AmateurScientist
Unregistered
- Joined
- Dec 14, 2001
- Messages
- 5,268
The IRS is not a law making body it is a tax collection agency. The law is seperate from IRS code. If the IRS code does not follow guidelines set by the real law makers then it is unlawful and it does not matter what it says. The law says taxes must be apportioned or indirect, the 16th amendment didn't change that fact according to the supreme court on several occasions. The tax on wages does not fit the guidelines for apportioned or indirect, therefore it is unconstitutional.
The Internal Revenue Service is part of the Department of the Treasury. Although it is not a legislative body, and is in fact an administrative agency within the executive branch of the United States Government, it most certainly does make law. I will explain how below, but first here is some background on the various sources of tax law. It comes from all three branches of the government.
Federal tax law in the United States has several components. Their sources are the U.S. Constitution, statutory law, federal regulations, decisions of the United States Tax Court, decisions of United States District Courts, U.S. Courts of Appeals, the United States Supreme Court, Revenue Rulings issued by the Tax Commissioner, and private letter rulings and technical advice memorandums issued by the Service. Those vary in their applicability to any given party or situation, but they all come into play and work together as part of a seamless web of a body of law.
In order of hierarchy of supremacy, it goes like this: Article I, Section 8, U.S. Constitution: "The Congress shall have power to lay and collect taxes..." Next is the Sixteenth Amendment, U.S. Constitution: "The Congress shall have power to lay and collect taxes on incomes, from whatever source derived, without apportionment among the several states, and without regard to any census or enumeration."
As Congress is the legislative branch and is primarily responsible for law making, it has enacted numerous statutes which, collectively have evolved to form the body of statutory law addressing taxation by the federal government. For the sake of convenience, the body of tax laws enacted in statutory form is collected together, bound, and printed and issued as the "Internal Revenue Code" (or simply "IRC"), and is used by tax professionals and by the Service (the IRS). Its contents are identical to, and taken directly from what is found in the United States Code, which collectively is the official body of all federal legislation currently in effect at any given time. The only difference between the IRC and the version in the U.S. Code is the citation. In other words, when you see IRC Section 61 cited, it is precisely the same as the text found at 26 U.S.C. Section 61. Thus, the official citation for the tax code is to 26 U.S.C. Section 1, et seq (and following). It is broken into various sections and subsections (called "subtitles" and "chapter," respectively), depending on the topic. You can see it here:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/html/uscode26/usc_sup_01_26.html
Notice that Subtitle A is the relevant section concerning income tax.
Here comes the law making role the IRS plays in tax law. Congress has enacted what is referred to as "enabling legislation" with respect to most federal executive agencies. Enabling legislation simply means that Congress has enabled and delegated to the various respective federal executive agencies -- in this case that is the Internal Revenue Service -- the authority to enact binding regulations dealing with the administration of its duties, and with some of the finer details of the substantive law itself. As with other federal agencies tasked with the oversight and enforcement of a particular function of government, the IRS has enacted regulations pursuant to its authority to do so under the enabling legislation passed by Congress. Suffice to say there are lots of IRS regulations. You can find them at the IRS' website if you like. Make no mistake; they have the force of law, and can be just as enforceable and binding on taxpayers in court as the statutes passed by Congress.
Revenue rulings issued by the Tax Commissioner (the head of the IRS) tend to address narrow issues which arise from time to time and which may need immediate dissemination and which are not appropriate for waiting for the notice and comment period required for provisions of regulations. Private letter rulings and technical advice memorandums are issued at the request of taxpayers or their professional representatives, such as attorneys and accountants. All three sources of law mentioned in this paragraph come directly from the IRS itself, not from Congress, and all three are binding legally, although the latter two may apply only to the specific parties involved, depending on the circumstances.
(The above two paragraphs directly refute your erroneous contention that the IRS is not a law making body. Its primary purpose is not law making, but it most certainly does make law, and that law is binding and enforceable in courts).
The United States Tax Court is a judicial creature, but it is a creation of Congress. It is what judges and lawyers call an "Article I court," versus an "Article III court," which is what the Supreme Court, the United States Courts of Appeals, and the United States District Courts are. For the distinction, please see Article I, Section 8 ("The Congress shall have power ... to constitute tribunals inferior to the Supreme Court ...), versus Article III, Section 1, U.S. Constitution ("The judicial power of the United States, shall be vested in one Supreme Court, and in such inferior courts as the Congress may from time to time ordain and establish"). Its judges are tax lawyers who are well versed in not only substantive tax law, but also in evidence and trial procedure law. There are 19 such judges, and they are based in Washington, DC, but travel to the taxpayer, or a location near him/her/it, for actual trials in tax court. They are non-jury trials, and are civil, not criminal, in nature. Lawyers for the IRS represent the U.S. Government in the proceedings. Taxpayers may represent themselves, or they may be represented by private lawyers admitted to practice before the U.S. Tax Court.
Here is a link to the tax court's site for a brief overview of what it does:
http://www.ustaxcourt.gov/about.htm
Decisions made in U.S. Tax Court may be appealed as a matter of right to the applicable United States Court of Appeals, and those decisions are subject to discretionary review by writ of certiori to the U.S. Supreme Court. Under certain circumstances, if I recall correctly, some matters are reviewable in the United States District Court, and some disputes may even by brought in the U.S. Court of Claims. In any event, all such published opinions of the courts listed above have the effect of law, and are binding on taxpayers in their respective jurisdictions.
All of the above constitutes the body of federal tax law in the United States.
Learn the system of government we are in, I found fourth grade to be enlightening. I think it is very clear who writes the laws when you study Intro to American Government. The IRS is not a fourth branch with power to create a tax without a law written and approved by congress then signed by the president. That is the law that needs to be cited, not tax code written by people who have no power at all to create tax.
Game, set, match my ass.
Shuize formerly practiced law in the US, so I suspect very much he knows a great deal about our system of government.
I suggest you eat a big slice of humble pie before you shoot your mouth off here again in this thread.
AS
Last edited: