"Except for cases of rape or incest". Why?

Your reference to playing russian roulette was the silly part

So you don't consider repearedly having unprotected sex to be a form of gambling similar to russian roulette?

Do you have any objection to abortion other than the fact that you think it should be banned as a form of punishment?

Please show exactly where I have stated that abortion should be banned, or that it is a form of punishment not having one. If you can't, please retract your statment.
 
Name one.

A few years ago here there was a newspaper article about students doing exactly this, having unprotected group sex, with the guys all putting money into a pool so they could pay for an abortion if needed. Do you consider that acceptable behaviour?
 
So you don't consider repearedly having unprotected sex to be a form of gambling similar to russian roulette?



Please show exactly where I have stated that abortion should be banned, or that it is a form of punishment not having one. If you can't, please retract your statment.

I don't see the relevance of repeatedly having unprotected sex to anything I have said. But it is not a good idea: it is better to prevent unwanted pregnancies and STDs than to have to abort or take antibiotics.
It wasn't a statement, it was a question.
I was under the impression that you opposed abortion.
Was I wrong?
And forcing a woman to continue with an unwanted pregnancy is punishment.
 
A few years ago here there was a newspaper article about students doing exactly this, having unprotected group sex, with the guys all putting money into a pool so they could pay for an abortion if needed. Do you consider that acceptable behaviour?

yes.
 
I don't see the relevance of repeatedly having unprotected sex to anything I have said.

Well maybe you need to start reading what I write for a change.

But it is not a good idea: it is better to prevent unwanted pregnancies and STDs than to have to abort or take antibiotics.

Thank you, now we are getting towards being on the same page.

It wasn't a statement, it was a question.

Saying it was a "fact that {I} think {abortion} should be banned as a form of punishment" is a question?

I was under the impression that you opposed abortion.
Was I wrong?

I oppose the use of abortion as a form of birth control. I oppose what is essentially teaching of our children and teens that it's all right to have risky sex because there's an easy out if you get pregnant. I oppose people putting themselves in a position where they then feel they need to use abortion to protect their present lifestyle.

And forcing a woman to continue with an unwanted pregnancy is punishment.

So you have switched from "unwilling" to "unwanted". Cool. Do you think that forcing parents to raise an unwanted child is a punishment too?
 
So you have switched from "unwilling" to "unwanted". Cool. Do you think that forcing parents to raise an unwanted child is a punishment too?

That is not a switch. Surely your understanding of English is not so confused? If a person is unwillingly pregnant, the pregnancy is unwanted. How could it mean anything else?
Yes. People should not be forced to raise unwanted children. Do you think that would be good for the children?
 
}


I oppose the use of abortion as a form of birth control. I oppose what is essentially teaching of our children and teens that it's all right to have risky sex because there's an easy out if you get pregnant. I oppose people putting themselves in a position where they then feel they need to use abortion to protect their present lifestyle.

Do you think abortions should be denied where they are used as birth control?
That a pregnancy in that case should be enforced?
Why should contraceptives be used to protect a lifestyle, but not abortion?
 
That is not a switch. Surely your understanding of English is not so confused? If a person is unwillingly pregnant, the pregnancy is unwanted. How could it mean anything else?

Not at all true. A woman can unwillingly become pregnant, by definition becoming pregnant against their will, but decide to keep it, thus while it is unwilling pregnancy it is not an unwanted one.

Conversely, a woman can willingly become pregnant, but decide she doesn't want it, thus have an unwanted pregnancy.

They are not the same thing, though I would accept that often they occur together.

Yes. People should not be forced to raise unwanted children.

Should they be allowed to terminate them?

Do you think that would be good for the children?

Funnily enough, abortion isn't about what would be good for the child.
 
Should they be allowed to terminate them?



Funnily enough, abortion isn't about what would be good for the child.

No, people should not be able to kill other people. Quite a silly question to ask.
Indeed abortion is not about what would be good for the child, because there is no child. Abortion is about what a woman chooses as best for her.
Although abortion could be best for some foetuses which would become severely handicapped children.

So, do you think that pregnancies resulting from inefficient contraception should be enforced?
Should people use contraceptives to protect their lifestyles?
If so, why not abortion?
 
Do you think abortions should be denied where they are used as birth control?

According to New Zealand law? Yes. Under NZ law abortions are only acceptable where there is a danger to the mother's life, her physical or mental health, or if there is a risk of the fetus being handicapped. It is therefore illegal to perform an abortion purely for birth control reasons.

That a pregnancy in that case should be enforced?

Personally I'd rather see there no longer be a demand for it from women just wanting to no longer be pregnant because they were not getting pregnant unless they wanted too. Contraceptives in NZ are readily available and effective, there really is no excuse for not taking the appropriate precautions, or abstaining if they are not available.

This is not the message we are giving out to our young people however. And if you don't believe it, look at the stats. In 2008 we had almost 18,000 abortions, 37% of which were to women who had previously had an abortion, and 23% of them to women under the age of 20 (30% to the 20-25 range.)

Now do you really believe that there were 18,000 cases where the mother's life was honestly in danger, of the child was likely to be handicapped? Do you really believe that over six and a half thousand women who knew that getting pregnant was dangerous to them life or health would have managed to fail to use every measure in their power to prevent pregnancy again?

If so I have 7,300 tons of French scrape metal for sale....

Why should contraceptives be used to protect a lifestyle, but not abortion?

Is the use of contraception the same as a termination of a life?
 
No, people should not be able to kill other people. Quite a silly question to ask.

Is it? What is the difference between killing a new-born and a fetus?

Indeed abortion is not about what would be good for the child, because there is no child. Abortion is about what a woman chooses as best for her.

And yert you are willing to oppose her right to chose what is best for her after the child is born.

Although abortion could be best for some foetuses which would become severely handicapped children.

So it'd be okay to terminate them after birth? After all they wouldn't know any different, not at a few hours old. Surely that is better than having to grow up handicapped.

So, do you think that pregnancies resulting from inefficient contraception should be enforced?

Do you think that Doctors should be breaking the law to do so when there is plenty of effective birth control available?

Should people use contraceptives to protect their lifestyles?
If so, why not abortion?

Is the use of a contraceptive the ending of a life?
 
I've heard some pro-life advocates say that they are against abortion except in cases of rape or incest. Why? Is that baby any less human? Wouldn't it still qualify as killing the unborn?

Just for the record, I'm pro-choice.
Because:
1. Many people who oppose pregnancy termination are far less sure of themselves when confronted with a scenario such as "what if your mother/wife/sister/daughter/girlfriend was raped" and make this exception to salve their consciences.
2. Support for banning terminations in such cases is usually far less than for 'social' reasons and those who wish to restrict termination services know this.

Note that the 'rape/incest' clause doesn't allow for termination where the mother's life is endangered or where the foetus simply isn't viable and, in my opinion, is far less logical than:
1. A complete blanket ban on terminations, enforced by imprisonment of the mother where necessary.
2. Termination allowed where the foetus isn't viable or continuing the pregnancy would endanger the life of the mother.
3. Termination on request.
At lest these scenarios have IMO some logical consistency to them.

Catsmate; pro-choice since '83, veteran of three referendum campaigns.:boggled:
 
Sperm donor, in the usual sense of the term, or unintentional sire?
.
Sire, with no intent to be a father. Just getting his rocks off.
There's three kids, with three different fathers.
Down the street there's a cluster of seven like that.
With drivers licenses tied to paying child support, such a brood mare can live nicely.
 
Hence my point as to what is meant by "unwilling" and quite obviously the title of the thread itself. There is a rather large difference between becoming pregnant though the actions of an abuser, be it rape or incest, and becoming pregnant because you knowingly took the risk with the idea that it wouldn't matter because you would use abortion as a form of bith control anyway.



And your point?
.
To many rapists, the age of the vagina is no interest... 6 months to 85 or older, that's OK with them.
Some of my lady friends won't press for a condom, and consequently, have abortions.
Others just go with the flow, and pop out another kid.
 
To the OP:

The Catholic Church actually doesn't make an exception for rape and incest.

Or the mother's tragically young age, the fetus' mental and/or physical defects, danger to the mother's health or life, etc.

(Opinions on the last one vary, though. There was a time when a mother was expected to sacrifice her life for her child's life, if there was a conflict between the two. However, other sources tell me that danger to the mother's life is the only exception that the RCC will grant. Heck, I was raised Catholic and I don't know. It seems to depend on who you ask- like much of the RCC's teachings.)

So even when a 9 year old girl gets molested by her father, gets pregnant with twins, could die in childbirth and the two fetuses would most likely die too, anyway, they are opposed to abortion.

Even in the case of an OBVIOUS- OBVIOUS BEYOND OBVIOUS- exception to the rule, they are against abortion.

As someone who is uh, you know, *********** SANE!, I'm appalled.

As a former philosophy student, I have to admire their philosophical consistency.

If a fetus is a person, yes, there would be no exceptions (except danger to the mother's life, arguably. Someone could very well argue that, in that case, the woman has the moral right to kill the fetus, the same way I'd have the right to kill another human being who was a direct threat to my life. In that case, it is self defense. One human being's life weighed against another human being's life. Equal right to life to both parties- but since one threatens the other, well, that one has to be eliminated to save the other.)

The Catholic Church is absolutely and totally correct.


ETA: For the record, I have mixed feelings about abortion.
.
When I first heard this as the official stance of the Church, at age 10 or so, I was *********** appalled! The fetus has little invested in it, the mother is a functioning person.
It is licit :) to prioritize the value of the respective lives.
 
You didn't use the word 'punishment' but that is the effect of what you propose.
As to being willing to accept the 'consequences', the consequences are either continue wirh the pregnancy or have an abortion. You want the consequences to be continue with the pregnancy: punishment by any other name.

And willing to put oneself in what position,exactly? Possibly becoming pregnant?
Would you say that those who unintentionally contract an STD should suffer the consequences? After all, they willing put themselves in that position. Surely they should then not have treatment.
.
Yes.
Consequences = punishment.
God punishes both the child by rewarding it with a reluctant parent to neglect it for the rest of its life, and the parent gets to hate and abuse the child for the same period.
What a loving god.
 
...
The consequences of getting pregnant are either to continue the pregnancy, or abort it. There are no other possibilities.
...
.
There's the third which comes from the first... Continue the pregnancy and one or both die.
 
So what you are saying is that it's perfectly acceptable to play russian roulette with getting pregnant because you can always abort it if it all goes wrong?
.
To many, yes, that is acceptable.
Not all reluctant pregnancies are due to that attitude, some are genuinely blunders, no malice aforethought.
But once knocked up the woman/fetus can be in a risky condition, which abortion fixes... if the natural 50% failure rate of all conceptions doesn't get there first.
 
Personally I'd rather see there no longer be a demand for it from women just wanting to no longer be pregnant because they were not getting pregnant unless they wanted too. Contraceptives in NZ are readily available and effective, there really is no excuse for not taking the appropriate precautions, or abstaining if they are not available.

This is not the message we are giving out to our young people however. And if you don't believe it, look at the stats. In 2008 we had almost 18,000 abortions, 37% of which were to women who had previously had an abortion, and 23% of them to women under the age of 20 (30% to the 20-25 range.)

Now do you really believe that there were 18,000 cases where the mother's life was honestly in danger, of the child was likely to be handicapped? Do you really believe that over six and a half thousand women who knew that getting pregnant was dangerous to them life or health would have managed to fail to use every measure in their power to prevent pregnancy again?

If so I have 7,300 tons of French scrape metal for sale....



Is the use of contraception the same as a termination of a life?

Actually, contraception isn't as easy as all that. The pill becomes less safe as a woman gets older, dangerous if she is over 30 and smokes. Condoms alone are one of the least effective forms of birth control (although much, much better that nothing.) The methods in between have their own problems.

Woman can remain fertile into their late 40's/early 50's. The older a woman a gets, the more problematic pregnancy can become. It is not uncommon for a woman to become pregnant after the age of 30 but it carries additional risks to the fetus and mother. There are many fertile years when the most effective birth control is not available.

For example, a married woman who is 35 might not be able to take the pill, other forms of birth control are less effective and abstinence is not an option. She is at risk for unwanted pregnancy. Considering that 70% of the women in your statistics are over 25, there is a good chance that many of them fall into some variation of this.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom