EVIDENCE of skeptic/atheist/freethinker sexism REQUESTED

I never said it was impossible. You've really got to stop with that dichotomy. It's not the point. It's not typical. That leads us to question the bias of those who say they would be creeped out. How likely is it they are simply asserting that they wouldn't like to be in a situation that made them uncomfortable? As opposed to saying that this situation would always make them uncomfortable simply because of all the other variables. How do we know that attractiveness of the person making the proposition has been factored?

How did you get "impossible" from "it's a situation you have to be in..." Stop arguing against things I didn't say. "It's a situation you have to be in..." is a statement which leaves open the possibility of changing your mind with experience. You don't know if attraction is a factor but suggesting that things would be different if she was attracted to him is loaded.

Of course. Not typical though. We tend to be much more forgiving for people we are attracted to.

"You burp and guys think its adorable. You puke and they line up to hold your hair back. " --Truth about cats and dogs.

Are you speaking for everyone or just your own person experience? Yes, people can be more forgiving if there is an attraction but if she puked on your shoes on your first introduction, would you find yourself compelled to get her number or would that be a turn off?

Right? Even given your example I don't doubt many women would say "yeah that creeps me out" but if they were approached by someone that made their heart skip a beat suddenly that all goes out the window. You said in your example that it was someone you could be attracted to. You didn't say you were. Did you decide you were not attracted to this person before or after you decided his behavior was odd?

I didn't say could, I said he was my type; meaning, if we had met under less odd circumstances I might have gone for it. being followed off a highway is not my idea of romantic, it's a bit stalker-ish for me.

NO! I'm sorry but this is just wrong. It's VERY relevant. SG can't speak for everyone nor should she have to. She's only saying that attraction is more (or can be more) than looks. Will you not concede that to be true? Why does this have to be like pulling teeth? If YOU can find something not physically attractive then THAT is your answer.

SG was letting me know what there is, when there is zero prior knowledge of the person, many ways of being attracted to someone that don't involve looks. I'm still waiting for that answer. If you have some, by all means, share. Obviously, my view is, if you are checking out someone from across the room, it's probably not for their book collection but I am open for suggestions.
 
How did you get "impossible" from "it's a situation you have to be in..."
If it's not impossible then your point is moot.

Are you speaking for everyone...
Since my point has always been that it's wrong to extrapolate from an individual to a group then you know that answer.

...or just your own person experience? Yes, people can be more forgiving if there is an attraction but if she puked on your shoes on your first introduction, would you find yourself compelled to get her number or would that be a turn off?
I would absolutely get her number.

I didn't say could, I said he was my type; meaning, if we had met under less odd circumstances I might have gone for it.
Which is my point. Had you been attracted to that person you likely would not have found the situation creepy. You didn't formulate your opinion until after the incident. Had you seen this guy first, even a few moments before the possible stalker idea entered your brain, and was smitten it likely wouldn't have been a big deal. People have a very powerful ability to rationalize to get what their heart desires.

SG was letting me know what there is, when there is zero prior knowledge of the person, many ways of being attracted to someone that don't involve looks.
Are you really so lacking in imagination? I'm very attracted to Robyn Quivers (Howard Stern show) and I was so for years before I ever saw her. Many things women say I find attractive. The way the say things I can find attractive. What they do I can find attractive. Simply being in a skeptics conference I can find attractive. Simply stating a preference for something I can find attractive. A smile, bubbly personality, wit, giggle, smart quip, etc.
 
Last edited:
I think "creepy" is negatively correlated to being attracted to.

I can't think of an environment that would creep me out if someone I was attracted to asked me out.

Really? because I can think of a few. I was closing up the bar one time, had already locked up the front door (deadbolt) and found a guy sleeping like a baby in one of the booths between me and the back door. Nothing bad happened. I woke him up, he left. No biggie.

Had it been someone who thought it would be a good idea to hide and wait until everyone was gone to ask me out, I would have been very creeped. No matter what he looked like. Especially if I had never spoken to him before. I can also remember numerous times when I told a friend "He was really cute, too bad he was (an ass, an idiot, or a pig.)"

Simply finding someone attractive doesn't excuse flaws.
 
Really? because I can think of a few. I was closing up the bar one time, had already locked up the front door (deadbolt) and found a guy sleeping like a baby in one of the booths between me and the back door. Nothing bad happened. I woke him up, he left. No biggie.

Had it been someone who thought it would be a good idea to hide and wait until everyone was gone to ask me out, I would have been very creeped. No matter what he looked like. Especially if I had never spoken to him before. I can also remember numerous times when I told a friend "He was really cute, too bad he was (an ass, an idiot, or a pig.)"

Simply finding someone attractive doesn't excuse flaws.
I'm sure I could think of some examples too, but as long as these are the exceptions, RF's point stands.
 
I'm sure I could think of some examples too, but as long as these are the exceptions, RF's point stands.

RF's point is that Watson's discomfort was related to the fact that she did not find this man physically attractive. In my experience, how people act is more influential in our response to them than how they look. How many times have you heard "He/she was cute until they opened their mouth."

This also leaves out the more-likely possibility that Watson's initial reaction to him was completely neutral and became negative when he asked her to his room. Neutral is the most common default setting. When we enter an elevator we make a casual note of who has joined us. Even if we don't find that person attractive, we don't form a negative opinion unless there is something about them that is threatening or anti-social. (Someone who is obviously angry, or has horrific body odor, for example.)
 
If it's not impossible then your point is moot.

I have to admit, I am really lost now. You said, "I can't think of an environment that would creep me out if someone I was attracted to asked me out."

So I said then it's something you haven't experienced. How does that translate to A) it being impossible or B) a moot point? With all due respect, it really is feeling like you ignore what I did say and respond to what I didn't.

Since my point has always been that it's wrong to extrapolate from an individual to a group then you know that answer.

We tend to be much more forgiving for people we are attracted to.

Oh, I am sorry, I was thrown off by you using the word "we" instead of I.

I would absolutely get her number.

So you don't have a deal breaker? I could counter the Truth About Cats And Dogs quote with the scene from Shallow Hal, where Jason Alexander can't get past the big toe, regardless of how beautiful she was.

Which is my point. Had you been attracted to that person you likely would not have found the situation creepy. You didn't formulate your opinion until after the incident. Had you seen this guy first, even a few moments before the possible stalker idea entered your brain, and was smitten it likely wouldn't have been a big deal. People have a very powerful ability to rationalize to get what their heart desires.

Do you get that I smiled at him because I thought he was cute, before he followed us, which means my opinion of his appearance was already there. You can't twist it into what ever you need to suit your case. You may get gaga but not everyone does, which was my point from the beginning.

Are you really so lacking in imagination? I'm very attracted to Robyn Quivers (Howard Stern show) and I was so for years before I ever saw her. Many things women say I find attractive. The way the say things I can find attractive. What they do I can find attractive. Simply being in a skeptics conference I can find attractive. Simply stating a preference for something I can find attractive. A smile, bubbly personality, wit, giggle, smart quip, etc.

You have history with Robyn Quivers. You listened to her on Howard Stern. RW plainly stated that she never talked to this guy. The smile is looks, the wit, the giggle and the smart quip kind of rely on communication, which didn't exist between RW and EG.
 
Good lord this is a monster thread. I'm just here to comment on one thing. Yeah it's not outrageous to get hit on, yes you can get over it and no it won't send anyone sane home blubbing or anything. But it is also not fun to go to a social event where you just want to get into some interesting conversations and every other person is hitting on you. It's not horrible. It's just tiresome. And if you're talking about wanting to encourage people to participate in your social events it's usually a good idea to try to create a situation that is not tiresome.
 
SG was informing me that there are many ways someone can be attracted to a complete stranger without looks being involved. I am simply asking her to clarify. What I find attractive is irrelavent.
I didn't say "looks" aka appearance didn't matter. I said attractive appearance did not always mean "hot" or require a sexual attraction in the way you described it.


If he creeped her out prior to the proposition in the elevator, I must have missed it but from what I recall, it was the invite to his room in the elevator, the conversation in a particular environment that creeped her out.
It's not relevant 'when' he creeped her out.


I admit, I was away for a week, redecorating my house but did rules change in that time? When did opinions become immune to scrutiny? If this is the case then apology accepted from all of you for challenging my first statement because I did start it off with "I think..." a clear indication that it was my opinion. When did assume become a statement of fact?

I'm having a very hard time not believing that if RW had found EG seriously attractive, her reaction would have been very different.

It means you are starting off with the premise that she didn't find EG seriously attractive; a premise that lacks any base.
It means I am stating my opinion, it does not mean I am asserting my opinion as fact. Scrutinize all you want, but don't do it by distorting what I said.
 
RF's point is that Watson's discomfort was related to the fact that she did not find this man physically attractive. In my experience, how people act is more influential in our response to them than how they look. How many times have you heard "He/she was cute until they opened their mouth."
This is an argument that doesn't follow. I would imagine the same thing could be said, he has a fantastic personality, but I'm just not physically attracted to him.


This also leaves out the more-likely possibility that Watson's initial reaction to him was completely neutral and became negative when he asked her to his room. Neutral is the most common default setting. When we enter an elevator we make a casual note of who has joined us. Even if we don't find that person attractive, we don't form a negative opinion unless there is something about them that is threatening or anti-social. (Someone who is obviously angry, or has horrific body odor, for example.)
Again, you are missing the point. Neutral or not attracted can be lumped together. RandFan's example was that of RW being interested in EG before he spoke to her.
 
Good lord this is a monster thread. I'm just here to comment on one thing. Yeah it's not outrageous to get hit on, yes you can get over it and no it won't send anyone sane home blubbing or anything. But it is also not fun to go to a social event where you just want to get into some interesting conversations and every other person is hitting on you. It's not horrible. It's just tiresome. And if you're talking about wanting to encourage people to participate in your social events it's usually a good idea to try to create a situation that is not tiresome.
Except this was not RW's complaint.
 
So I said then it's something you haven't experienced. How does that translate to A) it being impossible or B) a moot point? With all due respect, it really is feeling like you ignore what I did say and respond to what I didn't.
{sigh}


  • I said I can't think of a situation.
  • You give me a situation
  • I point out that just because I can't think of a situation doesn't mean that it's not possible.
What's so hard to understand?

Oh, I am sorry, I was thrown off by you using the word "we" instead of I.
Too bad you didn't notice the word "tend".

So you don't have a deal breaker? I could counter the Truth About Cats And Dogs quote with the scene from Shallow Hal, where Jason Alexander can't get past the big toe, regardless of how beautiful she was.
I can't think of one. Doesn't mean it's impossible.

Do you get that I smiled at him because I thought he was cute, before he followed us, which means my opinion of his appearance was already there. You can't twist it into what ever you need to suit your case. You may get gaga but not everyone does, which was my point from the beginning.
Do you get that you hadn't made up your mind that you wanted to be with him?

You have history with Robyn Quivers. You listened to her on Howard Stern. RW plainly stated that she never talked to this guy. The smile is looks, the wit, the giggle and the smart quip kind of rely on communication, which didn't exist between RW and EG.
All could have been. I've been attracted by a woman on our first meeting over the phone or on the internet. It's not really that complicated you just don't want to admit that it's possible much less that it often happens.
 
Except this was not RW's complaint.

I'm not following that part of the discussion because it looks completely fruitless to me. I was mostly commenting on the situation you described in post #3 and your response:

My first comment is that this "problem" of too much attention given women attendees still needs quantifying. Then we need some kind of quality evaluation. It disappoints me that we are supposed to assume the typical woman cannot handle this unwanted attention. Is it really that overwhelming? Or are there a couple women who vocalized their own distress and it's being amplified as if it were a common problem?

and trying to point out that 'not being able to handle it' isn't the same thing as not particularly feeling like attending an otherwise interesting event because you don't enjoy having to deal with it. It doesn't have to be amplified to a strawman of 'oh no the poor women are so stressed out by the batted eyelashes of a few lonely guys' for you to go 'oh really? Are we supposed to be that pathetic?' at. It's just not fun, that's all.
 
I didn't say "looks" aka appearance didn't matter. I said attractive appearance did not always mean "hot" or require a sexual attraction in the way you described it.


It's not relevant 'when' he creeped her out.


It means I am stating my opinion, it does not mean I am asserting my opinion as fact. Scrutinize all you want, but don't do it by distorting what I said.

hello pot, I'm kettle
 
I'm not following that part of the discussion because it looks completely fruitless to me. I was mostly commenting on the situation you described in post #3 and your response:



and trying to point out that 'not being able to handle it' isn't the same thing as not particularly feeling like attending an otherwise interesting event because you don't enjoy having to deal with it. It doesn't have to be amplified to a strawman of 'oh no the poor women are so stressed out by the batted eyelashes of a few lonely guys' for you to go 'oh really? Are we supposed to be that pathetic?' at. It's just not fun, that's all.
That still doesn't make sense in terms of the thread topic, which I admit we've totally passed at this point. If you have a specific incident in mind where the complaints you made actually occurred, and said event occurred at a skeptic, atheist or free thinker event, then please give us the basic info so we can add it to the list. The reason for the thread was not to add to the non-specific perceptions people have about what they like or don't like, think or don't think and so on. The point of the thread was to get passed people's selective memories and false perceptions about skeptic, atheist and/or free thinker events and try to document or quantify specific witnessed events.
 
{sigh}


  • I said I can't think of a situation.
  • You give me a situation
  • I point out that just because I can't think of a situation doesn't mean that it's not possible.
What's so hard to understand?

I think I got you, then. I thought you were flip flopping.

Too bad you didn't notice the word "tend".

I did but I picked up on the "we". You may tend to but who is we? Most people? A lot of people? Everyone you know?

Do you get that you hadn't made up your mind that you wanted to be with him?

I didn't have the chance, he weirded me out and once that happened, his looks became irrelavent; which is exactly my point. No one knows what RW's opinion of EG was, before he "creeped" her out.

All could have been. I've been attracted by a woman on our first meeting over the phone or on the internet. It's not really that complicated you just don't want to admit that it's possible much less that it often happens.

Did the phone ring and you developed an attraction or was there conversation? Similarly, did you have chats or was something said to catch your attention or did you just read a screen name and decide you are attracted to them? Remember, what we are talking about is RW, having no contact with EG, prior to the elevator conversation. I am not saying you can't like somebody without ever meeting them, I am saying your attraction to someone you are seeing can't be more than physical if you know absolutely nothing about them.
 
I did but I picked up on the "we". You may tend to but who is we? Most people? A lot of people? Everyone you know?
I'd say most people. Do you think that it is not trivially true?

I didn't have the chance, he weirded me out and once that happened, his looks became irrelavent...
Which is exactly my point. Once your heart says "I want" the other stuff isn't so relevant "but mom I love him".

...which is exactly my point. No one knows what RW's opinion of EG was, before he "creeped" her out.
She didn't say, "there was this guy I was attracted to..."

Did the phone ring and you developed an attraction or was there conversation?
I can be attracted to someone with just a few words.

Remember, what we are talking about is RW, having no contact with EG, prior to the elevator conversation. I am not saying you can't like somebody without ever meeting them, I am saying your attraction to someone you are seeing can't be more than physical if you know absolutely nothing about them.
The attraction is likely looks coupled with a witty comment or laugh. The point is that visual stimulus isn't necessary (or blind people could never be attracted to another person) nor is long exposure to someone necessary. A moment is all that is necessary. I can be attracted to someone the first time I hear them on the phone.

But I find this back and forth absurd as I think you simply don't want to accept what is trivially true.
 
You totally lost me here.

First,
I didn't say "looks" aka appearance didn't matter. I said attractive appearance did not always mean "hot" or require a sexual attraction in the way you described it.

Where did I describe it as sexual? You added the sexual when you decided to lecture me not wanting to sleep with your son's attractive friends. The only time I brought sex into this was when I was responding to Snide's Brad Pitt look alike, meaning I wasn't talking to you.

You also took pity on me for not knowing the "many" ways that one can be attracted to someone without finding them "physically hot."
It's presumptuous of you to decide I meant physically "hot" when there are many ways to interpret "attractive". Apparently that is hard for you to believe.
(love the weasler, btw)
In this particular situation, there was no conversation prior so it can't be about gaining interest through personality and charm.

It's not relevant 'when' he creeped her out.

How is it not relevant? Are you going to back that up or is this just an opinion?

It means I am stating my opinion, it does not mean I am asserting my opinion as fact. Scrutinize all you want, but don't do it by distorting what I said.

...and there it is; I's distorting. the words I used were presumptuous and assume and even provided definitions with links, yet you still insist that the words mean asserting as fact. You can't change the meanings of words to suit your argument. If you are bothered that I challenged your OPINION, don't put it out there to be challenged.
 
I'd say most people. Do you think that it is not trivially true?

I think, to a degree but once someone tips the scale into the "weird" zone, that tends to be the deal breaker.

Which is exactly my point. Once your heart says "I want" the other stuff isn't so relevant "but mom I love him".

You don't get the similarity? It's a guy I found attractive but upon first speaking with him, I felt a red flag, so his attractiveness became irrelevant. Hypothetically, RW notices a guy she finds attractive but their first conversation puts up a red flag, to her, the attraction becomes irrelevant. Is there a reason why one works and the other doesn't?

She didn't say, "there was this guy I was attracted to..."

She didn't say, "there was this guy I wasn't attracted to..." either.

I can be attracted to someone with just a few words.

If the very first words were something that made you uncomfortable or "creeped" you out?

The attraction is likely looks coupled with a witty comment or laugh. The point is that visual stimulus isn't necessary (or blind people could never be attracted to another person) nor is long exposure to someone necessary. A moment is all that is necessary. I can be attracted to someone the first time I hear them on the phone.

But I find this back and forth absurd as I think you simply don't want to accept what is trivially true.

You are still ignoring the complete lack of exchange prior to the "creepy" moment. This isn't about a few words, this is about zero conversation, why are you ignorning that?
 
She didn't say, "there was this guy I wasn't attracted to either..."
Conceded. I'm still not sure how "I was attracted to this guy but he creeped me out" is reconciled? I doubt most of us who found the object of our affection asking us out in an elevator would suddenly be creeped out. If Eva Mendez leaned over in an elevator at 4:00 am and asked me to her room for coffee I WOULDN'T BE CREEPED OUT.

I honestly don't think most people would IF the person doing the propositioning was a desirable person (attractive). I reject that the time and place are defacto reasons for being creeped out for the vast majority of people.

If the very first words were something that made you uncomfortable or "creeped" you out?
It's possible over the phone. If I found her hot in person, no, very not likely. I can excuse an awful lot. Given how many people hook up with deplorable people I think it's safe to say most people can. Not every one makes snap judgements.

You are still ignoring the complete lack of exchange prior to the "creepy" moment. This isn't about a few words, this is about zero conversation, why are you ignorning that?
I thought we were discussing a larger point. I apologize. I agree that there was nothing other than the guys looks and his words he spoke at that moment.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom