[Ed.]What requires that I pay the income tax?

i dont see evidence that the definition of income, as defined by the constitution, has changed

the definition of income is "gains..." (the ... represents alot of other wording)

so no, income is not the money you got paid. income is your GAIN

you got paid 800 dollars, to get that currency you spent your labor (which is worthless) so the equation is

800 - 0 = 800 dollars of income

that is how it works legally, considering i see no evidence that the definition of income has actually changed, the courts have simply determined that LABOR of U.S. citizens in the context of law has no value
 
Ed, I would suggest you talk to Kent Hovind about your anti-tax campaign. He, too, believes that there is no law compelling him to pay income taxes. In fact, he put his (considerably untaxed) money where his mouth was on the subject when the IRS came a-callin'. See if you can guess the results... ;)

In the meantime, Hovind was raided by agents of the IRS last Wednesday for failure to pay taxes on any of his apparently large income. According the article linked to above, the IRS contends that Hovind has made bank deposits in excess of 1 million dollars per year during some of the last several years. Yet he has no business licenses for any of his ventures, nor are any of them registered as tax-exempt organizations. In the past, he has even denied having any income.
http://www.pandasthumb.org/archives/2004/04/hovind_in_troub.html
 
i dont see evidence that the definition of income, as defined by the constitution, has changed

the definition of income is "gains..." (the ... represents alot of other wording)
Exactly where are you finding this definition of "income" in the US Constitution? My copy must be defective because the word, income, occurs only once (in Amendment XVI in the form 'incomes'), and the word, gains, doesn't appear at all.
 
I am not ed, lol, i made this thread to educate myself so i could convince ed that he has to pay the income tax. dont wana see him get hurt
 
Oh, and sorry, dude, but it seems clear to me you are misusing the word "gains" here. It should be read in the sense of "obtains" (e.g. They gained the summit). You are reading "nett gains", i.e. improvements or additions (e.g. My investments gained value). Even in other countries, your income includes what you earn through labour.

Actually, any money you acquire is "income". You may have invested wisely when young, and have a whole share portfolio that you live off. You don't labour at all, provide no services to anyone - just sit in the Laz-E-Boy all day and flip TV channels getting fat. But your investments are still earning "income", so you will be paying income tax...

Your only out is to seek and use any of the legitimate income-reducing options, or any tax-break options available in your locality. But trying to redefine the law off your own bat is out-and-out foolishness. If you want to do that, you REALLY need to get organised!
 
Exactly where are you finding this definition of "income" in the US Constitution? My copy must be defective because the word, income, occurs only once (in Amendment XVI in the form 'incomes'), and the word, gains, doesn't appear at all.


He says it will take him 2 or 3 days to read it, so we will have to wait. :rolleyes:
 
Actually, any money you acquire is "income". You may have invested wisely when young, and have a whole share portfolio that you live off. You don't labour at all, provide no services to anyone - just sit in the Laz-E-Boy all day and flip TV channels getting fat. But your investments are still earning "income", so you will be paying income tax...

HOLY BATMAN I DID NOT KNOW THAT... lol... yeah im being sarcastig are you serious? of course that is income. you take the original cost of the stock subtract it from the new cost calculate your total revenues and you have your proffit (income)

your gain is your income.

i still believe what i believed in the beginning of this thread, but anti-sophist explained it perfectly






1.) The U.S. judicial branch is given the power by the constitution to determine what written laws and the definition of terms when dealing with law mean, and 2.) The U.S. judicial branch (the courts) have unaminously determined that the LABOR of U.S. citizens in the context of law has no value (essentially, they determined that all people in the U.S.A. are slaves), and because the constitution gives the power to the U.S. judicial branch to determine the definition of written law, we are legally required by the constitution to treat their determination that our labor has no value in the context of tax laws as truth

Because of these 2 occurances, it now means there IS GAIN when you recieve a wage or salary, meaning when you recieve a wage or salary you are recieving income (defined as "gains...") in the constitution, due to the courts determination that all citizens in America are slaves and therefore our labor has a value of zero dollars.

because of the US judicial branch determining that all U.S. citizens are slaves and therefore our labor is worthless and has no value, it means that your salary and wage now does qualify as income in the context of US law, meaning all of those federal laws applying to your "income" (or "gains..." as defined by the constitution) now apply to your wage and salary.

Its that simple.

but your explanation "its income because its the money you get, LOL" aint really accurate.
 
I love how he reduces all rule of law into, "We have the guns, so you have to do what we say!!!!"

That's such a teenager way of thinking. It just totally removes all responsibility from the people who, over decades have voted this system in place and agreed to live by it. If you want the benefits and protections of doing business in the USA, you have to agree to play by the rules and help fund said benefits and protections.

But then again, he thinks all money collected from income taxes is shipped to China to build slave labor camps or something so he may not have the firmest grip on reality.
 
HOLY BATMAN I DID NOT KNOW THAT... lol... yeah im being sarcastig are you serious? of course that is income. you take the original cost of the stock subtract it from the new cost calculate your total revenues and you have your proffit (income)

your gain is your income.
You didn't read what I wrote, did you.

Here, it's simple. Any non-accountant, or even a reasonably bright child, can follow along:

1) You get INCOME by whatever means: labour, services, investments, etc.

2) You have OUTGOINGS: food, utilities, alimony, DVD rental, etc.

3) Your PROFIT (or "gain" as you call it) is your INCOME less your OUTGOINGS.

4) TAX is an OUTGOING, and is calculated on your INCOME, not on your PROFIT (hence the name "income tax").

5) People and companies try to reduce TAX because it affects their PROFIT, not their INCOME.


Now, if you decide that this is not how things work in your world, then you are living in a different world from the rest of us. However if you agree that this is correct then your whole notion as outlined is based on totally spurious assumptions. That is, you are just making it up to please yourself. In which case, have fun with that, OK?
 
I love how he reduces all rule of law into, "We have the guns, so you have to do what we say!!!!"

That's such a teenager way of thinking. It just totally removes all responsibility from the people who, over decades have voted this system in place and agreed to live by it. If you want the benefits and protections of doing business in the USA, you have to agree to play by the rules and help fund said benefits and protections.

I dont get entirely what you're saying. Are you saying the tax on wages and salaries funds government?

hahahahahahhhhaa man thats funny


anyway
Yeah man, and if i ever became emperor of some other nation in the world the U.S. would just force us to go under UN law :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes:

Have you read the U.N. charter of rights? We would get all these great rights and in article 28 it takes them all away, you only get those rights if the UN deems/orders it LOL

But then again, he thinks all money collected from income taxes is shipped to China to build slave labor camps or something so he may not have the firmest grip on reality.

you should check up on that the carlyle group has been investing in recently.



You didn't read what I wrote, did you.

Here, it's simple. Any non-accountant, or even a reasonably bright child, can follow along:

1) You get INCOME by whatever means: labour, services, investments, etc.

2) You have OUTGOINGS: food, utilities, alimony, DVD rental, etc.

3) Your PROFIT (or "gain" as you call it) is your INCOME less your OUTGOINGS.

4) TAX is an OUTGOING, and is calculated on your INCOME, not on your PROFIT (hence the name "income tax").

5) People and companies try to reduce TAX because it affects their PROFIT, not their INCOME.


Now, if you decide that this is not how things work in your world, then you are living in a different world from the rest of us. However if you agree that this is correct then your whole notion as outlined is based on totally spurious assumptions. That is, you are just making it up to please yourself. In which case, have fun with that, OK?

All 5 points are true.

The statement: Income is defined as gains.
is true (havn't seen otherwise)

The statement: Gains is defined as accession to wealth from economic events by the calculations of revenues less costs other accounting equations to determine the breadth of increase in wealth.
is true

you seem to think simply gaining money is a form of income? not in the business world im taking 300 level accounting classes and revenue is gaining money, income is whats left after you subtract all your expenses and costs from all your revenue and sales accounts then put that info on your income statement for the business and then you close the expense accounts but whatever

my point is, income is gains. simply getting money isnt always a gain... but now wages and salaries are considered gains under written law because the courts have determined that labor has no value.
 
Last edited:
many other countries have taxes on labor and salaries and wages, and they call it an income tax

many other countries have taxes on business income, and they call it an income tax

are they the same thing? depends.

if the country claims both are taxes on gains, then they have done what US has done and determined that labor has no value so salaries and wages are counted as gains

if the country claims they are different taxes and they claim salaries and wages are not gains but are taxed as income, then they are just defining the term income as incoming money flow and they allow businesses to claim expenses off of that. theres probably a few other ways it could work. but it doesnt matter tax laws are different in many places you already know that

both ways have the same outcome (people get taxed) and the definitions and rules of the tax depend upon the country in question.
 
Wages and Salaries are not income

Oh, yes they are income, you blithering idiot.

http://evans-legal.com/dan/tpfaq.html#wagesincome

(Wait, don't tell me, that link is part of a huge conspiracy to hide the truth...)

because when you trade labor for money you're trading 100 dollars of labor (1 hour) for 100 dollars of currency.

If that idiotic statement were true, what would be your problem with taxes? After all, it's just a fair exchange: the government takes your money and gives you in return roads, the police, etc.

So you actually aren't being taxed at all, you see. It's just a fair trade.
 
I dont get entirely what you're saying. Are you saying the tax on wages and salaries funds government?

hahahahahahhhhaa man thats funny

That's the generally accepted notion, yes. It's one thing to make weird claims about law, since you can get a lot done by simply being ridiculously pedantic, but to say that the money collected by the IRS goes to a completely different place than they say it goes to is a rather big and tangible claim to make.

If the income tax doesn't go to the government, then suddenly the government is getting way less money than they say they do, which does not explain how they manage to run the government. Do they overstate costs to cover up the conspiracy or do they get enough money to cover the difference from secret loans or something?

you seem to think simply gaining money is a form of income? not in the business world im taking 300 level accounting classes and revenue is gaining money, income is whats left after you subtract all your expenses and costs from all your revenue and sales accounts then put that info on your income statement for the business and then you close the expense accounts but whatever

That's net income, which is generally more useful for accounting purposes, but gross income is what is the law says is taxed, as was stated on the first page.
 
revenue is gaining money, income is whats left after you subtract all your expenses and costs from all your revenue and sales accounts


Exactly.

Thats why labor is deemed to have "no value". It costs you nothing to perform. Its not an expense for you. Therefore you can't decuct it from your income.
 
Last edited:
Oh, yes they are income, you blithering idiot.

http://evans-legal.com/dan/tpfaq.html#wagesincome

(Wait, don't tell me, that link is part of a huge conspiracy to hide the truth...)

I made that statement assuming the courts had not determined that labor had no value.

Yes, you are correct, because the courts have determined that labor has no value it now means wages and salaries are income.


However, if you are saying wages and salaries are income in a hypothetical world where the courts didnt determine that labor was worthless, you would be dead wrong. So if you want to talk about that let me know but I dont know if thats what you mean.


If that idiotic statement were true, what would be your problem with taxes? After all, it's just a fair exchange: the government takes your money and gives you in return roads, the police, etc.

So you actually aren't being taxed at all, you see. It's just a fair trade.

The statement you quoting me saying is not true, at least it wasnt true within the last 50 years.

It used to be true when labor was defined as having value. But the courts have the power to determine the definitions of terms when in the context or breadth of written law so they can define labor as not having value, which they did, so wages and salaries are sources of income - YOU ARE RIGHT


I was making those original posts before anti-sophist explained to me how courts are allowed to determine the definitions of written law and terms that deal with civil law


That's the generally accepted notion, yes. It's one thing to make weird claims about law, since you can get a lot done by simply being ridiculously pedantic, but to say that the money collected by the IRS goes to a completely different place than they say it goes to is a rather big and tangible claim to make.

The IRS says the tax on wages and salaries is absorbed into the national debt. Translation: it goes to the private banks of the federal reserve that we owe the national debt to.

Maybe you forget about the tax on income from business operation. That tax goes into our military mostly. The tax on wages and salaries goes into the national dept. IRS says this.
That's net income, which is generally more useful for accounting purposes, but gross income is what is the law says is taxed, as was stated on the first page.

sorry about that. when i think of income tax related to business income statements i think about the tax that would be on net income because all of the expenses and costs are deducted from the tax on gross income related to business so in reality they only end up paying their portion of net income as taxes to the government so i usually mix the two phrases.
 
Last edited:
You make it sound like it's an American conspiracy to force you to give your government money so that they can use it to wage war.

Everybody in the modern world who works are supposed to pay their taxes. It's part of the adult life, you work, you contribute to society.

Simple equation. You don't like it, move to Antarctica, I hear it will be a good summer vacation spot soon.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom