"Except for cases of rape or incest". Why?

I have had occasion to debate the issue with some fairly smart pro-lifers whose reasoning abilities I otherwise respected. They never seemed the slightest bit swayed by any argument - rational, practical, moral or otherwise.

And were you swayed even in the slightest by their arguments? See, you are automatically assuming you are right, and they aren't. What if you're the one that is wrong?
 
Right. Because knowing the rest of your life that your baby is out there somewhere is an option.

Isn't it? Why is that more troubling than spending the rest of your life knowing that you killed what could have been your child?

Because there are 1.5 million families just hoping to raise some malnourished, seventeen year-old's child.

Because there are 1.5 million abortions from malnourished seventeen-year-olds. Because removing the option to have an abortion would have absolutely no effect on the rate of unwanted pregnancies.

Because the fact that both parents have to consent to an adoption doesn't make things even slightly more difficult.

If the father doesn't consent to adoption, the father can get custody. The mother still isn't forced to raise the child.
 
Right. Because knowing the rest of your life that your baby is out there somewhere is an option. Because there are 1.5 million families just hoping to raise some malnourished, seventeen year-old's child. Because the fact that both parents have to consent to an adoption doesn't make things even slightly more difficult. Nope, no issue here. [/extraordinarily obvious sarcasm]

Wow, both parents have to sign the papers? I didn't know that. That's what pro-lifers should be fighting for! Make it more reasonable for someone to give their baby up for adoption, clean up the foster care system, support your local Planned Parenthood so they can continue giving prenatal care to people who otherwise could not afford it.
 
The point I was trying to make is that those who oppose abortion do not seem to me to be likely to be reasoned into changing their views. And I would say this of many, many beliefs, both politically divisive and not. Careful, factual debate doesn't seem to change many minds on issues of morality.


And were you swayed even in the slightest by their arguments? See, you are automatically assuming you are right, and they aren't. What if you're the one that is wrong?


Can you read? I didn't except myself from anything. Nor did I even hint anywhere in my post that I thought my view was right or that an opposing view was wrong.
 
That would be called giving birth.

No, aborting the fetus during the 39th week would be called a third trimester abortion.

Seriously, do you think that any woman would wait all that time to decide she didn't actually want to be pregnant?

It doesn't require someone wait. They could change their mind. And yes, given the range of human behavior (including murdering your own children), I think it would happen.

But that's irrelevant to what fuelair believes. Regardless of how often he thinks the question might arise, he still either finds it acceptable or unacceptable. And so do you. Would YOU care to state which?
 
Can you read? I didn't except myself from anything. Nor did I even hint anywhere in my post that I thought my view was right or that an opposing view was wrong.

Yes I can read, and I find it highly disingenuous of you to change the quote to which I was responding.
 
it's perfectly exceptable to pop it in a plastic bag and toss it in the garbage?

Such a thing is extremely rare and so is most certainly 'exceptable'.
It is somewhat ironic that a couple of posts before this you were accusing another poster of raising a strawman.
A woman who has given birth is no longer pregnant, so your hypothetical scenario is pointless to the argument.
 
Yes I can read, and I find it highly disingenuous of you to change the quote to which I was responding.



I didn't change one word of my original post. The fact that you chose to quote a single sentence of that post which happened not to be inconsistent with your accusation is not my fault. By showing a different part of my post, I pointed out that you had failed either to read or comprehend the entire gist of my statement.
 
Compared to Caucasians, in the USA, yes.

I wasn't just meaning "in the US", but since you bring that up....

Isn't it true that "in the US" Caucasians make up around 65% of the population, and thus would have more demand, purely in numbers?

Isn't it also true that around a quarter of all African American child placed each year are placed in non-African American homes, a practice that many groups consider wrong and speak out against because they don't think children should be raised outside of the African American community?

Isn't also true that of the 200,000 children adopted in the US from overseas in the last 15 years, 50% were asian?

It would seem to me that most adoptive parent really don't care as to the race, it's outsiders who do.
 
I've heard some pro-life advocates say that they are against abortion except in cases of rape or incest. Why? Is that baby any less human? Wouldn't it still qualify as killing the unborn?

Just for the record, I'm pro-choice.

For my two cents, as far as I'm concerned this is the wrong question. Why should the government force anybody to bring to term a child that isn't wanted? Or, to reverse the issue, why should a child be forced to be brought into a home where it wasn't wanted?

I wasn't just meaning "in the US", but since you bring that up....

Isn't it true that "in the US" Caucasians make up around 65% of the population, and thus would have more demand, purely in numbers?

Isn't it also true that around a quarter of all African American child placed each year are placed in non-African American homes, a practice that many groups consider wrong and speak out against because they don't think children should be raised outside of the African American community?

Isn't also true that of the 200,000 children adopted in the US from overseas in the last 15 years, 50% were asian?

It would seem to me that most adoptive parent really don't care as to the race, it's outsiders who do.

I'm genuinely curious about this as well, if for nothing else than academic reasons. If anyone has recent numbers, they're welcome.

This seems to be a constant in a lot of social issues (gay rights, for instance), where in order to be truly worked-up about something, one must be removed from it for all intents and purposes. While I haven't heard anyone actually complain about black children being placed in non-black (or whatever heterogenous combination you prefer) homes when adopted, opposition to this does ring true, and I'd place it in the same backward, narrow-minded vein that opposes interracial relationships (it's not only rural white trash who favor exclusion; admittedly anecdotal - I've heard many a black woman say that blacks should only date/marry each other).

There are bound to be outsiders who oppose these sorts of things. Whether we should care or not of course is up to each person (but the correct answer's "no, we shouldn't" :D).
 
Last edited:
Such a thing is extremely rare and so is most certainly 'exceptable'.
It is somewhat ironic that a couple of posts before this you were accusing another poster of raising a strawman.
A woman who has given birth is no longer pregnant, so your hypothetical scenario is pointless to the argument.

So no difference between not wanting to be pregnant for nine moths and not wanting to be a mother for nineteen years? Of course a great way to avoid having to answer the question.
 
So no difference between not wanting to be pregnant for nine moths and not wanting to be a mother for nineteen years? Of course a great way to avoid having to answer the question.

I have made no comment at all about being a mother for any number of years. I said women who do not want to be pregnant should be able to have abortions.
Which question do you think I have avoided?
 
I didn't change one word of my original post. The fact that you chose to quote a single sentence of that post which happened not to be inconsistent with your accusation is not my fault. By showing a different part of my post, I pointed out that you had failed either to read or comprehend the entire gist of my statement.

I didn't say you did change your original post, I said you changed the quote I was responding to, which you did. You didn't actually address my point, you changed the quote and went off on a sidetrack. Your post was about people not being willing to change their minds despite what you consider rational arguments against their position, you stated that you "had occasion to debate the issue with some fairly smart pro-lifers whose reasoning abilities I otherwise respected. They never seemed the slightest bit swayed by any argument - rational, practical, moral or otherwise." The only reason to believe that they should have been swayed is if you believe they were wrong and you were right. I am suggesting that perhaps this is not true.

Consider this:

"I have had occasion to debate the issue with some fairly smart 911-debunkers whose reasoning abilities I otherwise respected. They never seemed the slightest bit swayed by any argument - rational, practical, moral or otherwise."
 
I have made no comment at all about being a mother for any number of years. I said women who do not want to be pregnant should be able to have abortions.
Which question do you think I have avoided?

So you think it is acceptable for a woman who is pregnant to not look after the life she's helped create?

Why then is it not just as acceptable for a woman who is no longer pregnant to not look after the life she's helped create?
 
Wow, both parents have to sign the papers? I didn't know that. That's what pro-lifers should be fighting for! Make it more reasonable for someone to give their baby up for adoption, clean up the foster care system, support your local Planned Parenthood so they can continue giving prenatal care to people who otherwise could not afford it.
.
Many of the state vehicles around here have "Don't abandon your baby" bumper stickers.
The mother can take the child to a fire station say, and drop it off.
The sperm donor need have no further input, other than the sperm. And typically doesn't, other than bragging rights with his buddies on spawning another bastard.
 
So you think it is acceptable for a woman who is pregnant to not look after the life she's helped create?

Why then is it not just as acceptable for a woman who is no longer pregnant to not look after the life she's helped create?

1. Yes. A woman who does not want to be pregnant should not be forced to stay pregnant. Do you think it acceptable that a woman who is unwillingly pregnant should be forced to stay pregnant?
2. It is just as acceptable. A woman who is not pregnant should not be forced to care for a child she does not want. Do you think a woman should be forced to care for a child she does not want?
 
1. Yes. A woman who does not want to be pregnant should not be forced to stay pregnant. Do you think it acceptable that a woman who is unwillingly pregnant should be forced to stay pregnant?
2. It is just as acceptable. A woman who is not pregnant should not be forced to care for a child she does not want. Do you think a woman should be forced to care for a child she does not want?

1) Depends on the meaning of unwilling. In my personal opinion, if you are unwilling to be pregnant, then don't take actions that will lead to that consequence. If you do the deed willingly, then that would indicate to me, that there is a responsibility to deal with any consequences.

2) I think that a woman that has a child should be responsible for taking care of it, whether that means raising it herself, helping her parents raise it, giving it over to the Father to raise, or making sure that it goes to a caring family to raise. She helped bring it into the world, thus she has the responsibility to make sure it is safe and protected.

You apparently disagree.
 
1) Depends on the meaning of unwilling. In my personal opinion, if you are unwilling to be pregnant, then don't take actions that will lead to that consequence. ....
.
Having a vagina is the "action" that leads to rape in a large number of cases.
.
2) I think that a woman that has a child should be responsible for taking care of it, whether that means raising it herself, helping her parents raise it, giving it over to the Father to raise, or making sure that it goes to a caring family to raise. She helped bring it into the world, thus she has the responsibility to make sure it is safe and protected.

You apparently disagree.
.
Any number of sperm donors are as far from being capable of fathering a child as the salmon that spread their eggs and sperm willy-nilly and then leave the scene (die). The human versions might as well.
One of the kids next door has a sperm donor as father. He is one abusive m.f.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom