Instead of quoting everyone seperately, I will put it like this: up until the moment he propositioned her, it's fair game; we have no idea what her opinion of his appearance (encompassing everything about what his face looked like, to the way he talked, to the way he walked) was. He didn't become "creepy" to her, until he actually made a proposition that she found creepy so until that moment, all you have is assumptions.
I can't think of an environment that would creep me out if someone I was attracted to asked me out.
Then it's a situation you have yet to be in. I can think of one. My sister, my friend, and I were driving down a highway when we noticed that guy in the car next to us was checking us out. We smiled and waved, then proceeded with our singing and laughing. Miles down the road, my sister pulls off to a gas station and we realized that he had followed us. He wasn't getting gas, he didn't go into the store, his only reason for being there was to approach us. At the time, he was my type; long hair, metal looking, kind of cute, and driving an old Camaro didn't hurt. Still, the approach kind of weirded us all out. We were friendly and gave him a phoney number but spent the rest of the ride looking in our rear view mirror.
It's a rhetorical question. When I'm attracted to someone it doesn't usually creep me out. You?
Is your attraction always final and constant? Does your attraction ever fade as a result of something they said or did?
SG was informing me that there are many ways someone can be attracted to a complete stranger without looks being involved. I am simply asking her to clarify. What I find attractive is irrelavent.
You negated the well-spoken part...huh? You mean you proved it irrelevant? So you don't think how someone asks for coffee can make a difference between annoying/creepy/etc. and attractive? It's a hypo, for Ed's sake. If the spoken word is one's soft spot, Mystery attractive guy could have asked for coffee in a much more attractrive way than EG. You negated nothing, unless I am misunderstanding what you meant by that word.
If it sounded like I was high fiving myself, I am sorry. I wasn't claiming victory over your statement. I was just stating that apparently it wasn't his conversational skills that she "could" have been attracted to because she was creeped out by their first conversation.
I know she said she was not attracted to him. He creeped her out.
If he creeped her out prior to the proposition in the elevator, I must have missed it but from what I recall, it was the invite to his room in the elevator, the conversation in a particular environment that creeped her out.
I haven't assumed anything. I haven't said it was a fact that RW would have acted differently given a more attractive (to her) guy. I said it was hard to believe otherwise. That means I'm not presuming to know, I am only saying what seems more likely to me.
I admit, I was away for a week, redecorating my house but did rules change in that time? When did opinions become immune to scrutiny? If this is the case then apology accepted from all of you for challenging my first statement because I did start it off with "I think..." a clear indication that it was my opinion. When did assume become a statement of fact?
I'm having a very hard time not believing that if RW had found EG seriously attractive, her reaction would have been very different.
It means you are starting off with the premise that she didn't find EG seriously attractive; a premise that lacks any base.