This is just a very offensive and sheltered position, and unreasonably accusative and presumtive. You make it seem like there is one type of pro lifer, someone who believes all abortions of all kinds are horrible and murder and any pro lifer who says otherwise is lying for political reasons.
Sorry to have offended you. I don't think I made myself understood very well. The point I was trying to make is that those who oppose abortion do not seem to me to be likely to be
reasoned into changing their views. And I would say this of many, many beliefs, both politically divisive and not. Careful, factual debate doesn't seem to change many minds on issues of morality.
You are right, however, that my opinions are colored by the types of abortion opponents I have run into. Where I live, a liberal state of mind is the default and the only pro-lifers you hear from at all are the ones who are really, really strident. In fact, my largest exposure to the pro-life mindset comes from documentaries, news stories and tv.
I have had occasion to debate the issue with some fairly smart pro-lifers whose reasoning abilities I otherwise respected. They never seemed the slightest bit swayed by any argument - rational, practical, moral or otherwise.
I certainly never meant to imply that all people who are against abortion are the same or that none of them can ever be reasoned with. Heck, as a moral issue,
I'm against abortion. I think it's a lousy solution to a whole lousy set of problems. It's a better solution than forcing poor women to do what rich, white voters want. And it's a better solution than flooding the country with millions of children without resources to care for them. But it still sucks no matter how you look at it.