Faith leads to evil.

Which is the definition I used. So, for example, my giving to charity is an example of an altruistic action.

If you get no benefit then it's altruistic. Obviously from the point of view of the recipients of the benefit, they don't care if the motives are pure.

Bullcrap. All you're doing is defining altruism as impossible, by saying that if you perform an altruistic action and then have the gall to feel good because you did it, it ceases to be an altruistic action. That's complete and utter nonsense - an action does not cease to be altruistic just because a person feels good about doing it. 'Feeling good' is not a 'gain' in this sense of the word (you don't get extra resources because you 'feel good', you don't have a better chance of finding a mate because you 'feel good', and so on).

But those actions are undertaken in order to feel good. Human beings are animals who seek out resources and mates not because they've calculated the benefit in some abstract way. They do it because eating and having sex makes them feel good. Any acts undertaken in order to trigger a release of the right chemical in the brain should be considered on the same basis.

Yeah, because you've tried to twist the meaning of words to fit your argument. All you've done is come up with a 'theory of altruism' that explains nothing, because you've defined altruism as impossible.

If I'd defined altruism as impossible, that would be a point. But I've given a definition of altruism that is possible. It's just very difficult.

It's also reasonable, when discussing altruism from an evolutionary or biological viewpoint, to use a different definition to when using an ethical viewpoint. From a biological viewpoint, an organism can be considered to be acting altruistically if prompted by feeling good to share food with a close relative. Ethically, he will be getting a reward for doing this.

You can't commit the fallacy of equivocation and then pretend that your unfalsifiable hypothesis has won an argument.
 
But those actions are undertaken in order to feel good. Human beings are animals who seek out resources and mates not because they've calculated the benefit in some abstract way. They do it because eating and having sex makes them feel good. Any acts undertaken in order to trigger a release of the right chemical in the brain should be considered on the same basis.

What you are doing, and it is an easy mistake to make, is you are failing to examine why chemicals are released that make people feel good. In the case of eating, we require food to give us energy to live, and so the brain rewards us when we eat. For sex, the idea is similar - we have sex in order to pass on our genetic material to a new generation, and the good feeling we get is an incentive to do so (in the case of humans, we have found a way to bypass the procreation and just get the pleasure...and more power to us :p).

Actions such as giving to charity (or, if you prefer, giving to charity anonymously - because high profile giving could have social benefits) may (though perhaps not always) result in a good feeling. But what is that good feeling? It is not analogous to the good feeling we get when we eat or have sex - those feelings exist because we have benefitted ourselves in some way: They are the incentive to strive for a benefit, and not the benefit itself.

Giving to charity anonymously may give us a good feeling, but it does so in absence of the actual benefit such good feelings usually signify. Most likely such feelings exist as an evolutionary by-product of something else - we used to get a benefit by doing something similar, and while the benefit no longer exists the feeling does. For example (and I am now entering the realm of conjecture), when the society we lived in was smaller (tribal society), foregoing immediate benefits yourself in order to help another member of your tribe may well have had foreseeable long term benefits. However, now that society has changed, such actions no longer bring us the benefit they used to - our brains however have not adapted, and thus we still get a good feeling in the absence of a benefit.

It is important not to confuse the tangible benefit with the subjective feeling, which is what you have been doing. Hopefully I have explained the difference well in this post.
 
Forgive me RobRoy, for I have sinned. I have not done something quite so drastic as rescuing somene I don't like and aren't related to from a burning building, with knowledge that it would cause my death.

Really now, must an act be quite so drastic in order to classify as altruistic? Could you not consider simple actions instead?

Ummm, did you actually intend this for me?

If it was then as I said, my question was not intended as a trap. I just wondered what you considered your own altruistic actions. “Simple actions” will do fine, and I saw you said you gave to charity. That seems to work nicely.

I give to charity too, but that’s in order to maintain peace in my household, not for a warm fuzzy. In my case, I would not consider my actions altruistic at all, though I would consider yours to be so. I would gladly stop giving to charity and put that money to work for the greater benefit of myself and my family. My wife sees things differently, and since I want to maintain her as my wife, I give in on this, and every month I write a check, always larger than I would prefer.

But I am glad that you give to charity without such malcontent and ulterior motives. In your case, I would consider it altruistic in nature.

Thanks for the response, and sorry for the confusion. :D

So if I put something in quote marks, somehow it's more believable?

Actually, yes, it does. ;) I can tell you all day what your church believes, but that, as you keep saying, is only my interpretation. This is exactly why I didn’t do that, but nailed down which church we were dealing with, performed the research and provided the information. :D If I quote it and provide a reference which you can investigate for yourself, that removes my own interpretation and provides a direct source for the argument. This is called fulfilling the burden of proof. And you . . .

If you really care, you can evaluate the evidence for yourself. If you don't, that's okay. :)

. . . have not met the burden of proof. However, given that you have responded with this . . .

He isn't speaking for the beliefs of the Congregational church as a whole.

. . . it doesn’t matter what your book says, since your source isn’t germane to the discussion. Your evidence is rendered invalid. Which makes your whole argument impotent. Sorry! Would you care to try again? :)

No one does. That's the point. It's called a creedless church for a reason - they have no dogma or set of beliefs.

Given the evidence I’ve supplied, this is obviously false . . . unless you want to claim that they’re lying? :cool:

That's okay. I wouldn't want to deprive volatile of his hat. :)

Agreed. And since you’re wrong, and now have no support for your statements, I don’t have to. :cool:

As I said, I don't interpret it that way.

Doesn’t matter what your interpretation is. Only matters what the church’s statements are. Sorry that you seem confused by this. We probably could have saved a lot of time.

Once again, why is your interpretation to be preferred over that of the members and ministers of that church?

Primary sources are always preferred. So, it's not my interpretation. It’s the church’s statement. Fortunately for us, those statements are right there for God and everyone to see. Even those who don’t believe in God can see them! :D
 
Last edited:
RobRoy said:
So if I put something in quote marks, somehow it's more believable?

Actually, yes, it does. ;) I can tell you all day what your church believes, but that, as you keep saying, is only my interpretation. This is exactly why I didn’t do that, but nailed down which church we were dealing with, performed the research and provided the information. :D If I quote it and provide a reference which you can investigate for yourself, that removes my own interpretation and provides a direct source for the argument. This is called fulfilling the burden of proof. And you . . .
Provided with you with an independent source. Sorry, it's not on the internet.
. . . have not met the burden of proof. However, given that you have responded with this . . .

He isn't speaking for the beliefs of the Congregational church as a whole.

. . . it doesn’t matter what your book says, since your source isn’t germane to the discussion. Your evidence is rendered invalid. Which makes your whole argument impotent. Sorry! Would you care to try again? :)

No one does. That's the point. It's called a creedless church for a reason - they have no dogma or set of beliefs.

Given the evidence I’ve supplied, this is obviously false . . . unless you want to claim that they’re lying? :cool:
Er, no. I'm not claiming they are lying. I'm claiming what you quoted doesn't constitute a creed or dogma. You have inferred from it something that members don't. Why should I believe your inference regarding that vision statement you quoted over what I've been told by the ministers and members of the church? Answer is: I don't. If you don't want to believe me, fine. But I have provided a credible independent source for you to confirm what I've said. If you choose not to bother, that's okay. But pretending I haven't provided proof of my claim is ungentlemanly, sir!

As I said, I don't interpret it that way.

Doesn’t matter what your interpretation is. Only matters what the church’s statements are. Sorry that you seem confused by this. We probably could have saved a lot of time.
I'm not confused. I'm saying the church's statements don't say what you claim. You're making inferences that are incorrect.
Once again, why is your interpretation to be preferred over that of the members and ministers of that church?

Primary sources are always preferred. So, it's not my interpretation. It’s the church’s statement. Fortunately for us, those statements are right there for God and everyone to see. Even those who don’t believe in God can see them! :D

Yes, primary sources are always preferred. Yes, they are right there for God and everyone to see. I'm sure some folks here will agree with you and others with me. Been a relatively pleasant discussion sir. Thanks.
 
Last edited:
Ummm, did you actually intend this for me?
[snip]

I was making a joke, imploring the forgiveness of a forum member in lieu of god, and your name seemed appropriate as I had been talking to you in this thread. The actual post wasn't intended for you - sorry for the confusion! :)

Good to see Beth is, if nothing else, consistent...;)
 
Provided with you with an independent source. Sorry, it's not on the internet.

At this point, since your independent source is not germane to the discussion, it doesn't matter.

Er, no. I'm not claiming they are lying. I'm claiming what you quoted doesn't constitute a creed or dogma.

Great. Kindly advise me what each site meant when they referenced the "Lord Jesus Christ".

But pretending I haven't provided proof of my claim is ungentlemanly, sir!

ROFL. Flattery will get you no where with me, miss. :D

I'm sure some folks here will agree with you and others with me.

Point out one other person in this discussion who agrees with you. :cool:

Mobyseven said:
I was making a joke, imploring the forgiveness of a forum member in lieu of god, and your name seemed appropriate as I had been talking to you in this thread. The actual post wasn't intended for you - sorry for the confusion!

Thank Moby!

No worries, it just read as ultra-sarcastic toward me, but I now see where the sarcasm was aimed. Feel free to offer any prayers in my direction that you like. I promise a 24-hour turnaround. Customer service for salvation is my top priority!

Good to see Beth is, if nothing else, consistent... ;)

Yes, it's an endearing quality. I could almost start forming a crush based on that alone. :blush:
 
Thank Moby!

No worries, it just read as ultra-sarcastic toward me, but I now see where the sarcasm was aimed. Feel free to offer any prayers in my direction that you like. I promise a 24-hour turnaround. Customer service for salvation is my top priority!

Dear RobRoy. For Atheistmas, I want a billion dollars, a small Greek island and a controlling share in Ikea. And a pony.
 
Love thy neighbor wasn't a new teaching of Christ's, it first comes from Leviticus.
And where did I state that it was a new teaching of Christ? Are you sure you were keeping up with the conversation? :confused:
19:18 Thou shalt not avenge, nor bear any grudge against the children of thy people, but thou shalt love thy neighbour as thyself: I am the LORD
Vengeance is mine, sayeth the Lord seems to fit in this rubric, wouldn't you say?

But two down and it's telling us the penalty for ****ing engaged slaves:
19:20 And whosoever lieth carnally with a woman, that is a bondmaid, betrothed to an husband, and not at all redeemed, nor freedom given her; she shall be scourged; they shall not be put to death, because she was not free
Seems to fit into the old "Thou shalt not commit audltery" bit, don't you think?

I get a real kick out of sola scriptura atheists.

How many of you confuse a flight manual with a pilot? Why do you choose to do so treat the Bible and Christians, I wonder?

DR
 
Yes, it's an endearing quality. I could almost start forming a crush based on that alone. :blush:
Consistent Crush is the second song on the album Birth Canal, soon to be released by the neo-punk band Schizophrenic Fetus. (That means release as soon as I can gather the talent and production facilities to release the first ALbum, After Birth, with it's hit singles "A Womb with a Few" and "Soliloquol Twins" as well as the B-side hits "Head Out" and "Headin' Home.")

DR
 
Last edited:
How many of you confuse a flight manual with a pilot? Why do you choose to do so treat the Bible and Christians, I wonder?

DR

Possibly because of three things:

(1) Christians claim to have access to some absolute moral authority; and
(2) Christians very frequently refer to the Bible as being an accurate reflection of this absolute moral authority; and
(3) The thoughts of individual Christians are so disparate that it seems their "absolute moral authority" is a matter of mere convenience.

The determination of Christians to both claim absolute moral authority and then pick and choose what they like from the buffet on a mere matter of whim seems contradictory to those of us actually trying to understand stuff, you know...?

Honestly, for the "new age" Christian, it seems anything is permitted... :D
 
I get a real kick out of sola scriptura atheists.

How many of you confuse a flight manual with a pilot? Why do you choose to do so treat the Bible and Christians, I wonder?

I know this wasn't aimed at me, but since I've had the same accusation aimed at my arguments (on both sides), I think it's worth being addressed.

The Bible is so large, so complex, and covers such a great (and somewhat random) number of writers, few of whom were specifically aiming at the same target (if they aimed at all), that it is hard to deal with the entire document when having any kind of discussion. Thus, when making and supporting a particular case, and searching through the scriptures for reference points and quotations, it's easy to overlook some portions in the focus to find others. In the main, both sides of a particular Bible-focussed argument can easily find themselves having quoted one set of verses, only to another, contradictory set, shot back. I don't think that anyone who is legitimately open to discussion and argumentation does this on purpose.

There are certainly those who do this, and they seem far more interested in seeing their own words up on the screen rather than participating in a worthwhile discussion. They generally like to cast aspersions on anyone who doesn't immediately agree with them, or fall in line with their statements and then accusations of "apologist" or "atheist" are leveled, as if these are dirty-word insults.
 
How many of you confuse a flight manual with a pilot? Why do you choose to do so treat the Bible and Christians, I wonder?

DR

I wonder why it is that when some atheists insist certain verses need to be interpretted certain ways - they seem to prefer the negative verses and interpretations over other interpretations.

Is this a form of Ad Hominem?
 
I know this wasn't aimed at me, but since I've had the same accusation aimed at my arguments (on both sides), I think it's worth being addressed.

The Bible is so large, so complex, and covers such a great (and somewhat random) number of writers, few of whom were specifically aiming at the same target (if they aimed at all), that it is hard to deal with the entire document when having any kind of discussion. Thus, when making and supporting a particular case, and searching through the scriptures for reference points and quotations, it's easy to overlook some portions in the focus to find others. In the main, both sides of a particular Bible-focussed argument can easily find themselves having quoted one set of verses, only to another, contradictory set, shot back. I don't think that anyone who is legitimately open to discussion and argumentation does this on purpose.

There are certainly those who do this, and they seem far more interested in seeing their own words up on the screen rather than participating in a worthwhile discussion. They generally like to cast aspersions on anyone who doesn't immediately agree with them, or fall in line with their statements and then accusations of "apologist" or "atheist" are leveled, as if these are dirty-word insults.

I'd like to add to this that if you are having a discussion about Christianity, you're going to have to discuss the bible at some point - and far more likely, the bible is going to be a major centrepiece of the discussion. The reason for this is simple: The bible is a major part of Christianity.

When I discuss the bible, I'm not going around searching for the worst possible thing I can find and then twisting it to try and be worse, just so I can say, "Look at how eeeeevil the bible is!!!" I'm generally responding to a point that has been made - when people claim the bible is the source of their morality, for example, I get a bit confused, because I can point to parts of the bible that are inconsistent with some of their moral positions. If someone makes a claim about an event that occurred in the bible (such as the resurrection), I can go and check, and find that the event is described multiple times in mutually inconsistent ways.

Rather than just say your holy book has been misrepresented, or deliberately interpreted in an unfavourable light, explain why that is the case. Justify your position! Darth Rotor and RobRoy have both been making an effort, and as such the discussion has progressed where they have been involved - possibly for the first time since I've been on the forums, I have been involved in a discussion on religion* that hasn't devolved into a bickering match, and I must say it is a pleasant experience.

*Specifically religion, not theism. I've had some good discussions on theism with people on the forum, that haven't been useless or counter-productive.
 
This is a thread about faith... and how do people get their religious faith... from people who teach who get their message from others and so on and so on back to an inspired book or supposed revelation, etc. That is how beliefs come about right? But, each individual is going with his own translation... and interpretation... nobody believes the same things... theoretically all Christians believe in the crucifixion for "original sin" and the resurrection-- and that Jesus was great guy who really lived and taught people important things and that believing "in him" is part of salvation... right? But everyone seems to have their own definition of god and why he's not testable and what, if anything, is meant by a trinity and so forth. "Original Sin"--the whole reason Jesus was supposedly "sacrificed" is also interpreted differently by all sorts of people. And believers get test when you try to pin them down on what they believe and why. They want to believe it-- they don't want to have it questioned.

Why couldn't these kinds of beliefs lead people to do what Fred Phelps does or the Crusades did or the inquisition did? What could keep that from happening again? Just because your interpretation or picking and choosing from your faith leads you to a different message and an apologetic tone or dismissal for the parts you don't agree with, doesn't mean that others don't take home completely different messages and completely different interpretations "important messages".

Do you think Andrea Yates ensured her Children's eternal salvation by killing them before they were old enough to sin? If you believe this, then can you "blame" Andrea Yates for believing it? If you are sure her kids are living happily ever after-- that they just started their eternity earlier... then why wouldn't Andrea Yates? But isn't that the belief promoted by religion--kids go straight to heaven to begin their happily ever after?

Don't you see where all this moral certainty that is totally open to interpretation can lead? You don't know what messages other people are getting from that text or their invisible friend or the voices in their head-- and they all are as sure or more sure than you are that their message is the true one.

How can you feel "more moral" than the supposed moral relativism of an atheist.? What you have is clearly moral relativism dressed up as something fancy in your head. There is no evidence that it leads to better behavior and lots of evidence to show that it can lead to human suffering. Everyone thinks their faith is a font of "higher truths" and moral wisdom.

And that's why I use the term apologist. It's like some people just can't see the obvious.
You want to believe that religion is good and makes people better people and that when harm comes from faith it really isn't "faith"-- it's something else that is the problem. You want to believe that you are a better person because of your faith. But where is the evidence. You never really say what you have faith in or why --or why whatever you're using to get your divine truths can't be used by others to come up with some very alarming "truths". What are you beliefs based on? A book clearly written by mortals? Voices in your head? A feeling? Something the people you trust told you when you were little? Fear of not believing? Egotism? Security? Can't whatever your beliefs are based on be used to justify horrific actions with the same "warm" feelings of divine certainty? You don't say, and then you judge and put yourself above those who dare to ask these questions. I think it's because you are afraid of these questions. You have to see the asker as the bad guy for fear of losing faith.

And that makes faith "dangerous". It makes people who "need" the lie... for their imagined "salvation"... and often they need to prove their "faith" to an invisible savior that demands it. Why wouldn't people do anything... including what Andrea Yates did... if they really truly believed that life was a test for eternity... and that you never really die... and that "faith" is the most important attribute you can show your invisible judge?? What wouldn't you do for your faith. What wouldn't you do to ensure the blissful eternity of the people you love most-- and/or yourself?
 
Last edited:
I wonder why it is that when some atheists insist certain verses need to be interpreted certain ways - they seem to prefer the negative verses and interpretations over other interpretations.

Is this a form of Ad Hominem?
.
The book is allegedly a guide, right?
Like a traffic sign, it tells you what you should do.
There's only one "interpretation" that works for STOP, for instance.
Rolling stops are common 'interpretations" of the guide, but can be frowned on by those that have the power to frown.
I would expect a similar "absolute" from a life guide that's been vetted by BSD himself, thru trial and error.
 
Exactly... how much of a scofflaw are you willing to be in the eyes of the big judge in the sky?

And I don't "prefer" any biblical verses... I just am interested in seeing how you pick and choose from your "divinely inspired moral guide" and then pretend that it's not relativism. Clearly not everyone is getting the same message from the supposed "same source". Not everyone is feeling the urge to STOP at the stop sign. Some seem to feel it's contingent upon interpretation. Why?
And what about those who are a little more obedient to the letter of the law than you. Aren't they doing "more" to ensure the words are what you claim it is?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom