"Except for cases of rape or incest". Why?

i am not going to follow your derail.
Back to my question: how is enforced pregnancy not punishment?

For the same reason that enforced child support is not punishment -- it's about the responsibility to fulfill the needs of the child, not the desire to take something away from the parent.
How do we know this? Simple: if it were possible to transfer the fetus to another person, do you think the majority of pro-lifers would object to this? How about safely delivering unwanted fetuses into test tubes where they can safely grow? If you agree that pro-lifers would not object to these methods, how can you say that their desire for women to remain pregnant is about punishing the woman rather than saving the child?
 
For the same reason that enforced child support is not punishment -

You are comparing a monetary obligation to biological servitude. Do you really think they are similar? How about we shove a bowling ball up your bowels for 9 months and tell you it will save a life?
 
Actually, I pointed out WHY they are silly. They believe in souls and other such magical nonsense.

I do realize that, but the argument is quite worthless in a debate about morality. Almost all people agree that there is something morally significant about a human life, call it a soul or not. Where that something begins is a much more difficult problem, and it won't be solved by simply saying 'souls don't exist, stupid'.
 
I don't agree there is a moral significance to human life. People, however, I do think are significant.
 
I don't agree there is a moral significance to human life. People, however, I do think are significant.

That's fine. But be that as it may, the majority of people don't agree, and it's not a particularly effective argument to simply state they are all wrong.
 
Yes,I would call it punishment to force a woman to remain pregnant.

Then you would be using a different meaning of the word than usual. A punishment implies a crime, yet in my example there was no such, but merely the duty to save a life.
 
... how can you say that their desire for women to remain pregnant is about punishing the woman rather than saving the child?

At least one poster has argued that women who get pregnant should take responsibility for their careless behaviour and remain pregnant.
 
Then you would be using a different meaning of the word than usual. A punishment implies a crime, yet in my example there was no such, but merely the duty to save a life.

A punishment does not imply a crime. You are using a different meaning of the word than usual.
There is no duty to save a life.
 
A punishment does not imply a crime. You are using a different meaning of the word than usual.

I checked a few dictionary definitions, and they all clearly stated the word does imply a crime, sin, fault or some such. What dictionary are you using?

(Some dictionaries do give the definition 'the act of punishing' for 'punishment', but 'to punish' always implies a crime. And of course there are alternative definitions which simply refer to inflicting damage or pain, but those are much less often used.)


There is no duty to save a life.

Most people disagree. At least in my country, so does the law.*

*No, it does not refer to abortion; it refers to situations such as coming across an injured or drowning person.
 
I checked a few dictionary definitions, and they all clearly stated the word does imply a crime, sin, fault or some such. What dictionary are you using?

Ah, moving goalposts. You first said 'crime'. Sins, faults and some suches are not crimes.
 
Most people disagree. At least in my country, so does the law.*

*No, it does not refer to abortion; it refers to situations such as coming across an injured or drowning person.

Does this duty include risk to your own well being?
 
Does this duty include risk to your own well being?

Only if you have some responsibility for their condition.
In other words, you may have an obligation to risk your safety to save a drowning person, if you have some responsibility for the person's well-being.
For example -- because you are their parent.
 
You are comparing a monetary obligation to biological servitude. Do you really think they are similar? How about we shove a bowling ball up your bowels for 9 months and tell you it will save a life?


That's ... um ...

First of all, we can and do compare monetary obligations to biological harms and even servitude every day. When you will a judgment against the grocery store for slipping and breaking your arm, you are being paid money in an amount that the law says is equal to the harm and the pain that you have suffered.

Second, shoving a bowling ball anywhere will not actually save a life. But carrying a fetus to term will create a life. You're comparing something that cannot possibly be effective to something that frequently is effective.

Now, there are a whole lot of differences between being forced to pay child support and being forced to carry a baby to term. But you've failed to effectively point to any of them.

And there are similarities also. Both cause pain, although to widely varying degrees. And both (rightly or wrongly) are intended by their proponents to focus on the needs of the child, without regard to how those needs affect the parent.

It's not so crazy a comparison as to invite "bowling ball"-level derision.
 
Ah, moving goalposts. You first said 'crime'. Sins, faults and some suches are not crimes.

All right. What dictionary are you using that says a punishment implies a sin, fault or some such, but not a crime? And how does any of that invalidate my point that requiring someone to go through pain in order to save a life is not, by any common definition, a punishment?

Does this duty include risk to your own well being?

Do you mean the legal duty or the moral one? If the former, generally no. If the latter, that depends on the moral system.
 
Only if you have some responsibility for their condition.
In other words, you may have an obligation to risk your safety to save a drowning person, if you have some responsibility for the person's well-being.
For example -- because you are their parent.

What a curious idea. Whatever happened to 'love thy neighbour'?
 
At least one poster has argued that women who get pregnant should take responsibility for their careless behaviour and remain pregnant.

But again, this doesn't imply that the pregnancy is punishment. It's an obligation that follows as a consequence for their behavior. So is child support.
The fact that mandatory child support and mandatory pregnancy are different obligations doesn't change the fact that both are obligations that arguably arise from the responsibility one has for one's own behavior. If you want to say that no behavior can specifically create an obligation to one's body like pregnancy, that's fine -- but you can't generalize it beyond that, because clearly we do allow one's behavior to create some kinds of obligation that are not punishment.
Our law and the principles behind it allows for the idea of duties, some of which arise from status or situation and some of which arise from prior behavior. The discussion is what duties are imposed by parenthood. The notion that all duties are automatically "punishments" just doesn't fly.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom