Faith leads to evil.

...
Rather than just say your holy book has been misrepresented, or deliberately interpreted in an unfavourable light, explain why that is the case. Justify your position!

In the case of biblical fundamentalists, there is an obvious contradiction. It's not possible to reconcile the literal interpretation of the Bible with science. More significantly, much of the approved behaviour in the Old Testament is incompatible with Christian morality.

But a Catholic, say, wouldn't approach things from the same point of view. They would start with Christ founding the church, and acting as a living presence within the church. It's perfectly possible to argue that this is a nonsensical view, but it's not a form of faith that's debunked by studying the bible.

Darth Rotor and RobRoy have both been making an effort, and as such the discussion has progressed where they have been involved - possibly for the first time since I've been on the forums, I have been involved in a discussion on religion* that hasn't devolved into a bickering match, and I must say it is a pleasant experience.

Up till now, anyway.
 
How can you feel "more moral" than the supposed moral relativism of an atheist.? What you have is clearly moral relativism dressed up as something fancy in your head. There is no evidence that it leads to better behavior and lots of evidence to show that it can lead to human suffering. Everyone thinks their faith is a font of "higher truths" and moral wisdom.

And that's why I use the term apologist. It's like some people just can't see the obvious.

The obvious is that "faith" doesn't lead to evil. I'm not an apologist for not embracing a wrong and pithy generalization.

And "no evidence"? So you can use Phelps or Yates as evidence it leads to evil but others can't use Gandhi or Mother Theresa or the local soup kitchen/Salvation Army as evidence that it leads to good? Both conclusions are equally wrong btw. Faith can lead to justifications of actions that may be considered good or evil. So can science. So can rationality. So can atheism. So can scientology. So can video games. So can "rock and roll music". So can utilitarianism. So can etc. etc.

And that makes faith "dangerous". It makes people who "need" the lie... for their imagined "salvation"... and often they need to prove their "faith" to an invisible savior that demands it. Why wouldn't people do anything... including what Andrea Yates did... if they really truly believed that life was a test for eternity... and that you never really die... and that "faith" is the most important attribute you can show your invisible judge?? What wouldn't you do for your faith. What wouldn't you do to ensure the blissful eternity of the people you love most-- and/or yourself?

Everything is dangerous if it's used as justification for an evil act. An atheist rationalist murderer could justify killing her kids by the lack of an afterlife meaning life on Earth is all there is and life on Earth is not worth living due to the evil of the faithful majority and sociological prediction that the faithful majority will remain throughout the kids' lifetimes. Her justification would be bollocks and she'd go to jail or get off due to insanity. Same as the theist.

Both murderers would've based their killing of their kids on their surety in their chosen belief system. It wouldn't change anything if their beliefs were 100% metaphysically correct, or 0%. The children would still be dead, the action would still be evil.
 
The obvious is that "faith" doesn't lead to evil. I'm not an apologist for not embracing a wrong and pithy generalization.

And "no evidence"? So you can use Phelps or Yates as evidence it leads to evil but others can't use Gandhi or Mother Theresa or the local soup kitchen/Salvation Army as evidence that it leads to good? Both conclusions are equally wrong btw. Faith can lead to justifications of actions that may be considered good or evil. So can science. So can rationality. So can atheism. So can scientology. So can video games. So can "rock and roll music". So can utilitarianism. So can etc. etc.

Here, here. I believe a number of us have been saying similar things, but not so succinctly as this.

If you are looking for a BFF, I'd be willing to apply for the job. :D
 
People don't justify their actions because of faith. They are motivated by faith to take action. Sure, faith can lead to good deeds as well as evil, however, the nature of faith is that the faithful place faith over reason and do the deed that their faith calls for without thought or provocation. This is why faith is so dangerous, it enslaves mankind by placing chains around their ability to think.
 
People don't justify their actions because of faith. They are motivated by faith to take action. Sure, faith can lead to good deeds as well as evil, however, the nature of faith is that the faithful place faith over reason and do the deed that their faith calls for without thought or provocation. This is why faith is so dangerous, it enslaves mankind by placing chains around their ability to think.


For the love of reason (*sigh*): SOME people! You really never seem to tire of the same type of overreaching, broad sweeping "straw man" fallacy. Some people are controlled by religion (most who are would likely find themselves controlled by something else with prescriptive capabilities); people who are controlled by religion are prone to being controlled. NOT ALL RELIGIOUS PEOPLE ARE SUCH BECAUSE THEY ARE BRAINWASHED.

You invalidate your points by speaking in absolutes. ;)
 
Last edited:
No. All people who have faith are prone to blind obedience. The more faithful, the more prone they are. Since when does speaking in absolutes invalidate a point?
 
Last edited:
No. All people who have faith are prone to blind obedience. The more faithful, the more prone they are.


Your statements above (already notably toned-down compared to the one I addressed previously) are a slippery attempt to restate your perspective, but still suffer from absolutism. Some pick and choose the humanitarian elements of “doctrine” to follow and exclude the supernatural elements; while this does make them not fundamentalists, they are still faithful in the eyes of many, and most importantly, their own.

If one has "faith" in humanism, one is not necessarily prone to blind obedience, are they?

Since when does speaking in absolutes invalidate a point?


This is not rocket science...

Since you have done so without evidence (except potentially that which applies to the extremes); and since all of our understanding of the world around us is measured with human implements and the resulting data is perceived by humans (and therefore subject to human flaws, bias, and revision)...

If you are merely speaking in terms of your opinion, then I assume your apology for not stating so, and I apologize for misinterpreting your purpose. If not, you are presenting an unsubstantiated claim phrased in definitive terms w/o proof. I’m not suggesting you can’t do that, just that it’s flawed and hurts your claims; think about it.

;)
 
Last edited:
Please, people - I'll give you an awesome hint here, free of charge: Stop using Mother Teresa as an example of 'religious good'.
 
mobyseven said:
Please, people - I'll give you an awesome hint here, free of charge: Stop using Mother Teresa as an example of 'religious good'.

Here's a better hint--it doesn't matter if she was good or evil. The point of using her as an example was as a counterexample to using Yates, Phelps et al as some kind of "proof" of concept. In both cases the examples fail to prove the concept.

RobRoy said:
Here, here. I believe a number of us have been saying similar things, but not so succinctly as this.

You and others have been quite clear, the arguments just seem to meet an iron wall of knee-jerk resistence.

Richard Dawkins said:
There is a logical path from religious faith to evil deeds. There is no logical path from atheism to evil deeds.

This is utterly ridiculous, yet seems to be what many in the thread actually believe (in addition to the Weinberg quote). In addition to Paranoid Android's responses:

Ted Bundy's Logical Path said:
Then I learned that all moral judgments are “value judgments,” that all value judgments are subjective, and that none can be proved either right or wrong.

I even read somewhere that the Chief Justice of the United States had written that the American Constitution expressed nothing more than collective value judgments.

Believe it or not, I figured it out for myself - what apparently the chief justice couldn’t figure out for himself - that if the rationality of one value judgment was zero, multiplying it by millions would not make it one whit more rational. Nor is there any “reason” to obey the law for anyone, like myself, who has the boldness and daring - the strength of character - to throw off shackles….I discovered that to become truly free, truly unfettered, I had to become truly uninhibited.

And I quickly discovered that the greatest obstacle to my freedom, the greatest block and limitation to it, consists in the insupportable “value judgment” that I was bound to respect the rights of others. I asked myself, who were these “others”? Other human beings, with human rights? Why is it more wrong to kill a human animal than any other animal, a pig, or a sheep, or a steer? Is your life more to you that a hog’s life to a hog? Why should I be willing to sacrifice my pleasure more for the one than for the other?

Surely, you would not, in this age of scientific enlightenment, declare that God or nature has marked some pleasures as “moral” or “good” and others as “immoral” or “bad”?

In any case, let me assure you, my dear young lady, that there is absolutely no comparison between the pleasure I might take in eating ham, and the pleasure I anticipate in raping and murdering you. That is the honest conclusion to which my education has led me - after the most conscientious examination of my spontaneous and uninhibited self.

But of course, Bundy wasn't really being logical, or wasn't really an atheist, etc. Or he's an atypical outlier example. Maybe he just wasn't smart enough to really understand rationalism, or he would've naturally been a nice good humanist.

Neither faith nor atheism or rationality should be privy to a moral high-ground or relegated to a moral abyss, unlike what Dawkins' absolute statement and folks in this thread contend. Recognizing this isn't apologism, it's being objective.

thaiboxerken said:
This is why faith is so dangerous, it enslaves mankind by placing chains around their ability to think.

Yet in Bundy's case, his breaking those chains led to evil. Should he be an example of free-thinking? Or do only "good" free-thinkers get to claim the title of atheist or rationalist?
 
For the love of reason (*sigh*): SOME people! You really never seem to tire of the same type of overreaching, broad sweeping "straw man" fallacy. Some people are controlled by religion (most who are would likely find themselves controlled by something else with prescriptive capabilities); people who are controlled by religion are prone to being controlled. NOT ALL RELIGIOUS PEOPLE ARE SUCH BECAUSE THEY ARE BRAINWASHED.

You invalidate your points by speaking in absolutes. ;)

And as a corollary, the twentieth century illustrates very clearly that it is quite possible to control people who have no religious belief, or people whose religious belief is at odds with the controlling ideology or political system.

The cultural revolution wrecked a country and ruined many millions of lives, and no religious belief was involved. A sensible analysis would find the common thread in religious and political blind fanaticism and isolate that as the danger, rather than obsessing about religion alone.
 
Here, here. I believe a number of us have been saying similar things, but not so succinctly as this.

If you are looking for a BFF, I'd be willing to apply for the job. :D

He's certainly started well. Only here since April and already hitting 'em out of the park. Has Articulett put him on ignore yet?
 
He's certainly started well. Only here since April and already hitting 'em out of the park. Has Articulett put him on ignore yet?

I don't think his post count had even reached double figures :D.
 
Your statements above (already notably toned-down compared to the one I addressed previously) are a slippery attempt to restate your perspective, but still suffer from absolutism. Some pick and choose the humanitarian elements of “doctrine” to follow and exclude the supernatural elements; while this does make them not fundamentalists, they are still faithful in the eyes of many, and most importantly, their own.

If one has "faith" in humanism, one is not necessarily prone to blind obedience, are they?

If they pick and choose humanism, they aren't being faithful. Faith isn't a choice, it's a condition of brainwashing.

Since you have done so without evidence (except potentially that which applies to the extremes); and since all of our understanding of the world around us is measured with human implements and the resulting data is perceived by humans (and therefore subject to human flaws, bias, and revision)...

If you are merely speaking in terms of your opinion, then I assume your apology for not stating so, and I apologize for misinterpreting your purpose. If not, you are presenting an unsubstantiated claim phrased in definitive terms w/o proof. I’m not suggesting you can’t do that, just that it’s flawed and hurts your claims; think about it.

Faith is the enslavement of the mind. The more faithful the person, the less rational they are and more prone to do irrational things. Al Queda = more faithful than average Muslim.
 
Yet in Bundy's case, his breaking those chains led to evil. Should he be an example of free-thinking? Or do only "good" free-thinkers get to claim the title of atheist or rationalist?

Bundy was hardly a rationalist. He may have been atheist. There was nothing rational about his actions and his opinion is rather irrational. Try again.
 
Bundy was hardly a rationalist. He may have been atheist. There was nothing rational about his actions and his opinion is rather irrational. Try again.

And what precisely was irrational about his statement? I can't see an obvious flaw in it.

The No True Atheist viewpoint strikes again.
 
And what precisely was irrational about his statement? I can't see an obvious flaw in it.

The No True Atheist viewpoint strikes again.

Pathetic. I said he was atheist.

Bundy made the non-sequitor jump to conclusion that value-judgement is subjective, therefore there are no consequences to breaking the law. Obviously, he was wrong, he suffered the consequences.

Of course, since you are a believer, I can forgive you for not being able to see poor reasoning when it's given.
 
thaiboxerken said:
Your statements above (already notably toned-down compared to the one I addressed previously) are a slippery attempt to restate your perspective, but still suffer from absolutism. Some pick and choose the humanitarian elements of “doctrine” to follow and exclude the supernatural elements; while this does make them not fundamentalists, they are still faithful in the eyes of many, and most importantly, their own.

If one has "faith" in humanism, one is not necessarily prone to blind obedience, are they?

If they pick and choose humanism, they aren't being faithful. Faith isn't a choice, it's a condition of brainwashing.

Since you have done so without evidence (except potentially that which applies to the extremes); and since all of our understanding of the world around us is measured with human implements and the resulting data is perceived by humans (and therefore subject to human flaws, bias, and revision)...

If you are merely speaking in terms of your opinion, then I assume your apology for not stating so, and I apologize for misinterpreting your purpose. If not, you are presenting an unsubstantiated claim phrased in definitive terms w/o proof. I’m not suggesting you can’t do that, just that it’s flawed and hurts your claims; think about it.

Faith is the enslavement of the mind. The more faithful the person, the less rational they are and more prone to do irrational things. Al Queda = more faithful than average Muslim.


You have already said as much; still no evidence I see (some conjecture, again, as to the extremes..."straw man" anyone). Keep it up, Ken; I never fail to find your opinions...revealing, so to speak.

Try this once in front of the mirror and see if your brow doesn't unfurl just enough to allow some consideration: repeat after me, "faith enslaves some minds. My perception of faith is not infallible or definitive. I am a flawed human...and just might not be right all the time"...

...oh right; for a minute there I thought I might be dealing with someone rational.

Support your claims or continue stating your jaded, flawed absolutist opinions, your choice; you state far more about you than anything useful about faith.

...carry on...
 
And what precisely was irrational about his statement? I can't see an obvious flaw in it.

The No True Atheist viewpoint strikes again.

If you're trying to talk to TBK you'll want to look a little to your left. That's a scarecrow you're trying to smack down there.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom