[Ed.]What requires that I pay the income tax?

"Compensation for labor or services, paid in the form of wages or salary, has been universally held by the courts of this republic to be income, subject to the income tax laws currently applicable." United States v. Romero, 640 F.2d 1014, 1016 (9th Cir. 1981).


I don't understand how you can stare reality directly in the face and just lie to yourself.

So they think its the law, and they have all the guns.

That doesn't mean I legally must pay it, it simply means I will go to jail if I don't... :p :p :p

You know, often when I come across a word whose meaning I don't know, or am unsure of, I look it up in a dictionary. I happen to have an old Random House dictionary here on my desk. Let's see what it says ...

im speaking about law. assuming the law or string of laws exist requiring that i have to file an income federal tax form, i would have to use the definition of the word income found in the IRS tax code (none), or the laws themself (none), or if none of those contain the definition, then use the definition of income as defined in the constitution.


But surely your wage is your employer paying you $800 for $800 worth of service. Whatever form that service takes. It might be digging ditches or programming computers, it doesn't matter. You provide a service for the employer and he/she pays for that service.

Correct, and after I am paid, my gain is 0 (zero), meaning there was never even any income to tax, because income is gains, and there is no gain.

the law says "I can tax income derived from labor"

I say "sure, ok, but income is gains, and there is no gain, so even if you try to tax my wage derived from labor, its not income, and the tax doesnt work"

the state says "LOLZ I HAVE GUNS. DIE! GO TO JAIL!"
 
Last edited:
I trade 800 dollars of labor for 800 dollars.

800 - 800 = 0

income is defined as gains, and there is no gain here, so my wage is not a form of gain derived from compensation for services, meaning my wage is not a form of income derived from compensation of services,

meaning the law doesn't force me to pay a tax on my wage

Thats not how it works though. Your labor only has value because you are compensated for it. If you go out and mow your yard does 100 dollars magically appear in your pocket? No.

Now if you go and mow a neighbors yard and he pays you 100 dollars you've just been compensated for services which would taxable.
Basically your "math" is wrong, it should be 0+800=800 showing a gain of 800 dollars.

They aren't taxing you for your labor (its intrinsically worthless), they are taxing the income you receive for your labor, which is why you don't have to pay taxes every time you go mow your own yard.
 
I think he's making a philosophical "social justice" kind of argument and thinking that the semantical interpretation is terribly clever.

There is a reason I checked his age when I saw the OP.

The topic title doesn't seem to be making that type of statement. I have no problem with people who have objections to the income taxes as currently instituted. They should contact their congressmen and ask them to amend the IRS code.

I do, however, have a problem with frivolous tax arguments based on on specious legal grounds. As long as they agree that the income tax is legal and enforceable, then ok. Once they start with the gibberish...
 
oahuoahu, are you aware that the arguments you're regurgitating are so old that there are [rule 8]ing FAQs about them?

Here's one that you might find a very useful resource:

The Tax Protestor FAQ

Your specific claims about wages not being income and income not being defined are addressed here and here respectively, complete with plenty of citations from the multiple court cases which have established their crapulousness.

Both of these claims (and indeed all of the standard-issue T.P.er claims the paranoid conspiracism industry markets) have been thrown down, danced upon and laughed at by the courts so many times that judges who encounter them now are less challenged by sorting out the legal issues than by trying to find a way to say "[rule 8] lunatic [rule 8]" without destroying their judicial dignity.

The little man from the IRS isn't going to disappear in a puff of smoke if you recite the correct magic formula.

Thse arguments didn't work in the past, don't work in the present and won't work in the future. They've been discredited for all time in the only venue that counts- the judicial system.

Remember the old saw about insanity consisting in doing the same thing again and again while expecting a different result? The T.P.ers' quasi-mystical word games are a truly prime example of this.

The legalistic approach has failed consistently and repeatedly. The logical conclusion is that if you want changes in tax laws and tax policy, the only way to achieve them is by political organization and action, not by tweaking a few words in an already-failed argument and trying it again.

These claims, and the ones about the Federal Reserve system, are all depressingly familiar. They're the same old [rule 8] that the proprietors of conspira-loon Web sites keep recycling endlessly, feeding on the fact that there's always a fresh crop of rubes who haven't heard them before and don't know enough to do a decent job of checking them out.

The paranoid conspiracy theory industry is not a reliable source of information, nor do its owners have the best interests of their readers at heart. You will most likely learn that at some point- I hope it won't be the hard way.
 
So they think its the law, and they have all the guns.

The judiciary doesn't have the guns. They are the ones granted the power to interpret the law. And that's what they are doing. You do not have the power to interpret the law. The constitution doesn't grant you that power, therefore their opinion is legally binding, and yours is not.

That doesn't mean I legally must pay it

In fact, yes it does. You asking for a legal interpretation of the laws. The courts are the ones granted this power by the Constitution. They have spoken rather conclusively..

That's what "legally" means. The ones with the legal authority to make this decision have. And you are wrong. That's as legal as it gets.

assuming the law or string of laws exist requiring that i have to file an income federal tax form

It does.

i would have to use the definition of the word income found in the IRS tax code

The courts have defined it, which is their job.

or the laws themself (none)

False.

or if none of those contain the definition, then use the definition of income as defined in the constitution.

False, again.

Correct, and after I am paid, my gain is 0 (zero), meaning there was never even any income to tax, because income is gains, and there is no gain.

the law says "I can tax income derived from labor"

I say "sure, ok, but income is gains, and there is no gain, so even if you try to tax my wage derived from labor, its not income, and the tax doesnt work"

the state says "LOLZ I HAVE GUNS. DIE! GO TO JAIL!"


Your interpretation of the law is interesting but wrong. The courts disagree with you. The Constitution grants them the authority to interpret the law, not you. So while your interpretation is interesting, it's unimportant and legally meaningless.
 
im speaking about law. assuming the law or string of laws exist requiring that i have to file an income federal tax form, i would have to use the definition of the word income found in the IRS tax code (none), or the laws themself (none), or if none of those contain the definition, then use the definition of income as defined in the constitution.


You were shown the definition in the IRS tax code, did you not see it?
You haven't bothered to look for the laws, they exist.
They do contain the definitions, you just don't understand the words.



Correct, and after I am paid, my gain is 0 (zero), meaning there was never even any income to tax, because income is gains, and there is no gain.

the law says "I can tax income derived from labor"

I say "sure, ok, but income is gains, and there is no gain, so even if you try to tax my wage derived from labor, its not income, and the tax doesnt work"

the state says "LOLZ I HAVE GUNS. DIE! GO TO JAIL!"

But there is a gain, you start out with 0 dollars and magically (well not magically,you get paid) you end up with 800, a net gain of 800.
 
Thats not how it works though. Your labor only has value because you are compensated for it.

My labor has value when I receive a wage? do you want to retract that? (because if you dont it means you're saying im right)

If you go out and mow your yard does 100 dollars magically appear in your pocket? No.

Correct.

Labor has value when a wage or salary is received, thus making the gain 0 (zero), thus meaning there is no income.

Now if you go and mow a neighbors yard and he pays you 100 dollars you've just been compensated for services which would taxable.
Basically your "math" is wrong, it should be 0+800=800 showing a gain of 800 dollars.

The law says that income derived from compensation for services is taxable, and as you said above my labor has value so the gain is zero so the income is zero so there is no income, so i cant be taxed

They aren't taxing you for your labor (its intrinsically worthless), they are taxing the income you receive for your labor, which is why you don't have to pay taxes every time you go mow your own yard.

but you said above my labor has value because im receiving payment for it, and if it has value then isn't there no gain and thus no income?
 
Last edited:
i bolded it simply to imply that that was the major argument....

so... is it?

I trade 800 dollars of labor for 800 dollars.

800 - 800 = 0

income is defined as gains, and there is no gain here, so my wage is not a form of gain derived from compensation for services, meaning my wage is not a form of income derived from compensation for services,


Why would I pay you $800 if Im JUST gonna get $800 value back? Might as well keep my $800. If Im giving you 800 to do labor, I value that labor more than the $800 i gave you.
 
In fact, yes it does. You asking for a legal interpretation of the laws. The courts are the ones granted this power by the Constitution. They have spoken rather conclusively..

That's what "legally" means. The ones with the legal authority to make this decision have. And you are wrong. That's as legal as it gets.

Ah damn, i've been owned then. I thought legally means through whats written on the laws not what the judges decide.

However, when you talk about JURYS, they are above the law. You are above the law when you are on a jury, and thus even if a man is guilty of murder the jury can say "we dont care" and he gets to walk free.

That is the beauty of the Magna Carta and Habeus Corpus, because it creates precedence that regardless of written law members of a jury (which represents the population) ultimately decide whether a man is in the right or in the wrong and goes to jail, is punished, or gets to walk free

However, laws do dictate whether or not you get arrested and see a jury.



Show me the law requiring that i must file a federal income tax return


I was referring to the presence of a definition of the word income in the written laws, and that definition doesn't exist


False, again.

I guess it can be argued "if there is no definition of the word income in written law or the IRS code, do we use the constitutions definition or the courts definition?

i claimed the constitutions definition, you claim i am wrong and we use the courts definition. i suppose its open to argument which one we should actually use
 
My labor has value when I receive a wage? do you want to retract that? (because if you dont it means you're saying im right)



Correct.

Labor has value when a wage or salary is received, thus making the gain 0 (zero), thus meaning there is no income.



The law says that income derived from compensation for services is taxable, and as you said above my labor has value so the gain is zero so the income is zero so there is no income, so i cant be taxed



but you said above my labor has value because im receiving payment for it, and if it has value then isn't there no gain and thus no income?

It boils down to your "labor value" is not tax deductable. Therefore it is not deductable from your gross income, therefore you pay taxes on your compensation received for services. In the end it works out to 0+800=800 a net gain of 800 dollars.
 
It boils down to your "labor value" is not tax deductable. Therefore it is not deductable from your gross income, therefore you pay taxes on your compensation received for services. In the end it works out to 0+800=800 a net gain of 800 dollars.

Well when you reach a jury, they will decide whatever they want to, regardless of law, because a jury is above the law, so I guess it doesnt matter much when you actually reach court. not like most lawyers use legal arguments to save their clients from going to jail LOL



The constitution defines income as gains, and the founding fathers spoke of the sacred agreement between employer and employee where labor is exchanged for currency.

But then the current day courts, some say labor has no value and convict people, some say labor has value and people walk free.

So i guess, using the courts definition, both of us are right. Using constitutions definition, i'm right :D
 
Show me the law requiring that i must file a federal income tax return

"Returns with respect to income taxes under subtitle A shall be made by the following..." -- US Code Title 26, Subtitle F, Chapter 61, Subchapter A, Part II, Subpart B, § 6012

I was referring to the presence of a definition of the word income in the written laws, and that definition doesn't exist

'gross income' is defined. The courts have clarified the definition repeatedly to include wages gained from labor.

I guess it can be argued "if there is no definition of the word income in written law or the IRS code, do we use the constitutions definition or the courts definition?

They are the same. The fact that you interpret the Constitution differently from the courts is of academic curiosity but not legal a one. Again, they have the authority to interpret to the law, and you don't.

i claimed the constitutions definition, you claim i am wrong and we use the courts definition. i suppose its open to argument which one we should actually use


They are the same, as I said. The only mistake you are making is assuming your interpretation of the Constitution is correct. It's not. You don't have the legal authority to do that, and the courts do. The courts have done this and they have disagreed with you. Again, their authority is superior to yours.

They are interpreting the Constitution differently from you. They are not contradicting it. Your assumption that you are correctly interpreting the Constitution and the courts are contradicting the Constitution is flawed. They aren't contradicting the Constitution. They are contradicting you.
 
Show me the law requiring that i must file a federal income tax return
http://frwebgate.access.gpo.gov/cgi-bin/getdoc.cgi?dbname=browse_usc&docid=Cite:+26USC6012




I was referring to the presence of a definition of the word income in the written laws, and that definition doesn't exist

They generally don't define words in laws that are commonly known by children.


I guess it can be argued "if there is no definition of the word income in written law or the IRS code, do we use the constitutions definition or the courts definition?

No it can't, taxable income is clearly written into law.




i claimed the constitutions definition, you claim i am wrong and we use the courts definition. i suppose its open to argument which one we should actually use

There is no constitutional definition, therefore you are wrong on that.
It may have been open to arguement at one time but the court did its job and cleared that up.
 
Well when you reach a jury, they will decide whatever they want to, regardless of law, because a jury is above the law, so I guess it doesnt matter much when you actually reach court. not like most lawyers use legal arguments to save their clients from going to jail LOL

This is equally false. Juries decisions can be (and are) thrown out if they made them illegally.

The constitution defines income as gains, and the founding fathers spoke of the sacred agreement between employer and employee where labor is exchanged for currency.

But then the current day courts, some say labor has no value and convict people, some say labor has value and people walk free.

So i guess, using the courts definition, both of us are right. Using constitutions definition, i'm right :D

By your interpretation, you are right. Your interpretation is interesting but legally meaningless. The court's interpretation of the Constitution differs from yours, and theirs is legally binding.
 
"Returns with respect to income taxes under subtitle A shall be made by the following..." -- US Code Title 26, Subtitle F, Chapter 61, Subchapter A, Part II, Subpart B, § 6012

Sorry i screwed up. Show me the law thats says I must pay the federal income tax (not file the tax return). the law you linked says if i must pay the federal income tax i must file the tax return, so next step is show me the law saying i must pay the federal income tax.

regardless, even if i must pay the federal income tax, my gross income is 0 because labor has value as defined by the courts

'gross income' is defined. The courts have clarified the definition repeatedly to include wages gained from labor.

I am not trying to redefine gross income.

This is the definition of gross income in the IRS website, "The Law: For federal income tax purposes, "gross income" means all income from whatever source derived and includes compensation for services.""

gross income is defined, income is not. the argument is whether or not labor has value, and thats what courts have been shaky on when it comes to definitions.

I am saying my wage is not income because there is no gain involved, because labor has value, thus it is not a form of income derived form compensation for services, meaning the definition of gross income written above doesn't include it.

They are the same. The fact that you interpret the Constitution differently from the courts is of academic curiosity but not legal a one. Again, they have the authority to interpret to the law, and you don't.

"gross income" is defined by all the courts with the same definition usually, but the word "income" is not defined in the written law in the courts. All i hear is "gross income is income derived from X" so that explains the definition of gross income but not the definition of income

Is a wage taxable by claiming it is income? the argument boils down to does labor have value or not, and thats what courts have been shaky on because...

some courts have let people go over this, some courts have sent people to jail over this. theres been a bunch of courts that give out different definitions of labor so "labor has value as defined by the courts" and "labor has no value as defined by the courts" are both true lol. so i guess it just depends on whether or not you are lucky and get the good court!


They are the same, as I said. The only mistake you are making is assuming your interpretation of the Constitution is correct. It's not. You don't have the legal authority to do that, and the courts do. The courts have done this and they have disagreed with you. Again, their authority is superior to yours.

They are interpreting the Constitution differently from you. They are not contradicting it. Your assumption that you are correctly interpreting the Constitution and the courts are contradicting the Constitution is flawed. They aren't contradicting the Constitution. They are contradicting you.

What? courts have defined the word income? dang tell me what their definition is please. i thought they only defined the term "gross income"
 
Last edited:
The constitution defines income as gains, and the founding fathers spoke of the sacred agreement between employer and employee where labor is exchanged for currency.

But then the current day courts, some say labor has no value and convict people, some say labor has value and people walk free.

So i guess, using the courts definition, both of us are right. Using constitutions definition, i'm right :D


Please show where the constitution defines income, I can't seem to find it.

Here is what the constitution say about income taxes.....

The Congress shall have power to lay and collect taxes on incomes, from whatever source derived, without apportionment among the several States, and without regard to any census or enumeration

No definition there. Except for a few of you, the definition of income is obvious.
 
This is equally false. Juries decisions can be (and are) thrown out if they made them illegally.

Im excited! interesting stuff

got any news articles about this for me?


And by illegally, do you mean they were bribed? because i understand that, or do you mean "they liked the guy and let him go" because i dont think they get thrown out for that


I'll have to re-read the whole constitution to tell you which section the definition is under, so expect it in 2-3days.
 
Last edited:
Show me the law thats says I must pay the federal income tax (not file the tax return).

Sure.

"There is hereby imposed on the taxable income of... a tax determined in accordance ..." -- US Code Title 26, Subtitle A, Chapter 1, Subchapter A, Part I, § 1

Where you gonna move the goalposts next?

regardless, even if i must pay the federal income tax, my gross income is 0 because labor has value as defined by the courts

That's your interpretation. Again, your interpretation is interesting but legally meaningless. Legally, your gross income includes your wages and therefore legally it is taxable.

gross income is defined, income is not. the argument is whether or not labor has value, and thats what courts have been shaky on when it comes to definitions.

Taxable income is based on the definition of gross income. Defining income is irrelevant if gross income is defined. Again, it is defined, and the courts have clarified this definition to specifically include wages. Legally, this issue is black and white.

I am saying my wage is not income because there is no gain involved,

And, again, your interpretation is interesting but legally meaningless. The Constitution doesn't give you the authority to make binding interpretations of the law. It does give that power to the Courts, and they disagree with your interpretation.

All i hear is "gross income is income derived from X" so that explains the definition of gross income but not the definition of income

The tax is on your taxable income (which is gross income subtracted by specificied exemptions). You don't need to define income if you have defined gross income, taxable income, and specified all the exemptions.

Is a wage taxable by claiming it is income? the argument boils down to does labor have value or not, and thats what courst have been shaky on because...

The courts haven't been shaky, at all. They have repeatedly found that wages are part of your gross income (and are not exempt, and therefore, part of your taxable income).

some courts have let people go over this, some courts have sent people to jail over this. theres been a bunch of courts that give out different definitions of labor so "labor has value as defined by the courts" and "labor has no value as defined by the courts" are both true lol. so i guess it just depends on whether or not you are lucky and get the good court!

Whoever has fed you full of all this gibberish is lying to you, my friend. No one is getting off on the reasons you think they are. Everything you've been told is a misrepresentation of reality and you are repeating it here w/o viewing it critically enough.

The courts, at least in the last 100 years, have been completely consistent on this issue. There is nothing 'shaky' about it.

What? courts have defined the word income? dang tell me what their definition is please. i thought they only defined the term "gross income"

The courts have repeatedly and specifically found that wages earned from labor are taxable as income.
 
Yes, the 16th amendment allows the US to form a law.

Just link me the laws that require a california citizen to pay a tax on his labor.

This is a repeat (could we have a sock puppet here) of a thread from ca. November - and it is phrased like the idiot then phrased it - IIRC. The taxing my LABOR was the giveaway.
 
Ah damn, i've been owned then. I thought legally means through whats written on the laws not what the judges decide.

Then our educational system has badly failed you. There is a reason court cases refer to other court cases when making decsions.

It's the entire foundation upon which our legal system is based. But I admit I didn't understand that at your age, either.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom