"Except for cases of rape or incest". Why?

1) Depends on the meaning of unwilling. In my personal opinion, if you are unwilling to be pregnant, then don't take actions that will lead to that consequence. If you do the deed willingly, then that would indicate to me, that there is a responsibility to deal with any consequences.

2) I think that a woman that has a child should be responsible for taking care of it, whether that means raising it herself, helping her parents raise it, giving it over to the Father to raise, or making sure that it goes to a caring family to raise. She helped bring it into the world, thus she has the responsibility to make sure it is safe and protected.

You apparently disagree.
1. Unwilling means unwilling. If you think a woman who gets pregnant unwillingly should be punished by being forced to stay pregnant, then I most emphatically do disagree. If she chooses to deal with the consequences by having an abortion, she is entitled to take that course.

2. Where did I say anything that makes you think I disagree? If she helped bring it into this world willingly, I very much doubt that she would take any other course. But that is totally irrelevant to whether or not a woman should be able to choose abortion.
 
Having a vagina is the "action" that leads to rape in a large number of cases.

Hence my point as to what is meant by "unwilling" and quite obviously the title of the thread itself. There is a rather large difference between becoming pregnant though the actions of an abuser, be it rape or incest, and becoming pregnant because you knowingly took the risk with the idea that it wouldn't matter because you would use abortion as a form of bith control anyway.

Any number of sperm donors are as far from being capable of fathering a child as the salmon that spread their eggs and sperm willy-nilly and then leave the scene (die). The human versions might as well.
One of the kids next door has a sperm donor as father. He is one abusive m.f.

And your point?
 
1. Unwilling means unwilling.

Well that really answers the question doesn't it. Blue means Blue too.

If you think a woman who gets pregnant unwillingly should be punished by being forced to stay pregnant, then I most emphatically do disagree.

Where did I say anything about it being a punishment? As for being unwilling, people that are unwilling to suffer consequences, don't put themselves into the position that those consequences can occur. If you are willing to put yourself in that position, then you are showing that you are willing to accept the consequences.

If she chooses to deal with the consequences by having an abortion, she is entitled to take that course.

So you are perfectly fine with people using abortion as a form of birth control instead of using one of the myrid of forms we have of preventing pregnancy in the first place?

2. Where did I say anything that makes you think I disagree? If she helped bring it into this world willingly, I very much doubt that she would take any other course. But that is totally irrelevant to whether or not a woman should be able to choose abortion.

You seem to have forgotten the original premise was one of one where the woman didn't know she was pregnant. However, let's assume that she did know and willingly gave birth, then changed her mind. How does this differ to someone willingly getting pregnant (or willingly taking the tisk knowing that she could get pregnant) and then changing her mind?
 
To the OP:

The Catholic Church actually doesn't make an exception for rape and incest.

Or the mother's tragically young age, the fetus' mental and/or physical defects, danger to the mother's health or life, etc.

(Opinions on the last one vary, though. There was a time when a mother was expected to sacrifice her life for her child's life, if there was a conflict between the two. However, other sources tell me that danger to the mother's life is the only exception that the RCC will grant. Heck, I was raised Catholic and I don't know. It seems to depend on who you ask- like much of the RCC's teachings.)

So even when a 9 year old girl gets molested by her father, gets pregnant with twins, could die in childbirth and the two fetuses would most likely die too, anyway, they are opposed to abortion.

Even in the case of an OBVIOUS- OBVIOUS BEYOND OBVIOUS- exception to the rule, they are against abortion.

As someone who is uh, you know, *********** SANE!, I'm appalled.

As a former philosophy student, I have to admire their philosophical consistency.

If a fetus is a person, yes, there would be no exceptions (except danger to the mother's life, arguably. Someone could very well argue that, in that case, the woman has the moral right to kill the fetus, the same way I'd have the right to kill another human being who was a direct threat to my life. In that case, it is self defense. One human being's life weighed against another human being's life. Equal right to life to both parties- but since one threatens the other, well, that one has to be eliminated to save the other.)

The Catholic Church is absolutely and totally correct.


ETA: For the record, I have mixed feelings about abortion.
 
Last edited:
Having an opinion about abortion rights is like having an opinion on the location of Arkansas--it's pointless, since neither of them are going anywhere any time soon.
 
Where did I say anything about it being a punishment? As for being unwilling, people that are unwilling to suffer consequences, don't put themselves into the position that those consequences can occur. If you are willing to put yourself in that position, then you are showing that you are willing to accept the consequences.

You didn't use the word 'punishment' but that is the effect of what you propose.
As to being willing to accept the 'consequences', the consequences are either continue wirh the pregnancy or have an abortion. You want the consequences to be continue with the pregnancy: punishment by any other name.

And willing to put oneself in what position,exactly? Possibly becoming pregnant?
Would you say that those who unintentionally contract an STD should suffer the consequences? After all, they willing put themselves in that position. Surely they should then not have treatment.
 
Last edited:
You seem to have forgotten the original premise was one of one where the woman didn't know she was pregnant. However, let's assume that she did know and willingly gave birth, then changed her mind. How does this differ to someone willingly getting pregnant (or willingly taking the tisk knowing that she could get pregnant) and then changing her mind?

You really don't understand the difference between being pregnant and not being pregnant? really?
 
You didn't use the word 'punishment' but that is the effect of what you propose.
As to being willing to accept the 'consequences', the consequences are either continue wirh the pregnancy or have an abortion. You want the consequences to be continue with the pregnancy: punishment by any other name.

So you consider that it is punishment to have consequences for your actions?

And willing to put oneself in what position,exactly? Possibly becoming pregnant?
Would you say that those who unintentionally contract an STD should suffer the consequences? After all, they willing put themselves in that position. Surely they should then not have treatment.

Do you really consider an STD and a protential human being to be the same thing?
 
You really don't understand the difference between being pregnant and not being pregnant? really?

What I do see is that you still refuse to answer the question I have posed, I have to wonder why. It can't be because you can't reconcile the belief that it's acceptable to throw away a life before it's out of the womb with the belief that it's unacceptable to throw away a life after it's out of the womb, can it?
 
So you consider that it is punishment to have consequences for your actions?



Do you really consider an STD and a protential human being to be the same thing?

If the consequences are enforced pregnancy against the woman's wishes, yes, most definitely punishment. That consequence is not inevitable. Abortion is a possible consequence.
I didn't say an STD and a potential human are the same thing.
I was pointing out the fallacy inherent in your face-the-consequences stance.
The consequences of getting pregnant are either to continue the pregnancy, or abort it. There are no other possibilities.
The consequences of contracting an STD are either to treat the disease, or leave it untreated. There are no other possibilities.
 
What I do see is that you still refuse to answer the question I have posed, I have to wonder why. It can't be because you can't reconcile the belief that it's acceptable to throw away a life before it's out of the womb with the belief that it's unacceptable to throw away a life after it's out of the womb, can it?

Because in one case a woman is pregnant and in the other she is not.
So in the case of pregnancy, an abortion is a possibility.
In the case of not being pregnant, an abortion is not a possibility.
And this is about whether a woman should be able to choose to have an abortion.
A child cannot be aborted.
 
If the consequences are enforced pregnancy against the woman's wishes, yes, most definitely punishment. That consequence is not inevitable. Abortion is a possible consequence.
I didn't say an STD and a potential human are the same thing.
I was pointing out the fallacy inherent in your face-the-consequences stance.
The consequences of getting pregnant are either to continue the pregnancy, or abort it. There are no other possibilities.
The consequences of contracting an STD are either to treat the disease, or leave it untreated. There are no other possibilities.

So what you are saying is that it's perfectly acceptable to play russian roulette with getting pregnant because you can always abort it if it all goes wrong?
 
So what you are saying is that it's perfectly acceptable to play russian roulette with getting pregnant because you can always abort it if it all goes wrong?

This is such a silly thing to say, it is not worth responding to.
 
No, you can take it that it is such a silly thing to say it is not worthy of a response.

Is it really silly when there are actually people that belive such a thing is not only acceptable, but a fun and exciting thing to do?
 
Is it really silly when there are actually people that belive such a thing is not only acceptable, but a fun and exciting thing to do?

Yes. Your presenting it in a discussion about abortion is silly.
Unless, that is, you are using it as further evidence that you think pregnancy should be compulsory as a punishment for behaviour you do not like.
 
Last edited:
So it's silly to present the use of Abortion as a form of Birth Control in a thread about Abortion.... okay....

Your reference to playing russian roulette was the silly part

Do you have any objection to abortion other than the fact that you think it should be banned as a form of punishment?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom