[Ed.]What requires that I pay the income tax?

The IRS is not a law making body it is a tax collection agency. The law is seperate from IRS code. If the IRS code does not follow guidelines set by the real law makers then it is unlawful and it does not matter what it says. The law says taxes must be apportioned or indirect, the 16th amendment didn't change that fact according to the supreme court on several occasions. The tax on wages does not fit the guidelines for apportioned or indirect, therefore it is unconstitutional.

The Internal Revenue Service is part of the Department of the Treasury. Although it is not a legislative body, and is in fact an administrative agency within the executive branch of the United States Government, it most certainly does make law. I will explain how below, but first here is some background on the various sources of tax law. It comes from all three branches of the government.

Federal tax law in the United States has several components. Their sources are the U.S. Constitution, statutory law, federal regulations, decisions of the United States Tax Court, decisions of United States District Courts, U.S. Courts of Appeals, the United States Supreme Court, Revenue Rulings issued by the Tax Commissioner, and private letter rulings and technical advice memorandums issued by the Service. Those vary in their applicability to any given party or situation, but they all come into play and work together as part of a seamless web of a body of law.

In order of hierarchy of supremacy, it goes like this: Article I, Section 8, U.S. Constitution: "The Congress shall have power to lay and collect taxes..." Next is the Sixteenth Amendment, U.S. Constitution: "The Congress shall have power to lay and collect taxes on incomes, from whatever source derived, without apportionment among the several states, and without regard to any census or enumeration."

As Congress is the legislative branch and is primarily responsible for law making, it has enacted numerous statutes which, collectively have evolved to form the body of statutory law addressing taxation by the federal government. For the sake of convenience, the body of tax laws enacted in statutory form is collected together, bound, and printed and issued as the "Internal Revenue Code" (or simply "IRC"), and is used by tax professionals and by the Service (the IRS). Its contents are identical to, and taken directly from what is found in the United States Code, which collectively is the official body of all federal legislation currently in effect at any given time. The only difference between the IRC and the version in the U.S. Code is the citation. In other words, when you see IRC Section 61 cited, it is precisely the same as the text found at 26 U.S.C. Section 61. Thus, the official citation for the tax code is to 26 U.S.C. Section 1, et seq (and following). It is broken into various sections and subsections (called "subtitles" and "chapter," respectively), depending on the topic. You can see it here:

http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/html/uscode26/usc_sup_01_26.html

Notice that Subtitle A is the relevant section concerning income tax.

Here comes the law making role the IRS plays in tax law. Congress has enacted what is referred to as "enabling legislation" with respect to most federal executive agencies. Enabling legislation simply means that Congress has enabled and delegated to the various respective federal executive agencies -- in this case that is the Internal Revenue Service -- the authority to enact binding regulations dealing with the administration of its duties, and with some of the finer details of the substantive law itself. As with other federal agencies tasked with the oversight and enforcement of a particular function of government, the IRS has enacted regulations pursuant to its authority to do so under the enabling legislation passed by Congress. Suffice to say there are lots of IRS regulations. You can find them at the IRS' website if you like. Make no mistake; they have the force of law, and can be just as enforceable and binding on taxpayers in court as the statutes passed by Congress.

Revenue rulings issued by the Tax Commissioner (the head of the IRS) tend to address narrow issues which arise from time to time and which may need immediate dissemination and which are not appropriate for waiting for the notice and comment period required for provisions of regulations. Private letter rulings and technical advice memorandums are issued at the request of taxpayers or their professional representatives, such as attorneys and accountants. All three sources of law mentioned in this paragraph come directly from the IRS itself, not from Congress, and all three are binding legally, although the latter two may apply only to the specific parties involved, depending on the circumstances.

(The above two paragraphs directly refute your erroneous contention that the IRS is not a law making body. Its primary purpose is not law making, but it most certainly does make law, and that law is binding and enforceable in courts).

The United States Tax Court is a judicial creature, but it is a creation of Congress. It is what judges and lawyers call an "Article I court," versus an "Article III court," which is what the Supreme Court, the United States Courts of Appeals, and the United States District Courts are. For the distinction, please see Article I, Section 8 ("The Congress shall have power ... to constitute tribunals inferior to the Supreme Court ...), versus Article III, Section 1, U.S. Constitution ("The judicial power of the United States, shall be vested in one Supreme Court, and in such inferior courts as the Congress may from time to time ordain and establish"). Its judges are tax lawyers who are well versed in not only substantive tax law, but also in evidence and trial procedure law. There are 19 such judges, and they are based in Washington, DC, but travel to the taxpayer, or a location near him/her/it, for actual trials in tax court. They are non-jury trials, and are civil, not criminal, in nature. Lawyers for the IRS represent the U.S. Government in the proceedings. Taxpayers may represent themselves, or they may be represented by private lawyers admitted to practice before the U.S. Tax Court.

Here is a link to the tax court's site for a brief overview of what it does:

http://www.ustaxcourt.gov/about.htm

Decisions made in U.S. Tax Court may be appealed as a matter of right to the applicable United States Court of Appeals, and those decisions are subject to discretionary review by writ of certiori to the U.S. Supreme Court. Under certain circumstances, if I recall correctly, some matters are reviewable in the United States District Court, and some disputes may even by brought in the U.S. Court of Claims. In any event, all such published opinions of the courts listed above have the effect of law, and are binding on taxpayers in their respective jurisdictions.

All of the above constitutes the body of federal tax law in the United States.

Learn the system of government we are in, I found fourth grade to be enlightening. I think it is very clear who writes the laws when you study Intro to American Government. The IRS is not a fourth branch with power to create a tax without a law written and approved by congress then signed by the president. That is the law that needs to be cited, not tax code written by people who have no power at all to create tax.

Game, set, match my ass.

Shuize formerly practiced law in the US, so I suspect very much he knows a great deal about our system of government.

I suggest you eat a big slice of humble pie before you shoot your mouth off here again in this thread.

AS
 
Last edited:
*ETA: For a thorough explanation of the role of IRS Regulations and Revenue Rulings, note the post by AS (who consistently impresses me with his ability to explain the complicated in a clear and patient manner) immediately below.

Thanks, Shuize. I appreciate your saying that.

AS
 
The IRC does not define income. That was deliberate. Congress, when debating the 1913 income tax act, decided that they should not define "income". If they defined it too broadly, the courts would have to rein them in. If they defined it too narrowly, they would miss out on a source of revenue. They decided to leave it to the courts.

The Supreme Court, in Merchants' Loan & Trust Co. v. Smietanka, 255 U.S. 509, wrote:

"'Income may be defined as the gain derived from capital, from labor, or from both combined,' provided it be understood to include profit gained through a sale or conversion of capital assets."
255 U.S. 509, 518.

Gain is not the excess of receipts over value as has been repeatedly suggested, but the excess of receipts over direct costs. Labor has no direct cost to the laborer, so his wage income is equal to the value of money and property received in exchange for his labor. Tax deniers get confused because labor has indirect costs, such as food to stay alive, transportation to the work site, etc.

That gain involves cost and not value is easily seen if one considers the sale of stock. Joe bought 1 share in XYZ, inc. for $2/share. The stock's price, it's value, has increased to $5/share. Joe sells his share, i.e., he trades his share, worth $5 for $5 cash, an even exchange. Joe has a gain of $3, the $5 he received less the $2 he paid for the stock.

26 USC §1 imposes the income tax on taxable income. 26 USC §63 defines taxable income as gross income minus allowable deductions. 26 USC §61 defines gross income as all income from whatever source unless an exception is provided for in Subtitle A of 26 USC. (There is no exception for income from wages in general.) 26 USC §6012 requires anyone with gross income in excess of the "exemption amount" to file a tax return. (The "exemption amount" is indexed for inflation. Each year's amount is published in the Internal Revenue Bulletin, part of the Federal Register, and in the instructions to Forms 1040, 1040A, etc.) 26 USC §6151 states that the person required to file a return is required to pay the tax associated with that return.

26 USC can be found at http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/html/uscode26/usc_sup_01_26.html among other places on the web.


A few bits of housekeeping:

John Cheek did not lose Cheek v. United States, 498 U.S. 192, as implied above. The issue in that case was whether his good faith belief that he was not required to file a tax return was a defense against a charge of willful failure to file. The Court said it was. Cheek was therefore allowed to use that defense at his trial. The jury convicted him, presumably because they did not believe he was that stupid.

Vernice Kuglin was not tried for willful failure to file. She was tried and acquitted of tax evasion, a much harder charge to prove. A conviction would have required the jury to find that Kuglin had hidden money from the government (there was no evidence that she had) or that she had lied to the government. If she had lied to her employer by filing a bogus W-4 (and she almost certainly had), then technically, that was also lying to the government. The jury was instructed by the judge that filing a false W-4 was an example of lying to the government, but I think they ignored that, because it just didn't sound right to them. The government's case hung on those false W-4s.

Last but not least, mowing your own lawn results in Hague-Simmons income. Nothing in the IRC or any court decision excludes it from income, but the IRS has never tried to tax it and imho never will.
 
Last edited:
Some quibbles.

Make no mistake; they have the force of law, and can be just as enforceable and binding on taxpayers in court as the statutes passed by Congress.
The Secretary of the Treasury can issue two types of regulations, legislative or interpretative. Legislative regulations are made pursuant to specific and limited grants of authority in the IRC. For example, IRC §6402(b) authorizes the Secretary to prescribe regulations for crediting an overpayment as an estimated tax payment instead of refunding it. Interpretative regulations are authorized by IRC §7805. The courts have held that interpretative regulations have the force of law unless they are inconsistent with the IRC.

Revenue rulings issued by the Tax Commissioner (the head of the IRS) tend to address narrow issues which arise from time to time and which may need immediate dissemination and which are not appropriate for waiting for the notice and comment period required for provisions of regulations.

That seems to imply that revenue rulings have legal authority. They do not. Revenue rulings are just open client letters written by the Commisioner's attorney, the IRS Chief Counsel. They state the IRS's position on the tax consequences of a particular set of facts. They are binding on no one, although the IRS will follow them unless they have become outdated due to an amendment of the IRC or the courts' interpretation of the law.
 
Some quibbles.


The Secretary of the Treasury can issue two types of regulations, legislative or interpretative. Legislative regulations are made pursuant to specific and limited grants of authority in the IRC. For example, IRC §6402(b) authorizes the Secretary to prescribe regulations for crediting an overpayment as an estimated tax payment instead of refunding it. Interpretative regulations are authorized by IRC §7805. The courts have held that interpretative regulations have the force of law unless they are inconsistent with the IRC.



That seems to imply that revenue rulings have legal authority. They do not. Revenue rulings are just open client letters written by the Commisioner's attorney, the IRS Chief Counsel. They state the IRS's position on the tax consequences of a particular set of facts. They are binding on no one, although the IRS will follow them unless they have become outdated due to an amendment of the IRC or the courts' interpretation of the law.

Thanks for the clarifications.

AS
 
...the the Supreme Court, in Brushaber v Union Pac. R.R. Co.,
240 U.S. 1 (1916), rejected the idea that the 16th Amendment
granted to the government the power to impose an
unapportioned direct tax, such as the current tax on wages.

...Court, in Brushaber v Union Pac. R.R. Co.,
240 U.S. 1 (1916), ruled that any contention that the 16th
Amendment treats a tax on income as a direct tax
is wholly without foundation.

The Supreme Court, in Stanton v. Baltic Mining Co., 240
U.S. 103 (1916), ruled that 16th Amendment did not confer any
new power of taxation, (as would be a power to impose an
unapportioned direct tax on the wages of ordinary Americans,) but
merely prohibited the complete and plenary power to tax income
derived from labor or capital from being taken out of the category
of un-apportioned indirect taxation to which it inherently belonged.
Without Rights,

Do you know what 'plagiarizing' means? It is usually considered a poor practice on this forum.
 
Steady, chaps! You're burying him in too many solid facts! ;)

That never stopped Irwin Schiff. No amount of reality could faze him. He'll die in prison, but he has never admitted defeat.
 
U.S.C. Title 26 §1 speaks alot about taxable income but does not define it, it is just to be assumed that taxable income means wages. If you would be so kind to show me what I am missing.

The fact that "taxable income" is defined in 26 USC §61, as you have been told repeatedly.
 
Which makes me doubt that you read them.

Read the first one again until you understand it.

Actually, Dr. A, he happens to be right in that the Internal Revenue Code does in effect define "income" as "income." It is a circular definition, but that's by design. Section 61 enumerates various kinds of income for illustration and because they are the most common types encountered, and it does state explicitly that the list is not exhaustive ("including but not limited to"). It simply doesn't define what "income" actually means. That's where tax protestors often try to get their foot in the door with their frivolous arguments. None have ever succeeded at convincing the courts that wages are not includable in gross income for income tax purposes, nor will they. Wages are clearly "compensation" within the meaning of Section 61(a)(1). Period.

AS
 
Last edited:
It defines taxable income in terms of gross income.

The phrase "gross income" is defined in dictionaries.

This is why I asked him if he knew what "gross income" meant.
 
It defines taxable income in terms of gross income.

The phrase "gross income" is defined in dictionaries.

This is why I asked him if he knew what "gross income" meant.

Not really. Section 61 contains the definition of "gross income," and it calls it "all income from whatever source derived." That's a circular definition, and not really an explanation. It is instead an indication that the intent is for it to be wholly encompassing in scope, regardless of the source of it.

Section 63 defines "taxable income." It necessarily incorporates "gross income" in its definition.

The Code is still left with a definition "problem," if you will, but again, that's by design. It's not an inadvertent mistake, and it's certainly not an open invitation for loonies to try to use it in their unsophisticated attempts at exploiting what they think is a loophole. It isn't a loophole; it never was, and never will be. They will never learn, however.

AS
 
Both Cheek and Kuglin were acquitted from the criminal charge of"willful failure to file" by convncing the jury they really, truly, were too stupid to understand they had to pay taxes. They both, of course, still had to pay their income tax, plus interest and penalties...
 
Not really ...
I understand what you mean, that these phrases are left to be interpreted by judges, that this becomes "case law", and that this was what the framers of the laws intended.

But I was making a different point. The phrase "gross income" has a meaning even besides the interpretations of judges --- those judges whom tax protestors believe are all Part Of The Plot.

Without Rights can look up "gross income" in a dictionary; or in a textbook of accounting, or of economics; and he will find that everyone who uses the phrase "gross income" does not deduct the market value of your labor from your gross income. This is not something that the US courts have interpreted, this is what "gross income" means, according to everyone.

---

We appear to be talking at cross-purposes. Certainly "gross income" is or may be defined by the courts. My point is that it is also defined the same way by everyone else, with respect to the point under discussion: your gross income for performing labor is what you get paid for it. Without Rights doesn't have to take the word of Evil US Judges for what "gross income" means --- everyone agrees that it includes wages paid for labor.
 
Last edited:
Not really. Section 61 contains the definition of "gross income," and it calls it "all income from whatever source derived." That's a circular definition, and not really an explanation. It is instead an indication that the intent is for it to be wholly encompassing in scope, regardless of the source of it.
But it also lists a whole bunch of things that are included in gross income, including "compensation for services" (which I have been harping on) which wages are a part of.
 
Without Rights can look up "gross income" in a dictionary; or in a textbook of accounting, or of economics; and he will find that everyone who uses the phrase "gross income" does not deduct the market value of your labor from your gross income. This is not something that the US courts have interpreted, this is what "gross income" means, according to everyone.

The dictionary definition of "gross income" is not the meaning of "gross income" as that phrase is defined in the IRC. "Gross income" is specifically defined as "all income from whatever source derived" unless otherwise provided in Subtitle A. As I noted before, Congress, when debating the 1913 tax act, discussed defining the word "income" in the act. They decided not to define income because any definition would be too broad or too narrow. They did include various examples of income sources as a starting point, but left the definition of income to the courts.

Gross income as defined in the Random House Unabridged Dictionary, which is the source for dictionary.com's definition is not really relevant to this discussion at all.

gross income
–noun Accounting. total revenue received before any deductions or allowances, as for rent, cost of goods sold, taxes, etc.

Income, as defined by the courts, is revenue minus the costs of goods sold (and maybe the direct costs of providing a service*). Laborers have few, if any, direct costs of providing labor, so for wages, there is seldom any difference between revenue and income.



* A series of cases in the 1940's involving the deductability of direct costs in excess of wartime wage caps left the question unresolved.
 
But it also lists a whole bunch of things that are included in gross income, including "compensation for services" (which I have been harping on) which wages are a part of.

I know you have, and I am well aware of that. Nevertheless, the term "wages" is not used in Section 61's definition. It's in a large body of case law. That omission, deliberate as it was and is, is what has allowed tax protestors to claim with a delusional sincerity (in some cases sincere, anyway) that wages are not income. Sure, courts have consistently held that at least in civil tax cases that argument simply cannot be made in good faith. It doesn't stop tax protestor nuts from claiming it.

Also, please note that in a previous post (not the one you responded to), I mention that Section 61 enumerates several types of income, and that "compensation for services" is the very first one.

AS
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom