EVIDENCE of skeptic/atheist/freethinker sexism REQUESTED

Sgt, you've drifted into rationalizing instead of actually discussing issues. There no sense going further with this.
 
Conceded. I'm still not sure how "I was attracted to this guy but he creeped me out" is reconciled? I doubt most of us who found the object of our affection asking us out in an elevator would suddenly be creeped out. If Eva Mendez leaned over in an elevator at 4:00 am and asked me to her room for coffee I WOULDN'T BE CREEPED OUT.

I honestly don't think most people would IF the person doing the propositioning was a desirable person (attractive). I reject that the time and place are defacto reasons for being creeped out for the vast majority of people

"I was attracted to this guy until he creeped me out."

It's possible over the phone. If I found her hot in person, no, very not likely. I can excuse an awful lot. Given how many people hook up with deplorable people I think it's safe to say most people can. Not every one makes snap judgements.

A lot of hookups happen when both parties are looking for hookups. RW said she was looking to go to sleep.

I thought we were discussing a larger point. I apologize. I agree that there was nothing other than the guys looks and his words he spoke at that moment.

Things get mashed up and I may have gotten off track.
 
Good lord this is a monster thread. I'm just here to comment on one thing. Yeah it's not outrageous to get hit on, yes you can get over it and no it won't send anyone sane home blubbing or anything. But it is also not fun to go to a social event where you just want to get into some interesting conversations and every other person is hitting on you. It's not horrible. It's just tiresome. And if you're talking about wanting to encourage people to participate in your social events it's usually a good idea to try to create a situation that is not tiresome.

Look at the title. This whole mess exists, in part, because EG's behavior has been presented, by Watson and sycophants, as proof perfect of pervasive sexism that is keeping vast numbers of women away from skeptic groups.

The thread was asking for, at least, some confirming evidence of such pervasive sexism. As far as I can see, nothing much has been presented. A couple of anecdotes, enough to show that some are sexist, which is about as surprising that white paper is white. Some skeptics are even completely nuts, and all groups have to deal with this sort of thing.

So people keep going back to the original video and incident, I think because it's the part of this where Watson's statements and actions are the most defensible. (There is also the apparent belief, which I find hard to understand, that the way to make rude men behave better is to pontificate at other men. I don't see much evidence that this has worked over the past 30 years, and I don't expect it magically to start working now.)

In any event, Watson's subsequent statements have become far less defensible, and rather little evidence has been presented for the kind of pervasive sexism that Watson is waving her hands about.
 
Look at the title. This whole mess exists, in part, because EG's behavior has been presented, by Watson and sycophants, as proof perfect of pervasive sexism that is keeping vast numbers of women away from skeptic groups.

Fair enough. I agree pretty much everything that has followed is ridiculous internets drama of the highest order. I don't really understand why that nonsense can't be dropped and the whole thing scaled back to the bare bones. Though it baffles me that 'try not to hit on people if you can't tell whether they are enjoying it' is a controversial position met by cries of 'but why not no fair you want me to be a monk then or what' etc etc. Either way I agree that the whole thing is essentially pointless. The people most likely to turn women off of such gatherings are the same people who will not accept advice like that, or else will not cotton on to the fact they are 'doing it wrong' in the first place.

As far as the evidence SG wants to collect, that idea seems pretty worthlessly post hoc. If you really want something to go on you'd be better off asking women who attend these events to start documenting their current experiences, wouldn't you? Otherwise you might as well be collecting half-remembered UFO sightings. And I for one wouldn't bother submitting such tosh for anyone's perusal. It seems like a waste of time.
 
... If you really want something to go on you'd be better off asking women who attend these events to start documenting their current experiences, wouldn't you? Otherwise you might as well be collecting half-remembered UFO sightings. And I for one wouldn't bother submitting such tosh for anyone's perusal. It seems like a waste of time.
That would be nice. I did, however, mention earlier in the thread that the ideal data collection and/or study just wasn't within my capabilities and this was the next best thing. If you have the resources to do a proper study, go for it. :D
 
Fair enough. I agree pretty much everything that has followed is ridiculous internets drama of the highest order. I don't really understand why that nonsense can't be dropped and the whole thing scaled back to the bare bones. Though it baffles me that 'try not to hit on people if you can't tell whether they are enjoying it' is a controversial position met by cries of 'but why not no fair you want me to be a monk then or what' etc etc. Either way I agree that the whole thing is essentially pointless. The people most likely to turn women off of such gatherings are the same people who will not accept advice like that, or else will not cotton on to the fact they are 'doing it wrong' in the first place.

This is probably the best statement to come out of this whole thing. Very well said!
 
Unfortunately, there are sound reasons for sexism. I hope this isn't too long. It's my book review of The Protestor's Handbook by Bibi van Der Zee (published in Britain) highlighting the depressing way women won't think for themselves.

Guardian Books 2008, retitled and reprinted unchanged 2010

Guardian Books seems to be an imprint of the Guardian newspaper. In the most hypocritical manner possible, the Guardian is owned by or connected with the Scott Trust, or Scott Trust Limited, which does everything in a purely profit-making and tax-avoiding basis.

The authoress of this book appears to be purely journalistic; there are sections contributed by four lawyers, on subjects related to activism and protest, but her contributions are mainly interviews, with a few accounts of visits (e.g. to south America). It's not clear whether the interviews were hers, or the result of raiding Guardian files. Some may have been telephone interviews. Much of the material is biographical - a few random examples are: a Palestine Solidarity Group, protected by police, at a 'crucial' football match with Israel; Jon Trickett, a (then?) Labour MP who lobbied for a clause 'to include in their annual review anything that might harm profits because it endangers the company's reputation'; Sue who wanted to throw eggs at Tony Blair's car; Ralph Nader; Dave Currey, a wildlife trafficking investigator.

...

Edited for compliance with Rule 4. Do not copy and paste lengthy tracts of text from elsewhere. Instead, cite a short quote and post a link to the source.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: LashL
 
Last edited by a moderator:
<spammed book review snipped>
Is this supposed to be relevant to something? Or are you just unhappy that few women fall for your various delusions? Holocaust denial, nuclear energy denial, moon landing denial, AGW denial et cetera.

The leading people in all the following fields: crime statistics evaluation/ Shakespeare authorship/ World War 2 and 'Holocaust' work/ NASA frauds/ 9-11/ insecticides and poisoning/ investigators of mistakes in biological science/ weaponry and war crimes/ mistakes in educational practices/ population problems/ Jews and paper money/ honest criticisms of religion/ anti-war activity/ truth about Islam/ global warming-climate change/ Norway killings/ Darwin as plagiarist of Wallace etc etc etc and of course nuclear matters are virtually all male. Disappointingly, there seems no realistic chance that women in any numbers will have significant effects on genuine and important ideas.
 
The thread was asking for, at least, some confirming evidence of such pervasive sexism. As far as I can see, nothing much has been presented. A couple of anecdotes, enough to show that some are sexist, which is about as surprising that white paper is white. Some skeptics are even completely nuts, and all groups have to deal with this sort of thing.
I agree, the action (or over-reaction) of individuals doesn't necessarily translate into systemic issues. Not to mention "hitting on" is a pretty subjective social situation (Ooh, a pun).

I'm pretty sure some atheists have committed murder, etc... that doesn't mean atheists are all murderers, etc...
 
Catsmate, I'm pointing out, as a matter of fact rather than wishful thinking, that, as things stand, women do not contribute much to rational thought.

I didn't ask them not to; I would prefer it if the opposite were true; however, it isn't.
 
Catsmate, I'm pointing out, as a matter of fact rather than wishful thinking, that, as things stand, women do not contribute much to rational thought.

I didn't ask them not to; I would prefer it if the opposite were true; however, it isn't.

You post a book review, of a book written by a woman, and then claim that women do not contribute much to rational thought. How can you relate the writing of one person and extrapolate that to half the population?

Most women that I know think as rationally as most men. Here are some facts from the Department of The Blindingly Obvious:

1) Not everyone thinks the same way.
2) Not everyone is concerned by the same things that concern you
3) Many people, of both sexes, do not think rationally.
 
You post a book review, of a book written by a woman, and then claim that women do not contribute much to rational thought. How can you relate the writing of one person and extrapolate that to half the population?

Most women that I know think as rationally as most men. Here are some facts from the Department of The Blindingly Obvious:

1) Not everyone thinks the same way.
2) Not everyone is concerned by the same things that concern you
3) Many people, of both sexes, do not think rationally.
Don't forget that Rerevisionist refuses to accept the well documented reality about the Holocaust, the 11SEP terrorist attacks, nuclear energy, AGW and many other matters. Any connection he has with 'rational thought' are tenuous at best.
 
It's quite funny to read these ridiculous replies. That book was published and presumably sold quite a few copies; it also includes many examples of phoney female activists, who take the official line on such topics as 'climate change'. The total number of women who are indirectly included in that review is therefore very large.

The original poster seems to assume 'sexism' is any comment comparing female abilities etc with male - though it's not entirely clear. It also assumes that anyone who calls him/herself a freethinker etc actually is one, which of course is not the case.
____________

My book review has been cut - it's on Amazon; but I'm not sure the link is allowed. The point is it's a very detailed review including a survey of a lot of protestable material, a lot of which however is not protested against------
http://www.amazon.co.uk/product-rev...?ie=UTF8&showViewpoints=0&filterBy=addTwoStar
 
Last edited:
It's quite funny to read these ridiculous replies. That book was published and presumably sold quite a few copies; it also includes many examples of phoney female activists, who take the official line on such topics as 'climate change'. The total number of women who are indirectly included in that review is therefore very large.

The original poster seems to assume 'sexism' is any comment comparing female abilities etc with male - though it's not entirely clear. It also assumes that anyone who calls him/herself a freethinker etc actually is one, which of course is not the case.
____________

My book review has been cut - it's on Amazon; but I'm not sure the link is allowed. The point is it's a very detailed review including a survey of a lot of protestable material, a lot of which however is not protested against------
http://www.amazon.co.uk/product-rev...?ie=UTF8&showViewpoints=0&filterBy=addTwoStar

So you're saying that women generally don't believe a bunch of stupid conspiracy theories, and that's your problem with them?

I doubt this will be a convincing argument for sexism
 
@mid - the list I posted of fields in which women have contributed little was:
crime statistics evaluation/ Shakespeare authorship/ World War 2 and 'Holocaust' work/ NASA frauds/ 9-11/ insecticides and poisoning/ investigators of mistakes in biological science/ weaponry and war crimes/ mistakes in educational practices/ population problems/ Jews and paper money/ honest criticisms of religion/ anti-war activity/ truth about Islam/ global warming-climate change/ Norway killings/ Darwin as plagiarist of Wallace
Whether pro or con, women have, in fact, like it or not, contributed little. If you think these are 'a bunch of stupid conspiracy theories' then you are considerably ignorant and naive. The book review draws attention specifically to activism rather than writings, theory etc, but the record there also shows they have contributed little.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom