Faith leads to evil.

Bundy. I considered my semi recent choice to operate out of rational thinking, at the end of each day. I cut the pros and cons to considering Bundy's choices in life.

2 b known- went on a killing spree for four years.

2 b known- murdered (and raped, whether his women were alive or dead) 30 women.

End result for Bundy- Jail, and then executed.

Whether there is 'good or evil', was it worth it, was it rational?

Leaves me with two things to weigh:

1) Was it worth it/rational, from Ted's perspective? My reason, would say it would not be. Four years of fun (from Bundy's perspective, not mine) vs jail and being executed. My reason would say, from Bundy's position, there is more than 'one way to skin a cat' (meet his emotional/sexual..needs). I'd find an alternative to satisfy my cravings, and keep my life moving forward, rather than running the risk of sitting in jail waiting to be executed. I'd rather have another 30 years of life to do the things I like, and continue to 'skin the cats' - if in a more conducive alternative fashion.

2) Is it rational to destroy 30 lives for one man to have his bliss? -Particularly if you put a value to individual lives on an equal footing.

Then I look and see that Bundy didn't seem to indicate having any faith based mode of operation. Bundy seemed to do 'bad things' entirely on his own volition.

The more I listen to examples here, and ponder examples that I can toss, I believe it all comes down to what a person chooses to do, and the 'why he chooses to do it' seems to eminate from personal drives, wants, needs or compulsions.

Religion (and perhaps atheism as well) all fulfill a persons personal drive, want, or need. People latch on to religion (or atheism), or nakedly operate out from self, to aid themselves in their ventures. I think this would prove that actions come from each individual, more so than religion or atheism... Religion just seem to be the justification, the woobie blanket to operate under, that some people require in order to feel comfortable.

Now, I would say that religions seem to propagate certain behaviors, but again, it all comes down to personal choice - or the need for the person to meet their inner 'whatevers' by clinging to a faith that allows them to manipulate justification for their actions.

'Good or evil', or lack thereof, is relative to each person's perspective. Actions that make sense, or that do not make sense, are, indeed, up for debate.

Religion, is a consequence of people uniting under one umbrella to meet a/o perpetuate a mutual cause. There is no 'religion' without the people who created them. These creators of religion did so out of fulfillment for personal needs/justifications. There is no 'religion' without ensuing people who perpetuate it. These people also operate out of fullment for personal needs/justifications. This brings it back to the responsibility resting on the shoulders of each individual.

Good or evil - are perspectives and therefore 'fuzzy'. Sensible actions, or nonsensical actions exist, can be differentiated, can be debated via rationale and statistics.
 
Last edited:
When challenged as to the evil deeds religious people do, their defenders say they were "misguided" and/or not following the "true" religion. Atheists have no such defense.

Sure they do. Bundy as example, defended by thaiboxerken:

"Not only that, but they also try to say that Bundy's deeds were rational."

He's saying Bundy wasn't really rational, even though Bundy's actions were (according to a brief interview) a result of rational steps. He thought through his actions with zero input from faith, and arrived at a rational conclusion that he should be basically an egoist/hedonist, putting his own desires above others. Only a perfect rationality could prevent an imperfect rationality from being evil (assuming a perfect rationality always leads to good).

thaiboxerken said:
You are only half right. Atheism is the lack of belief, a void, evil cannot come from a void. I'm glad you've finally agreed that evil can come from faith.

Theism is the belief, evil cannot come from belief itself. Same silly latching on to words without a real logic.

Even if Bundy was "wrong" in applying rationalism to his belief-action system, he DID use rationalism as that basis. He is one example of "rationalism leads to evil" which is of course ridiculous as a generalization. But if you poo-poo his example, you also need to poo-poo every theist who has used theism "wrongly" to justify evil actions. You can't have the cake and eat it too. Unless of course you're simply biased beyond salvation and want generalities to become absolutes...

Basically rationalists are placing a rationalist morality at neutral or good outcome, based on "perfect" rationalism, which some like Bundy fail to reach, thus are discarded as a data-point. Well, the obvious thing to then ask them is--what is this "perfect rationalist morale"?

So, let's hear it! Utilitarianism? Secular humanism? Dispense with the single correct system and let us get on with it by following it (if it's so darn-gosh correct)!

westprog said:
He's certainly started well. Only here since April and already hitting 'em out of the park. Has Articulett put him on ignore yet?

Hehe, I hope not. Thanks for the support :) but I'm more like Tony Gwynn than Mark McGwire for hitting them out of the park. Sometimes I get lucky but I'm mostly flailing or hitting for contact. And I've lurked for awhile before posting. :)
 
How can you have a logical conversation with people who want to believe that Bundy or Stalin committed evil due to their lack of belief-- while refusing to accept that Hitler was a Christian or that Al Quaeda did awful things in the name of their faith? Or that Andrea Yates killed her kids to send them to their heavenly eternity early?

Bundy didn't commit evil as a result of his disbelief--but he used that + concurrent rationlism as a basis for his actions.

Yates may not have committed evil as a result of her faith--but used that + her extra-faith rationalism as a basis for her actions.

Two gross conclusions:

Both Yates and Bundy prove that both theism and atheism lead to evil...

Or both Yates and Bundy prove that they're screwed up individuals who will latch on to any belief system if it leads to furthering their screwed-up goals.

I accept Yates killed her kids based on her faith. I don't accept that that means "faith leads to evil". WTF?? That's a ridiculous conclusion, when the opposite also has examples of leading to evil.
 
He acted rationally given the irrational starting point? That's quite a concept. Anyway, you're still wrong.



Even caring for himself, he still acted irrational, as the consequences of his actions mean a life of loneliness devoid of love and friendship, which are some of the most exquisite experiences. There is also the consequence of having to hide his actions, constantly being afraid of being caught, and of course, the consequences when he did get caught.

Bundy clearly preferred to relate to people in a different way. As a psychopath, he didn't regard love and friendship as important. I think it's important to realise that some people are built differently. Bundy was probably as happy as someone like that could be, up until capture.

Whether he would have lived his life differently if he'd known he was to be caught - possibly. If he'd been able to carry on killing and not be caught, he'd have carried on doing it.

Why? What rational reason do you have to say what he did was wrong?

Because I think human beings have intrinsic value.

It's irrational because of reasons outlined above.


So his actions were rational even though they were based on irrational premise that could only end up with him causing much harm to the world and/or himself...........

Why should he care about causing harm to the world? He thought he was benefitting himself. How can anyone else judge that?

I note again that the main reason for calling Bundy's actions irrational is to assume that he'd react like a normal person, and that he'd be caught. Bear in mind that the only reason we have Bundy's testament is because he was caught. There are Bundy's out there who haven't been, and won't be caught. Are they acting rationally?
 
Last edited:
Bundy. I considered my semi recent choice to operate out of rational thinking, at the end of each day. I cut the pros and cons to considering Bundy's choices in life.

2 b known- went on a killing spree for four years.

2 b known- murdered (and raped, whether his women were alive or dead) 30 women.

End result for Bundy- Jail, and then executed.

Whether there is 'good or evil', was it worth it, was it rational?

Leaves me with two things to weigh:

1) Was it worth it/rational, from Ted's perspective? My reason, would say it would not be. Four years of fun (from Bundy's perspective, not mine) vs jail and being executed. My reason would say, from Bundy's position, there is more than 'one way to skin a cat' (meet his emotional/sexual..needs). I'd find an alternative to satisfy my cravings, and keep my life moving forward, rather than running the risk of sitting in jail waiting to be executed. I'd rather have another 30 years of life to do the things I like, and continue to 'skin the cats' - if in a more conducive alternative fashion.

But, ultimately, each person makes these judgements himself.

Suppose you're a black man in apartheid South Africa, in love with a white woman. Is it irrational to pursue such a relationship, given the likely consequences?

If the only thing to worry about is the fear of consequences, the one is as irrational as the other.
 
Sure they do. Bundy as example, defended by thaiboxerken:

"Not only that, but they also try to say that Bundy's deeds were rational."

He's saying Bundy wasn't really rational, even though Bundy's actions were (according to a brief interview) a result of rational steps. He thought through his actions with zero input from faith, and arrived at a rational conclusion that he should be basically an egoist/hedonist, putting his own desires above others. Only a perfect rationality could prevent an imperfect rationality from being evil (assuming a perfect rationality always leads to good).

And it's hard to see why perfect rationality should lead to good. Rationality can only be applied to values, which are chosen, not derived. Bundy applied rationality on a basis that other people had no value. It's hard to see how even perfect rationality could lead to a good outcome with those values.

Theism is the belief, evil cannot come from belief itself. Same silly latching on to words without a real logic.

Even if Bundy was "wrong" in applying rationalism to his belief-action system, he DID use rationalism as that basis. He is one example of "rationalism leads to evil" which is of course ridiculous as a generalization. But if you poo-poo his example, you also need to poo-poo every theist who has used theism "wrongly" to justify evil actions. You can't have the cake and eat it too. Unless of course you're simply biased beyond salvation and want generalities to become absolutes...

Basically rationalists are placing a rationalist morality at neutral or good outcome, based on "perfect" rationalism, which some like Bundy fail to reach, thus are discarded as a data-point. Well, the obvious thing to then ask them is--what is this "perfect rationalist morale"?

So, let's hear it! Utilitarianism? Secular humanism? Dispense with the single correct system and let us get on with it by following it (if it's so darn-gosh correct)!

I suppose that if we had the perfect value system, and could apply it perfectly, we'd have the best of all possible worlds. I think we're a little short of that.

As we've seen over the last hundred years, what can be really dangerous is the assumption that we do have the perfect system applied perfectly. That's the road to hell.

Hehe, I hope not. Thanks for the support :) but I'm more like Tony Gwynn than Mark McGwire for hitting them out of the park. Sometimes I get lucky but I'm mostly flailing or hitting for contact. And I've lurked for awhile before posting. :)

That'll teach me to use a sports analogy for a sport I don't really know.

In any case, by regarding rationality as something to be demonstrated rather than merely asserted, you're already in the top 10%.
 
Bundy is a weird case, because most people, religious or not, do not get a thrill out of torturing and killing people. Bundy did. Bundy's mother was very religious, but I don't think we really know what made him into the person he was. If religion controlled aberrant behavior or thoughts in a beneficial way, you wouldn't have any pedophile members of the clergy would you? We could just church the evil doers and --presto, they'd never hurt anyone again.

I think this kinds of instincts and feelings are primal in source... not subject to ready control--religious or otherwise... which is why we lock such people up. It doesn't matter that it's not their "fault" that they have desires that others don't have-- what matter is that others are protected from such people.

I'm not sure belief or lack of belief have much to do with your feelings, propensities, and so forth. I just see no evidence that "believing in gods" has any positive affect on behavior... nor do I see as "lack of belief" in anything as being nearly as influential as what you "believe in". Bundy wasn't a Scientologist... can we blame his murderous spree on that? I think it makes more sense to blame it on him not being a female, frankly.

Religious people are so damn blinkered the way they have come to see "non belief" as something responsible for "evil" while ignoring all the harms that come from faith. While faith is not responsible for all evil... nor does it always lead to evil... the faithful and their apologist buddies sure are blind to the many times when it does...

and they manufacture connections whenever they can to twist "lack of faith" into playing a role in every evil they can imagine so that they can play their "notice the hits" game to confirm their favorite bias.
 
If the only thing to worry about is the fear of consequences, the one is as irrational as the other

I understand, but I'll be pondering this one at work.

Rational to me, would be having more time to romp in this world. Then again, is it more rational to have one blaze of glory and have quality of what you want to attain? Or is it more rational to dole that out over a period of time, and in lesser quality, but open to more possibilities?

I wasn't quite looking at it as fear of consequence, but rather common sense, in relation to what is best for 'self'.

The passionate side of me would roll with doing the former - just doing it.

The rational side grabs the latter - opening up longer time for greater, or different possibilities.
 
If the only thing to worry about is the fear of consequences, the one is as irrational as the other

I understand, but I'll be pondering this one at work.

Rational to me, would be having more time to romp in this world. Then again, is it more rational to have one blaze of glory and have quality of what you want to attain? Or is it more rational to dole that out over a period of time, and in lesser quality, but open to more possibilities?

I wasn't quite looking at it as fear of consequence, but rather common sense, in relation to what is best for 'self'.

The passionate side of me would roll with doing the former - just doing it.

The rational side grabs the latter - opening up longer time for greater, or different possibilities.

Of course, if your blaze of glory is rescuing people from burning buildings, as opposed to what Bundy did, then it might be a matter of fullfillment to you, but it would make a lot of difference to other people.
 
Westprog.

Correct.

I was going to put 'self' (and others), but quibbled with myself. :drool:
 
Sure they do. Bundy as example, defended by thaiboxerken:

"Not only that, but they also try to say that Bundy's deeds were rational."

He's saying Bundy wasn't really rational, even though Bundy's actions were (according to a brief interview) a result of rational steps. He thought through his actions with zero input from faith, and arrived at a rational conclusion that he should be basically an egoist/hedonist, putting his own desires above others. Only a perfect rationality could prevent an imperfect rationality from being evil (assuming a perfect rationality always leads to good).


He certainly is saying Bundy's actions were rational, if not, he could not claim that rationalism lead to Bundy's evil deeds. Bundy's arguments were not rational given his premise, thus it cannot be a rational thought process that drove him. No, Bundy wasn't driven by rationalism, but by pure selfish desire and lust. He "rationalized" only in the sense that he sought to justify his deeds. It was irrationalism that led Bundy to his murderous spree.

Theism is the belief, evil cannot come from belief itself. Same silly latching on to words without a real logic.

Not at all. You may as well state that evil cannot come from actions while you're at it. The problem here is that I'm right and you're wrong. Beliefs motivate people, they cause people to take actions. Lack of beliefs do not motivate or cause people to take action. Seeds grow into plants. Lack of seeds doesn't cause plants to disappear. Beliefs are seeds. Atheism is th lack of seeds.

Even if Bundy was "wrong" in applying rationalism to his belief-action system, he DID use rationalism as that basis.

Wrongly applied rationalism isn't rationalism, but rather, it's irrationalism. It is the same kind of "rationalism" that the faithful use to justify their deeds. Bundy had selfish desires and simply used fallacious reasoning as excuses for his actions, much in the same way that the faithful use fallacious reasoning to "prove" their faith.

He is one example of "rationalism leads to evil" which is of course ridiculous as a generalization. But if you poo-poo his example, you also need to poo-poo every theist who has used theism "wrongly" to justify evil actions. You can't have the cake and eat it too. Unless of course you're simply biased beyond salvation and want generalities to become absolutes...

They really are absolutes, just like the speed of light in a vacuum.

Basically rationalists are placing a rationalist morality at neutral or good outcome, based on "perfect" rationalism, which some like Bundy fail to reach, thus are discarded as a data-point. Well, the obvious thing to then ask them is--what is this "perfect rationalist morale"?

That's a strawman. No one is saying there is a perfect rationalism. There is only rationalism. Anything that's not rational doesn't make the cut. Bundy didn't make rational choices and neither did he make rational arguments for his choices.

Now, feel free to tell me how Bundy's actions were rational.
 
Does anyone other than westrpog think that Ted Bundy was rational or a "rationalist"... I think westprog is a glaring example of an apologist... he sees what isn't there to related lack of belief to evil deeds... and ignores all those who do evil to prove their faith.

What evil things has your lack of belief in Scientology lead to again, Westprog? How about your lack of belief in rain dancing.? Is that a part of rationalism? How can that be...? --you consider rational lack of belief as a segue to evil. So why hasn't your lack of belief in astrology lead you to victimize people again? Or has it?

You are embarrassingly ridiculous. I hope everyone reads your words and aims not to sound anything like the sorry apologist you are.

Lack of belief is nothing... like lack of seeds. And no matter how many times that is told to you-- you have a bizarre (irrational) need to twist it into something else so you can pretend through your convoluted logic that faith is good... and that the faithful would never do what Bundy did. (I think you'd be surprised how many mass murderers and serial killers were pillars in their religious community... it sure isn't protective against sociopathy.)

Atheism is a lack of something. Rationalism is something... you can even read books about it. The Monty Hall Dilemma is a problem that can be solved rationally... but most people use "instinct" and make a poorer choice. Rationalism involves understanding the ways our "instinct" is off. Bundy was not interested as to why his "instincts" were off-- he only cared about fulfilling them... he was compulsive... the opposite of rational in many ways.

Your rationality is severely damaged if your faith has made you think that Ted Bundy or anyone else's evil actions were due to "rationality". Rationality is not the opposite of "good", you know. It's the opposite of irrational... which you seem to exemplify.

I think your double standard is hideous, and I blame your gurus and preacher men for the bigotry you exhibit. But thanks again, for illustrating the point of the OP beautifully in the few snippets I read from TBK quoting you.
 
I think your double standard is hideous, and I blame your gurus and preacher men for the bigotry you exhibit. But thanks again, for illustrating the point of the OP beautifully in the few snippets I read from TBK quoting you.

What's the point of putting someone on Ignore if you're going to respond to them via someone quoting them?
 
Here it says Ted Bundy is a Mormon (Mormons consider themselves Christian)
http://crime.about.com/od/murder/p/bundy.htm

He also "accepted Jesus" in jail so I guess that makes him heaven bound to many Christians.

And here is someone who says Ted Bundy is the REASON not to believe in a god who makes humans in his image.

http://mycaseagainstgod.blogspot.com/2006/04/gods-splendid-magnificent-creationted.html

If you theists want rational people to take you seriously, you need to bone up on rational thought. You just sound...so... blinkered by your faith. This is a skeptics forum... there are tons of links and videos and books... you are doing all believers and apologists a disservice by putting your ignorance on such embarrassing display here. I know not all theists are like westprog et. al. But he does leave a residue on the whole lot from my perspective.
 
The majority of people who attend TAM are non believers... there seems to be no shortage of love and friendship in the group... there's even intelligence and humor-- something often missing from the theist crowds I've been around. The stronger the faith, the suckier the sense of humor --and ability to reason I've noticed.

ETA-- look... "faith leading to evil"... http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/2008/05/true_monsters.php#comments

When has "lack of faith" lead to an "honor killing"?
 
Last edited:
Now, feel free to tell me how Bundy's actions were rational.

They don't need to be, he only needs to think they were. Just as Andrea Yates' actions didn't need to be properly "faithful", she just needs to have thought they were.

Theists shouldn't have to fall all over themselves showing why Yates wasn't really being faithful. You and Articulett shouldn't have to fall all over yourselves in showing why Bundy wasn't really rational.

The point is--you can't use one as an example but not the other. The proper course is using neither.

Not at all. You may as well state that evil cannot come from actions while you're at it. The problem here is that I'm right and you're wrong. Beliefs motivate people, they cause people to take actions. Lack of beliefs do not motivate or cause people to take action. Seeds grow into plants. Lack of seeds doesn't cause plants to disappear. Beliefs are seeds. Atheism is th lack of seeds.

Not according to Bundy's rationalization: "Surely, you would not, in this age of scientific enlightenment, declare that God or nature has marked some pleasures as 'moral' or 'good' and others as 'immoral' or 'bad'?"

His lack of a belief in god (atheism) led to or helped in his rationalization (rationalism) of his murderering and raping people (evil).

He's a nutcase who used or abused atheism for his own ends. That doesn't means atheism leads to evil. But the antithesis is also true--theism doesn't lead to evil. And some nutcase religious murderer can't be used as example that it does.

You're simply not being objective.

articulett said:
But thanks again, for illustrating the point of the OP beautifully in the few snippets I read from TBK quoting you.

wow
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom