[Ed.]What requires that I pay the income tax?

Sorry, I couldn't get through all 8 pages, so I apologize if this has been said ad nauseum.


Show me the law thats says I must pay the federal income tax (not file the tax return).


I am not trying to redefine gross income.

This is the definition of gross income in the IRS website, "The Law: For federal income tax purposes, "gross income" means all income from whatever source derived and includes compensation for services.""

You provide a service. You get compensated for it. You pay taxes on the compensation. In the majority of cases, the compensation is in the form of money, and is commonly known in the vernacular as "income".







you seem to think simply gaining money is a form of income? not in the business world im taking 300 level accounting classes and revenue is gaining money, income is whats left after you subtract all your expenses and costs from all your revenue and sales accounts then put that info on your income statement for the business and then you close the expense accounts but whatever


You're taking level 300 accounting classes, and this is what you think? Man, I haven't taken any and I know better. In the part I bolded above, substitute the word "profit" for the word "income" and you are closer to the truth. Maybe you should go back to level 100 courses for awhile....


Can't be bothered to read the entire thread because it looks like a bunch of hooey from an anti-tax dingbat.

However, I'll offer the following genuine, legal ways to avoid paying taxes on income:

1) Work for the UN. UN income is tax-free in practically any jurisdiction. While you do pay payroll deductions (sometimes called by UN employees 'taxes') when on the UN payroll - these go exclusively to fund UN employee benefit programs and pension schemes.

2) Become a non-resident for tax purposes in your home jurisdiction, and work in a country where there are no taxes on personal income, or no taxes on expatriate wages.

That's about it...

-AH.

3) Live in a cardboard box on the street corner. In fact, if you get someone to donate you the box, you could probably claim it as a deduction.
 
Good thing I'm not 'Merican (USian) then... ;)

While membership in the USA has its privilages the ability to be taxed by the IRS regardless of where you live is one of the downsides.

I looked around for info on Americans working for the UN and while I think working for the UN does qualify an American for the foreign earned income exemption (that ~$80,000 item mentioned in previous posts) I can't find where UN income is completely exempt from US taxes.

Now an American who sells everything in the US and leaves the country for good could theoretically not file with the IRS anymore on the assumption that they can't get him anyway, but it means that the person is committing a crime and would essentially never be able to go back to the US without facing a serious risk at being arrested for tax evasion. With the monitoring of passenger lists these days I wouldn't be surprised if such a person would be arrested the moment they landed in the US.
 
The article governing the taxability of UN salaries earned by staff is the 1946 Convention on the Privileges and Immunities of the United Nations - to which there are I believe 191 countries as signatories as of today. Article V Section 18 reads: Officials of the United Nations shall:

(a) be immune from legal process in respect of words spoken or written and all acts performed by them in their official capacity;
(b) be exempt from taxation on the salaries and emoluments paid to them by the United Nations;
(c) be immune from national service obligations;
(d) be immune, together with their spouses and relatives dependent on them, from immigration restrictions and alien registration;
(e) be accorded the same privileges in respect of exchange facilities as are accorded to the officials of comparable ranks forming part of diplomatic missions to the Government concerned;
(f) be given, together with their spouses and relatives dependent on them, the same repatriation facilities in time of international crisis as diplomatic envoys;
(g) have the right to import free of duty their furniture and effects at the time of first taking up their post in the country in question.

Since this law supercedes US Taxation law, then a direct employee of the UN is exempt from US taxes on their salary - unless there is some special reservation in US Income tax law (could be, I guess - I'm not an American, nor am I an authority on US taxes) that overrides this International agreement. Certainly, every UN employee I have met (and I have met hundreds) is not paying taxes in their home countries on their UN salaries - including US citizens. As I said earlier - grey area when it comes to contractors. A question could be asked about state taxes, but again the legal principle is that the UN law supercedes the state law.

My point on tax avoidance by emigrating was exactly as you pointed out Triangle. If you choose to drop out of the system, that is probably a choice made for life. My knowledge of Canada Border Services Agency practices suggests that if a warrant for criminal tax evasion was levied against someone, then yes, you could be stopped trying to re-enter - however in practice I doubt this would take place. Revenue Canada (at least when I left them) was frying more easily caught fish.
 
Last edited:
The article governing the taxability of UN salaries earned by staff is the 1946 Convention on the Privileges and Immunities of the United Nations - to which there are I believe 191 countries as signatories as of today.


Thanks for that, I wasn't aware of the document and looked it up.
From the Convention:
Section 18. Officials of the United Nations shall:

(a) be immune from legal process in respect of words spoken or written and all acts performed by them in their official capacity;

(b) be exempt from taxation on the salaries and emoluments paid to them by the United Nations;

Looked good to me - but then unfortunately for Americans there is a footnote:

3/ The United States of America deposited its instrument of accession on 29 April 1970, with the following reservations:

1. Paragraph (b) of section 18 regarding immunity from taxation and paragraph (c) of section 18 regarding immunity from national service obligations shall not apply with respect to United States nationals and aliens admitted for permanent residence.


IRS > UN , don't mess with the IRS! :vk:
 
Since this law supercedes US Taxation law...

[snip]


... A question could be asked about state taxes, but again the legal principle is that the UN law supercedes the state law.


No, it doesn't. There really is no such thing as supremacy of international law over the laws of sovereign nations. In fact, international civil law over individuals is basically nonexistent as a codified body of enforceable statutes.

What is enforceable, and what does govern individuals, is their own nation's and their host nation's laws. In the U.S., the U.S. Constitution gives federal law supremacy over state law. There is no provision in U.S. law which gives supremacy over federal law to "international law" or treaties, however.

Instead, what you have is federal law which implements the relevant portions of treaties and conventions to which the U.S. is a signatory. It's easy to confuse the two, but the only binding parts on U.S. residents at home and abroad of those treaties are the parts which have been incorporated into implementing federal legislation in the U.S. In other words, Congress has to have passed laws "domesticating," if you will, the relevant portions of the treaty. Remember that a treaty is essentially just a giant contract with multiple signatories and parties. It isn't truly legislation.

Also, permanent residents or citizens of the U.S. living abroad may be subject to the tax laws of their host nations. As someone else noted above, however, U.S. tax law generally gives the U.S. taxpayer living abroad a 100% credit towards his U.S. tax liability for income taxes owed and paid to a foreign government.

Anyway, I just wanted to clear that up. International law, such as it is, is most definitely not supreme and does not take precedence over the laws of any sovereign nation. International law derives from contract and consensus (treaties and declarations). It has far less teeth than and isn't truly binding on individuals as with the legislation (and constitutions) of sovereign nations. Please note that the UN is not a sovereign entity. It is a collection of nations who join together for the discussion and debate and action on diplomatic, human rights, and trade matters. It isn't a government in any meaningful sense.

AS
 
Hmm... I wonder if the IRS acknowledges the UN staff contribution (UN taxes) as 'tax' and if a US Citizen - UN employee claimed a credit for this amount, if the IRS would accept the payroll deduction as foreign income tax paid?

I also wonder if the UN files a W-2 or whatever the US calls their employee income statement (in Canada its a T4) for its American citizen employees? If there is no income reporting requirement for the UN on its personnel, then I wish the IRS luck.

OK - so I gotta amend my recommendation on how to avoid taxes.

Step #1 - Renounce your US citizenship.
 
Hmm... I wonder if the IRS acknowledges the UN staff contribution (UN taxes) as 'tax' and if a US Citizen - UN employee claimed a credit for this amount, if the IRS would accept the payroll deduction as foreign income tax paid?
Well I think UN employees qualify for that foreign income deduction so unless your income and benefits greatly exceed $80k-100k a year the US taxes will not be a big deal. Still have to file a return though.

OK - so I gotta amend my recommendation on how to avoid taxes.
Step #1 - Renounce your US citizenship.
I think someone else posted that even if you revoke citizenship the IRS has the right to tax you for 10 years. Don't know if it's true though.

The IRS is very powerful and my experience with US taxation is that it is very difficult to get away from it. That's why I wondered about the UN salaries as I was skeptical that the IRS would let that slide.

Anyway I find this sideline a much more interesting topic than the anti-tax stuff.
 
Hmm... I wonder if the IRS acknowledges the UN staff contribution (UN taxes) as 'tax' and if a US Citizen - UN employee claimed a credit for this amount, if the IRS would accept the payroll deduction as foreign income tax paid?

I don't know. My point was that the UN has no law making authority over citizens of sovereign nations, although it often acts as if it would like to have it. In particular, UN actions cannot and do not have any binding legal authority on the US' own legal authority to tax its residents and citizens. That is governed exclusively by U.S. law.

U.S. law may very well exempt the salaries of U.S. residents or citizens who are full time employees of the UN. I don't know. If it does, however, it is under authority of U.S. law, not under any color of authority of the UN.

AS
 
Perhaps I'm choosing the wrong term when I say 'supercede'. A couple of caveats: I'm not a lawyer, and I have never worked in the US.

However, in my role as an advisor to Finance Minister(s) in developing countries, where the state and rule of law is obviously in a different state of development than US laws; the issue of international agreements being germane to an issue is real.

For example, a hypothetical question we may have to face is the taxability of a contracting firm who receives funding from USAID. The US Gov't and the Gov't of Afghanistan exchanged an agreement/treaty in 1951 which governs the taxability of aid monies, and how far down the chain the exemption goes. (Primary contractor, sub-contractor, expat employees of contractor, national employees of contractor etc...)

So, in my personal, hands-on experience, international laws and agreements CAN affect how the law of a soveriegn nation is applied. Is 'supercede' the wrong term? Perhaps. However, the applicability of other laws to the income tax law of a country is definitely relevant.

(For those who are interested - www.mof.gov.af/tax to find out taxation information about Afghanistan... If you're planning to come out here, or want to invest in this climate...)
 
Last edited:
Perhaps I'm choosing the wrong term when I say 'supercede'. A couple of caveats: I'm not a lawyer, and I have never worked in the US.

That's cool, but "supersede" is indeed the wrong term here. It implies supremacy over law, and that simply isn't the case.

However, in my role as an advisor to Finance Minister(s) in developing countries, where the state and rule of law is obviously in a different state of development than US laws; the issue of international agreements being germane to an issue is real.

I have no doubt that it is real. What you are dealing with are agreements, however. In practice, they have the force of law because of comity between and among the signatories. That's a matter of diplomatic policy, and also likely law, but the law is within each sovereign nation state. It isn't truly international law per se as we commonly mean law, as in a statute passed by a legislative body.

For example, a hypothetical question we may have to face is the taxability of a contracting firm who receives funding from USAID. The US Gov't and the Gov't of Afghanistan exchanged an agreement/treaty in 1951 which governs the taxability of aid monies, and how far down the chain the exemption goes. (Primary contractor, sub-contractor, expat employees of contractor, national employees of contractor etc...)

Again, that's policy (and possibly applicable national law) as it is necessary to implement the intent of the various international agreements affecting your work.

So, in my personal, hands-on experience, international laws and agreements CAN affect how the law of a soveriegn nation is applied. Is 'supercede' the wrong term? Perhaps. However, the applicability of other laws to the income tax law of a country is definitely relevant.

Keep in mind that the international laws you are referring to are treaties and compacts. As such, it is much more useful to think of them as little more than contracts, written agreements between the signatory countries. Those countries still have to pass implementing legislation domestically in order to make the provisions of those treaties have any binding legal effect. Otherwise, you have little but a paper with a bunch of signatures, and no real body to enforce the provisions of it (forget the various international law courts; although they exist and they are real and they actually hear cases and issue rulings, they don't have any teeth like courts of sovereign entities, and their judgments are all but impossible to enforce without voluntary compliance).

AS
 
Also, permanent residents or citizens of the U.S. living abroad may be subject to the tax laws of their host nations. As someone else noted above, however, U.S. tax law generally gives the U.S. taxpayer living abroad a 100% credit towards his U.S. tax liability for income taxes owed and paid to a foreign government.


Correct. I am a US citizen working in MX, so I was given a basic understanding of what is going on (since someone else does my taxes). I am charged for all income (housing, utilities, etc) that the company pays for, but then I am given credits based on taxes paid to MX. Very convoluted, but ok with me since I do not have to do the returns.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom