Ichneumonwasp
Unregistered
- Joined
- Feb 2, 2006
- Messages
- 6,240
To get back to Dawkins, instead. If Dawkins had just said that he didn't believe in God, of any kind, then he couldn't have been said to misrepresent anyone's belief. But he's in fact said a lot more than that. He's commented about the nature of god, and produced probabilistic arguments as to why he's impossible. No, atheism per se is not misrepresentation of another's beliefs. But there's a lot more to Dawkins than that.
To be fair, Dawkins was clear in "The God Delusion" that he would only deal with personal gods. While he commented briefly about Deism and other potential views of god -- pantheism, for instance -- he provided no argument against those conceptions and was clear that he could provide no argument against them.
His arguments against personal gods were compelling.
Last edited: