"Except for cases of rape or incest". Why?

Wait, what? Doesn't FMLA pretty much guarantee maternity leave?
I am not educated on this issue.

They have to give you time, but not necessarily paid time. I worked full time for a bank for one year, then part time for another year while I attended college. I did not get maternity leave, I got short term disability with no pay (because of my part-time status).

Oh, and I've had 3 abortions. If anyone is interested in how fast, safe, and painless a procedure it was PM me.

I also have a baby with my husband. I had a planned cesarean. If anyone is interested in how painful, emotionally draining, and exhausting it was PM me.
 
Last edited:
I'm not sure there is a solution. Rape is a complete mess in our justice system. And you're right; this would create a situation similar to when rape was an affirmative defense against criminal promiscuity.

How, then, can you propose illegalization of abortions if, as you admit, there is no way to ensure that the victim of a rape will not be forced to carry the child of their rapist?
 
Oh, and I've had 3 abortions. If anyone is interested in how fast, safe, and painless a procedure it was PM me.

I also have a baby with my husband. I had a planned cesarean. If anyone is interested in how painful, emotionally draining, and exhausting it was PM me.

No kidding. I had an abortion when I was 17. I still say it saved my life. I now have three children with my husband. I can't imagine now how I could have gone through the process of a pregnancy and delivery at 17. It was hard enough as an adult with a loving and suportive partner.
 
No kidding. I had an abortion when I was 17. I still say it saved my life. I now have three children with my husband. I can't imagine now how I could have gone through the process of a pregnancy and delivery at 17. It was hard enough as an adult with a loving and suportive partner.

Since when to anti-abortionists give a crap about what the pregnant person thinks or experiences?
 
We are all pro-choice...the choice being to have an abortion or not. The "problem" arises when those against abortion try to impose their choice on everyone.
 
I didn't answer it because I had explained it at least a dozen times already -- there must be reasonable grounds for imposing an obligation, even if the obligation is an important one.
If I am responsible for a child and the child jumps in the water, I may have a duty to rescue the child. A stranger walking by at the same time may have no duty to rescue the child.
The purpose of the obligation is because saving children is important; children in danger should be rescued. However, the fact that the purpose of the obligation is important doesn't mean we will extend that obligation to everyone in all circumstances.
Just as a stranger may not have the same obligation to save a drowning child that the child's guardian has, so a pregnant woman who was raped may not have the same obligation to preserve the life of the fetus that a pregnant woman who willingly consented to sex has. And just as not imposing the duty to rescue on the stranger doesn't vitiate the reasoning behind imposing the duty on the guardian, so not imposing the duty to preserve the fetus on the raped woman doesn't vitiate the reasoning behind imposing the duty on other pregnant women.

Frankly that still does not say explain anything.

When all is counted you make the moral obligation (read : force) to keep the child on the willingness of the sex. You do not explain why in the case of the willing sex there is a moral obligation toward the fetus , but not in case of rape.

Fact is, in both case the fetus should have a right to live, or in both case the woman should have a right to decide. From the point of view of the fetus, that the sex is willing or not, make no difference. Therefore if you choose the right to choose to the woman in case of unwilling sex, from the point of view of the fetus, there is NO reason to refrain from the same right when willing sex is happenning.

No, the only reason you make a difference, is not out of concern from the fetus , but as a moral burden toward the willingness/unwillingness of the sex. If it was the fetus only you would not care.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom