"Except for cases of rape or incest". Why?

We can play semantic games, but essentially, yes, enforcing a pregnancy is a punishment for being pregnant. It sure as hell isn't a reward, and it sure as hell isn't neutral.


It may feel punishing, but it is not a punishment. It is not designed to specifically or generally deter behavior, rehabilitate or vindicate. It's designed to allow one individual life. The expense may be an extraordinary imposition (in my mind, too great an imposition), but that doesn't make it a punishment from the state against the individual. It just doesn't.
 
Then you would be using a different meaning of the word than usual. A punishment implies a crime, yet in my example there was no such, but merely the duty to save a life.

In many of the anti-abortionist's eyes, having sex outside of wedlock is a crime and the punishment is pregnancy. I've seen it argued plenty of times, in not so many words but veiled as "take responsibility for their actions" type of nonsense.
 
In many of the anti-abortionist's eyes, having sex outside of wedlock is a crime and the punishment is pregnancy. I've seen it argued plenty of times, in not so many words but veiled as "take responsibility for their actions" type of nonsense.

And I've explained several times now that "take responsibility for their actions" is not a veiled substitute for "punish with pregnancy". It's exactly what we expect of parents, intentional or not. The only question is when the obligation begins, and what it includes.
 
And I've explained several times now that "take responsibility for their actions" is not a veiled substitute for "punish with pregnancy".


Yes, it is. This is especially true since anti-abortionists want to argue that having an abortion is not a responsible choice. If the only "responsible" choice is to suffer the consequence of getting pregnant to full term, then it is definitely an implication that the pregnancy is a punishment for having too much "fun". I've also seen the same type of argument from the same people about how victims of HIV should suffer their consequence as well.
 
Yes, it is. This is especially true since anti-abortionists want to argue that having an abortion is not a responsible choice.
Apparently you missed this whole idea of "parental duty to the child".
I don't fulfill my child support obligation by throwing my two-year-old in the river, either.
Protecting the child you create is an obligation, not a punishment. There's a difference.
 
See, again, you're creating the fallacy that every affirmative duty or obligation is a punishment.

Nonsense. I said forcing an unwillingly pregnant woman to continue with the pregnancy is a punishment.
Can you explain how it is not?
 
I have given a very clear explanation as to why it is an obligation not a punishment. You have supplied no counterargument; you just keep saying the same thing over and over again.
Do you have any actual reason underlying your bald assertion that forced pregnancy is a punishment rather than an obligation?
 
And I've explained several times now that "take responsibility for their actions" is not a veiled substitute for "punish with pregnancy". It's exactly what we expect of parents, intentional or not. The only question is when the obligation begins, and what it includes.

Excellent. An unwillingly pregnant woman who has an abortion is taking responsibility. If the state, or anyone else, denies her that choice, she is being punished for being pregnant.
She is, of course, not a parent so there is no parental obligation, and if there were she could chjoose to have the child adopted. But this has nothing to do with the choices of a pregnant woman.
 
Do you have any actual reason underlying your bald assertion that forced pregnancy is a punishment rather than an obligation?

Yes. A woman should not be forced to be pregnant. I am not convinced that there is any such obligation, despite your bald assertion that there is.
 
Just like an unwilling mother of a two-year-old who slits his throat is taking responsibility.
No.

I agree. It is a ridiculous comparison. Who made it?

Let me ask you to clarify your position: do you think that all pregnant women have an obligation to proceed to birth? Those who have been raped?
If not, why not?
 
Yes. A woman should not be forced to be pregnant.

That's not an argument for why forcing a woman to be pregnant is a punishment. It's a reason for why you disagree that forcing a woman to be pregnant should be an obligation.
If you still don't understand the difference between a mandatory action being a punishment and a mandatory action being an obligation, I'm not sure there's much more I can do to explain it to you.
 
Let me ask you to clarify your position:

I'm not explaining my position; I'm explaining the "pro-life with exception for rape" position.

do you think that all pregnant women have an obligation to proceed to birth? Those who have been raped?
If not, why not?
Again, if you're not responsible for the pregnancy then you have no obligation to bring the child to term. Just as a man who's raped has no obligation to pay child support, and someone who has $2000 charged on her card without her consent has no obligation to pay it back.
 
Apparently you missed this whole idea of "parental duty to the child".
I don't fulfill my child support obligation by throwing my two-year-old in the river, either.
Protecting the child you create is an obligation, not a punishment. There's a difference.

A fetus is not a child. A pregnancy is a medical condition. Apparently, you missed the whole idea of forcing women to carry an unwanted medical condition to term.
 
Again, if you're not responsible for the pregnancy then you have no obligation to bring the child to term. Just as a man who's raped has no obligation to pay child support, and someone who has $2000 charged on her card without her consent has no obligation to pay it back.

Thus, showing that it's merely a punishment you seek, not any actual welfare of a child.
 
Thus, showing that it's merely a punishment you seek, not any actual welfare of a child.

That makes no sense. I gave three examples of obligations, not punishments.
How does the fact that a person fraudulantly charged $2000 doesn't have to pay it back, imply that a person who does have to pay back the $2000 is being punished?
By your same argument, the fact that YOU don't have to pay child support for SOMEONE ELSE'S child implies that their mandatory child support is a punishment.
 
That makes no sense. I gave three examples of obligations, not punishments.
How does the fact that a person fraudulantly charged $2000 doesn't have to pay it back, imply that a person who does have to pay back the $2000 is being punished?
By your same argument, the fact that YOU don't have to pay child support for SOMEONE ELSE'S child implies that their mandatory child support is a punishment.

It often can be considered a punishment, just like the "obligation" of a bank robber to serve time in prison. The difference here is that pregnancy involves women feeling pain, depression, illness, nausea and many other biological "punishments" because of her supposed "obligation" to carry out an unwanted pregnancy.

FORCING WOMEN TO STAY PREGNANT IS A PUNISHMENT.
 
Thus, showing that it's merely a punishment you seek,

I'll be explicit: what is being sought is the justification for imposing an obligation. Again, no duty to rescue a stranger. In the absence of responsibility for the obligation, imposing the obligation is improper.
That doesn't suddenly convert the obligation to a punishment when the responsibility is there, though -- any more than for any other obligation.
 
FORCING WOMEN TO STAY PREGNANT IS A PUNISHMENT.

Apparently you also don't understand the difference between a punishment and an obligation, despite my very clear explanations and examples. I am forced to conclude that your shouting on the subject is a symptom of emotion rather than logical argument, and therefore my further explanations will not make the situation any clearer.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom