Faith leads to evil.

Indeed. But theism and atheism are values, they are neutral ontological views. Values only come into play when we start projecting our own prejudices onto god or the universe. There is nothing inherently purposeful or purposeless about either atheism or theism: One can easily say, "God exists and has made us for a purpose," but can also easily say, "God exists, and made us for no purpose." Similarly, one can say, "There is no god, therefore life is pointless," but one could also say, "There is no god, therefore we create our own purpose." Until one starts adding things to theism and atheism, they are value neutral.

I have to disagree. Gods are usually made in man's own image or image of what they think is "perfect." Theists believe in this image, while atheists simply don't believe such a being exists. A theist's relgion is often, if not always, built into that god. Atheists have no such connection.

Here is where your claim that atheism and theism are neutral value systems fails. With atheism, you are correct, because atheism is a lack of belif in any and all gods. WIth theism, there is a belief in, at least, one god. The neutrality is lost when the theist is asked to define the god. At that point, they bring to light what their god thinks is moral and just and what they must do to appease that god. In essence, the definition of the god they believe in defines their religion and religious values. This is just another example where faith causes action while lack of faith causea none.
 
Last edited:
Then I can't help you. It's like seeing the difference between black and white. Faith takes no thought process, just blind obedience. Rationality involves a logical thought process based on evidence and knowledge.

Do you believe in rationality or not?

WTF are you talking about? Atheism is just a lack of belief in a god. Theism is a belief in a god.

I think you're hung up on atheism as a non-belief, you think that protects it from misuse. It doesn't. Nutcases can believe in atheism. Atheism itself is neutral.

Nutcases whose parents revealed to them they were Santa Claus can use a-santaism as a basis for going around stealing presents from children.

Then we'll have to disagree. I think irrationality is evil, as well as faith. Although both may lead to good deeds, the potential for evil deeds outweighs them.

Yeah, agree to disagree. I'll say though that the understanding I had of this was that it wouldn't rely on probabilities or likelihoods. As in Dawkin's claim that "I am not even concerned with statistical generalizations about the majority of religious people (or atheists)."

His further statements and some of yours seem to claim that faith inherently leads to evil (or, moreso than atheism or rationality do), which I think is nonsense.

Mobyseven said:
Indeed. But theism and atheism are values, they are neutral ontological views. Values only come into play when we start projecting our own prejudices onto god or the universe. There is nothing inherently purposeful or purposeless about either atheism or theism: One can easily say, "God exists and has made us for a purpose," but can also easily say, "God exists, and made us for no purpose." Similarly, one can say, "There is no god, therefore life is pointless," but one could also say, "There is no god, therefore we create our own purpose." Until one starts adding things to theism and atheism, they are value neutral.

Agreed, very nice post.
 
I have to disagree. Gods are usually made in man's own image or image of what they think is "perfect." Theists believe in this image, while atheists simply don't believe such a being exists. A theist's relgion is often, if not always, built into that god. Atheists have no such connection.

Here is where your claim that atheism and theism are neutral value systems fails. With atheism, you are correct, because atheism is a lack of belif in any and all gods. WIth theism, there is a belief in, at least, one god. The neutrality is lost when the theist is asked to define the god. At that point, they bring to light what their god thinks is moral and just and what they must do to appease that god. In essence, the definition of the god they believe in defines their religion and religious values. This is just another example where faith causes action while lack of faith causea none.

What does belief in at least one god automatically entail?

That question is really the crux of the issue here - as I pointed out above belief in god, in and of itself, does not actually entail anything. It is only when we start projecting our own prejudices onto god that values can come into play, and indeed, you said it yourself above: "The neutrality is lost when the theist is asked to define the god. At that point, they bring to light what their god thinks is moral and just and what they must do to appease that god. In essence, the definition of the god they believe in defines their religion and religious values."

A good example to highlight here is deism. Deists believe, in some form, in a creator god who essentially did the deed of universal creation, and then buggered off into the background. What, then does belief in the deist god entail? This is a god that doesn't demand anything, and whose intentions are forever unknown. In what way could belief in a deist god lead to either acts of 'good' or 'bad'?

I'm not for a moment suggesting that belief in god is rational, mind you. But I object to the idea that there is something inherent in theism, prior to human projection or addition, that could lead people to perform acts of 'evil'.
 
I agree Moby...

It's the gods that demand faith and obedience that are most likely to lead to evil.

Because there is no better way to prove faith and obedience, but then to act like you REALLY believe what you've been indoctrinated to believe.

Like the hijackers.

Like Andrea Yates.

I think most Christians believe that Andrea Yates' kids are living happily ever after in heaven... they didn't die; they just started their "happily ever after" earlier. And it's not earlier... because god is omniscient and would have known. And, although Yates misses her kids, she already believed she was going to hell for not being a good enough mother--in her mind, she saved her kids from the same fate. And according to most Christians she did as well. She did what she did because she really had faith, and she figured a short bit of suffering was worth the guarantee of eternal heavenly bliss for the people she loved the most.

Faith makes people do crazy things to prove their faith. Gods that require or demand faith or obedience are recipes for peoples' voices in their head to control their behavior under the guise of divine guidance.

Theism itself is neutral-- it's the glorification of faith that seems to be the real catalyst for extreme behavior. Extremely IRRATIONAL behavior-- from the atheist point of view.

Of course, Andrea Yates', et. al. behavior is perfectly rational within her belief system. If you believe life is a pass/fail test for eternity... why wouldn't you do everything possible to ensure the people you loved the most passed--even if it means you fail? Why isn't Andrea Yates a martyr to those who share her belief system-- after all, she clearly has MORE FAITH that her kids are living "happily ever after" thanks to her plan than they do--and she guaranteed it by killing them before they could be eligible for HELL.
 
I'm sick of waffle. What's your point.

Nobody does anything in the name of "religion". They do it in the name of a specific religion.

In the same way, people don't do things in the name of atheism. They might do it in the name of some value system which starts with atheism and proceeds from there. I won't say "based on" as that might imply that atheism necessarily leads to a particular value system.

Indeed. But theism and atheism are values, they are neutral ontological views. Values only come into play when we start projecting our own prejudices onto god or the universe. There is nothing inherently purposeful or purposeless about either atheism or theism: One can easily say, "God exists and has made us for a purpose," but can also easily say, "God exists, and made us for no purpose." Similarly, one can say, "There is no god, therefore life is pointless," but one could also say, "There is no god, therefore we create our own purpose." Until one starts adding things to theism and atheism, they are value neutral.

It's also true that one can mix and match one's own views with off-the-shelf boxes of values.
 
...snip...

Similarly, theism is neutral as well. Theism, in and of itself, cannot lead to good and evil - belief in god does not in and of itself entail any other logical consequences. Thus the reason I said that 'good' and 'evil' can be committed in the name of religion; not that 'good' and 'evil' can be committed in the name of theism.

Just on this I'm not too sure you can in practise make such a sharp distinction. If you think about it a theist has to believe in something, which means it has properties (otherwise their label "god" would mean, quite literally, nothing).

Now obviously some theists could believe in a god that has properties such that there would be no logical consequences of that belief and therefore you couldn't say that it would lead to good nor evil as you state. However others could believe in a god and given the properties of that god there would be logical consequences which may indeed lead to good or evil.

(Yes it is a tad of a nit-pick and I do I agree in general with your comment.)
 
Last edited:
Nobody does anything in the name of "religion". They do it in the name of a specific religion.

I never said otherwise.

In the same way, people don't do things in the name of atheism. They might do it in the name of some value system which starts with atheism and proceeds from there. I won't say "based on" as that might imply that atheism necessarily leads to a particular value system.

Eh...I really don't think you can start a value system with atheism. If you can name one, great, but while atheism may feature in some value systems, it usually features as a consequence of some aspect of the system, not a premise.

It's also true that one can mix and match one's own views with off-the-shelf boxes of values.

Well, yeah. If you mean what I think you mean, then yes.
 
Just on this I'm not too sure you can in practise make such a sharp distinction. If you think about it a theist has to believe in something, which means it has properties (otherwise their label "god" would mean, quite literally, nothing).

Now obviously some theists could believe in a god that has properties such that there would be no logical consequences of that belief and therefore you couldn't say that it would lead to good nor evil as you state. However others could believe in a god and given the properties of that god there would be logical consequences which may indeed lead to good or evil.

(Yes it is a tad of a nit-pick and I do I agree in general with your comment.)

A particular theist has to believe in a specific god. The group of 'theists' just have to believe in 'god'.

But your nitpick is noted.
 
How could it be? In what way can atheism, a lack of belief in god, be intrinsically good or evil? In what way can theism, a belief in god, be intrinsically good or evil?

Why are you equating good and evil with a value system? Are those inherent in value-systems?

You could just as easily believe in a god who is an omni-prick, hardly a 'good' thing, but not in itself inconsistent with theism.

Agreed, (and I laughed out loud at "omni-princk") but I think you're missing my point, which I'll address below.

I understand what you're saying, but you're viewing atheism and theism as more than they actually are. How does one act in a fashion consistent with the non-existence of god? Perhaps you might say that obviously they would not devote time to worshipping god - and you'd be true, but then there is nothing in the definition of theism that says you should devote time to worshipping god either. Thus, not devoting time to the worship of god is consistent with both theism and atheism. The same can be said of anything else you can think of - there is nothing in the definition of theism that says we shouldn't murder each other, or that we should endorse slavery, or anything else...theism is value neutral, and from that it follows that atheism is also value neutral.

In concept, yes. But it's the practice, where I'm getting hung up on your statement, ". . . belief in god does not in and of itself entail any other logical consequences." Once you go through the motions of accepting theism or atheism, the next step should be to act in a fashion consistent with that belief structure, right? An individual theist might not take time to worship (though most would) but he/she might do other things consistent with their theism (religious charities, getting a gris-gris, reading scriptures, dressing in full pirate regalia, etc.). The same with atheism.

I can't see someone who takes the time to legitimately go through the motions of accepting, well, almost any belief structure, and then not acting in a consistent fashion with that belief structure to whatever extent.

Strip away the commonly attached prejudices from theism and atheism, and you'll see them both for the value neutral positions they are.

I can see what you're saying here, and in concept I agree. But these concepts don't exist in a vacuum of thought. The process of progression for most individuals would be to take the next step, so that belief in God does entail other logical consequences.
 
Why are you equating good and evil with a value system? Are those inherent in value-systems?

The values that I'm discussing are moral values which address the idea of 'good' and 'evil' (though I put them in quotes for a reason). I thought that was clear by the context of the discussion - if not, take it as a given from now on.

In concept, yes. But it's the practice, where I'm getting hung up on your statement, ". . . belief in god does not in and of itself entail any other logical consequences." Once you go through the motions of accepting theism or atheism, the next step should be to act in a fashion consistent with that belief structure, right? An individual theist might not take time to worship (though most would) but he/she might do other things consistent with their theism (religious charities, getting a gris-gris, reading scriptures, dressing in full pirate regalia, etc.). The same with atheism.

I can't see someone who takes the time to legitimately go through the motions of accepting, well, almost any belief structure, and then not acting in a consistent fashion with that belief structure to whatever extent.

I can see what you're saying here, and in concept I agree. But these concepts don't exist in a vacuum of thought. The process of progression for most individuals would be to take the next step, so that belief in God does entail other logical consequences.

I see what you're saying, and I think it comes from a misunderstanding of why I say atheism and theism don't automatically entail anything, that they are value neutral.

I'm not saying that they are value neutral because they are consistent only with value neutral actions. I say that they are value neutral because both atheism and theism are consistent with every action one could take. There is no action that a person could perform that would be inconsistent with either atheism or theism - an atheist could attend church without it being inconsistent with her atheism; a theist can murder a goat without it being inconsistent with her theism (hell, some gods might expect it!)

Because every action is consistent with theism, and every action is consistent with atheism, there is no moral 'ought' that can be derived from the two positions. A view that murder is good is not in and of itself inconsistent with either atheism or theism, but then neither is the (thankfully more common) view that murder is good.

As any action - 'good', 'bad' or 'neutral' - is consistent with both atheism and theism, and therefore atheism and theism cannot automatically entail any particular action.

I understand what you are saying about beliefs not occurring in a vacuum, but that is exactly my point. The 'atheism' or the 'theism' is not the thing that leads people to 'good' or 'evil' - it is the values we project onto our beliefs that make the difference.
 
But theism does entail something... it entails a belief. Just as belief in astrology entails something. Atheism-- or "lack of belief", doesn't entail anything. It is as morally neutral as lack of belief in homeopathy or rain dancing. It says nothing about what people have in common-- just something they don't have. It's like saying people who don't have immunity against measles. Having immunity implies having something... it "entails" something... just the same way "belief in something" entails something... and theism entails "belief in god".

So they are not equally neutral terms. One entails a belief... one is just a lack of belief. Atheism doesn't mean "active disbelief"... it just means a lack of a belief in gods. To me it's the same as my skepticism or "lack of belief" in other supernatural areas. It may or may not motivate some people in some way... but, in itself, it's a lack of belief. It entails nothing.

Theism entails "belief in a god or gods". Right? And that's something... and it usually entails the notion that "belief in" this god is good or true or ennobling. Right? Although they might both be "value free" terms--

That something can motivate people to do "good" or "evil" or take action or hurt others etc. Lack of belief in gods... like lack of belief in rain dancing... doesn't really have the power to motivate. I might donate blood because I think it's a valuable thing for humans to do or it makes me feel good or I feel thankful to have healthy blood-- but my lack of belief in a god has nothing to do with it. Someone else might be motivated to give blood to please god or not to give blood because they believe god doesn't like that (Jehovah Witnesses) or they can give blood for completely secular reasons like me.

In that way, "belief in" something is not neutral in the same way lack of belief is.

If you think in terms of moral--amoral--immoral

The universe is amoral... it doesn't care about morality. That's a neutral term like atheist. Wheras "moral" and "immoral" are value laden terms. It is minor. But Darat's point makes sense to me.
 
Last edited:
@ Articulett: It's true that theism entails belief in god. My point relates not to belief or lack of belief, but to actions.
 
Yes. There is no inherent action implied with either. However, there is motivation empowered by belief with theism. It's what you believe and feel that moves you to act. If you believe your child has been kidnapped you are motivated to act. If you lack that belief... it's just a lack of belief. It doesn't motivate any action.

So I agree that there is nothing inherently wrong or evil about faith... nor do I think that faith necessarily leads to evil or "action". Theism is a fairly neutral term. But faith can motivate a person to do things they would not normally do... beliefs can be powerful motivators or fear producers. Lack of belief is just lack of belief... even though theists often try to put lack of belief on par with belief.

Belief in rain dances may encourage one to do such a dance to please the gods... "lack of such a belief" doesn't encourage any action or nonaction... a rationalistic world view might lead one to teach people to utilize more successful ways of making sure peoples' crops get enough water. What you believe in and feel and think inspires action--serves as motivators for positive or negative and everything else-- not the stuff you don't "believe in". There's an infinity of things people don't believe in.

A theist may be "motivated" to pray to help solve a problem. A non believer might seek professional advice or take some other action. While the "belief" motivated the person who prays; it's not "lack of belief" that causes the non-theist to do whatever they do to solve the problem. It's the methods they "believe in" or have evidence for-- not the invisible god they they don't believe in that is the motivator of the action taken.

I can't think of a situation where "not believing in something" is a catalyst for action (unless the action is sleeping in on Sundays :) ), but I can think of tons of situations where beliefs guide or compel action-- from prayer to working hard to picketing to martyrdom. In this way, faith is much more likely to lead to human suffering than mere "lack of faith" in that same thing.

In my experience my atheism is more akin to all the woo and religions that theists don't believe in (Scientology for example) rather than being the "opposite" of what they do "believe in" much as they continually try to paint such a picture. I think that's true of most atheists. I think theists bend over backwards not to realize this, because it puts their belief on the same level as all the woo they don't believe in --and it's hard to feel holier than those evil atheists when you understand that they feel the same way about your religion as you feel about all those "other" wacky religions.

I don't think Scientology necessarily leads to evil. Most of the time, it seems benign. I've heard it helps people and has gotten a lot of people off drugs. However, it's much more likely to lead people to cause suffering in other humans (in the name of faith) then is mere "lack of belief in Scientology". I assume the vast majority of people on this planet share my lack of belief in Scientology. I can't assume anything else about them from that. But when someone identifies as a believer-- if nothing else, they are indicating that they think faith is a means of knowledge--something good-- and that can, of course, be a motivator for action... in a way that mere "non belief" cannot be.

Belief is a lot more fertile ground than "non belief". These are not equally neutral terms when it comes to potentiating action--no matter what value judgments assorted humans give that action.
 
Last edited:
I think theism encourages a kind of backwards thinking where the believer learns to associate everything good with their faith or belief or god (or "by the grace of god")-- and they learn to associate all that is bad with "lack of faith" or "the wrong faith" or "not a true Christian" or-- "not the god I believe in" --or anything and everything EXCEPT faith or God or religion.

To me it's glaring. But believers and apologists seem blind to it. They could plug in woo they don't believe in (say, Scientology) in place of "religion in general" and "non belief in Scientology" in place of atheism to see their glaring double standard. But they don't and won't-- they'd rather attack the non believer then understand the point. Even though the point is really simple. They hear what isn't there to avoid hearing what is.

And yes, westprog-- theism represents all beliefs in gods... all religions... "religion in general" and atheism is disbelief in all gods... disbelief in "divine knowledge" in general. You can plug in Scientology to stand for religion (or any other woo belief you don't have) and the big picture regarding theism, atheism, and motivation can be seen. Yes, specific religion can lead to specific actions. But it's also specific people who describe those actions as "evil", "good", and so forth-- there is no agreement or outside reference point. That's why you plug in a theism you don't believe in to approach if you don't want to be biased. There is no specificity to "lack of belief". An atheist disbelieves in all gods equally. All religions are "Scientology" to me (or they may as well be). Just as all the religions you don't share the beliefs of are "Scientology" to you.
 
Last edited:
I never said otherwise.

Then I think we are merely at cross purposes.

Eh...I really don't think you can start a value system with atheism. If you can name one, great, but while atheism may feature in some value systems, it usually features as a consequence of some aspect of the system, not a premise.

I'd add that I think that most people derive their moral system from individual cases, rather than start with the principles. And I think in practice such systems are more culturally driven than by belief systems.

Well, yeah. If you mean what I think you mean, then yes.

Well, this argument isn't working out at all.
 
Mobyseven said:
I see what you're saying, and I think it comes from a misunderstanding of why I say atheism and theism don't automatically entail anything, that they are value neutral.

So, if I'm reading what you're saying correctly, then value's are assigned, and not inherent in any system of belief (or disbelief) if you will.

But then I think you and I always agreed on that point, so far as the OP was concerned, faith (or lack of faith) in almost anything doesn't directly lead to evil, or to good.

To me it's glaring. But believers and apologists seem blind to it. They could plug in woo they don't believe in (say, Scientology) in place of "religion in general" and "non belief in Scientology" in place of atheism to see their glaring double standard. But they don't and won't-- they'd rather attack the non believer then understand the point. Even though the point is really simple. They hear what isn't there to avoid hearing what is.

This is actually true on both sides of the coin. Atheists, not all mind, but a goodly portion, do this same thing to adherents. To requote, "they'd rather attack the believer than understand the point. Even though the point is really simple."

It's unfortunate, on both sides, and leads to a great deal of animosity. But there it is.
 
And yes, westprog-- theism represents all beliefs in gods... all religions... "religion in general" and atheism is disbelief in all gods... disbelief in "divine knowledge" in general.

There's a bit of a problem here. I might compose a really wonderful, convincing argument to Articulett, but unless someone not on her list quotes it, she'll never see it. A real "if a tree falls in the forest" dilemma.

That's probably not going to happen, because I'm not clear what her point is. I'm sure it's awfully good though.

To get back to Dawkins, instead. If Dawkins had just said that he didn't believe in God, of any kind, then he couldn't have been said to misrepresent anyone's belief. But he's in fact said a lot more than that. He's commented about the nature of god, and produced probabilistic arguments as to why he's impossible. No, atheism per se is not misrepresentation of another's beliefs. But there's a lot more to Dawkins than that.
 
What you believe in and feel and think inspires action--serves as motivators for positive or negative and everything else-- not the stuff you don't "believe in".

Says the woman who posts (an action) volumes inspired by her non-belief in all religions.

And doesn't the stuff Dawkins, Hitches, Harris, etc. don't believe in inspire them to write (which is an action) books against it.

Not to mention that this entire site we are are conversing on was created (again, an action) by Randi who was inspired by what he doesn't believe in.
 
Says the woman who posts (an action) volumes inspired by her non-belief in all religions.

And doesn't the stuff Dawkins, Hitches, Harris, etc. don't believe in inspire them to write (which is an action) books against it.

Not to mention that this entire site we are are conversing on was created (again, an action) by Randi who was inspired by what he doesn't believe in.

To be fair, though, non-belief is not the prime motivator for Hitchens, Harris, Dawkins, etc. They are motivated to write in opposition to other's beliefs because they perceive a danger arising from inaction -- motivation arising largely from 9/11.

None of us believe in invisible tree frogs that re-arrange our internal organs each night, so one is motivated to comment on them (except as a stupid example).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom