[Ed.]What requires that I pay the income tax?

Then our educational system has badly failed you. There is a reason court cases refer to other court cases when making decsions.

It's the entire foundation upon which our legal system is based. But I admit I didn't understand that at your age, either.

Lets say theres a law saying you cant throw rocks at someones house

what if 20 or so judges in the low courts say you can throw rocks at peoples house during 20 trials. does that automatically overturn the law? untill the law is re written, i didnt think so, and now im being told judges can interpret the definition of the law so if it says people arent allowed to do X they can say it means people are allowed to do X and that would be ok because judges are allowed to interpret what the written law means?

errr. my classes taught me that the supreme court judges interpret the law when they have a big controversial trial. I know that. But im talking about the lowest small courts do the judges have the power to change the written law there? if they do then damn i better make sure to bow down to every statesmen or officer i see and kiss their feet at every opportunity.
 
Thank you anti-sophist, you have ended my arguments.


You explained it pretty clearly. (1)The courts are allowed to determine what the written law, and the constitution, means. And they are consistent when it comes to wages and salarys, and they claim it is a part of taxable income.

I guess now i just need to research if (1) is true or not, or to what extent 1 is true. i will be back in a few days on this.

Regardless, do you have any news articles of what you mentioned earlier?

Juries decisions can be (and are) thrown out if they made them illegally.

?

but im not talking about jurys being bribed
 
I'll have to re-read the whole constitution to tell you which section the definition is under, so expect it in 2-3days.

2-3 days to read the constitution?

Its really short, heres a link

http://www.usconstitution.net/const.html

Also I already quoted the entire section pertaining to income taxes. I'll do it again.

The Congress shall have power to lay and collect taxes on incomes, from whatever source derived, without apportionment among the several States, and without regard to any census or enumeration.

Short, and no definition.
 
Last edited:
but im not talking about jurys being bribed

Why not? You said juries were above the law? How are bribes any different than any other law?

Jury decisions made illegaly are not valid. Furthermore, juries often have convictions overturned for a variety of legal reasons.

Your claim that juries can let a guy go for spurious reasons is somewhat true entirely because of the double-jeopardy laws which prevent the State from retrying these people, but that seems to be fairly off-topic.
 
Oh I just throught of something, there are 2 ways im thinking of that the courts and define a term to make me wrong.



A.) The courts have determined that income is no longer defined as "gains...", meaning even though labor has value you can still be taxed on your wage because income is defined as something else now (though I am not sure what)


B.) The courts have not changed the definition of income (so the definition of income still is "gains...") however the courts have determined that labor does not have value, so when you earn a wage there is a gain and thus it is taxable income



I think B is correct, or am I missing another explanation that is what is going on here?



Why not? You said juries were above the law? How are bribes any different than any other law?

Jury decisions made illegaly are not valid. Furthermore, juries often have convictions overturned for a variety of legal reasons.

Your claim that juries can let a guy go for spurious reasons is somewhat true entirely because of the double-jeopardy laws which prevent the State from retrying these people, but that seems to be fairly off-topic.

You're right, but I want to see non-bribe cases
 
Last edited:
Oh I just throught of something, there are 3 ways im thinking of that the courts and define a term to make me wrong.



A.) The courts have determined that income is no longer defined as "gains...", meaning even though labor has value you can still be taxed on your wage because income is defined as something else now (though I am not sure what)


B.) The courts have not changed the definition of income (so the definition of income still is "gains...") however the courts have determined that labor does not have value, so when you earn a wage there is a gain and thus it is taxable income



I think B is correct, or am I missing another explanation that is what is going on here?


Or C - Congress has yet to pass a law to allow your "labor value" to be deductable.
 
well if labor does have value, and income is still defined as "gains..." then im right.

since i see constant use of the word income at the IRS explanations page and in the IRS code, i dont think the definition of income has changed.

I simply think they have decided to say labor has no monetary value. That would make everything work the way they say it does and it would make my whole arguement wrong while preserving the definition of income.

Or C - Congress has yet to pass a law to allow your "labor value" to be deductable.

what u mean?
 
OH NO I AM STILL MISSING SOMETHING


Ok, i need to find the law that says I have to pay the income tax. i guess i will search for it online but i will check here too.

i think every state has a different law so lets just say, california

All I need is the law saying that I am "required to pay the tax" and boom I have everything I need
 
ouch, you made me hurt!

i think im gonna call the IRS and ask them about where i can find the tax laws for New Hampshire requiring people to pay business income taxes. because the courts have determined labor has no value, those tax laws should apply to wages now.

once i have that, i will have every piece of evidence I need to prove to ed brown that he has to pay a tax on his labor, and i will get his million dollars

http://www.showedthelaw.blogspot.com/

hehe, MY OWN PERSONAL CONSPIRACY PLOT HAS BEEN REVEALED

as for the rest of you, dont email him because it will just be spamming him. none of you explanations will be as believable as mine anyway
 
State taxes are different from Federal taxes, The IRS won't give a rats ass about New Hampshire tax laws.
 
i thought each state had a law saying "our citizens are required to pay the federal income tax"

i didnt know there was a federal law, applying to all citizens in all 50 states, saying "all us citizens are required to pay the federal income tax"

if there is yeah i need to find that one too
 
It just occurred to me: I, like most wage earners, am seriously underpaid by my employer. So, I guess my compensation minus the value of my labor would be a negative quantity.

Does that make me eligible for food stamps?

Seriously, though: It is an income tax. It is not an income-minus-value tax; it is an income tax. The tax code does provide for many types of deductions from your income (and also credits towards your taxes due), but the deductions don't make it an income-minus-value tax. Some of the deductions are income related (for example, a deduction for uniform expenses), while others are not related at all (interest on a mortgage).
 
Does that make me eligible for food stamps?


Maybe, but if you have under a certain income and have enough deductions and a few kids you will probably get back more than you paid at the end of the year.
 
It just occurred to me: I, like most wage earners, am seriously underpaid by my employer. So, I guess my compensation minus the value of my labor would be a negative quantity.

Your labor is equal in value to your wage.

HOWEVER, not anymore, the courts have ruled that your labor is equal in value to zero, so your wage is all income.
Does that make me eligible for food stamps?
no,. well maybe
Seriously, though: It is an income tax. It is not an income-minus-value tax; it is an income tax. The tax code does provide for many types of deductions from your income (and also credits towards your taxes due), but the deductions don't make it an income-minus-value tax. Some of the deductions are income related (for example, a deduction for uniform expenses), while others are not related at all (interest on a mortgage).

correct. and because the courts have determined labor has no value, wage is all income.

ive said that a few posts up.



anyway i need that law that says all US citizens must pay the federal income tax
 
Your labor is equal in value to your wage.
I see sarcasm is wasted on you.
HOWEVER, not anymore, the courts have ruled that your labor is equal in value to zero, so your wage is all income.
The whole point is that the "the value of the labor" is irrelevant. It is not income; income (in this context) is the money you got paid.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom