EVIDENCE of skeptic/atheist/freethinker sexism REQUESTED

I'm having a very hard time not believing that if RW had found EG seriously attractive, her reaction would have been very different.

"Tee hee, no thanks, but if you wait till about noon you can buy* meet me for breakfast."


* I concede RW's new role as a feminist probably means she wouldn't expect the guy to pay.
I tend to agree, which is why several pages ago in the other thread (or was it this one? I don't think so....) I made a point of saying that using Brad Pitt as a hypothetical was not as relevant (or at least as interesting to me) as simply a non-celebrity/stranger who was as attractive as Pitt. I was somewhat confused, then, as to why I was taken a bit to task for something that seemed obvious, but oh well. :)
 
I tend to agree, which is why several pages ago in the other thread (or was it this one? I don't think so....) I made a point of saying that using Brad Pitt as a hypothetical was not as relevant (or at least as interesting to me) as simply a non-celebrity/stranger who was as attractive as Pitt. I was somewhat confused, then, as to why I was taken a bit to task for something that seemed obvious, but oh well. :)

I think that is shallow and presumptuous. There probably is a considerable amount of people that would take the invite based on the inviters level of hotness but then there is also the type that don't turn into a quivering ball of sexual desires at the very first glance. Being you are not in RW's head, you just can make that call. Plain and simple, hot does not necessarily outweigh odd.
 
I think that is shallow and presumptuous. There probably is a considerable amount of people that would take the invite based on the inviters level of hotness but then there is also the type that don't turn into a quivering ball of sexual desires at the very first glance. Being you are not in RW's head, you just can make that call. Plain and simple, hot does not necessarily outweigh odd.

Nicely put!
 
I think that is shallow and presumptuous. There probably is a considerable amount of people that would take the invite based on the inviters level of hotness but then there is also the type that don't turn into a quivering ball of sexual desires at the very first glance. Being you are not in RW's head, you just can make that call. Plain and simple, hot does not necessarily outweigh odd.
Lots of "hot" guys are not hot to every woman. That's not what I was referring to.

I said if it had been a guy RW did find attractive, and that is a whole different thing than just a sexy body.
 
I think that is shallow and presumptuous. There probably is a considerable amount of people that would take the invite based on the inviters level of hotness but then there is also the type that don't turn into a quivering ball of sexual desires at the very first glance. Being you are not in RW's head, you just can make that call. Plain and simple, hot does not necessarily outweigh odd.
But this all boils don't to "likely" and what other people might likely think in that situation. If not then the discussion would not be taking place. We are not simply talking about what is in RWs head but what could be in her head and what could be in other people's head.

You can't have it both ways. You can't say that we should extrapolate from RW's experience to most other people as to likely response but we can't extrapolate by hypothetically changing any of the variables.
 
Lots of "hot" guys are not hot to every woman. That's not what I was referring to.

I said if it had been a guy RW did find attractive, and that is a whole different thing than just a sexy body.

That's still presumptuous and when I was referring to "hot guys" I was referring to what the invitee might find as hot. I am curious how it could be anything more than a sexy body, if there was nothing else known about the person.
 
That's still presumptuous and when I was referring to "hot guys" I was referring to what the invitee might find as hot. I am curious how it could be anything more than a sexy body, if there was nothing else known about the person.
Pheromones.
 
But this all boils don't to "likely" and what other people might likely think in that situation. If not then the discussion would not be taking place. We are not simply talking about what is in RWs head but what could be in her head and what could be in other people's head.

You can't have it both ways. You can't say that we should extrapolate from RW's experience to most other people as to likely response but we can't extrapolate by hypothetically changing any of the variables.

It's odd, though, that we feel the need to be factual when it comes to the inherant dangers of elevators or what EG actually meant by coffee but when it comes to negatively representing RW, variables are for the sake of conversation. EG might have been juggling his balls in his pocket when he asked her back to his room. It's not relevant to the discussion because she made no mention of such an act. I find it presumptuous to think that her not liking the approach automatically equates to she was not attracted to him.

I don't recall expecting anyone to extrapolate RW's experience and apply it to all women. As a matter of fact I did say that RW is out of line, presuming to speak for all women. What I did say is that when 40% of the participants (and I was apparently wrong because it was 60%) agree that the experience would have made them uncomfortable, you might want to rethink that particular approach.
 
It's odd, though, that we feel the need to be factual when it comes to the inherant dangers of elevators or what EG actually meant by coffee but when it comes to negatively representing RW, variables are for the sake of conversation. EG might have been juggling his balls in his pocket when he asked her back to his room. It's not relevant to the discussion because she made no mention of such an act. I find it presumptuous to think that her not liking the approach automatically equates to she was not attracted to him.

I don't recall expecting anyone to extrapolate RW's experience and apply it to all women. As a matter of fact I did say that RW is out of line, presuming to speak for all women. What I did say is that when 40% of the participants (and I was apparently wrong because it was 60%) agree that the experience would have made them uncomfortable, you might want to rethink that particular approach.
No because to say "60%" is to do precisely that, presume. To come up with that figure we need to make a hell of a lot of assumptions. These women were not there. They assume that there was some element that was creepy and therefore that would make them uncomfortable. Well duh, but that is presumptuous. So now we need to ask some rather important questions to test those presumptions. No. I'm not going to rethink it.
 
No because to say "60%" is to do precisely that, presume. To come up with that figure we need to make a hell of a lot of assumptions. These women were not there. They assume that there was some element that was creepy and therefore that would make them uncomfortable. Well duh, but that is presumptuous. So now we need to ask some rather important questions to test those presumptions. No. I'm not going to rethink it.

By that same logic, you would also have to concede to not knowing how you or any other individual would react differently than RW, in that same situation. It's a poll type structure to get an idea. It's a sampling to get an idea of the general view and by no means a factual statement.
 
By that same logic, you would also have to concede to not knowing how you or any other individual would react differently than RW, in that same situation.
And I've said so over and over. I have been the subject of unwanted attention on numerous occasions. I can imagine myself in RW's shoes. That's pretty easy.

It's a poll type structure to get an idea. It's a sampling to get an idea of the general view and by no means a factual statement.
I'm not sure what you think you are arguing against. Skepticism and critical thinking would lead us to question any intuitive assumptions. To question those assumptions we need to ask some pertinent questions like, what if the the person being propositioned was attracted to the person doing the propositioning?
 
Last edited:
And I've said so over and over. I have been the subject of unwanted attention on numerous occasions. I can imagine myself in RW's shoes. That's pretty easy.

So can you possibly grant the women that say that they would not appreciate the same propostion might, also have experience with unwanted attention?

I'm not sure what you think you are arguing against. Skepticism and critical thinking would lead us to question any intuitive assumptions. To question those assumptions we need to ask some pertinent questions like, what if the the person being propositioned was attracted to the person doing the propositioning?

You are very correct. So question how anyone knows that RW wasn't attracted to him. Simply saying no does not mean that she wasn't attracted to him. Why aren't you saying, "Maybe she was attracted to him until he approached her in a way that made her uncomfortable."
 
So can you possibly grant the women that say that they would not appreciate the same propostion might, also have experience with unwanted attention?
You can't be serious? Of COURSE!

You are very correct. So question how anyone knows that RW wasn't attracted to him. Simply saying no does not mean that she wasn't attracted to him. Why aren't you saying, "Maybe she was attracted to him until he approached her in a way that made her uncomfortable."
{sigh}

You seriously have me confused with someone else. I've thrown nothing out. If someone is arguing that RW could not possibly have felt uncomfortable I'd happily make that point. Your premise does not change anything. What we have are a lot of variables. If I was arguing that RW was wrong to feel the way she does then I would be presumptuous and any argument I made to support that contention would be easily dealt with by making the very same argument you are making now. I'm not making any such argument. So your premise is pointless as to the discussion at hand.
 
Lots of "hot" guys are not hot to every woman. That's not what I was referring to.

I said if it had been a guy RW did find attractive, and that is a whole different thing than just a sexy body.
Exactly. Plus, who said anything about "taking the invite?" She still absolutely could have said "no thank you," but just had a different outlook on the whole incident.
 
That's still presumptuous and when I was referring to "hot guys" I was referring to what the invitee might find as hot. I am curious how it could be anything more than a sexy body, if there was nothing else known about the person.
Pretty face, nice smile, well-groomed, well-spoken, nice taste in clothes,....many possiblities. Any one of those things might trigger a different response.
 
You can't be serious? Of COURSE!

{sigh}

You seriously have me confused with someone else. I've thrown nothing out. If someone is arguing that RW could not possibly have felt uncomfortable I'd happily make that point. Your premise does not change anything. What we have are a lot of variables. If I was arguing that RW was wrong to feel the way she does then I would be presumptuous and any argument I made to support that contention would be easily dealt with by making the very same argument you are making now. I'm not making any such argument. So your premise is pointless as to the discussion at hand.

Back to where we got off track, this doesn't boil down to what Snide or Skeptic Ginger claim they would do in that situation. They were suggesting that RW would have behaved differently, had she been attracted to him. With you saying that you have experienced unwanted attention so you can imagine yourself in RW's shoes, that's the same thing that the 60% were doing, they weren't presuming, they were identifying with RW. The first has no basis because they don't know how RW felt in the first place, the second, there is at least an experience to assimilate with.
 
Exactly. Plus, who said anything about "taking the invite?" She still absolutely could have said "no thank you," but just had a different outlook on the whole incident.

I was speaking from one end of the spectrum to the other. You can still have a negative reaction to an approach, regardless of the level of attraction.

Pretty face, nice smile, well-groomed, well-spoken, nice taste in clothes,....many possiblities. Any one of those things might trigger a different response.

Pretty face, nice smile, well groomed, and taste in clothing still boil down to appearances but I think in the case of well spoken, one would need some kind of exchange to decide that. RW said she didn't speak to him, all night, so that probably wouldn't have been the case in this situation. As a matter of fact, I think it's safe to say that RW does not consider EG well spoken. :D
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom