"Except for cases of rape or incest". Why?

I assume we agree there are non-religious arguments as to why a second-trimester fetus should have such a right? Why do these arguments not apply during the first trimester?

Basically, a second-trimester fetus has neural function and can possibly survive independent of it's mother. Which of these is more important is a matter of opinion.
 
I quite agree with you. Child abuse should be stopped because the rights of the parent do not supersede the rights of the child in question. The child has a right to not be beaten, sexually assaulted or psychologically traumatised, which is far more important than the rights of the parent to raise the child how they want to. I assume you agree with this, yes?
I believe this is a point of common understanding, which is why it's an analogy I like to use with people who come in swinging the "private lives" rhetoric around. No one here actually believes that your right to privacy lets you harm innocent people. The argument is really going back to the question of whether there are "innocent people" involved or not.

Two questions.
1. Why does the foetus have rights?
2. If the foetus does have rights, why don't the foetus' of rape or incestuous relationships?
1. Under this line of argument, for the same reason that born children have rights.
2. They do have the same right; the question is how far this right extends, and in what situations. The rape-exception argument comes from one reason by which an obligation is imposed on a parent not to kill a child -- because an obligation is required, and because a rape victim doesn't have this obligation, it is permissible for a rape victim to do less for the child than a consensual parent must do.
 
... and again, an obligation is not the same as a punishment. Nor does it translate into a punishment just because you really don't want the obligation.
 
I believe this is a point of common understanding, which is why it's an analogy I like to use with people who come in swinging the "private lives" rhetoric around. No one here actually believes that your right to privacy lets you harm innocent people. The argument is really going back to the question of whether there are "innocent people" involved or not.
No problem there.



1. Under this line of argument, for the same reason that born children have rights.

Err, no. A foetus isn't a human child. It isn't a child, and it's got less cognitive ability than a hamster. It's a small group of cells. That's it.

Why does that deserve the same rights as a human child?
 
Like I keep telling Kerikiwi I think abortion should be available to any pregnant woman who wants one. I just feel that in cases where a woman gets pregnant by consentual sex it would be nice for her to go ahead with the pregnancy. I'm not saying she should be forced to it just makes me happy when the choice is to proceed with having a baby. Put it up for adoption if she wants to.
 
Err, no. A foetus isn't a human child. It isn't a child, and it's got less cognitive ability than a hamster. It's a small group of cells. That's it.

This is the basic abortion argument -- whether or not the fetus deserves any protection at all under the law, and on what grounds. And then the separate question as to whether or not the fetus' protection overrides certain other rights of the pregnant woman.
And I'm sure there are a dozen threads on this forum where we argue this very issue.
It seems that the obligation vs. punishment issue has been thoroughly explored; is there anything else specific to the question on this thread?
 
This is the basic abortion argument -- whether or not the fetus deserves any protection at all under the law, and on what grounds. And then the separate question as to whether or not the fetus' protection overrides certain other rights of the pregnant woman.
And I'm sure there are a dozen threads on this forum where we argue this very issue.
It seems that the obligation vs. punishment issue has been thoroughly explored; is there anything else specific to the question on this thread?

I haven't read the whole thread, so I don't know if this has been mentioned yet, but there is always the concern of illegal and dangerous abortions if abortion becomes illegal. I think one would be foolish to pretend that some people would not resort to a "black market abortion" as it were, and I find this a reason for great concern.

Also, not sure if this has been mentioned, but if we were to allow an exception for victims of rape, would this mean any woman who claimed go be raped could get an abortion, or would she have to get a conviction first? If the former, the obvious problem would be an increase in false rape accusations just for the sake od getting an abortion. However, were we to rely on conviction, one has to keep in mind the abysmal report rate and even more abysmal conviction rate in rape cases. Were we to illegalize abortion, how would we deal with these issues?
 
I've never understood why this should be a question for anyone else besides the woman and her doctor. It certainly should not be a question that is decided by a male majority of lawmakers.

...and myowninvention is correct...the only thing outlawing abortion would "accomplish" would be to move abortions out of the medical facilities and back into the back alleys. Those who want abortion illegal care nothing for the health of baby or mother...they simply want it "out of sight" where they don't have to see it.
 
Forgot to include this in my last post...

However, were we to rely on conviction, one has to keep in mind the abysmal report rate and even more abysmal conviction rate in rape cases.

Unless it's an "instant" conviction this seems like an unworkable "solution". By the time some of those cases were decided, the question would be moot. (ie. 9 months later)
 
I've never understood why this should be a question for anyone else besides the woman and her doctor. It certainly should not be a question that is decided by a male majority of lawmakers.
Do you feel the same way about child abuse? Why should the appropriate level of violence for disobedient children be a question for anyone besides the parents?

...and myowninvention is correct...the only thing outlawing abortion would "accomplish" would be to move abortions out of the medical facilities and back into the back alleys.
Plenty of babies die slow deaths in dumpsters. Let's start a "postnatal abortion clinic" where we offer new parents the option to safely euthanize their newborns instead.

Those who want abortion illegal care nothing for the health of baby or mother...they simply want it "out of sight" where they don't have to see it.
Do you have statistics for how much post-partum assistance is provided by abortion clinics, compared with that provided by anti-abortion crisis centers? Are you aware of what percentage of abortion clinics provide any assistance at all to mothers who choose not to go through the procedure? You'd be surprised to learn who really cares about babies and mothers.
This whole discussion is a red herring. Villifying advocates on either side isn't the way to conduct these discussions.
 
... so we're totally past the specific morality issues brought on by the "rape exception" situation? Fair enough.
 
Do you feel the same way about child abuse? Why should the appropriate level of violence for disobedient children be a question for anyone besides the parents?

I'm not going to argue irrelevant comparisons...including this and the rest of your post.
 
Do you have statistics for how much post-partum assistance is provided by abortion clinics, compared with that provided by anti-abortion crisis centers? Are you aware of what percentage of abortion clinics provide any assistance at all to mothers who choose not to go through the procedure? You'd be surprised to learn who really cares about babies and mothers. This whole discussion is a red herring. Villifying advocates on either side isn't the way to conduct these discussions.

If you don't think vilifying either side is productive, then don't. Both sides really care about mothers and babies.

Although Planned Parenthood have been painted as an "abortion" clinic, they are actually a gyn-ob center. So they offer both abortion and pregnancy services. They also work with other sliding scale medical providers and do refer women to mental health professionals.
 
If you don't think vilifying either side is productive, then don't. Both sides really care about mothers and babies.

You are correct.
The discussion progresses in a much more meaningful way if we don't insist that any group has ulterior motives.
 
Like I keep telling Kerikiwi I think abortion should be available to any pregnant woman who wants one. I just feel that in cases where a woman gets pregnant by consentual sex it would be nice for her to go ahead with the pregnancy. I'm not saying she should be forced to it just makes me happy when the choice is to proceed with having a baby. Put it up for adoption if she wants to.

Nice? Ah, the blissful apathy of the ivory tower.

Pregnancy has a higher mortality rate than abortion. It can lead to long-term medical problems. If she is in the US, her chances of having maternity leave are very small. She will need to take time off work or lose her job. If she's just starting out in her profession, this can cause her to fall behind. Even with help from an adoption agency, pregnancy is expensive and time consuming.

Nice doesn't really cover it.
 
Pregnancy has a higher mortality rate than abortion. It can lead to long-term medical problems. If she is in the US, her chances of having maternity leave are very small.

Wait, what? Doesn't FMLA pretty much guarantee maternity leave?
I am not educated on this issue.
 
... so we're totally past the specific morality issues brought on by the "rape exception" situation? Fair enough.

Well, you chose not to respond to that part of my post. What, in your oppinion, should be the process to ensure that an actual rape victim could get an abortion while safeguarding men from potential false acusations from women who just want an abortion? Given the legal system at the moment, I find it hard to imagine a viable solution to this which would both prohibit abortions in general, an allow them to rape victims, and I haven't heard any funcional solutions to this potential problem. I would be very interested to hear your thoughts on how this would be dealt with.
 
Well, you chose not to respond to that part of my post. What, in your oppinion, should be the process to ensure that an actual rape victim could get an abortion while safeguarding men from potential false acusations from women who just want an abortion? Given the legal system at the moment, I find it hard to imagine a viable solution to this which would both prohibit abortions in general, an allow them to rape victims, and I haven't heard any funcional solutions to this potential problem. I would be very interested to hear your thoughts on how this would be dealt with.

I'm not sure there is a solution. Rape is a complete mess in our justice system. And you're right; this would create a situation similar to when rape was an affirmative defense against criminal promiscuity.
 
Wait, what? Doesn't FMLA pretty much guarantee maternity leave?
I am not educated on this issue.

The only national policy in the US is FMLA which gives you 12 weeks unpaid leave and the promise of your job, if the company has more than 50 people and if you have been working there for a full year+. Not many people can afford to take 3 months off without pay.

Paid maternity leave varies by state and company. Some corporations offer it as a perk, some offer 50% pay for 6 weeks from a fund that the employees pay into.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom