[Ed.]What requires that I pay the income tax?

I don't understand how you can differentiate the income earned by a business as a result of the labour of employees from the income earned by those employees by their own labour.

Does business income come from nothing and is therefore taxable?

Is money earned by individuals somehow different from money earned by groups of individuals?
 
Fine I will explain.

Theres income. Income is the gains derived from business; revenues minus costs is income as defined by the constitution.

The 16th amendment allowed the government to levy taxes on all forms of income, which it already had the power to do.

Wages and Salaries are not income, because when you trade labor for money you're trading 100 dollars of labor (1 hour) for 100 dollars of currency. When your labor becomes more valuable you get a raise, or maybe you have an easy job and your labor is less valuable.

If I make 100 dollars an hour and I work 8 hours I have 0 dollars of income, because my labor has value. So I spent 800 dollars of labor (cost) to gain 800 dollars of currency.

800 - 800 = 0

0 income.

Anyway, there are laws that say you have to pay a tax on your business income. That is good income tax that goes to fund mostly our military.
The trick is when we pay income tax on our wage or salary. We are told that wages and salaries are income. Whatever.

Most of the time, i've found laws that say if you are required to file a federal income tax return yo must file a state tax return for [this state] or vice versa, and I can't find the law that says citizen of [this state] must file a federal income tax return.

Even if you HAD to file an income tax return, you would have to use the term income as defined in the IRS tax code, but the IRS tax code never defines the word income in its 55,000+ pages. Until the IRS tax code defines the word income, we use the constitutions definition.

Nope, actually your 8 hours of labor is worthless unless someone chooses to give you money for it. It is not something you actually paid for. So basically, your revenue vs. cost statement looks more like:

800-0=800
 
Last edited:
Lets just assume hypothetically I live in california and make 100 dollars an hour and I work 8 hours a day monday through friday. Which laws, whether state or federal laws, require that I pay a tax on my labor.



Link them to me or type them out so I can comment. Thank you.

Let me guess - you're an anti-tax woo-woo?
 
Nope, actually your 8 hours of labor is worthless unless someone chooses to give you money for it. It is not something you actually paid for. So basically, your revenue vs. cost statement looks more like:

800-0=800

My labor is worthless? I guess I am a slave.

Even though the founding fathers talked about the "sacred agreement" between employer and employee where labor is TRADED for wage and/or salary
I don't understand how you can differentiate the income earned by a business as a result of the labour of employees from the income earned by those employees by their own labour.

Does business income come from nothing and is therefore taxable?

Is money earned by individuals somehow different from money earned by groups of individuals?
The employees input their labor and get their payout, there is no income. Assume a employee is paid 50 dollars for 50 dollars of labor.

50 - 50 = 0 dollars of income, for the employee

The business pays the employees 800 dollars for their labor, and that labor produces 2000 dollars of proffits for the company.

2000 - 800 = 1200 dollars of income, for the business

so the business must pay its income tax, on 1200 dollars of taxable income

but the employee has 0 dollars of taxable income

another 2 examples of how a business can produce income is a business buying items and selling them or using them.

Items original cost 2000 dollars, sold for 5000.

5000 - 2000 = 3000 dollars of income.

Or items original cost 2000 dollars, produced 7000 dollars of productivity.

7000 - 2000 = 5000 dollars of income.


I have taken college level accounting classes and there are many forms of cost proffit revenue expense analysis that you use to put together an income statement for a business to find its total taxable income. this is the easy to explain nutshell version.
 
Last edited:
Theres income. Income is the gains derived from business; revenues minus costs is income as defined by the constitution.

(emphasis mine)

Where, exactly, in the Constitution are you finding this definition of income?

The 16th amendment allowed the government to levy taxes on all forms of income, which it already had the power to do.

Right. The new bit was "without apportionment among the several States, and without regard to any census or enumeration", which prior to the ratification of the 16th Amendment was forbidden by Article I, Section 9.

Also, since the 16th Amendment is very short, you can't have failed to notice the phrase "from whatever source derived", which clearly means it doesn't matter how you get your income. As Al Capone found out.

the IRS tax code never defines the word income in its 55,000+ pages. Until the IRS tax code defines the word income, we use the constitutions definition.

I don't imagine that pretending not to know what the word income means will impress a judge. Try it out, though, and let us know how it goes.
 
Right. The new bit was "without apportionment among the several States, and without regard to any census or enumeration", which prior to the ratification of the 16th Amendment was forbidden by Article I, Section 9.

Also, since the 16th Amendment is very short, you can't have failed to notice the phrase "from whatever source derived", which clearly means it doesn't matter how you get your income. As Al Capone found out.
before the 16th amendment the government was seen as "bad" when they claimed income tax fraud on someone who sold their family house and the government tried to take some of that claiming it was taxable business income, it was seen as "taboo" or bad for government to do that. "from whatever source derived" part of the amendment speaks to stuff like that. Im pretty sure government already had the power to do that and they just added it in there for fun, almost 100% of the bills passed in congress never get read so im pretty sure non of the congressmen even cared about what it said anyway.

As for the "without apportionment among the several States, and without regard to any census or enumeration" part, that refers to the uniform of the tax in question. The constitution says an apportioned tax is "uniform (or uniformed?) throughout the states". It just means that the government can be unfair and make some people pay more of their income than others. I believe you are correct that this is a new power the amendment granted the government.

Still regardless, so I guess the government gained the power to turn a uniform income tax into a non-uniform income tax from the 16th amendment, but it didnt change the definition of the word income.
 
Last edited:
Yes, the 16th amendment allows the US to form a law.

Just link me the laws that require a california citizen to pay a tax on his labor.
Let me guess, oahuoahu, you feel you shouldn't have to pay income tax on the money you get for your labor, am I correct?

If so, do you think anybody who "labors" for a living (as opposed to living off of investments) should have to pay income tax?
 
before the 16th amendment the government was seen as "bad" when they claimed income tax fraud on someone who sold their family house and the government tried to take some of that claiming it was taxable business income, it was seen as "taboo" or bad for government to do that.

I find it hard to believe that the government charged anyone with "income tax fraud" prior to the ratification of the 16th Amendment. Perhaps you can cite such a case?

"from whatever source derived" part of the amendment speaks to stuff like that. Im pretty sure government already had the power to do that and they just added it in there for fun, almost 100% of the bills passed in congress never get read so im pretty sure non of the congressmen even cared about what it said anyway.

Dude. Seriously. Amending the Constitution is an undertaking of considerable effort. Wording is not added to proposed amendments "just for fun" and generally speaking the various state legislatures read the amendments and consider their meaning very carefully. To suggest otherwise is just seeking out a whole new level of silliness.

Still regardless, so I guess the government gained the power to turn a uniform income tax into a non-uniform income tax from the 16th amendment, but it didnt change the definition of the word income.

This would be the definition that you previously said was in the Constitution, yes? Did you miss the first question in my post? If so, I'll ask it again:

Where, exactly, in the Constitution are you finding this definition of the word income?
 
Thank you for the clarification. You are wrong.

This was addressed judically in the famous court case Cheek vs. United States. Cheek lost. The IRS specifically addresses this argument in one of their official publications, with the relevant case law, and calls it "frivolous."


Thank you for your participation.

This argument asserts that wages, tips, and other compensation received for personal services are not income, because there is allegedly no taxable gain when a person "exchanges" labor for money. Under this theory, wages are not taxable income because people have basis in their labor equal to the fair market value of the wages they receive; thus, there is no gain to be taxed. A variation of this argument misconstrues section 1341, which deals with computations of tax where a taxpayer restores a substantial amount held under claim of right, to somehow allow a deduction claim for personal services rendered.

Another similar argument asserts that wages are not subject to taxation where a person has obtained funds in exchange for their time. Under this theory, wages are not taxable because the Code does not specifically tax these so-called "time reimbursement transactions." Some take a different approach and argue that the Sixteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution did not authorize a tax on wages and salaries, but only on gain or profit.

The Law: For federal income tax purposes, "gross income" means all income from whatever source derived and includes compensation for services. I.R.C. § 61. Any income, from whatever source, is presumed to be income under section 61, unless the taxpayer can establish that it is specifically exempted or excluded. In Reese v. United States, 24 F.3d 228, 231 (Fed. Cir. 1994), the court stated, "an abiding principle of federal tax law is that, absent an enumerated exception, gross income means all income from whatever source derived."

Section 1341 and the cases interpreting it require taxpayers to return funds previously reported as income before they can claim a deduction under claim of right. To have the right to a deduction, the taxpayer should appear to have an unrestricted right to the income in question. See Dominion Resources, Inc. v. United States, 219 F.3d 359 (4th Cir. 2000). It is a frivolous argument to claim a section 1341 deduction when there has been no repayment by the taxpayer of an amount previously reported as income. The Internal Revenue Service issued, 2004-1 C.B. 627, warning taxpayers of the consequences of making this frivolous argument.

The Sixteenth Amendment provides that Congress shall have the power to lay and collect taxes on income, from whatever source derived, without apportionment among the several states, and without regard to any census or enumeration. U.S. Const. amend. XVI. Furthermore, the U.S. Supreme Court upheld the constitutionality of the income tax laws enacted subsequent to ratification of the Sixteenth Amendment in Brushaber v. Union Pacific R.R., 240 U.S. 1 (1916). Since that time, the courts have consistently upheld the constitutionality of the federal income tax. For a further discussion of the constitutionality of the federal income tax laws, see section I.D. of this outline.

All compensation for personal services, no matter what the form of payment, must be included in gross income. This includes salary or wages paid in cash, as well as the value of property and other economic benefits received because of services performed, or to be performed in the future. Furthermore, criminal and civil penalties have been imposed against individuals relying upon this frivolous argument.

I see them call it frivolous but they still don't define the word income.

they say "The Law: For federal income tax purposes, "gross income" means all income from whatever source derived and includes compensation for services."

But the word service in current business practice and probably the constitution (I'll have to check) means the services that business provides to customers. So obviously the money a costumer gives to a business for services like internet access can be taxable income

then it says "The Law: For federal income tax purposes, "gross income" means all income from whatever source derived " but still doesn't even define the word income. It is actually right, that is what gross income means, and gross income is taxable, but Im talking about my wage and salary here.

I never said my income wasn't taxable, I said my wage and salary wasn't based on current law, but I have to use the word income because of the propaganda machine convincing everyone that the words are interchangable

So what I'm really saying is, "My wage or salary is not taxable income, assuming I am required to file an income tax return by law, unless income is defined to include wages and salaries"
 
Commissioner v. Glenshaw Glass Co., 348 U.S. 426, 429-30 (1955) – referring to the statute’s words "income derived from any source whatever," the Supreme Court stated, "this language was used by Congress to exert in this field ‘the full measure of its taxing power.’ . . . And the Court has given a liberal construction to this broad phraseology in recognition of the intention of Congress to tax all gains except those specifically exempted."

- Yes, congress CAN tax all gains, but my salary and wage is not a gain

Commissioner v. Kowalski, 434 U.S. 77 (1977) – the Supreme Court found that payments are considered income where the payments are undeniably accessions to wealth, clearly realized, and over which a taxpayer has complete dominion.

- My wage and salary does not contribute to my wealth. wealth is similare to the word gains. if i was given money, that is accession to wealth. when i labor for money that is not accession to wealth because i gained nothing.

United States v. Sloan, 939 F.2d 499, 500 (7th Cir. 1991) – in rejecting defendant’s argument that the revenue laws of the United States do not impose a tax on income, the court recognized the "Internal Revenue Code imposes a tax on all income."

- But is my wage or salary, my income?

United States v. Becker, 965 F.2d 383, 389 (7th Cir. 1992) – the court found defendant’s contention that wages are not income to be "ridiculous."
United States v. Connor, 898 F.2d 942, 943-44 (3d Cir.), cert. denied, 497 U.S. 1029 (1990) – the court stated that "[e]very court which has ever considered the issue has unequivocally rejected the argument that wages are not income."
Stelly v. Commissioner, 761 F. 2d 1113 (5th Cir. 1985) – the Fifth Circuit affirmed the Tax Court’s holding against the taxpayer’s argument that taxing wage and salary income is a violation of the constitution because compensation for labor is an exchange, not gain. The Fifth Circuit also fined the taxpayer for bringing a frivolous appeal.
United States v. White, 769 F. 2d 511 (8th Cir. 1985) – the court issued a permanent injunction to prevent the promotion of the argument that there is no tax imposed on an exchange of property (labor) in an equal exchange for property (wages).
United States v. Richards, 723 F.2d 646, 648 (8th Cir. 1983) – the court upheld conviction and fines imposed for willfully failing to file tax returns, stating that the taxpayer’s contention that wages and salaries are not income within the meaning of the Sixteenth Amendment is "totally lacking in merit."
United States v. Romero, 640 F.2d 1014, 1016 (9th Cir. 1981) – the court affirmed Romero’s conviction for willfully failing to file tax returns, finding, in part, that "[t]he trial judge properly instructed the jury on the meaning of [‘income’ and ‘person’]. Romero’s proclaimed belief that he was not a ‘person’ and that the wages he earned as a carpenter were not ‘income’ is fatuous as well as obviously incorrect."

- Oh. Okay.

Lonsdale v. Commissioner, 661 F.2d 71, 72 (5th Cir. 1981) – the court rejected as "meritless" the taxpayer’s contention that the "exchange of services for money is a zero-sum transaction . . . ."

- This taxpayer was wrong for using the word "services" he should have used the word "labor". Or maybe a messup occured and someone mixed up the two words somewhere between documents.



So it seems they think its the law, and they have all the guns, so I should just comply.
Well, regardless, my situation is hypothetical, anyone want to prove i or he is liable to pay a tax on his wage or salary?

I predict that oahuoahu, in true 9/11 nutter fashion, will ignore all that.

I'm not a twoofer


I have said about 2-3 times how there is no evidence that 1,2 and 7 were CD, and I have explained (with proof) how 1,2 and 7 were not CD.


Sometimes I counter misleading information, but I make sure to say "if the twoofer conspiracy was real, this and this and this and this"


An example of this is when people say alex jones blames the firefighters. I will counter that misleading information. Is it because I am a twoofer? no, I am just annoyed by people spreading misleading information. Alex jones has never blamed the firefighters, and I explain things more clearly for people.


Now i am sure I have never said I believe in the twoofer conspiracy, but if you ever thought I do I probably just forgot to add "if the twoofer conspiracy was real," before my words


regardless, how nice of you to call me a twoofer because I cant find a tax law that requires ME to pay a tax on my wage or salary. All i'm doing is asking a question.
 
Last edited:
We dont need taxes! The country can run off smiles and sunshine.

Its easy if you dont wanna pay income tax JUST DONT WORK!!! You're not forced to work. Have a blissful life living under a bridge somewhere.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom