Faith leads to evil.

Hang on a second...I've been following this conversation for a bit. Wouldn't the whole point be that if Bundy's actions weren't rational, then he was acting irrationally? Isn't whether or not he thinks he is acting rationally an unrelated side note, perhaps an interesting view into a twisted mind, but not evidence that his atheism rationally led to his acts?
 
Hang on a second...I've been following this conversation for a bit. Wouldn't the whole point be that if Bundy's actions weren't rational, then he was acting irrationally? Isn't whether or not he thinks he is acting rationally an unrelated side note, perhaps an interesting view into a twisted mind, but not evidence that his atheism rationally led to his acts?

There are two aspects to Bundy's rationality. Firstly, he had a wish to rape and murder people. That's not rational or irrational - it's a preference. He also had, one presumes, a wish not to go to prison, or to be executed. That's again not irrational.

We don't know quite what the balance was between his preferences. However, if he simply gave in to his wish to kill without worrying about his risk of being caught, he would be acting irrationally. He would be failing to foresee the obvious results of his actions.

If he balanced the risk of being caught, and the consequences, against the pleasure of carrying out his deeds, and decided that the risk was worth it - for him - then he might well have been acting entirely rationally. The fact that he eventually got caught doesn't mean he was wrong in his assessment - just that things didn't work out for him.

Bear in mind that while Bundy was caught, other killers never are, or are caught late in life. Consider, say, the Austrian who kept his daughter in a cellar. He has done what he likes his entire life, and has managed to put off punishment until he is over seventy. He might well conclude that it was a reasonable bargain.

Of course, such calculations are based on a system that doesn't treat other people as if they had intrinsic value.
 
Last edited:
The majority of people who attend TAM are non believers... there seems to be no shortage of love and friendship in the group... there's even intelligence and humor-- something often missing from the theist crowds I've been around. The stronger the faith, the suckier the sense of humor --and ability to reason I've noticed.

I know that I have no sense of humour. I used to have, but I carefully eradicated it in case it lead to sin. Laugh on, Articulett, but every giggle brings you to damnation.
 
I know not all theists are like westprog et. al. But he does leave a residue on the whole lot from my perspective.

It's interesting to know that there's a Hindu in Calcutta, a Catholic in Montevideo, and a Muslim in Jeddah, and Articulett thinks a little less of all three of them all thanks to me.
 
Incidentally, while I have no particular reason to doubt the Bundy statement, it seems a little bit too perfect to me. It shows a level of self-understanding which I don't, as someone with no particular expertise whatsoever, think of a typical in a psychopath. Let's say that I wouldn't be surprised if it turned out to be not entirely authentic.

This makes no particular difference to the general argument, of course. And I'm certainly not making any accusation against the person who posted the quote, which I'm sure was in good faith, and may well be authenticated.
 
Hang on a second...I've been following this conversation for a bit. Wouldn't the whole point be that if Bundy's actions weren't rational, then he was acting irrationally? Isn't whether or not he thinks he is acting rationally an unrelated side note, perhaps an interesting view into a twisted mind, but not evidence that his atheism rationally led to his acts?

Yes or no, depending on one's views on whether or which basic motives/rationales can inherently and always tend to good or evil. My bringing him up (or Gandhi or Mother Theresa) was an attempt to foster some objectivity by forcing those using Yates and others as examples to more carefully review their position.

Consider a post such as this:

Wouldn't the whole point be that if Yates' actions weren't truly faithful, then she wasn't acting from true faith? Isn't whether or not she thinks she is acting faithfully an unrelated side note, perhaps an interesting view into a twisted mind, but not evidence that her theism led to her acts?

Replace Yates with pro-slavers or anti-slavers, and theism with atheism or rationality or Santa Claus...humans define morality and there is no objective immutable morality that never changes with society, not in atheism, not in theism. Faith doesn't lead to evil or good; neither does atheism or rationality.
 
Incidentally, while I have no particular reason to doubt the Bundy statement, it seems a little bit too perfect to me. It shows a level of self-understanding which I don't, as someone with no particular expertise whatsoever, think of a typical in a psychopath. Let's say that I wouldn't be surprised if it turned out to be not entirely authentic.

This makes no particular difference to the general argument, of course. And I'm certainly not making any accusation against the person who posted the quote, which I'm sure was in good faith, and may well be authenticated.

You're right on all counts, except I didn't post it in good faith--that is I didn't verify the statement from other sources like I usually would. It doesn't matter if Bundy used rationalism for justification of evil, but it was a quick example that it's certainly possible. And the reaction to it has been illuminating.

ETA: I do want to apologize to Thaiboxerken, a lot of my arguing was directed at Articulett's position, originally at least, and I wasn't sure if she was still able to read my posts. Sorry if I used you as a proxy and didn't fully respond to some of your other arguments. Apparently I am on her ignore so I'll drop it and respond better in the future.
 
Last edited:
Replace Yates with pro-slavers or anti-slavers, and theism with atheism or rationality or Santa Claus...humans define morality and there is no objective immutable morality that never changes with society, not in atheism, not in theism. Faith doesn't lead to evil or good; neither does atheism or rationality.

I can agree with you in part - there is no objective morality, and such.

I would, however, suggest that faith can lead to acts that are considered evil by many human moral systems by virtue of its emphasis on blind acceptance, and I would also suggest that atheism cannot lead to such acts because it is merely the absence of a particular belief - there are no 'tenets' of atheism upon which one could be lead to do 'evil' (or, for that matter 'good' - atheism is neutral).

However, that does not mean that atheists are entirely neutral, incapable of evil or good. Atheists are not necessarily rational, and faith is not the exclusive provenance of religion and theism.
 
I can agree with you in part - there is no objective morality, and such.

I would, however, suggest that faith can lead to acts that are considered evil by many human moral systems by virtue of its emphasis on blind acceptance, and I would also suggest that atheism cannot lead to such acts because it is merely the absence of a particular belief - there are no 'tenets' of atheism upon which one could be lead to do 'evil' (or, for that matter 'good' - atheism is neutral).

However, that does not mean that atheists are entirely neutral, incapable of evil or good. Atheists are not necessarily rational, and faith is not the exclusive provenance of religion and theism.


It's also the case that people don't do good or evil in the name of religion or faith. Nobody says "I believe in religion, just not anything in particular". Except maybe in California.

In the same way, nobody's just an atheist. They always have a value system attached, formal or otherwise.

Whether rational evil is possible remains an open question. I might even disagree with Dragoonster on that one.
 
It's also the case that people don't do good or evil in the name of religion or faith.

Er...yes, they do. In the name of religion that is - I'm not sure how someone would do something 'in the name of faith', they do things in the name of [insert ideology they have faith in here].

The Crusades. The Inquisition. The 9/11 terrorists. All acts of 'evil', all committed in the name of a religion.

In the same way, nobody's just an atheist.

Well, obviously. It would be a strange person indeed who defined themselves entirely by one belief that they do not hold.

They always have a value system attached, formal or otherwise.

No. They have a value system - but it is not 'attached' to atheism. One cannot commit an act 'in the name of atheism', because atheism is merely the lack of a belief in any god. Atheism cannot lead to good or evil, because atheism is neutral.

Similarly, theism is neutral as well. Theism, in and of itself, cannot lead to good and evil - belief in god does not in and of itself entail any other logical consequences. Thus the reason I said that 'good' and 'evil' can be committed in the name of religion; not that 'good' and 'evil' can be committed in the name of theism.
 
Er...yes, they do. In the name of religion that is - I'm not sure how someone would do something 'in the name of faith', they do things in the name of [insert ideology they have faith in here].

The Crusades. The Inquisition. The 9/11 terrorists. All acts of 'evil', all committed in the name of a religion.

Yes, a religion. Not in the name of religion. The Crusades were in the name of Christianity. 9/11 was in the name of Islam. I can imagine that some kind of collective action might be mounted in the name of religion in general, but I can't think of any occasion where that has actually happened.

No. They have a value system - but it is not 'attached' to atheism. One cannot commit an act 'in the name of atheism', because atheism is merely the lack of a belief in any god. Atheism cannot lead to good or evil, because atheism is neutral.

However, when someone creates a value system, it would be surprising if it wasn't effected by an overall view of the universe and its purpose or purposelessness.

Similarly, theism is neutral as well. Theism, in and of itself, cannot lead to good and evil - belief in god does not in and of itself entail any other logical consequences. Thus the reason I said that 'good' and 'evil' can be committed in the name of religion; not that 'good' and 'evil' can be committed in the name of theism.
 
He's certainly started well. Only here since April and already hitting 'em out of the park. Has Articulett put him on ignore yet?

Haha! It does seem to be a bar worthy of achievement, doesn't it?! :D

It is interesting, though, that for putting people on ignore, she sure seems to like to argue with them a lot! :cool:

It's also the case that people don't do good or evil in the name of religion or faith. Nobody says "I believe in religion, just not anything in particular". Except maybe in California.

Hey now, that's my adopted stated. Remember, we have the Guv-a-nator on our side! (Anyone else picture Schwartznegger walking around like Mel Brooks in Blazing Saddles with a white GOV on the back of his jacket?)

Mobyseven said:
No. They have a value system - but it is not 'attached' to atheism. One cannot commit an act 'in the name of atheism', because atheism is merely the lack of a belief in any god. Atheism cannot lead to good or evil, because atheism is neutral.

Wait, this seems a bit off to me. Why wouldn't a value system be attached to atheism?

Similarly, theism is neutral as well. Theism, in and of itself, cannot lead to good and evil - belief in god does not in and of itself entail any other logical consequences. Thus the reason I said that 'good' and 'evil' can be committed in the name of religion; not that 'good' and 'evil' can be committed in the name of theism.

But the natural step foreward, after making a decision to believe in one or the other, is to act in some fashion consistent with that belief, correct? Does someone make the concious decision to become religious or become atheist and then change nothing else, or act in ways that are contrary to their beliefs . . . I mean in the main here, because obviously some people do so on the occasion, but generally for reasons other than their guide of religion or atheism.

Does my question make sense?
 
They don't need to be, he only needs to think they were. Just as Andrea Yates' actions didn't need to be properly "faithful", she just needs to have thought they were.

Wrong. If one does irrational acts or has flawed rationality, then you cannot say they acted rationally. However, faith is the intense belief in something regardless of evidence or logic. Andrea Yates was faithful, unless she was lying about her beliefs.

Theists shouldn't have to fall all over themselves showing why Yates wasn't really being faithful.

Theists CAN'T refute Yates faith it's her belief.

You and Articulett shouldn't have to fall all over yourselves in showing why Bundy wasn't really rational.

I shouldn't have to, you people should be showing us how he acted rationally.

The point is--you can't use one as an example but not the other. The proper course is using neither.

The problem is, one example is accurate. The other is not.

Not according to Bundy's rationalization: "Surely, you would not, in this age of scientific enlightenment, declare that God or nature has marked some pleasures as 'moral' or 'good' and others as 'immoral' or 'bad'?"

That's irrationalism, not rationalism.

His lack of a belief in god (atheism) led to or helped in his rationalization (rationalism) of his murderering and raping people (evil).

Except it didn't. His lack of belief merely allowed him to make his own decisions, and he made very poor ones. He wasn't enslaved to faith, but to his own mental illness.

He's a nutcase who used or abused atheism for his own ends.

No, he didn't. One cannot use or abuse a LACK of belief in a god.

That doesn't means atheism leads to evil. But the antithesis is also true--theism doesn't lead to evil. And some nutcase religious murderer can't be used as example that it does.

Yes, it can, especially since religion teaches people to act irrational or believe in the irrational. It teaches absurdities, and thus opens the path to absurd actions.

You're simply not being objective.

:rolleyes:
 
Faith often entails belief in and obedience to an invisible divine authority... how does one show this "faith" unless one does something that one wouldn't do unless they truly had faith? Why wouldn't you prove you had faith in whatever it was you believed you were supposed to have faith in, if you believed your ETERNITY was at stake.

There is nothing about atheism or lack of belief that has anywhere near that kind of motivation, is there. There is nothing in the world of rationalism that would lead anyone to prove anything to an invisible or divine entity...

Westprog, you need to get your head examined. Belief is not the same as lack of belief. A life guided by rationality is the OPPOSITE of a life guided by faith.
 
Wrong. If one does irrational acts or has flawed rationality, then you cannot say they acted rationally. However, faith is the intense belief in something regardless of evidence or logic. Andrea Yates was faithful, unless she was lying about her beliefs.

You can say they performed an action (or mis-action) based on their understanding of their chosen action system. In Bundy's case it was irrationalism from rationalism from atheism, in Yates case it was non-Christian acts from Christianity from faith. Rationalists priviledge reason and logic above faith as a "best" explanatory power. The faithful priviledge faith above reason and logic as their basis. I really don't see a fundamental difference.

Theists CAN'T refute Yates faith it's her belief.

Then atheists CAN'T refute Bundy's rationalism it's his belief.

Except it didn't. His lack of belief merely allowed him to make his own decisions, and he made very poor ones. He wasn't enslaved to faith, but to his own mental illness.

If he'd been faithful perhaps his belief wouldn't have allowed him to make his own decisions. Perhaps he wouldn't have done evil, and in his case if he'd had faith he would have done good. The "merely" in the above is hardly merely, to the ethical mind of a theist.

I haven't apologized for Yates, but here's a quick stab:

http://www.chron.com/disp/story.mpl/special/drownings/1268306.html

"It was the seventh deadly sin. My children weren't righteous. They stumbled because I was evil," Ferguson quoted Yates as saying. "The way I was raising them they could never be saved. ... Better for someone else to tie a millstone around their neck and cast them in a river than stumble. They were going to perish."

[...]

Yates said she could hear Satan behind the jail walls and heard growling noises coming from the hallway. To "calm the beast," she said, she put her plastic food tray in the doorway at a certain angle, Ferguson testified. She also said she heard Satan's voice coming through the intercom in her cell.

Ferguson said she asked Yates whether she realized how sick she was, but that Yates insisted she was not mentally ill. She had no insight into the severity of her disease or that she was profoundly depressed, Ferguson testified.

So if I actually thought it was relevant, I'd refute (or dimiss) Yates' faith because it wasn't proper. True faithful wouldn't think they were Satan or kill their children. She wasn't enslaved to faith, but to her delusions and mental illness.

No, he didn't. One cannot use or abuse a LACK of belief in a god.

So when he talks about the age of science and God no longer being an acceptable basis for morality what is he abusing? It's certainly not theism. If it's not atheism and not theism, what exactly is it?

Yes, it can, especially since religion teaches people to act irrational or believe in the irrational. It teaches absurdities, and thus opens the path to absurd actions.

Neither irrationality or absurdity is evil though, imo. Evil types of them are, but one can twist any belief into evil.
 
If you believe that Andrea Yates children are in Heaven living happily ever after, then you believe the exact thing that had her conclude that she had better kill them so their paradise could be ensured.

There are some horrors committed solely because of faith. The kid who died of diabetes while her parents prayed instead of getting medicine... discrimination against homosexuals, 9-11, the inquisition, stonings, witch hunts, etc. These are acts brought on by faith.

Lack of belief is just lack of belief... it's exactly like all the things you lack a belief in. It's exactly like your lack of belief in Scientology. I cannot believe the way religion has brainwashed people into seeing lack of belief as something it is not while blinding the faithful to the harms caused by faith. That is sort of twisted and evil. And yet people who have swallowed this belief, imagine themselves more moral than those who lack the nutty meme!

Those who imagine the Emperor in the finest clothes think they are the most moral of all, while calling the honest and sane "evil" for pointing out the obvious-- the emperor is naked. Those who claim to see clothes are delusional, mistaken, or lying.
 
Yes, a religion. Not in the name of religion. The Crusades were in the name of Christianity. 9/11 was in the name of Islam. I can imagine that some kind of collective action might be mounted in the name of religion in general, but I can't think of any occasion where that has actually happened.

I'm sick of waffle. What's your point.

However, when someone creates a value system, it would be surprising if it wasn't effected by an overall view of the universe and its purpose or purposelessness.

Indeed. But theism and atheism are values, they are neutral ontological views. Values only come into play when we start projecting our own prejudices onto god or the universe. There is nothing inherently purposeful or purposeless about either atheism or theism: One can easily say, "God exists and has made us for a purpose," but can also easily say, "God exists, and made us for no purpose." Similarly, one can say, "There is no god, therefore life is pointless," but one could also say, "There is no god, therefore we create our own purpose." Until one starts adding things to theism and atheism, they are value neutral.
 
Wait, this seems a bit off to me. Why wouldn't a value system be attached to atheism?

How could it be? In what way can atheism, a lack of belief in god, be intrinsically good or evil? In what way can theism, a belief in god, be intrinsically good or evil?

As I mentioned above, the value of atheism or theism can only com about once one has added extra things to the definition of atheism or theism. So, for example, if you are a theist, and the god you believe in is omnibenevolent, well, that would seem to be a 'good' thing...but there's nothing in the definition of theism that says god has to be omnibenevolent. You could just as easily believe in a god who is an omni-prick, hardly a 'good' thing, but not in itself inconsistent with theism.

But the natural step foreward, after making a decision to believe in one or the other, is to act in some fashion consistent with that belief, correct? Does someone make the concious decision to become religious or become atheist and then change nothing else, or act in ways that are contrary to their beliefs . . . I mean in the main here, because obviously some people do so on the occasion, but generally for reasons other than their guide of religion or atheism.

Does my question make sense?

I understand what you're saying, but you're viewing atheism and theism as more than they actually are. How does one act in a fashion consistent with the non-existence of god? Perhaps you might say that obviously they would not devote time to worshipping god - and you'd be true, but then there is nothing in the definition of theism that says you should devote time to worshipping god either. Thus, not devoting time to the worship of god is consistent with both theism and atheism. The same can be said of anything else you can think of - there is nothing in the definition of theism that says we shouldn't murder each other, or that we should endorse slavery, or anything else...theism is value neutral, and from that it follows that atheism is also value neutral.

Strip away the commonly attached prejudices from theism and atheism, and you'll see them both for the value neutral positions they are.
 
You can say they performed an action (or mis-action) based on their understanding of their chosen action system. In Bundy's case it was irrationalism from rationalism from atheism, in Yates case it was non-Christian acts from Christianity from faith.

I didn't say anything about systems, but about faith. Bundy followed no "system" of rationality that was rational. However, Yates had faith.

Rationalists priviledge reason and logic above faith as a "best" explanatory power. The faithful priviledge faith above reason and logic as their basis. I really don't see a fundamental difference.

Then I can't help you. It's like seeing the difference between black and white. Faith takes no thought process, just blind obedience. Rationality involves a logical thought process based on evidence and knowledge.

Then atheists CAN'T refute Bundy's rationalism it's his belief.

I can. His beliefs were irrational. No matter what you say, you can't change that fact. He had fallacious arguments to justify his beliefs.

If he'd been faithful perhaps his belief wouldn't have allowed him to make his own decisions. Perhaps he wouldn't have done evil, and in his case if he'd had faith he would have done good. The "merely" in the above is hardly merely, to the ethical mind of a theist.

Perhaps, but then that leads him to be enslaved to do the will of those who teach him what to be faithful in. That is where the "evil" of faith comes from.

So if I actually thought it was relevant, I'd refute (or dimiss) Yates' faith because it wasn't proper. True faithful wouldn't think they were Satan or kill their children. She wasn't enslaved to faith, but to her delusions and mental illness.

The problem with the entire argument there is that faith knows no reason. Faith doesn't care for logic or evidence. Faith teaches that the most absurd, nonsensical things are real. This is why Yate's faith cannot be dismissed, because with true faith, the most absurd and impossible things can be believed.


So when he talks about the age of science and God no longer being an acceptable basis for morality what is he abusing?

He's abusing logical thought. He's ignoring everything else.

It's certainly not theism. If it's not atheism and not theism, what exactly is it?

WTF are you talking about? Atheism is just a lack of belief in a god. Theism is a belief in a god.


Neither irrationality or absurdity is evil though, imo. Evil types of them are, but one can twist any belief into evil.

Then we'll have to disagree. I think irrationality is evil, as well as faith. Although both may lead to good deeds, the potential for evil deeds outweighs them.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom