[Ed.]What requires that I pay the income tax?

Ok, so the Supreme Court is never wrong? Than we all accept the 2000 election witth no problems, right????
 
Can't be bothered to read the entire thread because it looks like a bunch of hooey from an anti-tax dingbat.

However, I'll offer the following genuine, legal ways to avoid paying taxes on income:

1) Work for the UN. UN income is tax-free in practically any jurisdiction. While you do pay payroll deductions (sometimes called by UN employees 'taxes') when on the UN payroll - these go exclusively to fund UN employee benefit programs and pension schemes.

2) Become a non-resident for tax purposes in your home jurisdiction, and work in a country where there are no taxes on personal income, or no taxes on expatriate wages.

That's about it...

-AH.
 
Tax Honesty Movement is anything but. It's a bunch of conspiracy theory nonsense. Have fun, Scooby Doo.
Joe Banister former IRS investigator and CPA
Larry Becraft Constitutional law attorney
William Benson Former Dept of Revenue investigator
Jack Cohen legal researcher
William Conklin Tax consultant
Jeffory Dickstein Tax attorney
Sherry Jackson former IRS examanation officer
Donald MacPherson Tax attorney
John Turner former IRS collection officer



I suspect you wouldn't know a statute if it bit you on the ass. I did cite law. That's what the United States Code is. As for the law that requires you to report your wages as income on your tax return, I suspect you know damn well where it is. It's the one cited numerous times here that defines "income," and the numerous other sections of what is informally referred to as the tax code. Yes, I'm well aware that the statutory definition of "income" in the US is circular. It always has been. Deal with it.

Ok, nothing really there to respond to.

Apportioned or indirect says the Constitution, the 16th amendment allowed no new forms of taxation according to the supreme court so a unapportioned direct tax is unconstitutional. The law you would really need to cite would be one that amends the Constitution to include unapportioned direct taxes. The law you cite does not say wages are taxable because it would be unconstitutional. "Compensation for service" is very vauge and it is all you and the IRS have to cling to. "compensation for services" meets the constitutional requirements if it is referring to business and corporate tax. Even if a law was clearly written that says wages are income (which there is not) it would still be unconstitutional unless they made it apportioned which it is not or they amended the constitution.
 
In order of hierarchy of supremacy, it goes like this: Article I, Section 8, U.S. Constitution: "The Congress shall have power to lay and collect taxes..." Next is the Sixteenth Amendment, U.S. Constitution: "The Congress shall have power to lay and collect taxes on incomes, from whatever source derived, without apportionment among the several states, and without regard to any census or enumeration."

Supreme Court "no new powers of taxation"


Make no mistake; they have the force of law, and can be just as enforceable and binding on taxpayers in court as the statutes passed by Congress.

And they use it with an iron fist and that is why the IRS needs to be reformed or eliminated. They seize property from people who never get convicted and then they never return the property (unconstituional), they refuse to offer a redress of grievances, they go after people who speak against them, they act like a mafia and they are a thorn in the side of every American. We are not supposed to fear our government.

Shuize formerly practiced law in the US, so I suspect very much he knows a great deal about our system of government.

The fourth grade comment was not made to Shuize it was made to Miss Anthrope. Shuize reponded to it but it was not directed at him/her.
I suggest you eat a big slice of humble pie before you shoot your mouth off here again in this thread.
I was insulted I insulted back eat the pie yourself.
 
Apportioned or indirect says the Constitution, the 16th amendment allowed no new forms of taxation according to the supreme court so a unapportioned direct tax is unconstitutional.
I find it amusing that people can dismiss the stunning clarity of:
The Congress shall have power to lay and collect taxes on incomes, from whatever source derived, without apportionment among the several States, and without regard to any census or enumeration.
in favor of a tortured misreading of the SCOTUS decision in Stanton v. Baltic Mining Co. to end up at the argument, above. What makes it even more amusing is that the decision in the Stanton v. Baltic Mining Co. case actually rejected the arguments about the income tax being unconstitutional.
 
Joe Banister former IRS investigator and CPA
Larry Becraft Constitutional law attorney

William Benson Former Dept of Revenue investigator

Convicted of tax evasion after using the dumb-as-rocks "ratification" theory:

http://www.quatlosers.com/bill_benson.htm

William Conklin Tax consultant

One of the "there's no constitutional requirement to pay income tax" people.

Actually, he's a paralegal, but that doesn't stop him from claiming he is right and everybody who actually went to law school--SCOTUS judges included--are wrong about the law.

He is also a big, fat, liar. For example, he claims that he has six "wins" against the IRS are only tax protestor "wins": that is, they are loses.

http://www.quatlosers.com/bill_conklin.htm

Ok, nothing really there to respond to.

If the other guys on your list are have the same degree of "expertise" and "success" with tax law as these two, you're right--there is nothing to respond to.

Apportioned or indirect says the Constitution, the 16th amendment allowed no new forms of taxation according to the supreme court so a unapportioned direct tax is unconstitutional.

Oh, dear.

http://evans-legal.com/dan/tpfaq.html#nonewpower
 
However, I'll offer the following genuine, legal ways to avoid paying taxes on income:

1) Work for the UN. UN income is tax-free in practically any jurisdiction. While you do pay payroll deductions (sometimes called by UN employees 'taxes') when on the UN payroll - these go exclusively to fund UN employee benefit programs and pension schemes.

2) Become a non-resident for tax purposes in your home jurisdiction, and work in a country where there are no taxes on personal income, or no taxes on expatriate wages.
I don't know about #1 but I'm pretty sure #2 does not work for US citizens. US citizens have to file a tax return even if they do not live in the US. They get a resonable deduction such that their tax is minimal on amounts earned under something like $80k, but they have to file returns every year. All of the Americans I know in Bermuda and Qatar have to file.

Canadians, Australians and, I believe, Brits do not need to pay taxes if they live abroad :) (under specific circumstances, please contact a tax professional for more information).
 
UN income is tax-free because of an international bilateral agreement to which the US is a signatory - so yes, an American resident and/or citizen would not have to pay US taxes on UN income earned as a direct employee of the UN. (A contractor to the UN could be more of a grey area.)

Re my point #2 - yes, I believe the first $100k of overseas earned income is tax-free for US residents. However, if someone was serious, they would need to look at becoming a true non-resident. In Canada, for example, if you sever all ties to Canada and become a non-resident (there are a number of tests for this) then your overseas income is tax-free (and there is no similar arrangement in Canada as what US folks have). You keep your passport but that's it. I'm not a US tax expert - I know that you can only be in the US for about 30 days a calendar year to not lose that first $100k exemption - but if you LEAVE the US (sell your house, car, move the wife, kids, all assets and dog to another jurisdiction), then I find it hard to see how the US would be ABLE to collect taxes from you.
 
UN income is tax-free because of an international bilateral agreement to which the US is a signatory - so yes, an American resident and/or citizen would not have to pay US taxes on UN income earned as a direct employee of the UN. (A contractor to the UN could be more of a grey area.)

Re my point #2 - yes, I believe the first $100k of overseas earned income is tax-free for US residents.
It's around $80,000 of earned income ($82,400 for 2006). But with additional housing allowances, you may be correct that it's closer to $100,000.

However, if someone was serious, they would need to look at becoming a true non-resident. In Canada, for example, if you sever all ties to Canada and become a non-resident (there are a number of tests for this) then your overseas income is tax-free (and there is no similar arrangement in Canada as what US folks have). You keep your passport but that's it. I'm not a US tax expert - I know that you can only be in the US for about 30 days a calendar year to not lose that first $100k exemption - but if you LEAVE the US (sell your house, car, move the wife, kids, all assets and dog to another jurisdiction), then I find it hard to see how the US would be ABLE to collect taxes from you.
Two quick points. This is by no means tax advice, but it is my understanding that unlike most of the world, the U.S. taxes citizens (and permanent residents) on the basis of "worldwide" income. U.S. citizens, regardless of their residency status, have an obligation to file U.S. taxes on income earned anywhere in the world (subject to the same minimum filing requirements as citizens in the U.S.). The possibility of double-taxation is reduced by treaties allowing for various tax credits for taxes paid overseas as well as the "foreign earned income exclusion" referenced above. This exclusion applies to the first $80,000 of income provided the taxpayer meet one of two tests: The first is known as the "physical presence test" which, as I recall, only allows a limited number of days in the U.S. per year but is nearly automatic if the taxpayer is physically outside the United States for the required number of days. The second, known as the "bona fide residence" test, is based on residence overseas. I understand it is slightly more difficult to establish but allows something approaching 6 months in the U.S. per year. I seem to remember that both tests will reduce the amount of the exclusion allowed based on a ratio of the number of days spent in the United States. However, neither allows the taxpayer to avoid his obligation to file. In fact, I've heard that the exclusion is only valid if the taxpayer does file.

ETA: I forgot to mention, if a U.S. citizen renounces citizenship in order to avoid paying U.S. taxes, I believe the IRS may still tax such an individual's income for the following 10 years.
 
Last edited:
Again - I make no attestation that I am a US tax expert - but if you are CLEARLY a non-resident - as in you are outta there - then I fail to see how on the basis of holding a US Passport and NOTHING ELSE that you are taxable in the US.
 
Again - I make no attestation that I am a US tax expert - but if you are CLEARLY a non-resident - as in you are outta there - then I fail to see how on the basis of holding a US Passport and NOTHING ELSE that you are taxable in the US.

Cook v. Tait, 265 U.S. 47 (1924)
 
Last edited:
The law you cite does not say wages are taxable because it would be unconstitutional.

The law doesn't say wages are taxable, because it is an income tax. Income from whatever source deriived, including wages, is taxable and taxed unless specifically exempted in Subtitle A. Wgae income is not exempted.

Why would it be unconstitutional to tax wage income? Congress can tax anything other than exports. Any direct tax must be apportioned. Unless it is a tax on income, in which case the 16th Amendment exempts it from the apportionment requirement. The SC, in bot Pollock and Brushaber, said all taxes on income are indirect taxes. Therefore, the exemption in the 16th Amendment changed nothing as far as congressional power is concerned, because Congress could always tax wage income and no court has ever held otherwise.

So, Congress could always tax income, including income from wages. Such taxes are indirect, so they are not required to be apportioned. Which brings us back to the question at hand, what makes you think a tax on wage income is unconstitutional?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom