EVIDENCE of skeptic/atheist/freethinker sexism REQUESTED

You don't, societal behaviors change, but when someone comes out and says that a certain behavior is creepy and then something in the range of 40% of the participants in that exchange agree that it is creepy...
And you know this 40% because? And if it's possible to convince men not to engage in said behavior is it possible to convince those who find said behavior creepy that their perceptions are perhaps irrational or unwarranted thus significantly reducing the perception?

Communication is always a bit of a crapshoot, especially when cultural lines are crossed, but the more information that is available, the more chance you have at successful communication.
AGREED 100% I would only add that the cool thing about the dialectic is that there is no predeclared outcome. The discussion could lead to several different good outcomes. For instance (though I doubt it) the discussion could lead to elevator hookups everywhere. It could lead to women being less creeped out by men in general. Then again, it could lead to men being more cognizant of the fact that women often are uncomfortable with a range of male behaviors and the men might alter their tack.

IMO, we should discuss and try to persuade the different sides without deciding ahead of time what is absolute right and wrong behavior. The truth is it just doesn't work that way. Never has. Never will. Let's get realistic and try to raise awareness and see where it takes us.
 
Last edited:
You don't, societal behaviors change, but when someone comes out and says that a certain behavior is creepy and then something in the range of 40% of the participants in that exchange agree that it is creepy, it's now known that there is a good chance that you are going to come off as creepy. Communication is always a bit of a crapshoot, especially when cultural lines are crossed, but the more information that is available, the more chance you have at successful communication.

Stats pulled from where ? But anyway let us look at what it means :
* 40% finding it creepy that means that 60% means it is not creepy or have no opinion. Just sayin'.
* Furthermore at which point a behavior become creepy ? When 40% agree it is crrepy ? 51% ? 5% ? 0.1% ?
* who decide that ?
 
Stats pulled from where ? But anyway let us look at what it means :
* 40% finding it creepy that means that 60% means it is not creepy or have no opinion. Just sayin'.
* Furthermore at which point a behavior become creepy ? When 40% agree it is crrepy ? 51% ? 5% ? 0.1% ?
* who decide that ?
And don't fortget to add, how creepy? Minor creepy, EG was a tad too old and not very attractive? Moderately creepy, EG made non-verbal cues indicating he clearly had sex in mind, he was lecherously too old, and very unattractive? Or, major creepy, EG did all of the above and he purposefully and obviously blocked RW's exit from the elevator?
 
Damn, I'm jealous. I didn't deserve a mention?

Linda
That's funny because one of the thoughts I had was, wow, I made it into the category of people who are hated enough someone attacked outside of the forum. But then I realized it wasn't the first time. The first time was when I got involved in a blog about no atheists in foxholes. The blogger had a slew of defending friends.

Hmmm, or maybe it was before that. It's kind of a blur. :p
 
Last edited:
That's funny because one of the thoughts I had was, wow, I made it into the category of people who are hated enough someone attacked outside of the forum. But then I realized it wasn't the first time. The first time was when I got involved in a blog about no atheists in foxholes. The blogger had a slew of defending friends.

Hmmm, or maybe it was before that. It's kind of a blur. :p
I attacked you to my orthodontist once. I was coming out of anesthesia and he asked me who skeptic girl was. Then he said I must not like you very much. Who knows. ;)
 
I attacked you to my orthodontist once. I was coming out of anesthesia and he asked me who skeptic girl was. Then he said I must not like you very much. Who knows. ;)
You know, I can't remember why I put you on ignore once. You are so much more fun now that you've changed political parties. :)
 
And don't fortget to add, how creepy? Minor creepy, EG was a tad too old and not very attractive? Moderately creepy, EG made non-verbal cues indicating he clearly had sex in mind, he was lecherously too old, and very unattractive? Or, major creepy, EG did all of the above and he purposefully and obviously blocked RW's exit from the elevator?

I can partially understand the too old (because the experience of life assymetry), but finding that people which are not attractive making a pass are more creepy than people which are attractive making the same exact pass at somebody, I saw that reaction in real life, and I never *EVER* understood why people felt that way.

Probably because I have always looked old and unatractive even when I was 20 :D.
 
You don't, societal behaviors change, but when someone comes out and says that a certain behavior is creepy and then something in the range of 40% of the participants in that exchange agree that it is creepy, it's now known that there is a good chance that you are going to come off as creepy. Communication is always a bit of a crapshoot, especially when cultural lines are crossed, but the more information that is available, the more chance you have at successful communication.

I'd like to say thank you. I share your opinion in this and other posts you have made, but you are able to state that opinion more clearly and concisely than I have managed.

Stats pulled from where ?
I think she may be referring to some posts I made earlier in this thread where I gave the results of my review of approx 2,000 posts from two different sites and allocated those who were female regarding whether they stated they would find such an invitation uncomfortable or whether it would not bother them. I found slightly more than 60% of females who stated an opinion to be on the uncomfortable side.
 
And don't fortget to add, how creepy? Minor creepy, EG was a tad too old and not very attractive? Moderately creepy, EG made non-verbal cues indicating he clearly had sex in mind, he was lecherously too old, and very unattractive? Or, major creepy, EG did all of the above and he purposefully and obviously blocked RW's exit from the elevator?
The crux of the entire problem. The problem with gathering this type of data is that it's so difficult to control for preconception. RW used the word creepy so when women voice an opinion are they thinking of Brad pit when they wonder if a request in an elevator would creep them out or are they thinking of some creep? Yeah, being asked out by someone you think is creepy can be creepy, regardless of the situation.
 
The crux of the entire problem. The problem with gathering this type of data is that it's so difficult to control for preconception. RW used the word creepy so when women voice an opinion are they thinking of Brad pit when they wonder if a request in an elevator would creep them out or are they thinking of some creep? Yeah, being asked out by someone you think is creepy can be creepy, regardless of the situation.
I'm having a very hard time not believing that if RW had found EG seriously attractive, her reaction would have been very different.

"Tee hee, no thanks, but if you wait till about noon you can buy* meet me for breakfast."


* I concede RW's new role as a feminist probably means she wouldn't expect the guy to pay.
 
* I concede RW's new role as a feminist probably means she wouldn't expect the guy to pay.

Never ever? I mean, I must be a stressful experience to have a date with a radical feminist.

"Why did you pay?", "why did you keep the door open for me?".

Hell, the next time I see a radical feminist I'll slam the door in her face and then I'll wait for her aproval, because, "hey I'm in your team". :boggled:

I'm joking, of course. But on the other hand I've had some awkward situations when keeping doors open for women, when in fact I act identically with men. It's very subtle. It's more about glances telling me "what do you mean" than verbal disaproval. Does anyone know what I'm talking about?

Sorry for the digression. I'll let you with the discussion of a rather unimportant issue (the fact that a man dared to invite a woman for coffee in his room at 4.00 a.m in a hotel elevator when he wasn't given a non-verbal cue previously).
 
Never ever? I mean, I must be a stressful experience to have a date with a radical feminist.

"Why did you pay?", "why did you keep the door open for me?".

Hell, the next time I see a radical feminist I'll slam the door in her face and then I'll wait for her aproval, because, "hey I'm in your team". :boggled:

I'm joking, of course. But on the other hand I've had some awkward situations when keeping doors open for women, when in fact I act identically with men. It's very subtle. It's more about glances telling me "what do you mean" than verbal disaproval. Does anyone know what I'm talking about?

Sorry for the digression. I'll let you with the discussion of a rather unimportant issue (the fact that a man dared to invite a woman for coffee in his room at 4.00 a.m in a hotel elevator when he wasn't given a non-verbal cue previously).

I hear about this door thing a lot - "Oh, feminists hate it when you open a door for them!" but I've talked it over with feminist friends and the general consensus is "Who cares? They hold the door, I hold the door, whatever. Nod or say thanks and go about your day."

Now, I'm not saying that you haven't gotten the odd look. When people are walking, they are thinking about stuff - their job, the bills, the grocery list - if those thoughts involve stress, it will show on their face. That doesn't mean that it's about you, the door or some vague pseudo-feminist principal. Just that you caught them at a weird moment.

As the radical feminist who would be the recipient of your act, I have a few questions. First off, how would you know? I don't go walking around town in a Venus symbol t-shirt with my fist held high. Secondly, you fantasize about slamming a door in a stranger's face in response to a subtle glance from a different stranger at a previous time? Seems a bit much.
 
I'm joking, of course. But on the other hand I've had some awkward situations when keeping doors open for women, when in fact I act identically with men. It's very subtle. It's more about glances telling me "what do you mean" than verbal disaproval. Does anyone know what I'm talking about?

I would imagine you have been the recipient of these non-verbal cues Bookitty, Rebecca Watson, etc. have been talking about, which Elevator Guy should have noticed were absent. I predict that Bookitty will now congratulate you for entering the realm of "non-creep" by demonstrating that you are able to attend to these clues and modify your behaviour. The sound you hear when the door slams will be cheers.

Linda
 
I hear about this door thing a lot - "Oh, feminists hate it when you open a door for them!" but I've talked it over with feminist friends and the general consensus is "Who cares? They hold the door, I hold the door, whatever. Nod or say thanks and go about your day."

It was a joke.

Now, I'm not saying that you haven't gotten the odd look. When people are walking, they are thinking about stuff - their job, the bills, the grocery list - if those thoughts involve stress, it will show on their face. That doesn't mean that it's about you, the door or some vague pseudo-feminist principal. Just that you caught them at a weird moment.
It was a joke.

A woman might stop for a second and think "is he doing this because I'm a woman?", while a man might think "I hope she doesn't think I'm doing this because she's a woman". Which is all very trivial and subtle. I've talked about this with women, even after being in this situation with them.

As the radical feminist who would be the recipient of your act, I have a few questions. First off, how would you know? I don't go walking around town in a Venus symbol t-shirt with my fist held high. Secondly, you fantasize about slamming a door in a stranger's face in response to a subtle glance from a different stranger at a previous time? Seems a bit much.
It was a joke.
 
Last edited:
....
As the radical feminist who would be the recipient of your act, I have a few questions. ...
Radical feminist? Interesting.

Radical feminism considers the male-controlled capitalist hierarchy, which it describes as sexist, as the defining feature of women's oppression. Radical feminists believe that women can free themselves only when they have done away with what they consider an inherently oppressive and dominating patriarchal system. Radical feminists feel that there is a male-based authority and power structure and that it is responsible for oppression and inequality, and that, as long as the system and its values are in place, society will not be able to be reformed in any significant way. Some radical feminists see no alternatives other than the total uprooting and reconstruction of society in order to achieve their goals.[16]
Over time a number of sub-types of radical feminism have emerged, such as cultural feminism, separatist feminism, and anti-pornography feminism, the last opposed by sex-positive feminism.


I lean more toward liberated feminism myself.
Liberal feminism asserts the equality of men and women through political and legal reform. It is an individualistic form of feminism, which focuses on women's ability to show and maintain their equality through their own actions and choices. Liberal feminism uses the personal interactions between men and women as the place from which to transform society. According to liberal feminists, all women are capable of asserting their ability to achieve equality, therefore it is possible for change to happen without altering the structure of society. Issues important to liberal feminists include reproductive and abortion rights, sexual harassment, voting, education, "equal pay for equal work", affordable childcare, affordable health care, and bringing to light the frequency of sexual and domestic violence against women.[1]


Not that there is any way to adequately define such terms. But the gist seems to fit the discussion in this thread.
 
And you know this 40% because? And if it's possible to convince men not to engage in said behavior is it possible to convince those who find said behavior creepy that their perceptions are perhaps irrational or unwarranted thus significantly reducing the perception?

Early on in this thread, Beth already answered that for me.

AGREED 100% I would only add that the cool thing about the dialectic is that there is no predeclared outcome. The discussion could lead to several different good outcomes. For instance (though I doubt it) the discussion could lead to elevator hookups everywhere. It could lead to women being less creeped out by men in general. Then again, it could lead to men being more cognizant of the fact that women often are uncomfortable with a range of male behaviors and the men might alter their tack.

I like talking, I love meeting interesting people and having conversations that go on forever. This particular situation wasn't about two people that met, talked all night, and then he invited her to his room. He skipped all the formalities and went right to it, in a place that apparently (and I stress apparently because outside of the skeptic community, it could be quite different) a lot of women would not appreciate that kind of approach.

Stats pulled from where ? But anyway let us look at what it means :
* 40% finding it creepy that means that 60% means it is not creepy or have no opinion. Just sayin'.
* Furthermore at which point a behavior become creepy ? When 40% agree it is crrepy ? 51% ? 5% ? 0.1% ?
* who decide that ?

Apparently I had the stats wrong, it was more like 60%. It's not an either/or when you are dealing with people who have opinions. The behavior is not tried and judged as creepy, I just said that 40% who participated in that discussion found it creepy, which was wrong and I was being hasty. 60% said it would make them feel uncomfortable.
 
And don't fortget to add, how creepy? Minor creepy, EG was a tad too old and not very attractive? Moderately creepy, EG made non-verbal cues indicating he clearly had sex in mind, he was lecherously too old, and very unattractive? Or, major creepy, EG did all of the above and he purposefully and obviously blocked RW's exit from the elevator?

I don't think he forgot to add anything; Why would he ask me that? I wasn't in the elevator that night, so I wouldn't be able to answer that.
 
This particular situation wasn't about two people that met, talked all night, and then he invited her to his room.
Not my point. I'm not talking about RW and EG talking. My point is that WE talk about the issues. Though to be fair you were talking about the meeting between RW and EG so my bad.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom