EVIDENCE of skeptic/atheist/freethinker sexism REQUESTED

@mid - the list I posted of fields in which women have contributed little was:
Whether pro or con, women have, in fact, like it or not, contributed little. If you think these are 'a bunch of stupid conspiracy theories' then you are considerably ignorant and naive. The book review draws attention specifically to activism rather than writings, theory etc, but the record there also shows they have contributed little.

Women have been involved in lots of activisim such as at Greenham Common, the anti war movement, the suffrage movement, temperance, the abolition of slavery movement etc. to name just a few that spring to mind. Just because they aren't necessarily involved in the activisim you're interested in doesn't negate it.
As for your list:

crime statistics evaluation: I work with a number of women that are looking at crime stats at the moment.
Shakespeare authorship: the idea that Shakespeare didn’t write his works is fringe and vaguely snobbish, unless of course you’re just claiming that he wrote his own works and he was a man?
World War 2 and 'Holocaust' work: again there’s a number of female historians. Unless you’re claiming there’s not many female holecaust deniers, in which case good for women.
NASA frauds & 9-11: let’s just bunch these under stupid conspiracy theories.
insecticides and poisoning: to which I’ll respond Rachel Carson (I’ll leave it to another day as to whether her contribution was beneficial)
investigators of mistakes in biological science: there’s plenty of female biologists
weaponry and war crimes: a number of peace campaigners and campaingners for human rights are female
mistakes in educational practices: no idea what this means
population problems: I’ll grant you that Malthus was male
Jews and paper money: glad to see women aren’t wasting their time with that drivel either
honest criticisms of religion: there’s plenty of female aithests/agnostics and relgious sceptics as well as believers
anti-war activity: have you ever seen an anti war march? It’s not all men there you know
truth about Islam: no idea nor do I care what you’re getting at there
global warming-climate change: again there is such things as female scientists you know
Norway killings: yes you’re right the killer is male
Darwin as plagiarist of Wallace: another silly idea
 
Last edited:
I think David "Unabashed Nazi Fanboi No. 1" Irving might think Deborah Lippstadt did contribute to the historiography of the holocaust.
 
@mid - the list I posted of fields in which women have contributed little was:
Whether pro or con, women have, in fact, like it or not, contributed little. If you think these are 'a bunch of stupid conspiracy theories' then you are considerably ignorant and naive. The book review draws attention specifically to activism rather than writings, theory etc, but the record there also shows they have contributed little.

Activism? Really? Well, it sure was nice of all those men to protest for female reproductive rights.

If you are seriously suggesting that women have stayed away from your list of fields, I can only take it as a compliment to my sex. Thank you.
 
Kitty - you appear to be the only female commentator here. I don't know if you have any formal, or informal, education. You say:--
If you are seriously suggesting that women have stayed away from your list of fields, I can only take it as a compliment to my sex. Thank you.
Let's look at them:--

** crime statistics evaluation. One of very many issues here is assaults and rapes on white women by blacks; the figures, if accurate, show these to be enormously higher than the other way round. If you support that, well, it's your choice.
** Shakespeare authorship is an issue involving the most literary man who ever lived, and the full undersatnding of his works. Possibly you're not interested in literary culture.
** World War 2 and 'Holocaust' work. There are many issues here, including mass murder in the USSR by Stalin, the rights and otherwise of huge wars, and thge truth of what happened in the whole region of eastern Europe. As far as I know, women have done little work in any of these or related fields.
** NASA frauds, 9-11 Involve huge amounts of money, destroyed raw materials, and corruption of science. I'm pretty sure women have done little work here, apart from e.g. forming groups in New York to try to get serious investigations.
** Insecticides and poisoning: the organophosphate debate, such as it was, in Britain showed a connection between neurological damage to farm animals (and people) caused by these chemicals. Again, women played little part in any investiagtions.
** investigators of mistakes in biological science. This will mean nothing to you, or most readers, so I won't emphasise it; but there is systematic fraud in biology. However, women have played little part in investigating this, either pro or co.
** Weaponry and war crimes. This is a large topic, and quite a serious one, as you very possibly don't know. However, women have done little to investigate or publicise, or anything else.
** Well, there are these too. ... mistakes in educational practices/ population problems/ Jews and paper money/ honest criticisms of religion/ anti-war activity/ truth about Islam/ global warming-climate change/ Norway killings/ Darwin as plagiarist of Wallace ... However it seems unlikely you'll read this far.

It's not a compliment to your sex.
 
Last edited:
You seem to equate your personal interests and the sides you support in them as the measure of what is rational discourse. Dare I suggest that might not be the case?
Your passive-aggressive attempts at insults like you don't the status of bookitty's education are also noted. I think they are puerile and do not contribute to the argument you wish to make.
 
Kitty - you appear to be the only female commentator here. I don't know if you have any formal, or informal, education. You say:--

Let's look at them:--

** crime statistics evaluation. One of very many issues here is assaults and rapes on white women by blacks; the figures, if accurate, show these to be enormously higher than the other way round. If you support that, well, it's your choice.
** Shakespeare authorship is an issue involving the most literary man who ever lived, and the full undersatnding of his works. Possibly you're not interested in literary culture.
** World War 2 and 'Holocaust' work. There are many issues here, including mass murder in the USSR by Stalin, the rights and otherwise of huge wars, and thge truth of what happened in the whole region of eastern Europe. As far as I know, women have done little work in any of these or related fields.
** NASA frauds, 9-11 Involve huge amounts of money, destroyed raw materials, and corruption of science. I'm pretty sure women have done little work here, apart from e.g. forming groups in New York to try to get serious investigations.
** Insecticides and poisoning: the organophosphate debate, such as it was, in Britain showed a connection between neurological damage to farm animals (and people) caused by these chemicals. Again, women played little part in any investiagtions.
** investigators of mistakes in biological science. This will mean nothing to you, or most readers, so I won't emphasise it; but there is systematic fraud in biology. However, women have played little part in investigating this, either pro or co.
** Weaponry and war crimes. This is a large topic, and quite a serious one, as you very possibly don't know. However, women have done little to investigate or publicise, or anything else.
** Well, there are these too. ... mistakes in educational practices/ population problems/ Jews and paper money/ honest criticisms of religion/ anti-war activity/ truth about Islam/ global warming-climate change/ Norway killings/ Darwin as plagiarist of Wallace ... However it seems unlikely you'll read this far.

It's not a compliment to your sex.

Just because you don't mean it as a compliment doesn't mean that I am not flattered. Especially after reading the homage to female intellect you've post above.
 

investigators of mistakes in biological science: there’s plenty of female biologists
Indeed when I read that category Frances Oldham Kelsey immediately came to mind, but I doubt Rerevisionist has ever heard of her, being too busy believing in his numerous, and contradictory, conspiracies.
 
bookitty doesn't seem able to manage more than a sentence.

catsmate - out of a whole list of subjects - picks one, and one irrelevant to the issue, which is rationalist criticism.

moss - I didn't know then, and still don't know, bookitty's educational level, since her replies are all but non-existent. It's not puerile to try to establsih whether a commentator knows what he/she is talking about.

Anyway; women have contributed little to serious topics; fact. Whether this will change remains to be seen; I have to say I doubt it very much.
 
I think Rerevisionist might want to research who got the first Nobel Peace Prize. Or who Tawakel Karman or Shirin Ebadi are. How about Waris Dirie?
As for criticism of Islam whether warranted or not: Try Seyran Ates. Try Ayaan Hirsi Ali.
For historians see above. Add Brigitte Harmann. Never heard of Hannah Arendt(Though she actually is more of a very interesting philosopher).
Do I need to go on?

ETA: List of female Nobel Prize laureates
 
Last edited:
I think Rerevisionist might want to research who got the first Nobel Peace Prize. Or who Tawakel Karman or Shirin Ebadi are. How about Waris Dirie?
As for criticism of Islam whether warranted or not: Try Seyran Ates. Try Ayaan Hirsi Ali.
For historians see above. Add Brigitte Harmann. Never heard of Hannah Arendt(Though she actually is more of a very interesting philosopher).
Do I need to go on?

ETA: List of female Nobel Prize laureates

From that article:

Following the awards of 2011 (other than the 2011 Economics Prize), the Nobel Prize has been awarded 807 times to men and 44 times to women (there have also been 23 awards to organizations).
 
The interesting bit to me is that a lot of those Nobel Prizes awarded to females were awarded in those areas Rerevisionist happens to think they did not participate overmuch in.
 
The interesting bit to me is that a lot of those Nobel Prizes awarded to females were awarded in those areas Rerevisionist happens to think they did not participate overmuch in.

Indeed. It seems to go with the trend of women being more represented in 'soft' areas rather than 'hard' sciences, and a very low representation overall in innovation.
 
What disappointing replies.

Yes, of course I'm serious - more serious than a pink and green plastic toy.

I'm not sure how many people here imagine that Nobel 'laureates' are awarded for serious work; I would guess probably all. Even in economics, and even for 'peace', with Kissinger a notable counter-example. I don't want to argue it here, but quite a high proportion of Nobel 'prizes' are for work which is fraudulent; they're not something I'd use in serious debate.

I have heard of Greenham Common, yes. What I haven't heard is female researchers seriously investigating nuclear weapons or nuclear power.

Serious criticism of Islam, and for that matter its tribal near-twin Judaism, is almost non-existent. Regrettably as of course women are likely to come out losers in the absence of criticism.

I notice nobody has commented on race and crime, or Shakespeare, or other serious topics which I listed.

Also, it's a bit disappointing that someone who starts a thread like this responds with a 'troll' comment rather than something intelligent.
 
a) You are derailing the thread
b) you stay pretty vague
c) Your selfselected interests are not necessarily relevant to a discussion of rationality
d) this is boring.
 
Yes, of course I'm serious - more serious than a pink and green plastic toy.

Given your track record of believing nearly every CT that has come down the pike:

"crime statistics evaluation/ Shakespeare authorship/ World War 2 and 'Holocaust' work/ NASA frauds/ 9-11/ insecticides and poisoning/ investigators of mistakes in biological science/ weaponry and war crimes/ mistakes in educational practices/ population problems/ Jews and paper money/ honest criticisms of religion/ anti-war activity/ truth about Islam/ global warming-climate change/ Norway killings/ Darwin as plagiarist of Wallace"

Yeah, I'm sure you're very serious indeed.

:D
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom