[Ed.]What requires that I pay the income tax?

The IRS says the tax on wages and salaries is absorbed into the national debt. Translation: it goes to the private banks of the federal reserve that we owe the national debt to.

Maybe you forget about the tax on income from business operation. That tax goes into our military mostly. The tax on wages and salaries goes into the national dept. IRS says this.


Of couse you will be able to provide us links to where the IRS says these things. Right? Or are you just going to continue use lies to try and back up your arguement, just like how the Constitution defines income?
 
You make it sound like it's an American conspiracy to force you to give your government money so that they can use it to wage war.
sry if u think that
Everybody in the modern world who works are supposed to pay their taxes. It's part of the adult life, you work, you contribute to society.
paying the tax on wages and salaries does not contribute to society

paying sales tax contributes to society
paying gasoline tax contributes to society
paying property tax contributes to society
paying the tax on corporate income contributes to society
paying the 1000+ other taxes americans may contribute to society

the IRS admits that the tax on wages and salaries is absorbed into the national debt debt to the federal reserve. do you think that means it contributes to society? do you know how our national debt is created??
Simple equation. You don't like it, move to Antarctica, I hear it will be a good summer vacation spot soon.

hehehe. nah i live on paradise hawai'i !

and i pay pay my income taxes, because I make all of my money from the stock market. even if labor had value, i dont get my money through labor i get it through other peoples labor so i would still need to pay MY income taxes

I get 0 money from labor, 0 money from wages, 0 money from salaries. all of my money now comes from my stocks increasing in value. so i calculate my gains and pay my income taxes on that. i dont feel bad doing it, i dont dislike it, because thats the income tax that goes to fund our military. i take pride in that!

Right? Or are you just going to continue use lies

lol. you think me saying the wage and salary tax is absorbed into the national debt is a "LIE"?

LOL MAN THATS HILARIOUS. your gonna be rolling when i post the links then to the IRS reports in a few days. dont worry its just hilarious how you think thats a lie. i thought everyone knew that
 
Last edited:
It used to be true when labor was defined as having value. But the courts have the power to determine the definitions of terms when in the context or breadth of written law so they can define labor as not having value, which they did, so wages and salaries are sources of income - YOU ARE RIGHT

Your argument, as I understand it, is that if you consider labor having the same value as whatever you are paid for the labor, the exchange is a wash, therefore your net income is zero, and therefore should not be taxed. Since they tax the fruit of your labor (the money you receive), your labor therefore must not have value.

Aside from what was already mentioned (that tax is on gross income, not net), there is another problem: by your logic, the IRS does assign a value to labor: that value is $5150 per year. That's the standard deduction that is not subject to income tax.

Anything above $5,150 is subject to income tax (plus numerous other deductions you can factor in). So, in fact, if you want to continue using your logic, the IRS has valued your income at $5,150 per year -- and considerably more if you are married and/or have children, or are over age 65.

So smile. The IRS values your labor.

EDIT: Although, given your last post, I should probably say that the IRS values other people's labor.

Also edited for clarity.
 
Last edited:
Well good luck with that, dude.

Before you get kicked out for flunking
ive passed all my other classes with A's!

not like it matters. i dont plan on getting a job i make all my money from the stock market. just taking classes for the heck of it


Aside from what was already mentioned (that tax is on gross income, not net), there is another problem: by your logic, the IRS does assign a value to labor: that value is $5150 per year. That's the standard deduction that is not subject to income

IRS doesn't say thats their assigned value to our labor, they just dont tax people who make less than that much income.

The assigned value to our labor, is 0, as determined by the courts.



well, I am also taking accounting because eventually im probably gonna have so much money invested into other companys its nice to have accounting knowledge so u can study their statements
 
Last edited:
IRS doesn't say thats their assigned value to our labor, they just dont tax people who make less than that much income.

Then you don't understand the standard deduction. They don't tax the first $5,150 of your income. For everyone. Actually for me, it was considerably more than that, since I am married and file jointly. But anyway, the $5,150 is the minimum standard deduction that everyone is entitled to. Regardless of your total income above that.
 
Then you don't understand the standard deduction. They don't tax the first $5,150 of your income. For everyone. Actually for me, it was considerably more than that, since I am married and file jointly.

You're right, I didn't read it! hahaha

ok so thats an interesting find you got there


So it means that for all intensive purposes, the IRS taxes our labor at a rate of 0, but the first 5150 isn't counted. So maybe our labor has a value of 5150 per year regardless of how much we work. That sounds plausible.

In todays world, thats almost zero anyway!
 
Having been a resident of both states you have referred to in your posts, I can assure you that:

1) New Hampshire doesn't have an income tax. Nor a sales tax. Completely irrelevant to the discussion.

2) Hawaii has a General Excise Tax. This is different from both a sales tax and an income tax.

You can look up "excise" in your 300 level econ. class text book, or Google it. Make sure you spell it e-x-c-i-s-e, not e-x-e-r-c-i-s-e. I've noticed your spelling isn't exactly "A" grade level.

If you don't work, why do you care about this so much? I would think that living on Oahu you would have more interesting things to do than post to conspiracy boards. Of course, Oahu is nowhere near the "paradise" you can find on any of the Neighbor Islands.
 
Last edited:
paying sales tax contributes to society
paying gasoline tax contributes to society
paying property tax contributes to society
paying the tax on corporate income contributes to society
paying the 1000+ other taxes americans may contribute to society

1. sales tax is state
2. gas is state and federal
3. property tax is state and/or local
4. Guess what, for a many businesses taxes are paid on individual returns.



lol. you think me saying the wage and salary tax is absorbed into the national debt is a "LIE"?
A portion of it is used to pay interest on the debt, the rest is spent on whatever Congress allocates it for in the budget.


LOL MAN THATS HILARIOUS. your gonna be rolling when i post the links then to the IRS reports in a few days. dont worry its just hilarious how you think thats a lie. i thought everyone knew that

Let me guess you're going to post a bunch of tax protester links.
 
You can look up "excise" in your 300 level econ. class text book, or Google it. Make sure you spell it e-x-c-i-s-e, not e-x-e-r-c-i-s-e. I've noticed your spelling isn't exactly "A" grade level
YES! internet lingo for the win dude i type so fast and i dont spellcheck

If you don't work, why do you care about this so much? I would think that living on Oahu you would have more interesting things to do than post to conspirancy boards. Of course, Oahu is nowhere near the "paradise" you can find on any of the Neighbor Islands.

Hmmm nope. Right now its 10pm and my remote controll to my TV doesnt work cause i need to buy new batteries.

this is fun!


also, i dont care about this. i simply made this thread to educate myself and figure out how the income tax on wages and salaries are legal, and anti-sophist explained it well. so im just about done, going to sleep soon. right now im just in the fun random talk stage of this thread doing the random clearification of someones info they got from page2 or something



A portion of it is used to pay interest on the debt, the rest is spent on whatever Congress allocates it for in the budget.
Hmm interesting last year I called the IRS asking for where i could go to find info on what the taxes are spent on and the page they linked me to and told me to research, i forget where it was im going to call up IRS again tomorrow to ask them, but I eventually found what i think they were talking about and I saw A HUGE CHUNK of it going to national debt and i assumed that huge cunk was the labor and salaries and wages tax because thats what the anti income tax movement says, but is some of that other stuff also wages and salaries tax too? I thought the rest of the stuff was from the corporate taxes

i dont know for sure. it didnt say which taxes were from where it just had the huge chunk showing me most of it was going to the national debt
 
Last edited:
Hmmm nope. Right now its 10pm and my remote controll to my TV doesnt work cause i need to buy new batteries.

Yeah right, any real college student on Oahu without the need for work due to amazing investments would be in bed by 9 in order to hit the North Shore before afternoon class. You do realize you need to be out there before the wind kicks up? :cool:
 
Hmm interesting last year I called the IRS asking for where i could go to find info on what the taxes are spent on and the page they linked me to and told me to research, i forget where it was im going to call up IRS again tomorrow to ask them, but I eventually found what i think they were talking about and I saw A HUGE CHUNK of it going to national debt and i assumed that huge cunk was the labor and salaries and wages tax because thats what the anti income tax movement says, but is some of that other stuff also wages and salaries tax too? I thought the rest of the stuff was from the corporate taxes

i dont know for sure. it didnt say which taxes were from where it just had the huge chunk showing me most of it was going to the national debt

Well theres your problem right there, listening to Alex Jones.
I believe most of the taxes go into the same pool except for SS and Medicare.
Some of the taxes might be assigned for certain purposes, like gas tax might be allocated to roads etc, but basically money is money and they like to spend it.


You keep trying to separate business taxes and "wages and salaries tax", its all income tax.

Also quit going back and doing major edits to your posts, it makes it difficult to keep up with your changes. Just make a new post.
 
Last edited:
alright threads basically over

ive basically been feuling it for the past hour or so i need to go to sleep now

i was basically "proven wrong" but in reality i was just playing the part of the anti-income-tax-movement guy , using their arguement, to see the intelligent responses of the people who knew the correct responses on how to refute it.

you may not believe me. i dont care. i did this to educate myself. i had watched freedom to fascism few weeks ago and i developed this plan several hours ago, pretend to be a anti income tax dude to get you guys to tell me why the tax is legal, because i found their arguements to be compelling, so i used their arguements in this thread to find the counter arguements to their arguements quickly, because i had not found them elsewhere.

anti sophist explained it well. i now understand. others of you dont get my explanation at all lol, anti sophist did and he refuted it properly and logically.

anyway, cya folks. hahaha its all fun and games but im done with this thread. ive already posted like a thousand times in it.


IF YOU WANT THE LINKS i get from IRS tomorrow when I call IRS and ask them where i can find the info then just PM me. or the other links i said i would give PM me for them. i will post them here too but i dont feel like bumping a worthless thread to make people laugh at me lolololol i'll think about it.
 
if i had asked you guys "please debunk Freedom to Facism for me, uhh and be logical" you would have laughed and linked me to some debunk site that probably doesnt even include the REAL counter arguement that i have received from this thread and it probably just contains a bunch of little stupid ones.

NO. I wanted to use what i determined to be the best arguement from that film, and I wanted THAT to be countered. So I presented it over and over again untill anti-sophist understood what i was saying and he was able to explain to me and counter the arguement that i wanted to be countered and he explained how that arguement doesnt mean the tax is illegal.

Thats why this was effective, in my opinion. what i actually wanted to get countered, got countered in a way i could understand...

i guess i doesnt matter. OK I RLY NEED 2go SLEEP NOW COMPUTER SHUT DOWN
 
No, it doesn't matter. And the phrase you wanted was "for all intents and purposes." Not "intensive purposes."


You great big college student, you.

--Class of 2006.
 
All 5 points are true.
Fine. Then your original argument is null and void.

The statement: Income is defined as gains.
is true (havn't seen otherwise)
But you just agreed above that WASN'T the case!

What sort of bone-headed idiot ARE you?

The statement: Gains is defined as accession to wealth from economic events by the calculations of revenues less costs other accounting equations to determine the breadth of increase in wealth.
is true
Oh. You. Moron.

you seem to think simply gaining money is a form of income? not in the business world im taking 300 level accounting classes and revenue is gaining money, income is whats left after you subtract all your expenses and costs from all your revenue and sales accounts then put that info on your income statement for the business and then you close the expense accounts but whatever
I don't need to think anything about it at all. It's all been thought out before for me. The basic way I described above is how it has been for, oh, several thousand years? Even the ancient Greeks had taxes on their incomes.

my point is, income is gains. simply getting money isnt always a gain... but now wages and salaries are considered gains under written law because the courts have determined that labor has no value.
Rubbish. And you blithering on otherwise does not make it smell any less rubbish.

Get it through your thick head. Wages and salaries are INCOME. Just as bank account interest, returns on investments, your inheritance from great-aunt Maude, and slot-machine wins are INCOME.

Your labour has no value per se. But the recompense for that labour does. And that recompense is still counted as INCOME.
 
However, if you are saying wages and salaries are income in a hypothetical world where the courts didnt determine that labor was worthless, you would be dead wrong. .

"I am correct in a hypothetical world" simply means "I am dead wrong", doesn't it?
 
Yes, the 16th amendment allows the US to form a law.

Just link me the laws that require a california citizen to pay a tax on his labor.

The laws are in the supreme court decisions concering taxation that go back to the 1800's.
And then there is the federal income tax act of 1913

http://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/index.php/Income_tax
http://www.taxhistory.org/thp/readi...2d52a4cfd2844fab85256e22007840e6?OpenDocument
http://www.answers.com/topic/federal-income-tax-of-1913
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom