EVIDENCE of skeptic/atheist/freethinker sexism REQUESTED

Exactly. Plus, who said anything about "taking the invite?" She still absolutely could have said "no thank you," but just had a different outlook on the whole incident.

Maybe, but this is nothing more than mere speculation. We don't know that, right? Or do you have conclusive evidence that, had RW found EG attractive, she wouldn't have found his behavior creepy and wouldn't have said "guys, don't do that"?

Sure, we can discuss things based on hypothetical facts, but I suggest that we stick to established facts.
 
Back to where we got off track, this doesn't boil down to what Snide or Skeptic Ginger claim they would do in that situation. They were suggesting that RW would have behaved differently, had she been attracted to him. With you saying that you have experienced unwanted attention so you can imagine yourself in RW's shoes, that's the same thing that the 60% were doing, they weren't presuming, they were identifying with RW. The first has no basis because they don't know how RW felt in the first place, the second, there is at least an experience to assimilate with.
The following is an exercise in perception, not necessarily intended to beleaguer the point. Here's what I said:

I'm having a very hard time not believing that if RW had found EG seriously attractive, her reaction would have been very different.
"Tee hee, no thanks, but if you wait till about noon you can buymeet me for breakfast."
* I concede RW's new role as a feminist probably means she wouldn't expect the guy to pay.



Now let's compare that to your perception of what I said:

SG: I'm having a very hard time not believing
sgt: That's still presumptuous (referring back to your conflating my comments with Snides: sgt: I think that is shallow and presumptuous).


I merely said what my gut reaction was. You seem to have stretched that into an assertion of fact.


SG: seriously attractive
sgt: "hot guys"


It's presumptuous of you to decide I meant physically "hot" when there are many ways to interpret "attractive". Apparently that is hard for you to believe. ;)


SG: her reaction would have been very different.
"Tee hee, no thanks, but if you wait till about noon you can ... meet me for breakfast."

sgt: "turn into a quivering ball of sexual desires at the very first glance" (granted this was in reply to the Brad Pitt example, but you did conflate what I said with what Snide said).


Agreeing to meet for breakfast at noon the next day is hardly the same as turning into a quivering ball of sexual desires.


Just saying......
 
Back to where we got off track, this doesn't boil down to what Snide or Skeptic Ginger claim they would do in that situation. They were suggesting that RW would have behaved differently, had she been attracted to him.
I don't think so but if they did I'm happy to correct them. Could you quote them?

With you saying that you have experienced unwanted attention so you can imagine yourself in RW's shoes, that's the same thing that the 60% were doing...
I can only say that I don't like bad things. I can say that if I was faced with unwanted attention I wouldn't like it. I can't say that if an attractive girl in an elevator asked me to her room at 4:00 am I would find that creepy. See the difference?

The first has no basis because they don't know how RW felt in the first place, the second, there is at least an experience to assimilate with.
But there is insufficient information to determine if others would have felt the same. That's the nasty detail in all of this.

We can all say we don't want bad things to happen to us. There is simply know way to extrapolate RW's feelings to everyone else.
 
The following is an exercise in perception, not necessarily intended to beleaguer the point. Here's what I said:

I'm having a very hard time not believing that if RW had found EG seriously attractive, her reaction would have been very different.
"Tee hee, no thanks, but if you wait till about noon you can buymeet me for breakfast."
* I concede RW's new role as a feminist probably means she wouldn't expect the guy to pay.



Now let's compare that to your perception of what I said:

SG: I'm having a very hard time not believing
sgt: That's still presumptuous (referring back to your conflating my comments with Snides: sgt: I think that is shallow and presumptuous).


I merely said what my gut reaction was. You seem to have stretched that into an assertion of fact.


SG: seriously attractive
sgt: "hot guys"


It's presumptuous of you to decide I meant physically "hot" when there are many ways to interpret "attractive". Apparently that is hard for you to believe. ;)


SG: her reaction would have been very different.
"Tee hee, no thanks, but if you wait till about noon you can ... meet me for breakfast."

sgt: "turn into a quivering ball of sexual desires at the very first glance" (granted this was in reply to the Brad Pitt example, but you did conflate what I said with what Snide said).

Please, enlighten me on the "many ways" one can be attractive, without having any history or prior conversation with the individual, yet having nothing to do with physical appearance. Pheromones; really? Wasn't it established that EG was middle aged?

Agreeing to meet for breakfast at noon the next day is hardly the same as turning into a quivering ball of sexual desires.


Just saying......

I honestly hope I don't have to explain hyperbole but either way, now you are defending your statements against my quoting and responding to Snide. If it appears that my comments have nothing to do with your impression of RW that's probably because it had nothing to do with it. I don't know why you linked those two. The only time I put yours and Snides comments together was in the paragraph that you quoted, which you managed to not address, at all.
 
Maybe, but this is nothing more than mere speculation. We don't know that, right? Or do you have conclusive evidence that, had RW found EG attractive, she wouldn't have found his behavior creepy and wouldn't have said "guys, don't do that"?
Nope. It was an educated guess.

Sure, we can discuss things based on hypothetical facts, but I suggest that we stick to established facts.
Cool. And I suggest that every now and then it's ok for even skeptics to speculate without having to prove anything with evidence. I wasn't trying to convince anyone of anything, after all. Nor was Skeptic Ginger I bet. (Oops, there I go speculating again.) :)
 
I don't think so but if they did I'm happy to correct them. Could you quote them?

It's at the top of this page.

I can only say that I don't like bad things. I can say that if I was faced with unwanted attention I wouldn't like it. I can't say that if an attractive girl in an elevator asked me to her room at 4:00 am I would find that creepy. See the difference?

No and I am not trying to be obtuse. They are saying that they wouldn't like that kind of attention, the same as you.

But there is insufficient information to determine if others would have felt the same. That's the nasty detail in all of this.

We can all say we don't want bad things to happen to us. There is simply know way to extrapolate RW's feelings to everyone else.

The way you can say you wouldn't like unwanted attention is the same way the women that said they would feel uncomfortable with that kind of approach, can say they wouldn't like it. Nobody is trying to apply it across the board, I don't know why you keep saying that.
 
I was speaking from one end of the spectrum to the other. You can still have a negative reaction to an approach, regardless of the level of attraction.



Pretty face, nice smile, well groomed, and taste in clothing still boil down to appearances but I think in the case of well spoken, one would need some kind of exchange to decide that. RW said she didn't speak to him, all night, so that probably wouldn't have been the case in this situation. As a matter of fact, I think it's safe to say that RW does not consider EG well spoken. :D
That's cool. I found your "hotness" bit as a strawman....it was never about how "hot" someone was in SG's hypo, but rather just whether RW would find said person attractive, which of course could happen in many ways other than being "hot." I should have just pointed that out. :)
 
Please, enlighten me on the "many ways" one can be attractive, without having any history or prior conversation with the individual, yet having nothing to do with physical appearance. Pheromones; really? Wasn't it established that EG was middle aged?

I honestly hope I don't have to explain hyperbole but either way, now you are defending your statements against my quoting and responding to Snide. If it appears that my comments have nothing to do with your impression of RW that's probably because it had nothing to do with it. I don't know why you linked those two. The only time I put yours and Snides comments together was in the paragraph that you quoted, which you managed to not address, at all.
I don't suppose you see the hypocrisy in these two paragraphs?

You are the one who conflated Snide's and my remarks. And here you are conflating what I described as "seriously attractive" with sexually attractive.

Even physical attraction can be separate from sexual attraction. Some of my son's friends are physically attractive but I certainly don't feel any sexual attraction toward them. Snide has already pointed out that one can gather all kinds of cues from first impressions that go beyond lust: "Pretty face, nice smile, well-groomed, well-spoken, nice taste in clothes,....many possiblities. Any one of those things might trigger a different response." The reason I said pheromones is because I think there is a legitimate role they play in who is attracted to whom at first encounters.
 
No and I am not trying to be obtuse. They are saying that they wouldn't like that kind of attention, the same as you.
Wait, "kind of attention"? What kind of attention? Unwanted kind? Look, you are missing the point, I wouldn't find being asked out at 4:00 am by an attractive woman creepy nor would I consider it unwanted attention. It only becomes unwanted if I'm not attracted to the woman. I might not feel amenable at the moment but I've never said of an attractive person (she's creepy). By attractive I don't just mean physically so.

The way you can say you wouldn't like unwanted attention is the same way the women that said they would feel uncomfortable with that kind of approach, can say they wouldn't like it.
Those are two very different categories of things. Saying I don't want something bad and saying that a particular approach is bad are apples and oranges. Would the women say that an attractive person would be creepy if he approached them in an elevator and how do we control for bias? (how do we know they have not already judged the situation because of what RW has said)

Nobody is trying to apply it across the board, I don't know why you keep saying that.
Because you keep doing it. You are making assumptions about some percentage of women. If we conducted an experiment with women and found a charming and attractive guy, one that made their hearts skip a beat, how many of them would hear him ask "hey, I find you interesting, would you like to go to my room for coffee" and find that creepy?
 
Last edited:
I don't think so but if they did I'm happy to correct them. Could you quote them?

I can only say that I don't like bad things. I can say that if I was faced with unwanted attention I wouldn't like it. I can't say that if an attractive girl in an elevator asked me to her room at 4:00 am I would find that creepy. See the difference?

But there is insufficient information to determine if others would have felt the same. That's the nasty detail in all of this.

We can all say we don't want bad things to happen to us. There is simply know way to extrapolate RW's feelings to everyone else.
Here, I'll quote us:

Originally Posted by Skeptic Ginger
I'm having a very hard time not believing that if RW had found EG seriously attractive, her reaction would have been very different.

"Tee hee, no thanks, but if you wait till about noon you can buy* meet me for breakfast."


* I concede RW's new role as a feminist probably means she wouldn't expect the guy to pay.
Originally posted by Snide
I tend to agree, which is why several pages ago in the other thread (or was it this one? I don't think so....) I made a point of saying that using Brad Pitt as a hypothetical was not as relevant (or at least as interesting to me) as simply a non-celebrity/stranger who was as attractive as Pitt. I was somewhat confused, then, as to why I was taken a bit to task for something that seemed obvious, but oh well.

I'm agreeing with (or rather, saying "me too" to) SG's first sentence, not the stab at humor that followed. :)


Maybe that's not fair to RW. Maybe it is. I have no proof, and I'm not trying to convince anyone.
 
...
I'm agreeing with (or rather, saying "me too" to) SG's first sentence, not the stab at humor that followed. :)
....
It wasn't a stab at humor, it was a second thought about what I said while I had already had it up there before editing so thought I'd strike it out and show my initial thought.
 
It wasn't a stab at humor, it was a second thought about what I said while I had already had it up there before editing so thought I'd strike it out and show my initial thought.
I was referring to the "tee hee," taking it as tongue-in-cheek. No offense intended.
 
Cool. And I suggest that every now and then it's ok for even skeptics to speculate without having to prove anything with evidence. I wasn't trying to convince anyone of anything, after all. Nor was Skeptic Ginger I bet. (Oops, there I go speculating again.) :)

Sure, no problem with that. In fact, it's difficult to avoid speculations with incidents about which we only have a broad description, but this particular speculation goes a step further than speculations about the nuances of the situation described and judged by RW. A similar speculation would be that the whole incident was made up by RW. Yes, that is possible too, but quite irrelevant to the discussion, don't you think? In both cases (what if she lies about the reasons behind her judgment?/what if she lies about what actually happened?) most people would be in agreement that RW's complaints would have no basis.
 
Back to where we got off track, this doesn't boil down to what Snide or Skeptic Ginger claim they would do in that situation. They were suggesting that RW would have behaved differently, had she been attracted to him.
I think you should read their wording a little closer. They are speculating about what they believe is likely based on a variable. I agree with that. What about the situation makes EG creepy and would someone that RW otherwise finds attractive suddenly become creepy by asking her to coffee at 4:00 am in an elevator? I don't find that their language comports with your claim.
 
Here's the deal folks. You've fantasized about some person. Let's say person X. You wish that somehow some way you could meet this person but you know even if you did it's unlikely that anything would come of it. So, there you are, 4:00 am. It's been a long day and you want to go to sleep. You enter the elevator and turn around and there is the person of your dreams. "Hi", they say, "I find you interesting, would you like to go to my room for coffee?"

Now how many of you have "creepy" leap to your mind?
 
Here's the deal folks. You've fantasized about some person. Let's say person X. You wish that somehow some way you could meet this person but you know even if you did it's unlikely that anything would come of it. So, there you are, 4:00 am. It's been a long day and you want to go to sleep. You enter the elevator and turn around and there is the person of your dreams. "Hi", they say, "I find you interesting, would you like to go to my room for coffee?"

Now how many of you have "creepy" leap to your mind?

Haha! Of course not.

But I don't think it's creepy either way.
 
I don't suppose you see the hypocrisy in these two paragraphs?

You are the one who conflated Snide's and my remarks. And here you are conflating what I described as "seriously attractive" with sexually attractive.

Even physical attraction can be separate from sexual attraction. Some of my son's friends are physically attractive but I certainly don't feel any sexual attraction toward them. Snide has already pointed out that one can gather all kinds of cues from first impressions that go beyond lust: "Pretty face, nice smile, well-groomed, well-spoken, nice taste in clothes,....many possiblities. Any one of those things might trigger a different response." The reason I said pheromones is because I think there is a legitimate role they play in who is attracted to whom at first encounters.

The hot part was in regards to the Brad Pitt scenerio; "attractive as Brad Pitt" (someone who I do not find attractive but apparently a lot of people do). As I said before, pretty face, nice smile, well groomed, and choice in clothing are all physical appearance and I already negated the well spoken part. Now, please, in your own words, what did you mean by attractive?
 
...what did you mean by attractive?
Are there things that YOU find attractive in other people? I want you to imagine that for a moment, that's it. Now you know. It's different for different people.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom