"Except for cases of rape or incest". Why?

But it takes two to tango, right?


Yes but does that makes it fair to shovel the consequences off onto someone else altogether?

Oh good, so "sometimes the father will have to marry the girl" is good enough. Or were you just talking about child support,


Either can significantly affect the life someone can expect to live, are you disputing this?
 
Nah, I don't see any reason to have the father involved at all. That just makes things all messy and you get into the question of whether the woman needs to get his permission to get an abortion and all of that.
If abortions are legal and available then there is no need for the guy to be involved unless he wants to be. I mean, if he really wants the kid then they can discuss between themselves the medical bills and his taking custody of the kid afterward.
My main problem is simply with the physical and mental stress of going through a full pregnancy. It's not fun by any stretch of the imagination, it leaves permanent marks on your body and you can have long term health side effects. I don't think any woman should be forced to go through that if she doesn't want to.
 
Therefore in most cases it should be left to the conscience of the woman concerned.

As is currently the case (UK) and doesn't need changing.

As the foetus gets nearer to term however, I do think we can legislate for the few circumstances where abortion would be the appropriate decision.

As is currently the case (UK) and doesn't need changing.
 
No. I'm saying that requiring you to donate blood to someone whose blood loss was your fault, is reasonable.

Actually, that's still completely unreasonable. If by my negligence, someone loses a great deal of blood, I may feel personally compelled to donate some of my own, but I can not think of any enforceable law that would legally compel me to do so.
 
Even if that were not the case, the quality of the child care system is a something that could be reversed, an abortion is not. And even if that never happened, I suspect most of the people who “suffer” though it would still find that preferable to not existing at all.

This works both ways: If abortion had been illegal in the US in 1979, neither my brother nor I would exist. I find my existence preferable to my non-existence.
 
As is currently the case (UK) and doesn't need changing.



As is currently the case (UK) and doesn't need changing.

Not quite - its true in Britain, but not in Northern Ireland. But yes I think the current laws are about right - although I think we should drop the charade of making 2 doctors agree that a woman’s health or life is gravely threatened by continuing with the pregnancy or that the fetus is likely to be born with severe physical or mental abnormalities - especially for first trimester abortions. What we really have is abortion on demand (up to certain time limits), and I think the law should be changed to be honest about that.
 
Last edited:
Not quite - its true in Britain, but not in Northern Ireland. But yes I think the current laws are about right - although I think we should drop the charade of making 2 doctors agree that a woman’s health or life is gravely threatened by continuing with the pregnancy or that the fetus is likely to be born with severe physical or mental abnormalities - especially for first trimester abortions. What we really have is abortion on demand (up to certain time limits), and I think the law should be changed to be honest about that.

Why? Do you or I hold dominion over a 14yr old girls body if she has one too many 'J20s' in the park and then gets 'oohmpa'd' in the band-stand. I don't feel that I do have the right to map out the next 20yrs of her life. Do you?


Anyways we should just ban it and buy in a load of coat hangers, 'cause that's what the 'Pro-Lifers (along as it's not the mothers life)' want, Yeah?
 
The existence/non-existence argument is nonsensical. A non-existent person cannot have an opinion of the relative merits of existence and non-existence, and an existent person can have no opinion on the merits of non-existence.
Also nonsensical is the argument of exemption for rape or incest.
A rape victim who wants an abortion does so because she does not want to be pregnant, and for no other reason.
An incest victim who wants an abortion also does so because she does not want to be pregnant.
A woman who fails to use effective contraception ( and this actually covers absolutely all pregnant women), for whatever reason, and seeks an abortion, also does so because she does not wish to be pregnant.
And that is the only reason anyone ever chooses abortion.

It is also a good enough reason to be able to have an abortion.
 
Why? Do you or I hold dominion over a 14yr old girls body if she has one too many 'J20s' in the park and then gets 'oohmpa'd' in the band-stand. I don't feel that I do have the right to map out the next 20yrs of her life. Do you?


Anyways we should just ban it and buy in a load of coat hangers, 'cause that's what the 'Pro-Lifers (along as it's not the mothers life)' want, Yeah?

What??? I think you must have misunderstood me. All I was saying is that the wording of the law as it currently stands is not a reflection of what actually happens and that we should change it to make them congruent. The law should actually say that you have a right to an abortion for whatever reason and get rid of the stupid 2 doctors must agree.... nonsense.
 
Not to repeat myself. but I have believed absolutely from the first time I heard of it (close to the time I had any real concept of the initial process - before I was in my teen's
for sure) in the right of anyone who wanted one to have an abortion. Nothing has changed that belief in the slightest. That's why the name "Miss Sherri" (Finkbine) is still quite familiar to me - though that was 5 or 6 years later.
 
Not to repeat myself. but I have believed absolutely from the first time I heard of it (close to the time I had any real concept of the initial process - before I was in my teen's
for sure) in the right of anyone who wanted one to have an abortion.

Including during, say, the 39th week?
 
But nobody is forced to raise a child in this country, and wouldn't be even if abortion were outlawed. Every abortion opponent I've ever heard of has also been a proponent of adoption as an alternative. Now, you could try to reformulate that argument with the idea that carrying the fetus to term is harmful to the mother, but raising it? Nope, that's not at issue here.


Right. Because knowing the rest of your life that your baby is out there somewhere is an option. Because there are 1.5 million families just hoping to raise some malnourished, seventeen year-old's child. Because the fact that both parents have to consent to an adoption doesn't make things even slightly more difficult. Nope, no issue here. [/extraordinarily obvious sarcasm]
 
Yes but does that makes it fair to shovel the consequences off onto someone else altogether?
Well, I do think that the 'sperm donor' in the situation should have some consequences for his actions, don't you?

Either can significantly affect the life someone can expect to live, are you disputing this?
As well they should, since creating a life should have some kind of effect on both of the people who took part in the procreative act, not just the one who has no choice but to be there for the birth of the result of that act.
 
But it takes two to tango, right?

Oh good, so "sometimes the father will have to marry the girl" is good enough. Or were you just talking about child support, like a CD of the month club with no cancellation clause?

However, under current US Law, even if the father is willing and able to raise the child himself without the mother's involvement, he doesn't get to have that choice if the mother won't allow it.
 
This is just a very offensive and sheltered position, and unreasonably accusative and presumtive. You make it seem like there is one type of pro lifer, someone who believes all abortions of all kinds are horrible and murder and any pro lifer who says otherwise is lying for political reasons.


Sorry to have offended you. I don't think I made myself understood very well. The point I was trying to make is that those who oppose abortion do not seem to me to be likely to be reasoned into changing their views. And I would say this of many, many beliefs, both politically divisive and not. Careful, factual debate doesn't seem to change many minds on issues of morality.

You are right, however, that my opinions are colored by the types of abortion opponents I have run into. Where I live, a liberal state of mind is the default and the only pro-lifers you hear from at all are the ones who are really, really strident. In fact, my largest exposure to the pro-life mindset comes from documentaries, news stories and tv.

I have had occasion to debate the issue with some fairly smart pro-lifers whose reasoning abilities I otherwise respected. They never seemed the slightest bit swayed by any argument - rational, practical, moral or otherwise.

I certainly never meant to imply that all people who are against abortion are the same or that none of them can ever be reasoned with. Heck, as a moral issue, I'm against abortion. I think it's a lousy solution to a whole lousy set of problems. It's a better solution than forcing poor women to do what rich, white voters want. And it's a better solution than flooding the country with millions of children without resources to care for them. But it still sucks no matter how you look at it.
 
The existence/non-existence argument is nonsensical. A non-existent person cannot have an opinion of the relative merits of existence and non-existence, and an existent person can have no opinion on the merits of non-existence.
Also nonsensical is the argument of exemption for rape or incest.
A rape victim who wants an abortion does so because she does not want to be pregnant, and for no other reason.
An incest victim who wants an abortion also does so because she does not want to be pregnant.
A woman who fails to use effective contraception ( and this actually covers absolutely all pregnant women), for whatever reason, and seeks an abortion, also does so because she does not wish to be pregnant.
And that is the only reason anyone ever chooses abortion.

It is also a good enough reason to be able to have an abortion.

And so I'm guessing that if a women has a child without realising she's pregnant (yes it does happen) and then decides that she doesn't want to have to have anything to do with it, it's perfectly exceptable to pop it in a plastic bag and toss it in the garbage?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom