Faith leads to evil.

To get back to Dawkins, instead. If Dawkins had just said that he didn't believe in God, of any kind, then he couldn't have been said to misrepresent anyone's belief. But he's in fact said a lot more than that. He's commented about the nature of god, and produced probabilistic arguments as to why he's impossible. No, atheism per se is not misrepresentation of another's beliefs. But there's a lot more to Dawkins than that.

To be fair, Dawkins was clear in "The God Delusion" that he would only deal with personal gods. While he commented briefly about Deism and other potential views of god -- pantheism, for instance -- he provided no argument against those conceptions and was clear that he could provide no argument against them.

His arguments against personal gods were compelling.
 
Last edited:
To be fair, though, non-belief is not the prime motivator for Hitchens, Harris, Dawkins, etc. They are motivated to write in opposition to other's beliefs because they perceive a danger arising from inaction -- motivation arising largely from 9/11.

Agreed. The motivation doesn't come from non-belief (or at least not solely from that), but, at least in articulett's case, from a belief that adherence is a bad thing and drives people to do bad things.

None of us believe in invisible tree frogs that re-arrange our internal organs each night, so one is motivated to comment on them (except as a stupid example).

No, not treefrogs. Keebler elves. Those cookies are just a front.
 
Yes, yes. Point well taken.


Of course, since those elves are merely shills for the Opus Dei and Trilateral Commission.............

Don't forget [Scottish accent] the Pentavirate! The Queen, the Vatican, the Gettys, the Rothschilds, and Colonel Sanders before he went t*** up![/Scottish accent]
 
Hang on a second...I've been following this conversation for a bit. Wouldn't the whole point be that if Bundy's actions weren't rational, then he was acting irrationally? Isn't whether or not he thinks he is acting rationally an unrelated side note, perhaps an interesting view into a twisted mind, but not evidence that his atheism rationally led to his acts?

Some more thoughts on this. Assume, for the sake of argument, that the world is divided into rational and irrational people. Assume, further, that all the rational people are atheists, and all the irrational people theists.

Suppose that the irrational people are lead to a disbelief in God. Will that make them inherently rational? We have in the example of Bundy someone who reasoned himself into a justification for mass murder. Will the people who believe in Jesus now become better people when they stop? At the very least, it's unproven.
 
To be fair, though, non-belief is not the prime motivator for Hitchens, Harris, Dawkins, etc. They are motivated to write in opposition to other's beliefs because they perceive a danger arising from inaction -- motivation arising largely from 9/11.
Let's assume that this perceived danger is genuine. Would it then be the case that a "lack of belief" in this danger could potentially lead to 'evil'?

None of us believe in invisible tree frogs that re-arrange our internal organs each night, so one is motivated to comment on them (except as a stupid example).

If 90% of the population did believe in these tree frogs, I would imagine there would be those in the other 10% who would comment on them, motivated, at least in part, by their disbelief.
 
To be fair, Dawkins was clear in "The God Delusion" that he would only deal with personal gods. While he commented briefly about Deism and other potential views of god -- pantheism, for instance -- he provided no argument against those conceptions and was clear that he could provide no argument against them.

His arguments against personal gods were compelling.

I would have said that his whole argument about intelligence coming only through evolution and the 'who made God?' type arguments were as much against Deism as any personal gods.
 
Then I think we are merely at cross purposes.



I'd add that I think that most people derive their moral system from individual cases, rather than start with the principles. And I think in practice such systems are more culturally driven than by belief systems.



Well, this argument isn't working out at all.

So, if I'm reading what you're saying correctly, then value's are assigned, and not inherent in any system of belief (or disbelief) if you will.

But then I think you and I always agreed on that point, so far as the OP was concerned, faith (or lack of faith) in almost anything doesn't directly lead to evil, or to good.

It seems that we're all trying to give eachother different directions to the same location.

(I.e. I agree. But I'm trying out new analogies.)
 
Last edited:
Some more thoughts on this. Assume, for the sake of argument, that the world is divided into rational and irrational people. Assume, further, that all the rational people are atheists, and all the irrational people theists.

Suppose that the irrational people are lead to a disbelief in God. Will that make them inherently rational? We have in the example of Bundy someone who reasoned himself into a justification for mass murder. Will the people who believe in Jesus now become better people when they stop? At the very least, it's unproven.

Good questions. Honestly, I'm probably the wrong person to ask them to - I highly doubt that merely changing from theist to atheist will make a person automatically either 'better' or 'worse', and I don't think that people who believe in Jesus are necessarily 'bad', or even not as 'good' as people who don't believe in Jesus - I believe they are mistaken, but that's a slightly different kettle of fish. Also, I'd point out that it's entirely possible to become an atheist for irrational reasons (Rael always makes for a good example here), so there's no guarantee that atheism makes a person more rational.
 
To be fair, though, non-belief is not the prime motivator for Hitchens, Harris, Dawkins, etc. They are motivated to write in opposition to other's beliefs because they perceive a danger arising from inaction -- motivation arising largely from 9/11.

None of us believe in invisible tree frogs that re-arrange our internal organs each night, so one is motivated to comment on them (except as a stupid example).

I think religion gets talked about because it can be so dangerous--this nutty notion that faith is good. I wish I could talk about religion like other woo without all the craziness and defensiveness and apologetics... I wish theists hadn't been so brainwashed to see atheism as something it isn't... and I wish they didn't need to prop up this straw man hatred notion... because then atheism would be like "a-Scientology" or "a-astrology" or "a-any other woo".

If theists would be as silent with their beliefs and opinions as they would like atheists to be-- I bet all vocal atheists would suddenly be as silent as modern day abolitionists. Every era has it's own battles, I guess.

But it's the special sense of entitlement that theists have come to expect and their desire to shut me up that has made me react as I do. I'm sure the same could be said on many levels for Dawkins and Harris. Moreover, Dawkins has helped further some of mankinds most fascinating knowledge regarding evolution... and theists hate him for it... they worship liars and distrust him. I think there's growing reasons to skewer this sacred cow. I think it will be nice when most everyone is assumed to be an atheist... just like most everyone is assumed to be an abolitionist. Then theists, like those who endorse slavery will feel more in line with keeping their opinions to themselves without the need to demonize the opposition so they can keep feeling super special and saved.

(BTW, Beth-- I loudly oppose all woo like Randi and Dawkins -- it's just the religious woo that you are ever apologizing for that rings loudly in your ears... because it's the one you care about--the one you believe is the "true woo" or the "good woo". Your apologist buttons don't get pushed when I'm dissing a woo you don't feel enamored with.)
 
Last edited:
It seems that we're all trying to give eachother different directions to the same location.


…there seems to still be a reluctant detractor or two on either side; otherwise this seems a generally accurate description from my following along…

...I highly doubt that merely changing from theist to atheist will make a person automatically either 'better' or 'worse', and I don't think that people who believe in Jesus are necessarily 'bad', or even not as 'good' as people who don't believe in Jesus - I believe they are mistaken, but that's a slightly different kettle of fish. Also, I'd point out that it's entirely possible to become an atheist for irrational reasons (Rael always makes for a good example here), so there's no guarantee that atheism makes a person more rational.


…a concise summary of a perspective that (it would seem) is shared by many posters on this thread (certainly expresses a good bit of my perspective).
 
Last edited:
It seems that we're all trying to give eachother different directions to the same location.

Different roads but they all lead to Rome.
Laurel and Hardy in a ten minute short.
Separate pages of the same book.
Crosby and Hope trying to get the girl.
Two sides of the same coin.
Zombies attacking the same farm house of survivors.
Watson and Crick defining DNA.

:D
 
Also, I'd point out that it's entirely possible to become an atheist for irrational reasons (Rael always makes for a good example here), so there's no guarantee that atheism makes a person more rational.

Indeed - there are plenty of ways to demonstrate irrationality, and religious belief is only one. (Assuming that religious belief is irrrational in the first place.)
 
If theists would be as silent with their beliefs and opinions as they would like atheists to be-- I bet all vocal atheists would suddenly be as silent as modern day abolitionists. Every era has it's own battles, I guess.

Articulett is following in the footsteps of the abolitionists? Hooray for her.

Dawkins has helped further some of mankinds most fascinating knowledge regarding evolution... and theists hate him for it...

Again, palpably not true. Dawkins' Selfish Gene theories are controversial within the field just like Gould's Punctuated Equilibrium. There's plenty of professional disagreement which is quite seperate from his religious views. And plenty of theists have no problem at all with Dawkins' science.

As usual, it's the hyperbole which lets her down.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom