"Except for cases of rape or incest". Why?

However, it doesn't seem like pro-lifers of any stripe are amenable to that kind of reasoning. Perhaps, their concession regarding "rape and incest" is a political one, calculated to try to win support from people on the fence.

This is just a very offensive and sheltered position, and unreasonably accusative and presumtive. You make it seem like there is one type of pro lifer, someone who believes all abortions of all kinds are horrible and murder and any pro lifer who says otherwise is lying for political reasons.

I wasn't lying for political reasons when I held that position, I truly believed it.

The type of pro lifer YOU are referring to, the rabid all-abortions-in-any-circumstances-are-murder actually represent only a tiny percentage or pro lifers I knew and know (and growing up in an overwhlemingly Catholic community). Extremists are the most vocal. Moderates aren't. Even though the Catholic church's OFFICIAL position is "its murder, no exception" that doesn't mean all Catholics believe that. The Catholic Church also says birth control is evil and I don't personally know a single Catholic under the age of 50 who believes that.

Pro lifers, like almost any other group, are not some homogenous group that are all best identified as foaming at the mouth with pictures of aborted fetuses outside a clinic yelling "baby killer."

When it comes to people I knew/know who are pro life (keeping in mind that I do come from a quite liberal, though Catholic community), the overwhleming majority are moderates who were more focused on, "How can we improve conditions in this country that make women less needy of abortion?" Promoting things like universal healthcare for children and adoption and birth control that will help prevent the need from abortions, not screaming at women going into clinics. Only a tiny, tiny minority of pro lifers I know (again, not saying this is true everywhere) would be against legal abortions in cases of rape or the mother being in danger.

Moderates on this issue don't march with signs, and they don't make offensive comments that make the news and get picked up on blogs. Just because the media most exposes you to the most extreme pro lifers does not mean they are representatives of all pro lifers.

I think this is one of the biggest problems when it comes to pretty much any ideology. Extremists get the press, and then people think they are representative of the group as a whole when in fact they just have the most headline grabbing antics.

Ever consider actually TALKING to people who think differently than you before you decide that you, in your infinite wisdom, must KNOW what they think? I've always found that having friends and interacting with people from different ideological standpoints makes me much less narrow minded in how I interperet the motivations of those who disagree with me. When you shelter yourself so that you only associate with like minded individuals, it's easy to start thinking the worst of people who aren't like you.

Edit: Though I am certainly not denying that there are some people who simply see this as a necessary political concession and don't actually believe this themselves. But your claim that ANY pro lifer of ANY stripe who holds such a position must think like this is just, to be frank, silly. It's silly to think that when it comes to ANY political or ideological position, that everyone who holds that position must have an identical opinion. Are you really so unexposed to the breadth of human opinion and experience that you think we are so easily pigeon holed? This is also very black and white thinking. All pro lifers must only think that all abortions in all context are evil? Really? There's such a thing as nuance, you know. It's not like all pro choicers are perfectly fine with aborting a perfectly healthy 8 month old fetus.

Just because a person holds an opinion...regarding abortion, the death penalty, health care, etc, it does not mean that position is absolute and does not have any caveats.
 
Last edited:
But nobody is forced to raise a child in this country, and wouldn't be even if abortion were outlawed. Every abortion opponent I've ever heard of has also been a proponent of adoption as an alternative. Now, you could try to reformulate that argument with the idea that carrying the fetus to term is harmful to the mother, but raising it? Nope, that's not at issue here.

Sayyyyy !

Now why the hell didn't anyone think of this before ?!

You're right. Every pregnant female should be forced to carry the zygote to full term, give birth (afterall giving birth is easy as pie and carries no risks whatsoever), and then just simply give it up for adoption !

Cause that's what we need... hundreds of thousands (or better yet, millions) of unwanted children rotting in an orphanage waiting, hoping, desparately needing to be loved by someone/anyone.

And if nobody adopts them, then they can just simply bounce around in the fostercare system ! Because the fostercare system is flawless and everyone who takes in foster kids loves them dearly and takes impeccable care of them.

All that will take is for taxes to get jacked way up to pay for it all !

Maybe we should also pass some regulation laws so that anyone who screams "pro life !!!!" should add themselves to the adoption list and adopt as many bundles of joy that they can financially handle... or they should at least become a foster parent, for crying out loud.

Man, why didn't anyone think of this sooner...
 
Last edited:
You're being hyperbolic. Even involuntary manslaughter still requires culpability: you had to make choices which led to the death, even if the death wasn't intended. But many miscarriages aren't caused by anything the mother chooses to do. Now, thinking of abortion as murder can lead to treating some miscarriages as crimes (such as those caused by drug or alcohol abuse), but miscarriages in general? Nope, not even under an extreme literal "abortion = murder" framework.

But what if she was wearing shoes that didn't have a very good grip on the soles and she slipped and fell down the stairs ?

She knew the potential danger of wearing slippery shoes. And to top it all off, she knew the potential danger of going down a flight of stairs.

In fact, women who are 8 months pregnant have a tendency to lose their balance quite easily. How dare they risk life and limb by even walking for crying out loud.

Murderess !!
 
Sayyyyy !

Now why the hell didn't anyone think of this before ?!

You're right. Every pregnant female should be forced to carry the zygote to full term, give birth, and then just simply give it up for adoption !

Way to show that you're interested in more than hyperbole. :rolleyes:
 
But what if she was wearing shoes that didn't have a very good grip on the soles and she slipped and fell down the stairs ?

What about that? If she happened to knock over an old granny on the stairs who fell and broke her neck, would she get charged with manslaughter? No, of course not.

In other words, you're being stupid.
 
Way to show that you're interested in more than hyperbole. :rolleyes:

Ignore the troll and engage in what's otherwise a pretty good discussion so far.
Which is surprising, as "Why do people with whom I strongly disagree believe Idea X?" is usually an invitation for ignorant speculation and unnecessary insults by people who agree with the OP.
 
My way of looking at it is that the older (and hence more developed) the foetus is the more "rights" it should have and that these should be balanced against the rights of the mother. This will always result in having to look at the individual circumstances and never be a black and white/ right and wrong line. Therefore in most cases it should be left to the conscience of the woman concerned. As the foetus gets nearer to term however, I do think we can legislate for the few circumstances where abortion would be the appropriate decision.

My view is that we as humans are not very good at differentiating between what’s right and what we personally want. When one persons rights are balanced against another it’s always best to have an independent arbiter working to a defined (but not absolute) standard.
 
Apparently, yes !

Uh, no. There's no "apparently" about it: she wouldn't. Your premise about what constitutes manslaughter is absurdly wrong, so your conclusion that treating a fetus legally like an adult (abortion = murder) would lead to criminal charges for miscarriages simply does not follow.
 
Giving birth is something that has long term effects on your body no mater what. It seems to me that this is similar to someone doing something stupid and getting their leg broken. Do we demand that they put up with the pain and take nine months to heal, and then have some permanent health problems for the rest of their life? Or do we set the leg and let them get on with their life?

Yes, I know that part of the argument is about when it counts as a human life with human rights but as far as I am concerned until it can survive outside the womb it is a part of the mother's body which she can do whatever she wants with. If they develop artificial wombs tomorrow that can take a fetus at earlier stages of development, that would be a different story entirely. But they haven't yet, and we'll deal with that one when it comes along.

For now, I just don't feel that a young woman should have her life, and possibly health, destroyed by a spur of the moment mistake. It's just not a proportional punishment. Do young men have their lives destroyed for the same mistake? Usually not.
 
This whole abortion thing is a non-issue as far as I'm concerned.

Other people's personal lives are none of my friggin' business. I don't walk in their shoes, therefore I have no right to form an opinion about it, nor do I have the right to tell them what they can and can't do in their personal life.




Ditto!
 
Giving birth is something that has long term effects on your body no mater what. It seems to me that this is similar to someone doing something stupid and getting their leg broken. Do we demand that they put up with the pain and take nine months to heal, and then have some permanent health problems for the rest of their life? Or do we set the leg and let them get on with their life?

Yes, I know that part of the argument is about when it counts as a human life with human rights but as far as I am concerned until it can survive outside the womb it is a part of the mother's body which she can do whatever she wants with. If they develop artificial wombs tomorrow that can take a fetus at earlier stages of development, that would be a different story entirely. But they haven't yet, and we'll deal with that one when it comes along.



It doesn’t seem to me like this is something that should depend out our technical capabilities of the day. For example, if we take your idea to it’s full extent then if we develop the capability to take a fertilized egg and raise it entirely outside a women’s body even a “day after pill” becomes murder when clearly a small bundle of cells isn’t a person no matter what our technical capability.

For now, I just don't feel that a young woman should have her life, and possibly health, destroyed by a spur of the moment mistake. It's just not a proportional punishment.


Perhaps some people argue based on “punishment” but more often it’s a sense that if someone is going to suffer consequence for an action it’s better for it to be the person who committed the action.

Do young men have their lives destroyed for the same mistake?

It may take a different form but it’s not at all uncommon for young men to make the very same mistake and suffer consequences for the rest of their lives. A different form of consequence, perhaps, but consequences nonetheless.
 
Uh, no. There's no "apparently" about it: she wouldn't. Your premise about what constitutes manslaughter is absurdly wrong, so your conclusion that treating a fetus legally like an adult (abortion = murder) would lead to criminal charges for miscarriages simply does not follow.

Yours and Avalon's premise that consensual sex resulting in pregnancy should be obligated to full term and giving birth because "nobody is forcing anyone to raise the child afterward" is absurdly wrong.

Do you not see the slippery slope ?

If you can play slippery slope, why can't I ?

One logical fallacy deserves another.
 
Perhaps some people argue based on “punishment” but more often it’s a sense that if someone is going to suffer consequence for an action it’s better for it to be the person who committed the action.

Unfortunately though, the actual person who suffers the consequences at the end of it all is the unwanted child that ends up in a very flawed child care system.
 
Yes, I know that part of the argument is about when it counts as a human life with human rights but as far as I am concerned until it can survive outside the womb it is a part of the mother's body which she can do whatever she wants with.

That's not part of the argument, that's the heart of the argument.

Do young men have their lives destroyed for the same mistake?

Often enough. This goes uncontested because the personhood of the child is not in dispute after it's born. If someone were to try to argue that a minor isn't really a person, and so fathers shouldn't be forced to pay child support because they shouldn't be punished, would you accept that argument? Would you try to argue that they should be forced to pay child support because DO deserve to be punished, or would you instead recognize that the fundamental disagreement is something different?
 
Unfortunately though, the actual person who suffers the consequences at the end of it all is the unwanted child that ends up in a very flawed child care system.

The number of people who wish to adopt newborn babies is vastly greater then the number of babies available for adoption.

Even if that were not the case, the quality of the child care system is a something that could be reversed, an abortion is not. And even if that never happened, I suspect most of the people who “suffer” though it would still find that preferable to not existing at all.
 
Perhaps some people argue based on “punishment” but more often it’s a sense that if someone is going to suffer consequence for an action it’s better for it to be the person who committed the action.

But it takes two to tango, right?

It may take a different form but it’s not at all uncommon for young men to make the very same mistake and suffer consequences for the rest of their lives. A different form of consequence, perhaps, but consequences nonetheless.

Oh good, so "sometimes the father will have to marry the girl" is good enough. Or were you just talking about child support, like a CD of the month club with no cancellation clause?
 
Yours and Avalon's premise that consensual sex resulting in pregnancy should be obligated to full term and giving birth because "nobody is forcing anyone to raise the child afterward" is absurdly wrong.

Wow, way to miss the point, Xephyr. That wasn't what I said at all. Rather, YOU claimed that abortion opponents wanted to force women to raise unwanted children. And that's plainly not true. Within that same post, I told you how to reformulate your argument so that it would NOT contain this false claim, but would still convey the essential logic behind your original argument. Rather than doing so, you have simply constructed straw men.

Do you not see the slippery slope ?

Not through all that straw.

If you can play slippery slope, why can't I ?

I'm not playing that game.

One logical fallacy deserves another.

And you're holding them all.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom