"Except for cases of rape or incest". Why?

But it was exactly that kind of reasoning I was amenable to once I was old enough to give the different scenarios the weighting they deserve and think about the issue in more depth.


I think the weight of the evidence would show that you are an uncommonly reasonable person.
 
As I mentioned above, the RCC position is that there are no exceptions.

Hence the child who was raped by her uncle being excommunicated for having an abortion, but the uncle still being a full member of the church.

I believe this was in South America in the last six months, should I get a cite?
 
Oh, I agree. But why bring catholic into it? This is not a catholic position, it is a subset of pro-lifers position.

Yes and no. It is not the church's position, but it is popular among the Catholics in the US. Many of whom use contraceptives and eat meat on Fridays, even during Lent!
 
I liked Matt's take on it on the AE.

Ask a pro lifer what they think the penalty for an ilegal abortion should be.

Since abortion cannot be done without intent, the penalty would have to classify as first degree murder.

Now find me someone who thinks a woman should get 25 to life (or whatever the equivelant in that particular area be) for an abortion.
 
I just don't know how to decide on this topic anymore. I can only state that I am glad that I'm not a woman.
 
I do not think one should use abortion as a way to fix a mistake. That mistake being having sex without protection! (I do not want to get involved with that 1% or so of 'beating the pill'.)

The baby isn't the mistake, ereasing it from existence doesn't fix the root cause, having sex without protection. (Again..not gonna get into beating the pill.)

No, I'm sure you don't want to get into the subject of birth control failure, as it would undermine your argument. It's quite a useful technique, declaring inconvenient facts off limits!


Because having sex is a mistake that deserves to be punished with 18 years of child-rearing! Sure, that may be a little inconvenient to the child being raised by a parent or parents who didn't want a child, but that's a small price to pay if it helps deter people from experiencing pleasure with each other's bodies!
 
Well from the POV of the traditional pro life mob you've just written the equivelent of:

"This whole murder thing is a non-issue as far as I'm concerned.

Other people's personal lives are none of my friggin' business. I don't walk in their shoes, therefore I have no right to form an opinion about it, nor do I have the right to tell them what they can and can't do in their personal life."

So the reason you view it is as a non issue is that prior to birth you feel that babies don't count as people.


Is abortion of a fertilized egg zygote embryo parasite baby "murder" ?

Based on that mentality then, every miscarriage of a zygote baby should be considered involuntary manslaughter and punishment should be dispensed to the murderess accordingly.

In fact, every woman who has an IUD inserted into her uterus should be charged and punished (because she knowingly and premeditatingly had the IUD put in) for attempted murder and/or 1st degree murder of the fertilized egg baby each and every month of her mentrual cycle if she has had sexual intercourse where sperm has been deposited inside her vagina.


Hmmm...

I guess it's not about someone's personal life choice afterall. It is our business and we should all make it our business and give a damn and do something about it to stop all of this baby slaughtering going on right under our noses !

Wow, was I ever wrong about this not being an issue...

Oh the humanity !
Stop the insanity !



Disclaimer :
Except, of course, if the woman is raped... then the fertilized egg embryo zygote baby is not counted as a person and abortion murder is perfectly okay.
 
My understanding is that it's a question of consent. It goes something like the following.
If I'm drugged at night and hooked up to a concert violinist (you know the analogy), then I have the right to demand to be disconnected even if it kills the violinist.
But if I volunteered to be hooked up to the guy -- if the guy is only in this situation because of my own actions -- then I don't have the right to disconnect and kill him. Since I'm responsible for his position, I don't have the right to abrogate responsibility and let him die.
This viewpoint says that a person can be reasonably expected to care for the children that his actions are responsible for creating. It's the same argument that we use for mandatory child support payments, extended to the notion that the baby is already in need of something (use of the woman's womb) even before birth. And the woman, responsible for the kid being here, has an obligation to allow it.
But a raped woman is not responsible for the baby, and therefore has a right to deny it her womb.
 
This whole abortion thing is a non-issue as far as I'm concerned.

Other people's personal lives are none of my friggin' business. I don't walk in their shoes, therefore I have no right to form an opinion about it, nor do I have the right to tell them what they can and can't do in their personal life.

Since the argument is usually primarily about whether or not the fetus/embryo has rights independent of the mother's, the "personal lives" argument seems to be a red herring.
To illustrate what I mean: Where do you stand on child abuse laws? If I want to strip off my six-year-old's skin with a cat-o-nine tails for burning the meatloaf, is that my part of my "personal life" as well?
 
We’ve already seen several people post in this thread that they think “abortion is a women’s choice, period” but not a single person has tried to argue the opposite extreme, that “any fertilized egg is a human and should all the same legal protection”.

This is pretty much in keeping with my experience which is that “pro-life” people tend to be much more apt to see that the morality on this issue is nuanced and shaded. Exceptions for rape/incest would fall under this not on the grounds that abortion is ok under those circumstances but that it’s the less objectionable choice.
 
I do not think one should use abortion as a way to fix a mistake. That mistake being having sex without protection! (
Thanks for admitting you basically want to punish women for having sex.

But, since you're clearly unaware, the 21st century has arrived. It waves and says hi.
 
Thanks for admitting you basically want to punish women for having sex.

But, since you're clearly unaware, the 21st century has arrived. It waves and says hi.


Heh, I've often heard it said that if men could get pregnant, not only would abortion be legal... it would be perfectly moral and an abortion clinic would be on every street corner.

:dl:
 
We’ve already seen several people post in this thread that they think “abortion is a women’s choice, period” but not a single person has tried to argue the opposite extreme, that “any fertilized egg is a human and should all the same legal protection”.

This is pretty much in keeping with my experience which is that “pro-life” people tend to be much more apt to see that the morality on this issue is nuanced and shaded. Exceptions for rape/incest would fall under this not on the grounds that abortion is ok under those circumstances but that it’s the less objectionable choice.

And maybe some people who haven't spelt out their position in full? As I said, I used to be pro life, but now my views are probably much closer to the pro choice position. However my views are much more nuanced than “abortion is a women’s choice, period”. My way of looking at it is that the older (and hence more developed) the foetus is the more "rights" it should have and that these should be balanced against the rights of the mother. This will always result in having to look at the individual circumstances and never be a black and white/ right and wrong line. Therefore in most cases it should be left to the conscience of the woman concerned. As the foetus gets nearer to term however, I do think we can legislate for the few circumstances where abortion would be the appropriate decision.
 
Last edited:
My understanding is that it's a question of consent. It goes something like the following.
If I'm drugged at night and hooked up to a concert violinist (you know the analogy), then I have the right to demand to be disconnected even if it kills the violinist.
But if I volunteered to be hooked up to the guy -- if the guy is only in this situation because of my own actions -- then I don't have the right to disconnect and kill him. Since I'm responsible for his position, I don't have the right to abrogate responsibility and let him die.
This viewpoint says that a person can be reasonably expected to care for the children that his actions are responsible for creating. It's the same argument that we use for mandatory child support payments, extended to the notion that the baby is already in need of something (use of the woman's womb) even before birth. And the woman, responsible for the kid being here, has an obligation to allow it.
But a raped woman is not responsible for the baby, and therefore has a right to deny it her womb.

That was one of the classic argument I have heard before. It provides some solace, but the analogy is just not apt, for two main reasons, in my mind at least:

1) Traditional society punishes the woman for getting pregnant out of wedlock, but no the man. So, she gets to look forward to months of stares and ridicule while the father does not. Maybe this is changing a bit with Bristol Palin being a darling of the right, but I think it will be a long time before we get past this.

2) The punishment does not fit the crime. To apply this to your example, what if the punishment for underage drinking was that the underage drinker had to donate a kidney to the concert violinist. Everyone knows this and yet the chances of getting caught are one in a million so teenagers continue to drink. We teach them to abstain, but no, they all think they can avoid the cops and won't have to donate a liver. But, everyone knows of someone who's been caught.

Now, the fact is that we have to combine those to have a really good analogy. So, imagine a system where boys that are caught drinking underage are taken home while girls who are caught drinking underage have to donate a kidney to the concert violinist. Throw in a society that really encourages underage drinking and ties social status to drinking and you are getting a bit closer. Have retailers that cater to kids show both boys and girls drinking in their ads, well, at least being around drinks, and putting the cup up to their mouths, but not actually taking a sip on camera, you get the point. That's where the real fun begins.
 
And maybe some people who haven't spelt out their position in full? As I said, I used to be pro life, but now my views are probably much closer to the pro choice position. However my views are much more nuanced than “abortion is a women’s choice, period”. My way of looking at it is that the older (and hence more developed) the foetus is the more "rights" it should have and that these should be balanced against the rights of the mother. This will always result in having to look at the individual circumstances and never be a black and white/ right and wrong line. Therefore in most cases it should be left to the conscience of the woman concerned. As the foetus gets nearer to term however, I do think we can legislate for the few circumstances where abortion would be the appropriate decision.

No, you can't be nuanced unless you are pro-life. Can't you read?

I'm pretty close to where you are, but maybe with a more practical slant: as awful as any single abortion is, a system that makes abortion illegal is worse.
 
It seems obvious to me that anyone who is willing to make an exception for "rape and incest," is already conceeding that abortion has a pragmatic aspect, and is not merely a moral decision. Thus, there should be room to argue that forcing a poor, single teenager to raise a child might be as harmful to those involved as forcing a woman to raise the child of her rapist.

But nobody is forced to raise a child in this country, and wouldn't be even if abortion were outlawed. Every abortion opponent I've ever heard of has also been a proponent of adoption as an alternative. Now, you could try to reformulate that argument with the idea that carrying the fetus to term is harmful to the mother, but raising it? Nope, that's not at issue here.
 
But if I volunteered to be hooked up to the guy -- if the guy is only in this situation because of my own actions -- then I don't have the right to disconnect and kill him. Since I'm responsible for his position, I don't have the right to abrogate responsibility and let him die.

Are you really trying to argue that if I agree to donate blood to someone, I am responsible to them for the rest of my life? And if I later refuse to donate blood and they die, that death is a first-degree murder that I should be jailed for?

That's a really tenuous position to take. It seems to me that this position negates any sort of severence clause from a contract - once you agree to something, you can never, ever change your mind.
 
Is abortion of a fertilized egg zygote embryo parasite baby "murder" ?

Based on that mentality then, every miscarriage of a zygote baby should be considered involuntary manslaughter and punishment should be dispensed to the murderess accordingly.

You're being hyperbolic. Even involuntary manslaughter still requires culpability: you had to make choices which led to the death, even if the death wasn't intended. But many miscarriages aren't caused by anything the mother chooses to do. Now, thinking of abortion as murder can lead to treating some miscarriages as crimes (such as those caused by drug or alcohol abuse), but miscarriages in general? Nope, not even under an extreme literal "abortion = murder" framework.
 
Are you really trying to argue that if I agree to donate blood to someone, I am responsible to them for the rest of my life?

No. I'm saying that requiring you to donate blood to someone whose blood loss was your fault, is reasonable.
I'm looking forward to uterine replicators making these issues moot.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom