to his "lack" of belief? Or was it more due to what he understood and taught to others?

Most atheists are probably humanist or rationalists which may inform their choices... but the stuff that people don't believe in, can't shape their choices any more than a theist's non belief in rain dancing shapes his choices.

Why is it so hard for some people to understand this simple message? Has their thinking been made that poor by their faith. If so, chalk up another "evil" in the name of "faith". Faith my not cause evil... but there does seem to be a very strong correlation between faith and ignorance coupled with arrogance. Of course, anyone who thinks they KNOW what God wants --is by definition both arrogant and ignorant. How can they be any other way? It's on par with claiming to know what clothes the Emperor is wearing while shaming those who don't see any clothes.
 
Last edited:
So what was wrong was basically that he was caught? If he'd gotten away with it, as many people do, for a long time at least, then would his reasoning have been valid?


Were the abortion clinic bombers' theology valid until they were caught?
 
So what was wrong was basically that he was caught? If he'd gotten away with it, as many people do, for a long time at least, then would his reasoning have been valid?

Are you so daft that you can only see the legal consequences of his actions?
 
How can you have a logical conversation with people who want to believe that Bundy or Stalin committed evil ....

Not only that, but they also try to say that Bundy's deeds were rational. These faithful people are so paralyzed by faith that they defend Bundy's actions as rational. I think this is just another way of their claiming that morality comes from a god.
 
Hitler believed that Jews were Jesus killers... I guess his theology was wrong because he was caught, eh?

The hijackers believed they would be rewarded in paradise. We can't prove that they aren't being rewarded... I guess that makes them, right eh?

Oh how crazy to extrapolate the way a theist does.
(Westprog has been made ridiculous by his faith... of course, the ridiculous are seldom aware of their ridiculousness...)
 
Not only that, but they also try to say that Bundy's deeds were rational. These faithful people are so paralyzed by faith that they defend Bundy's actions as rational. I think this is just another way of their claiming that morality comes from a god.

Ah....

Yes. So in Westprog's mind, Bundy was wrong because God says so... and Westprog refrains from such actions because God doesn't want him too.

I guess all of us atheists who don't kill, pillage, torture, lie, etc... are just really super extra moral people... because we do so without promises from god or threats of hell. But that means we better encourage "faith" among the weak-willed since they believe they will be awful without it. I wonder if faith has ever even prevented one murder or has even come close to helping to the extent that it's harmed? The statistics just don't show a positive correlation between faith and morality no matter where you look. The morality seems to exist entirely in the head of the faithful.
 
Last edited:
Figures often beguile me, particularly when I have the arranging of them myself; in which case the remark attributed to Disraeli would often apply with justice and force: "There are three kinds of lies: lies, damned lies, and statistics." ~ Mark Twain
 
Last edited:
Were the abortion clinic bombers' theology valid until they were caught?

I've said, numerous times, that I believe in a right and wrong which has real meaning. (That's as far as I've gone in this forum in stating my actual beliefs).

Hence whether or not a bomber is caught or not has no bearing on whether his actions are right or wrong. Neither does it make any difference in the case of Bundy.
 
Ah....

Yes. So in Westprog's mind, Bundy was wrong because God says so... and Westprog refrains from such actions because God doesn't want him too.

I didn't say that, or imply it. I said that I believe that moral standards are real. I didn't derive that from God. I haven't said anything about my beliefs in God.

I guess all of us atheists who don't kill, pillage, torture, lie, etc... are just really super extra moral people... because we do so without promises from god or threats of hell. But that means we better encourage "faith" among the weak-willed since they believe they will be awful without it. I wonder if faith has ever even prevented one murder or has even come close to helping to the extent that it's harmed? The statistics just don't show a positive correlation between faith and morality no matter where you look. The morality seems to exist entirely in the head of the faithful.

How can one be moral if morality doesn't have any actual meaning?
 
Are you so daft that you can only see the legal consequences of his actions?

I've said that I think that Bundy's actions were wrong regardless of what his own moral code was. I find that a relatively easy judgement to make. I am not a moral relativist.

That doesn't mean that I can necessarily know in every case what the right thing is. With Bundy, it's easy. With other things, it's far from obvious. However, I do believe that there is a right thing to do in every case.

It seems that it's necessary to keep restating what my own views are as I try to chase down moral relativism.
 
Not only that, but they also try to say that Bundy's deeds were rational. These faithful people are so paralyzed by faith that they defend Bundy's actions as rational. I think this is just another way of their claiming that morality comes from a god.

In what way were Bundy's actions irrational? He wanted gratification for perverted urges, and he didn't care about the consequences for other people. As far as I can see, he acted quite rationally, given that as a starting point.

Obviously, if Bundy had cared what happened to other people, then it would be irrational for him to act in that way. He didn't. He only cared about himself.

I believe that what Bundy did was wrong. Hence I believe he shouldn't have done it, regardless of whether he enjoyed it, whether he was caught, or whether he thought it was worth it even if he was caught. I believe it was wrong, and he shouldn't have done it, even if God forgave him and he went to heaven.

But if you don't believe in right and wrong, you're left with a problem if you want to condemn Bundy. Hence you need to say that what he did was irrational. It's not clear exactly how it was irrational - presumably because it was not in his own best interests.

I believe that it was wrong, not only for the victims, but for Bundy himself. But I think that on the basis in which he saw the world, his actions were rational. If he was deranged, it was in his abnormal appetites. It was not in the ways in which he gratified them.
 
Neither faith nor atheism or rationality should be privy to a moral high-ground or relegated to a moral abyss, unlike what Dawkins' absolute statement and folks in this thread contend. Recognizing this isn't apologism, it's being objective.

How can you have a logical conversation with people who want to believe that Bundy or Stalin committed evil due to their lack of belief-- while refusing to accept that Hitler was a Christian or that Al Quaeda did awful things in the name of their faith? Or that Andrea Yates killed her kids to send them to their heavenly eternity early?


The problem with putting everyone who disagrees with you on ignore is that you end up having to make up their opinions. Dragoonster was quite explicit in stating that evil deeds can come from either faith or atheism. I agree with him because it's obviously true.

Naturally Articulett has no interest in having a logical conversation with people who think that the people who flew aircraft into the WTC weren't motivated by faith. Sadly, she's not interested in talking to people who believe that Al Quaeda are religious fanatics whose beliefs are dangerous either.

Incidentally, I may have taken Dragoonster's Bundy quote and gone further with it than Dragoonster would do. I don't want to get our opinions confused. Dragoonster, if I understand him correctly, was simply showing that religious and non-religious beliefs can both produce good or evil behaviour - in rebuttal of the claims by Weinburg, Dawkins et al that religion is the outstanding cause of evil. I've explored the issue of exactly why atheists reject Bundy (as they mostly do) in the absence of a fixed moral standard.
 
When challenged as to the evil deeds religious people do, their defenders say they were "misguided" and/or not following the "true" religion. Atheists have no such defense.
 
Do you think such evasion and mendacity is endearing or productive?

I think that's an odd definition of mendacity. I'd almost call that an example of mendacity in itself. I've been very explicit in saying what I am and am not revealing. Naturally anyone is at liberty to draw their own conclusions as to my beliefs, and several have done so. I am not claiming that my arguments aren't influenced by my beliefs, or that I have no agenda.

I neither know nor care whether it's endearing or not. I am here to debate. If you want something endearing, here's a fluffy kitten.

hereiam500.jpg



As to whether it is productive - if I put forward arguments, they are intended to be self-sufficient, without my own autobiographical backup.
 
Being a babe in the woods as a relatively new atheist (I survived Christianity, and Catholicism.), a striving intellect (I have quite the ways to go.), I should say that one has to decide -if- they accept good and evil, and work it out from there.

Justification is what it seems to all come down to, whether you're a faith based person or not. Are we talking the validity, or lack thereof, regarding faith - or are we debating over how people justify or rationalize their actions (or inactions)?

Ultimately, it appears we all make our decisions - regardless of the bombarding memes of dogma. As a Christian, I made 'good' and 'evil' decisions, regardless of my faith AND sometimes as a result of it. I chose then, and now, to pursue mostly a 'good' path. The conclusion: I choose -regardless. (This time I strive towards the 'good' out of ultimate rationale, but I also understand sometimes that will require some 'bad'.)

Just tossn. Feedback welcomed.
 
Last edited:
In what way were Bundy's actions irrational? He wanted gratification for perverted urges, and he didn't care about the consequences for other people. As far as I can see, he acted quite rationally, given that as a starting point.

He acted rationally given the irrational starting point? That's quite a concept. Anyway, you're still wrong.

Obviously, if Bundy had cared what happened to other people, then it would be irrational for him to act in that way. He didn't. He only cared about himself.

Even caring for himself, he still acted irrational, as the consequences of his actions mean a life of loneliness devoid of love and friendship, which are some of the most exquisite experiences. There is also the consequence of having to hide his actions, constantly being afraid of being caught, and of course, the consequences when he did get caught.

I believe that what Bundy did was wrong. Hence I believe he shouldn't have done it, regardless of whether he enjoyed it, whether he was caught, or whether he thought it was worth it even if he was caught. I believe it was wrong, and he shouldn't have done it, even if God forgave him and he went to heaven.

Why? What rational reason do you have to say what he did was wrong?

But if you don't believe in right and wrong, you're left with a problem if you want to condemn Bundy. Hence you need to say that what he did was irrational. It's not clear exactly how it was irrational - presumably because it was not in his own best interests.

It's irrational because of reasons outlined above.

I believe that it was wrong, not only for the victims, but for Bundy himself. But I think that on the basis in which he saw the world, his actions were rational. If he was deranged, it was in his abnormal appetites. It was not in the ways in which he gratified them.

So his actions were rational even though they were based on irrational premise that could only end up with him causing much harm to the world and/or himself...........

:rolleyes:
 
Dragoonster was quite explicit in stating that evil deeds can come from either faith or atheism. I agree with him because it's obviously true.

You are only half right. Atheism is the lack of belief, a void, evil cannot come from a void. I'm glad you've finally agreed that evil can come from faith.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom