I never said it was impossible. You've really got to stop with that dichotomy. It's not the point. It's not typical. That leads us to question the bias of those who say they would be creeped out. How likely is it they are simply asserting that they wouldn't like to be in a situation that made them uncomfortable? As opposed to saying that this situation would always make them uncomfortable simply because of all the other variables. How do we know that attractiveness of the person making the proposition has been factored?
How did you get "impossible" from "it's a situation you have to be in..." Stop arguing against things I didn't say. "It's a situation you have to be in..." is a statement which leaves open the possibility of changing your mind with experience. You don't know if attraction is a factor but suggesting that things would be different if she was attracted to him is loaded.
Of course. Not typical though. We tend to be much more forgiving for people we are attracted to.
"You burp and guys think its adorable. You puke and they line up to hold your hair back. " --Truth about cats and dogs.
Are you speaking for everyone or just your own person experience? Yes, people can be more forgiving if there is an attraction but if she puked on your shoes on your first introduction, would you find yourself compelled to get her number or would that be a turn off?
Right? Even given your example I don't doubt many women would say "yeah that creeps me out" but if they were approached by someone that made their heart skip a beat suddenly that all goes out the window. You said in your example that it was someone you could be attracted to. You didn't say you were. Did you decide you were not attracted to this person before or after you decided his behavior was odd?
I didn't say could, I said he was my type; meaning, if we had met under less odd circumstances I might have gone for it. being followed off a highway is not my idea of romantic, it's a bit stalker-ish for me.
NO! I'm sorry but this is just wrong. It's VERY relevant. SG can't speak for everyone nor should she have to. She's only saying that attraction is more (or can be more) than looks. Will you not concede that to be true? Why does this have to be like pulling teeth? If YOU can find something not physically attractive then THAT is your answer.
SG was letting me know what there is, when there is zero prior knowledge of the person, many ways of being attracted to someone that don't involve looks. I'm still waiting for that answer. If you have some, by all means, share. Obviously, my view is, if you are checking out someone from across the room, it's probably not for their book collection but I am open for suggestions.