"Except for cases of rape or incest". Why?

Only if you have some responsibility for their condition.
In other words, you may have an obligation to risk your safety to save a drowning person, if you have some responsibility for the person's well-being.
For example -- because you are their parent.

I don't think that is true in most states of the US. The last thing we want is for parents who can't swim to be compelled by the law to jump in after drowning children. They do so on their own all too frequently and it rarely goes well.

I am unaware of any "good samaritan" laws that require one to put themselves at risk, but it is not really my expertise. And I don't think "good samaritan" laws are all that common, at least in the US. The closing chapters of Seinfeld notwithstanding.
 
I've had a couple of close calls in my single days, which didn't actually result in pregnancy. But the fear I lived with for several days was positively palpable. It's horrifying to think you might be pregnant by the wrong person, at the wrong time in your life. If it came to having an abortion, it would not have been an easy choice to make. I'd be worrying that I'd never be able to get pregnant again when I was older and married. Your mind is absolutely spinning when you think you might be facing an unwanted pregnancy. So I'm not going to condemn women for making the choices that they make. I'm certainly not going to think that some young single college student is going to be as happy about a pregnancy as an older married woman who was actively trying for a baby. I'm also not going to think that men really know how they would handle sex and reproduction from the female perspective, if the roles were reversed.

No, no, no . . . silly girl.

Didn't you read the whole thread? Girls are getting abortions willy nilly as a form of birth control instead of taking responsibility for the men in their lives who don't use condoms. THAT is why we have to force them to remain pregnant for the full term: to teach them better birth control. Once we take away the free pass that is legalized abortion women will become magically more responsible for their actions. And so will men. Really, you'll see.

/sarcasm

(The fact that I ever wore a condom is amazing when I think of the single-mindedness with which I approached sex in my youth.)
 
Only if you have some responsibility for their condition.
In other words, you may have an obligation to risk your safety to save a drowning person, if you have some responsibility for the person's well-being.
For example -- because you are their parent.

And this is enshrined in law, or is it just what you think it should be?
Do you make exceptions for abortion in cases of rape? I hope not, because that would make your argument that a fetus has a right to be kept alive against the woman's wishes unsustainable.
 
All right. What dictionary are you using that says a punishment implies a sin, fault or some such, but not a crime? And how does any of that invalidate my point that requiring someone to go through pain in order to save a life is not, by any common definition, a punishment?

Do you think we should be able to force you to donate a kidney, or bone marrow, or part of your liver, or any other body part you can spare, in order to save a life?
If not, why should you force a woman to stay pregnant to 'save a life'?
Have you seen the argument that women who fail to use effective contraception should face the consequences and continue with an unwanted pregnancy? How is that not punishment?
 
Is there, then, a duty to rescue in special cases, where the person is considered to be 'responsible'?

There is a pretty comprehensive list of such situations here:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duty_to_rescue

But do note this rather fundamental caveat, that is somewhat buried:

"Furthermore, the rescuer need not endanger himself in conducting the rescue."

There are very few duties under the law that require a human to endanger themselves for the good of others or for the greater good. I can't think of any off the top of my head, but I'm sure I'm missing some. Maybe the draft or following orders in the military. I stand by my assertion that it is rare.
 
The fact that mandatory child support and mandatory pregnancy are different obligations doesn't change the fact that both are obligations that arguably arise from the responsibility one has for one's own behavior.

Abortion also is taking responsibility.
How do you feel, then, about rape? Abortion is okay then, isn't it, because the woman is not responsible?
 
Do you think we should be able to force you to donate a kidney, or bone marrow, or part of your liver, or any other body part you can spare, in order to save a life?
If not, why should you force a woman to stay pregnant to 'save a life'?

See, this is moving goalposts. I merely jumped in on the discussion to point out you were misusing the word punishment. I've no desire to swerve to discussing whether a woman should have an obligation to go through with a pregnancy, as there's quite enough of that without me.

Have you seen the argument that women who fail to use effective contraception should face the consequences and continue with an unwanted pregnancy? How is that not punishment?

Well, that isn't the argument I presented, is it? Why would you even bring it up?

Remember, you said "Enforced pregnancy is punishment. How could it not be?". I explained that if the pregnancy was not enforced because of a crime, sin, fault etc. of the woman, then it was not a punishment. Do you understand what I am saying, and how it differs from the several separate issues you are attempting to slip into the debate?
 
There is a pretty comprehensive list of such situations here:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duty_to_rescue

But do note this rather fundamental caveat, that is somewhat buried:

"Furthermore, the rescuer need not endanger himself in conducting the rescue."

There are very few duties under the law that require a human to endanger themselves for the good of others or for the greater good. I can't think of any off the top of my head, but I'm sure I'm missing some. Maybe the draft or following orders in the military. I stand by my assertion that it is rare.

To clarify, I didn't mean to suggest there's a legal obligation to risk oneself to save another, but I am rather surprised to learn the legal obligation to help strangers is so rare in the United States.

But nevertheless, I believe most people would consider walking away from an injured person immoral, so there is a commonly agreed-upon 'duty to rescue', which was the point at question.
 
Well, that isn't the argument I presented, is it? Why would you even bring it up?

Remember, you said "Enforced pregnancy is punishment. How could it not be?". I explained that if the pregnancy was not enforced because of a crime, sin, fault etc. of the woman, then it was not a punishment. Do you understand what I am saying, and how it differs from the several separate issues you are attempting to slip into the debate?

I am not slipping these issues into the debate: it has already been argued that women with unwanted pregnancies should accept responsibility for their behaviour.
I say enforcing such pregnancies is punishment for getting pregnant. The perceived sin or fault is not using effective contraception.
 
To clarify, I didn't mean to suggest there's a legal obligation to risk oneself to save another, but I am rather surprised to learn the legal obligation to help strangers is so rare in the United States.

But nevertheless, I believe most people would consider walking away from an injured person immoral, so there is a commonly agreed-upon 'duty to rescue', which was the point at question.

Yes, there is a pretty good discussion on that wiki about the ethical considerations and most people will be compelled by their ethics to offer what they view as a reasonable effort at rescue.

The reason the legal duty is important is that most of us are discussing the legal duties of a pregnant mother. Does she have a duty to remain pregnant even if she does not want to? Do her reasons have to be compelling to others or do we allow her to make this decision without comparison to some standard?

It seemed that the conversation was tending toward a legal duty to maintain the pregnancy under some view of the duty of rescue. To make that leap you first have to understand that the duty of rescue is does not always have the force of law and never requires the rescuer to put themselves at risk. Therefore this would be a very stretched application of that duty if it were to carry the force of law and require the woman to put herself at risk. (The health risks of pregnancy are laid out in previous pages of this thread by others more familiar with them.)
 
For the same reason that enforced child support is not punishment -- it's about the responsibility to fulfill the needs of the child, not the desire to take something away from the parent.
How do we know this? Simple: if it were possible to transfer the fetus to another person, do you think the majority of pro-lifers would object to this? How about safely delivering unwanted fetuses into test tubes where they can safely grow? If you agree that pro-lifers would not object to these methods, how can you say that their desire for women to remain pregnant is about punishing the woman rather than saving the child?

I think there is some contingent of pro-lifers who would not like this solution at all. See the above diatribes about the inability of women to use contraception further up thread. The ability to simply transfer the fetus out of the woman at six to ten weeks would only make things worse in their view.

That being said, I think you and many other pro-lifers are genuine in thinking this would be an excellent solution. Although, I wonder how many frozen fetuses we would end up with? What the hell would we do if each one needed a woman to gestate in? I think of the frozen embryos that fertility clinics dispose of and the fact that pro-lifers hate the disposal but I've missed the lines of women lining up to be implanted.
 
I am not slipping these issues into the debate: it has already been argued that women with unwanted pregnancies should accept responsibility for their behaviour.
I say enforcing such pregnancies is punishment for getting pregnant. The perceived sin or fault is not using effective contraception.

Of course. But do you agree that if that argument is not used, then an enforced pregancy is not a punishment?
 
Yes, there is a pretty good discussion on that wiki about the ethical considerations and most people will be compelled by their ethics to offer what they view as a reasonable effort at rescue.

The reason the legal duty is important is that most of us are discussing the legal duties of a pregnant mother. Does she have a duty to remain pregnant even if she does not want to? Do her reasons have to be compelling to others or do we allow her to make this decision without comparison to some standard?

It seemed that the conversation was tending toward a legal duty to maintain the pregnancy under some view of the duty of rescue. To make that leap you first have to understand that the duty of rescue is does not always have the force of law and never requires the rescuer to put themselves at risk. Therefore this would be a very stretched application of that duty if it were to carry the force of law and require the woman to put herself at risk. (The health risks of pregnancy are laid out in previous pages of this thread by others more familiar with them.)

I'm personally for abortion, but I understand the reasoning that states a woman should have a duty to protect the life inside her. I was simply pointing that out, to which kerikiwi responded by stating there is no duty to rescue, to which I again replied, yes, there is.

A Good Samaritarian law and abortion legislation are certainly not fully analogous, but if a fetus is considered a person, there is a consistent moral case to be made that the mother should have the duty to care for the well-being of that person for as long as needed. And if that is the reasoning, then 'punishment' has nothing to do with it.
 
Do you make exceptions for abortion in cases of rape? I hope not, because that would make your argument that a fetus has a right to be kept alive against the woman's wishes unsustainable.

Again, the concept of responsibility for a situation creating an obligation does not imply that the obligation is a punishment. All enforced obligations are not punishments. Child support and anti-abortion laws are two examples.
It can be argued that a rape victim is not responsible for the pregnancy in the same way as a participant in consensual sex is, and therefore it can be argued that she doesn't have the same obligation to the child.
 
Of course. But do you agree that if that argument is not used, then an enforced pregancy is not a punishment?

I can imagine no scenario where a willingly pregnant woman would need to be forced to stay pregnant...The idea is simply bizarre.
 
I can imagine no scenario where a willingly pregnant woman would need to be forced to stay pregnant...The idea is simply bizarre.

Okay, so I was not making myself clear.

Let's say a woman is pregnant, but does not want to be.

Now let's say Lawmaker A considers the fetus inside the woman to be a human being with rights, and thus makes a law that forbids the woman from aborting it. Feeling sorry for the woman, but wanting to ensure the rights of the fetus?

Do you agree that Lawmaker A is not punishing the woman?
 
Okay, so I was not making myself clear.

Let's say a woman is pregnant, but does not want to be.

Now let's say Lawmaker A considers the fetus inside the woman to be a human being with rights, and thus makes a law that forbids the woman from aborting it. Feeling sorry for the woman, but wanting to ensure the rights of the fetus?

Do you agree that Lawmaker A is not punishing the woman?

We can play semantic games, but essentially, yes, enforcing a pregnancy is a punishment for being pregnant. It sure as hell isn't a reward, and it sure as hell isn't neutral.
 
We can play semantic games, but essentially, yes, enforcing a pregnancy is a punishment for being pregnant. It sure as hell isn't a reward, and it sure as hell isn't neutral.

See, again, you're creating the fallacy that every affirmative duty or obligation is a punishment. That's simply not true.

Let me give you the simplest example. Let's say that this month I buy a $2000 flat screen television on my Discover card.
Next month, Discover taps me on the shoulder and asks me for money. I am obligated to give them money; my actions created a duty that I am obligated to fulfill.
Now, having to pay Discover back -- "It sure as hell isn't a reward, and it sure as hell isn't neutral.". In fact, if I really don't want to pay them, it's pretty obviously a negative. But it's by no means a punishment. Discover doesn't want to punish me for charging $2000. They want me to fulfill my obligations.
The same is true if I'm a parent. Having to spend money on food and clothing, to make sure the child has proper medical care and is protected -- these aren't punishments for having a child, even though I may very well see all of them as very negative. Rather, they're duties for being a parent -- duties, by the way, that I may very well have regardless of whether I ever wanted to be a parent. And if I'm male, I may very well have these duties for a child that I've never actually seen or had anything to do with other than making the choice to have sex with the child's mother.
Now, you're welcome to argue as to whether or not a mother's obligations to her child can start before birth, or include continuing a pregnancy. But at no point are we talking about punishment here. We're talking about enforced duties. A very different concept.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom