[Ed.]What requires that I pay the income tax?

oahuoahu vbmenu_register("postmenu_2384091", true); - if you dont want to pay income tax, go ahead. no one here is going to cry if you stop. but be prepared to suffer the legal consequences of not paying that taxes that everyone else does.

by the way, can you quote me the law making it illegal to j walk?
 
But the word service in current business practice and probably the constitution (I'll have to check) means the services that business provides to customers. So obviously the money a costumer gives to a business for services like internet access can be taxable income

Yes businesses provide services for customers.

Employees provide services for employers (labor) and are compensated for those services. That compensation is income which is taxable.
 
Yes businesses provide services for customers.

Employees provide services for employers (labor) and are compensated for those services. That compensation is income which is taxable.

even if services means labor of employees, they say "The Law: For federal income tax purposes, "gross income" means all income from whatever source derived and includes compensation for services."

So assuming my wage is a compensation for service, because the phrase claims that income derived from compensation for services is (as far as law concerns) income derived from a source, the arguement then becomes, is my wage a form of income derived from a source?

So even if compensation for services includes wages, it comes back to the "is my wage a form of income arguement", which would require the word income to be defined as including wages and salaries


We dont need taxes! The country can run off smiles and sunshine.

Its easy if you dont wanna pay income tax JUST DONT WORK!!! You're not forced to work. Have a blissful life living under a bridge somewhere.

Americans pay over a thousand taxes that fund out government.

The tax we pay on our labor and wages go to the private banks that own/makeup the federal reserve. And they dont use this money to pay for the services we expect from government.
 
Last edited:
Americans pay over a thousand taxes that fund out government.

The tax we pay on our labor and wages go to the private banks that own/makeup the federal reserve. And they dont use this money to pay for the services we expect from government.

This is not entirely true.

You know what I suggest? Get active with the libertarians or other anti-tax groups and try and get the system changed. If you think you're going to do anything but wind up in a whole lot of legal trouble, play the game of semantics with the law and see what happens. NOTHING WILL CHANGE except that you will become a convicted criminal. And we, who pay taxes, will end up feeding and housing you!

I am all for getting rid of government pork. I am all for major change in the amount of tax we pay and how that money is used. But the game you're playing is sheer futility.

You're 19, don't throw your youth away with a criminal record. My suggestion would be grow in your education and perhaps choose a political action group that is addressing this issue legally and logically.
 
Americans pay over a thousand taxes that fund out government.

The tax we pay on our labor and wages go to the private banks that own/makeup the federal reserve. And they dont use this money to pay for the services we expect from government.

So our income taxes get stuffed under some giant govt mattress somewhere? BULLFLOP I SAY!!!
 
even if services means labor of employees, they say "The Law: For federal income tax purposes, "gross income" means all income from whatever source derived and includes compensation for services."

So assuming my wage is a compensation for service, because the phrase claims that income derived from compensation for services is (as far as law concerns) income derived from a source, the arguement then becomes, is my wage a form of income derived from a source?

So even if compensation for services includes wages, it comes back to the "is my wage a form of income arguement", which would require the word income to be defined as including wages and salaries

Pure semantics, and I do believe you know that it's semantics.
Not even Johnny Cochran could have spun this.
 
So our income taxes get stuffed under some giant govt mattress somewhere? BULLFLOP I SAY!!!

No, our illegal income taxes (theres legal and illegal income tax) go to the private banks of the federal reserve which are NOT part of our government.

The private banks of the federal reserve are not registered as businesses through the district of columbia so they are not US business and they dont need to be transparent, and they arent, so their actions are largely hidden.


IF I HAD TO TAKE A GUESS, they are probably using our illegal income tax dollars to buy chinese companys and or fund china to make sure we keep the slave trade coming from china to america (slave goods), SO IN A WAY, i guess you can claim that our illegal income tax dollars do give us a service we expect from government (slave goods)
 
Last edited:
Maybe out govt can run off a WOO WOO tax! This thread would generate millions. :D
 
even if services means labor of employees, they say "The Law: For federal income tax purposes, "gross income" means all income from whatever source derived and includes compensation for services."

Exactly, compensation (wages) for services (labor) is a taxable income.



So assuming my wage is a compensation for service, because the phrase claims that income derived from compensation for services is (as far as law concerns) income derived from a source, the arguement then becomes, is my wage a form of income derived from a source?

Assuming? It IS a compensation for services. Do you think that if you didn't perform your services, your employer would continue to compensate you?

Yes the income is derived from your employer.



So even if compensation for services includes wages, it comes back to the "is my wage a form of income arguement", which would require the word income to be defined as including wages and salaries

No it wouldn't. Compensation for services is pretty much the legal definition of wages and salaries.



ETA- please stop going back to edit your previous posts the way you do. It gets confusing when you add entire new responses to other peoples posts.
 
Last edited:
You forgot a few things.

No, our illegal income taxes (theres legal and illegal income tax) go to the private banks of the federal reserve which are NOT part of our government.

The private banks of the federal reserve are not registered as businesses through the district of columbia so they are not US business and they dont need to be transparent, and they arent, so their actions are largely hidden.


IF I HAD TO TAKE A GUESS, they are probably using our illegal income tax dollars to buy chinese companys and or fund china to make sure we keep the slave trade coming from china to america (slave goods), SO IN A WAY, i guess you can claim that our illegal income tax dollars do give us a service we expect from government (slave goods)

Have you ever:
  • Driven down an interstate highway?
  • Eaten in a clean, safe restaurant?
  • Gone out at night without being assaulted by brigands?
And that's just scratching the surface. Income taxes aren't "illegal" and used for "slave labor", they're payment for services rendered. (Well, ideally. I'm not sure about some farm subsidies...)
 
Assuming? It IS a compensation for services. Do you think that if you didn't perform your services, your employer would continue to compensate you?

Yes the income is derived from your employer.

ok, so then it is, so i will do the rest of the arguement now that i know it is....

"""The Law: For federal income tax purposes, "gross income" means all income from whatever source derived and includes compensation for services."""

the phrase claims that income derived from compensation for services is (as far as law concerns) income derived from a source, so arguement then becomes, is my wage a form of income derived from compensation for services?

if my wage is a form of income derived from compensation for services then it is income derived from a source or simply income and taxable

if my wage is not a form of income derived from compensation for services then the whole statement doesnt apply to my wage

So, as i have explained, the final arguement to be determined is...


Is my wage a form of income derived from compensation for services?

I trade 800 dollars of labor for 800 dollars.

800 - 800 = 0

income is defined as gains, and there is no gain here, so my wage is not a form of gain derived from compensation for services, meaning my wage is not a form of income derived from compensation for services,

meaning the law doesn't force me to pay a tax on my wage



And that's just scratching the surface. Income taxes aren't "illegal" and used for "slave labor", they're payment for services rendered. (Well, ideally. I'm not sure about some farm subsidies...)

I never said income taxes are illegal. I said there is legal income tax and illegal income tax. if it is a tax on wage or salary, it is "illegal income tax", which helps fund the private banks of the federal reserve and i dont know what they do with the money

as far as payment for services. are you talking about service from government? if so, the illegal income taxes do not pay for that, nor does the legal income tax pay for that.

education is largely funded by property taxes
highways are largely funded by gas taxes
there are over 1000 other taxes that americans pay to fund government services, and the illegal income taxes are not one of them
 
Last edited:
i bolded it simply to imply that that was the major argument....

so... is it?

I trade 800 dollars of labor for 800 dollars.

800 - 800 = 0

income is defined as gains, and there is no gain here, so my wage is not a form of gain derived from compensation for services, meaning my wage is not a form of income derived from compensation for services,
 
Last edited:
"Compensation for labor or services, paid in the form of wages or salary, has been universally held by the courts of this republic to be income, subject to the income tax laws currently applicable." United States v. Romero, 640 F.2d 1014, 1016 (9th Cir. 1981).


I don't understand how you can stare reality directly in the face and just lie to yourself.
 
You know, often when I come across a word whose meaning I don't know, or am unsure of, I look it up in a dictionary. I happen to have an old Random House dictionary here on my desk. Let's see what it says ...

The monetary or equivalent returns that come in periodically, esp. annually, from property, business, labor, etc.; revenue; receipts.

A popular online dictionary says this:

a gain or recurrent benefit usually measured in money that derives from capital or labor; also : the amount of such gain received in a period of time <has an income of $30,000 a year>

Careful readers will note that the word "labor" does appear in both definitions.
 
Aw, baloney. Wages is income. But, after deducting depreciation equal to that years income, there would be no tax due. Why not? Your working body only has so many years in it, you've used up one, so...
 
"Compensation for labor or services, paid in the form of wages or salary, has been universally held by the courts of this republic to be income, subject to the income tax laws currently applicable." United States v. Romero, 640 F.2d 1014, 1016 (9th Cir. 1981).


I don't understand how you can stare reality directly in the face and just lie to yourself.

I think he's making a philosophical "social justice" kind of argument and thinking that the semantical interpretation is terribly clever.

There is a reason I checked his age when I saw the OP.
 
What requires that you pay income tax?

If your house is burning down, guys show up to stop the fire. If someone shoots you, somebody goes and rounds them up so they don't shoot anyone else (and if you believe in revenge, they take that for you too). If you want some bread, you don't have to clean pots for the baker; you can just use money. Feel free not to use those services if you don't intend on paying taxes.
 
i bolded it simply to imply that that was the major argument....

so... is it?

I trade 800 dollars of labor for 800 dollars.

800 - 800 = 0

income is defined as gains, and there is no gain here, so my wage is not a form of gain derived from compensation for services, meaning my wage is not a form of income derived from compensation for services,

But surely your wage is your employer paying you $800 for $800 worth of service. Whatever form that service takes. It might be digging ditches or programming computers, it doesn't matter. You provide a service for the employer and he/she pays for that service.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom