[Ed.]What requires that I pay the income tax?

Did you miss the immediately previous quote? From Central Illinois[/i (footnotes omitted):
That was not a lie, it was a mistake which I'm sure you never make, but anyway I admitted my mistake.


Game, set, match.

Or prove yourself a liar.

The IRS is not a law making body it is a tax collection agency. The law is seperate from IRS code. If the IRS code does not follow guidelines set by the real law makers then it is unlawful and it does not matter what it says. The law says taxes must be apportioned or indirect, the 16th amendment didn't change that fact according to the supreme court on several occasions. The tax on wages does not fit the guidelines for apportioned or indirect, therefore it is unconstitutional.

Learn the system of government we are in, I found fourth grade to be enlightening. I think it is very clear who writes the laws when you study Intro to American Government. The IRS is not a fourth branch with power to create a tax without a law written and approved by congress then signed by the president. That is the law that needs to be cited, not tax code written by people who have no power at all to create tax.

Game, set, match my ass.
 
Did you miss the immediately previous quote? From Central Illinois[/i (footnotes omitted):


Learn the system of government we are in, I found fourth grade to be enlightening. I think it is very clear who writes the laws when you study Intro to American Government. The IRS is not a fourth branch with power to create a tax without a law written and approved by congress then signed by the president. That is the law that needs to be cited, not tax code written by people who have no power at all to create tax.

Game, set, match my ass.


My daughter is in the fourth grade. She has been shown this thread, and followed the links. Whenever I find an opportunity to educate her on critical thinking, I jump on it. She gets it, and spent a good deal of time exclaiming "Umm, how could he NOT think this is income!". Some mighty fine analogies followed. She'd explain it all to you on your level--she even offered--but she's not allowed to talk to boys on the internet.
 
So, you didn't bother to read them?
I read them

http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/html/uscode26/usc_sec_26_00000063----000-.html
U.S.C. Title 26 §63 defines taxable income as gross income minus certain deductions.
It defines income by calling it income...? O.k. I define a blue shilaphalet by saying a it is a green shilaphalet minus yellow. Now do you know what a shilphalet is?
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/html/uscode26/usc_sec_26_00000001----000-.html
U.S.C. Title 26 §1 imposes a tax on taxable income.
Yeah we already came to that conclusion but thanks, but still no definition of income.

You have been shown the law. If you are too frightened to read it or too stupid to understand it, that is your problem.

You got me there smarty, one law descibes deductions for people who are required to pay taxes the other allows taxes on taxable income. The law has standards for what is taxable and what is not. Apportioned or indirect is the only legal taxation allowed. The 16th amendment offers no new forms of taxation according to the Supreme Court

I think you may need to re-read the laws, where does it specifically define income. Where does it say the IRS can now tax beyond the standard of apportioned or indirect?
 
The IRS is not a law making body it is a tax collection agency. The law is seperate from IRS code. If the IRS code does not follow guidelines set by the real law makers then it is unlawful and it does not matter what it says. The law says taxes must be apportioned or indirect, the 16th amendment didn't change that fact according to the supreme court on several occasions. The tax on wages does not fit the guidelines for apportioned or indirect, therefore it is unconstitutional.

Learn the system of government we are in, I found fourth grade to be enlightening. I think it is very clear who writes the laws when you study Intro to American Government. The IRS is not a fourth branch with power to create a tax without a law written and approved by congress then signed by the president. That is the law that needs to be cited, not tax code written by people who have no power at all to create tax.

Game, set, match my ass.

So exactly which of the various tax codes that you were shown were NOT written and passed by congress then signed by the president?
 
I think you may need to re-read the laws, where does it specifically define income. Where does it say the IRS can now tax beyond the standard of apportioned or indirect?

This is why you have been labeled a CT. You absolutely refuse to look at the evidence. There is no point in arguing with you---you only see what you wish, and do not see anything you don't.

If you are so much smarter and hipper to the law, mount a lawsuit. If it's so cut and dried, you will succeed. Unless of course there is some vast conspiracy.............
 
My daughter is in the fourth grade. She has been shown this thread, and followed the links. Whenever I find an opportunity to educate her on critical thinking, I jump on it. She gets it, and spent a good deal of time exclaiming "Umm, how could he NOT think this is income!". Some mighty fine analogies followed. She'd explain it all to you on your level--she even offered--but she's not allowed to talk to boys on the internet.

That was a good way to avoid the issue. Well done.

But the IRS tax code is still not law. You can't cite it as law and niether can your daughter.
 
I am going to go back in this thread a bit and list to a post that should clarify it for you:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2386889#post2386889

Do you understand how the three branches of government work in the US system? Can you simply and clearly define the responsibilities of the Executive, Legislative, and Judicial branches? This may give you a hint to understanding how laws are written and applied. The main point being that in this case, the power of the Judicial branch is being applied.

Laws can be written that are unconstitutional or unclear. It is the duty of the Judicial branch to clarify or reject these laws. Look at Roe V. Wade for the most well-known example.

In the post linked to above, the judge has quite emphatically cleared up this point of law. All future cases can refer back to this decision when determining what exactly the laws mean. In other words, legally in the United States, "WAGES ARE INCOME." The Legislative branch may have failed to make the law clear, but the Judicial branch did not.
 
This is why you have been labeled a CT. You absolutely refuse to look at the evidence. There is no point in arguing with you---you only see what you wish, and do not see anything you don't.

If you are so much smarter and hipper to the law, mount a lawsuit. If it's so cut and dried, you will succeed. Unless of course there is some vast conspiracy.............

Whatever, he said the law says something, I read I don't see it I ask him to point me directly to the spot in the law. What is so unreasonable about that?
 
Whatever, he said the law says something, I read I don't see it I ask him to point me directly to the spot in the law. What is so unreasonable about that?

Dude, you have quoted the law yourself. How you fail to see that can only be termed wilfull blindness.

Income includes "compensation for services". Wages are "compensation for services". Therefore, they are income. And every single court case that has addressed whether wages are income has decided that wages are income.

What more do you want?
 
So exactly which of the various tax codes that you were shown were NOT written and passed by congress then signed by the president?
I guess you wern't follwing the thread very well. She quoted something from the IRS tax code not from the law books. I'm sure you are confused and are responding to the U.S Code also posted, but that was not what I was referring to. Reading all the posts might help if you want to make a informed response
 
That was a good way to avoid the issue. Well done.

But the IRS tax code is still not law. You can't cite it as law and niether can your daughter.

I'm glad you've started using the word "cite" correctly and have learned to spell rhetoric.

ONE MORE TIME. Twentieth time a charm? Case law is cited if you follow the link. Note the constitutional reference has been included.
http://www.irs.gov/taxpros/article/0,,id=159932,00.html#_Toc153765509

This argument asserts that wages, tips, and other compensation received for personal services are not income, because there is allegedly no taxable gain when a person “exchanges” labor for money. Under this theory, wages are not taxable income because people have basis in their labor equal to the fair market value of the wages they receive; thus, there is no gain to be taxed. A variation of this argument misconstrues section 1341, which deals with computations of tax where a taxpayer restores a substantial amount held under claim of right, to somehow allow a deduction claim for personal services rendered.
Another similar argument asserts that wages are not subject to taxation where a person has obtained funds in exchange for their time. Under this theory, wages are not taxable because the Code does not specifically tax these so-called “time reimbursement transactions.” Some take a different approach and argue that the Sixteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution did not authorize a tax on wages and salaries, but only on gain or profit.
The Law: For federal income tax purposes, “gross income” means all income from whatever source derived and includes compensation for services. I.R.C. § 61. Any income, from whatever source, is presumed to be income under section 61, unless the taxpayer can establish that it is specifically exempted or excluded. In Reese v. United States, 24 F.3d 228, 231 (Fed. Cir. 1994), the court stated, “an abiding principle of federal tax law is that, absent an enumerated exception, gross income means all income from whatever source derived.”
Section 1341 and the cases interpreting it require taxpayers to return funds previously reported as income before they can claim a deduction under claim of right. To have the right to a deduction, the taxpayer should appear to have an unrestricted right to the income in question. See Dominion Resources, Inc. v. United States, 219 F.3d 359 (4th Cir. 2000). It is a frivolous argument to claim a section 1341 deduction when there has been no repayment by the taxpayer of an amount previously reported as income. The Internal Revenue Service issued Revenue Ruling 2004-29, 2004-1 C.B. 627, warning taxpayers of the consequences of making this frivolous argument.
The Sixteenth Amendment provides that Congress shall have the power to lay and collect taxes on income, from whatever source derived, without apportionment among the several states, and without regard to any census or enumeration. U.S. Const. amend. XVI. Furthermore, the U.S. Supreme Court upheld the constitutionality of the income tax laws enacted subsequent to ratification of the Sixteenth Amendment in Brushaber v. Union Pacific R.R., 240 U.S. 1 (1916). Since that time, the courts have consistently upheld the constitutionality of the federal income tax. For a further discussion of the constitutionality of the federal income tax laws, see section I.D. of this outline.
All compensation for personal services, no matter what the form of payment, must be included in gross income. This includes salary or wages paid in cash, as well as the value of property and other economic benefits received because of services performed, or to be performed in the future. Furthermore, criminal and civil penalties have been imposed against individuals relying upon this frivolous argument.
 
Last edited:
I guess you wern't follwing the thread very well. She quoted something from the IRS tax code not from the law books. I'm sure you are confused and are responding to the U.S Code also posted, but that was not what I was referring to. Reading all the posts might help if you want to make a informed response

Hey, why don't you do a little work for a change? As with all extraordinary claims, you should be proving that the IRS has NOT been granted the authority to collect income tax. Knock yourself out.
 
Last edited:
Dude, you have quoted the law yourself. How you fail to see that can only be termed wilfull blindness.

Income includes "compensation for services". Wages are "compensation for services". Therefore, they are income.

What more do you want?

TITLE 26 > Subtitle A > CHAPTER 1 > Subchapter B > PART I > § 63 |
§ 63. Taxable income defined


(a) In general Except as provided in subsection (b), for purposes of this subtitle, the term “taxable income” means gross income minus the deductions allowed by this chapter (other than the standard deduction).




I guess you see something that I don't. Please explain, don't just say "You have it wrong"; "Your willfully blind" show me the section, it's that simple.

U.S.C. Title 26 §1 speaks alot about taxable income but does not define it, it is just to be assumed that taxable income means wages. If you would be so kind to show me what I am missing.
And every single court case that has addressed whether wages are income has decided that wages are income.

You are referring to the lower courts I assume.

First I think we can all agree that income tax is an unapportioned direct tax. Secondly the the Supreme Court, in Brushaber v Union Pac. R.R. Co.,
240 U.S. 1 (1916), rejected the idea that the 16th Amendment
granted to the government the power to impose an
unapportioned direct tax, such as the current tax on wages.

If it was an apportioned tax it would be Constitutional but it is not.

Court, in Brushaber v Union Pac. R.R. Co.,
240 U.S. 1 (1916), ruled that any contention that the 16th
Amendment treats a tax on income as a direct tax
is wholly without foundation.

The Supreme Court, in Stanton v. Baltic Mining Co., 240
U.S. 103 (1916), ruled that 16th Amendment did not confer any
new power of taxation, (as would be a power to impose an
unapportioned direct tax on the wages of ordinary Americans,) but
merely prohibited the complete and plenary power to tax income
derived from labor or capital from being taken out of the category
of un-apportioned indirect taxation to which it inherently belonged.
 
Hey, why don't you do a little work for a change? As with all extraordinary claims, you should be proving that the IRS has NOT been granted the authority to collect income tax. Knock yourself out.
Twisting my words now are we. I feel like I am arguing with your daughter. Anyway, I said the IRS does not have the power to write tax law, once the legislative branch writes the law the IRS does have the authority. They do have the power to collect income tax, but the Constitution says apportioned or indirect tax is all that is allowed. Tax on wages and labor are neither. Taxes on corporation and business is perfectly defined in law. Apportioned taxes and indirect taxes are perfectly defined in law. Excise tax is perfectly defined in law. Taxation on wages is not even mentioned except in what the IRS writes in the tax code, which is not law.

The Supreme Court also defined income (a direct quote):
“…Whatever difficulty there may be about a precise scientific definition
of ‘income,’ it imports, as used here, something entirely distinct from
principal or capital either as a subject of taxation or as a measure of the tax;
conveying rather the idea of gain or increase arising from corporate
activities.”

There is your definition by the highest court in the land. Lower courts have said differently but that doesn't matter since the SC trumps all lower courts.
 
(a) In general Except as provided in subsection (b), for purposes of this subtitle, the term “taxable income” means gross income minus the deductions allowed by this chapter (other than the standard deduction).


I guess you see something that I don't. Please explain, don't just say "You have it wrong"; "Your willfully blind" show me the section, it's that simple.
Your quote refers to 'gross income'. Your post on page five showed the definition of "gross income", which read in part:

61(a) GENERAL DEFINITION. --Except as otherwise provided in this subtitle, gross income means all income from whatever source derived, including (but not limited to) the following items:
61(a)(1) Compensation for services, including fees, commissions, fringe benefits, and similar items

As I, and the Courts, and other legislation have all said, wages are compensation for services. Therfore, they are part of gross income. And further, part of taxable income.

You are referring to the lower courts I assume.

Well, all courts that I am aware of. The cases that you cite again have nothing to do with whether wages are income. IF you can find one case that says that wages are NOT income, I'd like to see it. There have been several cases stating the opposite presented to you in this thread.
 
You put me in mind of a bloke who parked his mini-van @ 20th and M streets NW, Downtown Washington DC. He papered the outside of it with bogus "Certificate(s) of Occupancy" and for 24 hours dared the police (or anyone coming within earshot) to oust him. They did.

Simply put WOR, your type cannot be ad-hom'd in the traditional sense. This is simply because the rational level of your argument is below that of slightly retarded individuals. You guys (CT types) are so self-deluded that calling you an idiot and having that critique actually dent your misguided sense of purpose could only be construed by rational people as an uncommon kindness.

I however am not so kind. When I meet such insane people in person I am always ready to agree with them and make nice as the men with butterfly nets and white coats slyly approach from behind. Thus may I wish you luck and much happiness in your *ahem* eccentric pursuits??
[gives the signal]
Get 'im boys!

-z

Why? Because it remains apt...and perhaps will sink in if repeated oft enough??? Not likely I know...but hey...springs eternally hope.
 
Twisting my words now are we. I feel like I am arguing with your daughter. Anyway, I said the IRS does not have the power to write tax law, once the legislative branch writes the law the IRS does have the authority. They do have the power to collect income tax, but the Constitution says apportioned or indirect tax is all that is allowed. Tax on wages and labor are neither. Taxes on corporation and business is perfectly defined in law. Apportioned taxes and indirect taxes are perfectly defined in law. Excise tax is perfectly defined in law. Taxation on wages is not even mentioned except in what the IRS writes in the tax code, which is not law.

The Supreme Court also defined income (a direct quote):
“…Whatever difficulty there may be about a precise scientific definition
of ‘income,’ it imports, as used here, something entirely distinct from
principal or capital either as a subject of taxation or as a measure of the tax;
conveying rather the idea of gain or increase arising from corporate
activities.”

There is your definition by the highest court in the land. Lower courts have said differently but that doesn't matter since the SC trumps all lower courts.

(Bolding mine.) This was a specific definition applied to a specific case. Not all cases go to the Supreme Court. If the lower court ruling is satisfactory, it is assumed that the Supreme Court would also find it satisfactory. So the statement from the lower court that "WAGES ARE INCOME" still holds, unless the Supreme Court overturns that ruling (which is hasn't).

You may want to study the judicial system before making statements like you did in the quoted post.
 
(Bolding mine.) This was a specific definition applied to a specific case. Not all cases go to the Supreme Court. If the lower court ruling is satisfactory, it is assumed that the Supreme Court would also find it satisfactory. So the statement from the lower court that "WAGES ARE INCOME" still holds, unless the Supreme Court overturns that ruling (which is hasn't).

You may want to study the judicial system before making statements like you did in the quoted post.

The lower courts cannot overturn the supreme court. The Supreme Court says whats posted above and it is final unless the Supreme Court overturns the ruling. It is you who doesn't understand the judicial system. Yes it was a specific case, but in that case the Supreme Court defined income as it applies to the taxation of wages and came to the conclusion that income is profit derived from business activity. The lower courts have no authority to overturn that judgement.
 
The lower courts cannot overturn the supreme court. The Supreme Court says whats posted above and it is final unless the Supreme Court overturns the ruling. It is you who doesn't understand the judicial system. Yes it was a specific case, but in that case the Supreme Court defined income as it applies to the taxation of wages and came to the conclusion that income is profit derived from business activity. The lower courts have no authority to overturn that judgement.

Great, mount your lawsuit. But you might want to read the Union case a little more closely. It seems that the IRS cites it frequently in what I posted above.
 
Twisting my words now are we. I feel like I am arguing with your daughter. Anyway, I said the IRS does not have the power to write tax law, once the legislative branch writes the law the IRS does have the authority. They do have the power to collect income tax, but the Constitution says apportioned or indirect tax is all that is allowed. Tax on wages and labor are neither. Taxes on corporation and business is perfectly defined in law. Apportioned taxes and indirect taxes are perfectly defined in law. Excise tax is perfectly defined in law. Taxation on wages is not even mentioned except in what the IRS writes in the tax code, which is not law.

Without Rights,

I did not intend to post to you again, but since I have a few minutes, I'd like to respond to your post above.

I'm curious what it is exactly about the Sixteenth Amendment you do not understand? Here it is again for your review:

Amendment XVI

The Congress shall have power to lay and collect taxes on incomes, from whatever source derived, without apportionment among the several States, and without regard to any census or enumeration.

Now, after reading the Amendment again, I really cannot understand how a literate adult could possibly read the bolded section to mean "apportioned or indirect tax is all that is allowed." Feel free to enlighten me as to how the Sixteenth Amendment means what you believe it does.

My opinion notwithstanding, here are what just a few courts have said on the matter:

"[Becraft's] position can fairly be reduced to one elemental proposition: The Sixteenth Amendment does not authorize a direct non-apportioned income tax on resident United States citizens and thus such citizens are not subject to the federal income tax laws. ... We hardly need comment on the patent absurdity and frivolity of such a proposition. For over 75 years, the Supreme Court and the lower federal courts have both implicitly and explicitly recognized the Sixteenth Amendment's authorization of a non-apportioned direct income tax on United States citizens residing in the United States and thus the validity of the federal income tax laws as applied to such citizens." In re Becraft, 885 F.2d 547 (9th Cir., 1989).

"[W]e have rejected, on numerous occasions, the tax-protester argument that the federal income tax is an unconstitutional direct tax that must be apportioned. See, e.g., Lively v. Commissioner, 705 F.2d 1017, 1018 (8th Cir.1983) (per curiam)" United States v. Gerads, 999 F.2d 1255 (8th Cir. 1993), cert. den. 510 U.S. 1193 (1994).

"As the cited cases, as well as many others, have made abundantly clear, the following arguments alluded to by the Lonsdales are completely lacking in legal merit and patently frivolous: .. .. (3) the income tax is a direct tax which is invalid absent apportionment, and Pollock v. Farmers' Loan & Trust Co., 157 U.S. 429, 15 S.Ct. 673, 39 L.Ed. 759, modified, 158 U.S. 601, 15 S.Ct. 912, 39 L.Ed. 1108 (1895), is authority for that and other arguments against the government's power to impose income taxes on individuals.. .." Lonsdale v. United States, 919 F.2d 1440, 1448 (10th Cir. 1990).

Link: http://evans-legal.com/dan/tpfaq.html#individual

Please feel free to enlighten me as to why the judges -- those individuals granted the authority to interpret the Constitution and federal law -- are wrong and you are correct.*

*ETA: For a thorough explanation of the role of IRS Regulations and Revenue Rulings, note the post by AS (who consistently impresses me with his ability to explain the complicated in a clear and patient manner) immediately below.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom