"Except for cases of rape or incest". Why?

I'll be explicit: what is being sought is the justification for imposing an obligation.

So it has nothing to do with saving a "human life?"

Thanks for clarifying the position.

You call it obligation, I call it punishment.
 
I'm not explaining my position; I'm explaining the "pro-life with exception for rape" position.


Again, if you're not responsible for the pregnancy then you have no obligation to bring the child to term. Just as a man who's raped has no obligation to pay child support, and someone who has $2000 charged on her card without her consent has no obligation to pay it back.

How is a rapist not responsible for the ensuing pregnancy?
How is the credit card charge without consent exempt from responsibility, but the pregnancy without consent not exempt?
 
Apparently you also don't understand the difference between a punishment and an obligation, despite my very clear explanations and examples. I am forced to conclude that your shouting on the subject is a symptom of emotion rather than logical argument, and therefore my further explanations will not make the situation any clearer.

Understanding your explanation is not the same as agreeing with it.
Imposing an obligation is a punishment by any other name, if that obligation is against the will of the obligee.(I like that word. May I keep it?)
 
Last edited:
I recall a conversation in church (back when I actually went to church regularily) about a topic like this. The pastor posed this question: if an infant dies, does it go to heaven or hell? The logical response is that since it has not "given its life to god" it will go to hell. But the pator brought up an interesting point: its a baby. A baby is not physically capable of committing a sin. Babies cant lie, or steal, or kill, or anything like that, of their own free will. Since it has not committed any sins, the baby will go to heaven. I believe that there is some higher power, yeah, but I also believe that whatever it is has some sense of mercy.
 
I recall a conversation in church (back when I actually went to church regularily) about a topic like this. The pastor posed this question: if an infant dies, does it go to heaven or hell? The logical response is that since it has not "given its life to god" it will go to hell. But the pator brought up an interesting point: its a baby. A baby is not physically capable of committing a sin. Babies cant lie, or steal, or kill, or anything like that, of their own free will. Since it has not committed any sins, the baby will go to heaven. I believe that there is some higher power, yeah, but I also believe that whatever it is has some sense of mercy.

I thought this question was the reason for the existence of Limbo. A place that is not Heaven but not Hell where people who are virtuous but not Christian can safely be dumped without all the angst of asking if it's right to punish people who's only crime was a lack of information.
 
Imposing an obligation is a punishment by any other name, if that obligation is against the will of the obligee.

Now at least you've made it explicit: you define "punishment" as "anything mandatory that the person doesn't like".
That's not what the word "punishment" means. Since all you mean is that pro-lifers want the woman forced to continue the pregnancy, you should say what you really mean instead of coopting words that mean something else.
What you're doing is no different than "abortion is murder (which I define as any killing I am morally opposed to)".
 
That makes no sense. I gave three examples of obligations, not punishments.
How does the fact that a person fraudulantly charged $2000 doesn't have to pay it back, imply that a person who does have to pay back the $2000 is being punished?
By your same argument, the fact that YOU don't have to pay child support for SOMEONE ELSE'S child implies that their mandatory child support is a punishment.
Avalon, what exactly is the purpose of forcing a woman to stay pregnant? In the example with the credit card, the obligation arises from your original agreement with the creditor. And if the woman is raped, she may abort because she did not make any decisions that led to her pregnancy? Then for what reason must a woman stay pregnant? It is obviously not the life of the fetus, as we ignore that in the other case. So one of the following is true:

1. There is a reason.
2. She is obligated for obligations' sake by some notion of "taking responsibility" in lieu of a reason.
3. Her obligation to the fetus is stronger than her right to not be pregnant, but weaker than her right to not be pregnant if she did not choose to have sex.

If it is 1, I await the reason. 2 is foolish. If it is 3, why is abstinence favored over all other effective methods of pregnancy prevention? If I am misrepresenting your position please correct me.
 
Avalon, what exactly is the purpose of forcing a woman to stay pregnant? In the example with the credit card, the obligation arises from your original agreement with the creditor. And if the woman is raped, she may abort because she did not make any decisions that led to her pregnancy? Then for what reason must a woman stay pregnant? It is obviously not the life of the fetus, as we ignore that in the other case. So one of the following is true:

1. There is a reason.
2. She is obligated for obligations' sake by some notion of "taking responsibility" in lieu of a reason.
3. Her obligation to the fetus is stronger than her right to not be pregnant, but weaker than her right to not be pregnant if she did not choose to have sex.

If it is 1, I await the reason. 2 is foolish. If it is 3, why is abstinence favored over all other effective methods of pregnancy prevention? If I am misrepresenting your position please correct me.

I see AvalonXQ did not answer to this. But I think it is an excellent question. if one does allow abortion in case of rape, forcing the pregnancy in case of willing sex, is clearly making the forcing conditional on the willingness of the sex, and therefore it is quite clearly a punishment for the "willingness to have sex" rather than an obligation to any moral imperative on the fetus (those would apply in BOTH case!).
 
I see AvalonXQ did not answer to this. But I think it is an excellent question. if one does allow abortion in case of rape, forcing the pregnancy in case of willing sex, is clearly making the forcing conditional on the willingness of the sex, and therefore it is quite clearly a punishment for the "willingness to have sex" rather than an obligation to any moral imperative on the fetus (those would apply in BOTH case!).

I didn't answer it because I had explained it at least a dozen times already -- there must be reasonable grounds for imposing an obligation, even if the obligation is an important one.
If I am responsible for a child and the child jumps in the water, I may have a duty to rescue the child. A stranger walking by at the same time may have no duty to rescue the child.
The purpose of the obligation is because saving children is important; children in danger should be rescued. However, the fact that the purpose of the obligation is important doesn't mean we will extend that obligation to everyone in all circumstances.
Just as a stranger may not have the same obligation to save a drowning child that the child's guardian has, so a pregnant woman who was raped may not have the same obligation to preserve the life of the fetus that a pregnant woman who willingly consented to sex has. And just as not imposing the duty to rescue on the stranger doesn't vitiate the reasoning behind imposing the duty on the guardian, so not imposing the duty to preserve the fetus on the raped woman doesn't vitiate the reasoning behind imposing the duty on other pregnant women.
 
This whole abortion thing is a non-issue as far as I'm concerned.

Other people's personal lives are none of my friggin' business. I don't walk in their shoes, therefore I have no right to form an opinion about it, nor do I have the right to tell them what they can and can't do in their personal life.

Why do the b'leevers feel they have the right to interfere with someone's private life?
 
Why do the b'leevers feel they have the right to interfere with someone's private life?

It depends on their understanding of the nature and purpose of laws, and their roles in our lives.

Are you for or against the existence and enforcement of laws against child abuse?
 
It depends on their understanding of the nature and purpose of laws, and their roles in our lives.

Are you for or against the existence and enforcement of laws against child abuse?

Ooh,you are a one.Have you stopped beating your wife? The two subjects have nothing to do with each other.What a woman does with her body is her business.As for child abuse,I'm all for it,I used to beat my kids senseless every day.
 
It depends on their understanding of the nature and purpose of laws, and their roles in our lives.

Are you for or against the existence and enforcement of laws against child abuse?

Their understanding of nature is wrong because there are no gods or god and using a delusion to control women is wrong.
 
The two subjects have nothing to do with each other.

The two subjects are both about in what areas of our private lives it is appropriate for the government to legislate.
More specifically, both subjects are about whether it's appropriate to have laws that protect the helpless against those who are supposed to look after them.
Personally I think it's appropriate for us to enforce laws against abusing children, even though it violates the privacy of the abusing parents. Do you agree? Because if so, you clearly believe that protecting the helpless is worth interfering in our private lives.
The only remaining question is whether or not a fetus should have our protection like we agree a born child should. We've already acknowledged the basic principal and a principaled exception; it's just a matter of whether or not this situation fits the exception.
 
Their understanding of nature is wrong because there are no gods or god and using a delusion to control women is wrong.

Genetic fallacy. The fetus' right to life is a social/moral question whose answer is not dictated by the truth or falsity of any specific religious belief.
 
Genetic fallacy. The fetus' right to life is a social/moral question whose answer is not dictated by the truth or falsity of any specific religious belief.

Well, it is, actually. In countries where abortion is legal, a first-trimester fetus does not legally possess such a right. And there really isn't an argument outside religion for why it should; at least not one that isn't equally applicable to all germline cells.
 
The two subjects are both about in what areas of our private lives it is appropriate for the government to legislate.
More specifically, both subjects are about whether it's appropriate to have laws that protect the helpless against those who are supposed to look after them.
Personally I think it's appropriate for us to enforce laws against abusing children, even though it violates the privacy of the abusing parents. Do you agree? Because if so, you clearly believe that protecting the helpless is worth interfering in our private lives.
The only remaining question is whether or not a fetus should have our protection like we agree a born child should. We've already acknowledged the basic principal and a principaled exception; it's just a matter of whether or not this situation fits the exception.

I quite agree with you. Child abuse should be stopped because the rights of the parent do not supersede the rights of the child in question. The child has a right to not be beaten, sexually assaulted or psychologically traumatised, which is far more important than the rights of the parent to raise the child how they want to. I assume you agree with this, yes?

Two questions.

1. Why does the foetus have rights?

2. If the foetus does have rights, why don't the foetus' of rape or incestuous relationships?
 
Well, it is, actually. In countries where abortion is legal, a first-trimester fetus does not legally possess such a right. And there really isn't an argument outside religion for why it should; at least not one that isn't equally applicable to all germline cells.

I assume we agree there are non-religious arguments as to why a second-trimester fetus should have such a right? Why do these arguments not apply during the first trimester?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom