[Ed.]What requires that I pay the income tax?

Compensation for services including fees, commissions, fringe benefits, and similar items. Not wages, they are referring to business activity. People don't charge there employer fees. A wage is not a commission or a benefit. Wages are not similar to those items either.

[snip]

1978: Central Illinois Public Service Co. v. United States, 435 U.S. 21. Established that wages and income are NOT equivalent as far as taxes on income are concerned.

Is the Supreme Court irrelevant?

Don't you just love selective quoting? The case you cite here quite effectively makes my point. You see, it says that wages are not equivalent to income as income includes not only wages, but other sources of income as well.

Here is the case: http://caselaw.lp.findlaw.com/scripts/getcase.pl?court=us&vol=435&invol=21

The case is actually about the treatment of lunch allowances. But here is a quote for you:

The income tax is imposed on taxable income. 26 U.S.C. 1. Generally, this is gross income minus allowable deductions. 26 U.S.C. 63 (a). Section 61 (a) defines as gross income "all income from whatever source derived" including, under 61 (a) (1), "[c]ompensation for services." The withholding tax, in some contrast, is confined to wages, 3402 (a), and 3401 (a) defines as "wages," "all remuneration (other than fees paid to a public official) for services performed by an employee for his employer, including the cash value of all remuneration paid in any medium other than cash." The two concepts - income and wages - obviously are not necessarily the same. Wages usually are income, 5 but many items qualify as income and yet clearly are not wages. Interest, rent, and dividends are ready examples. And the very definition of "wages" in 3401 (a) itself goes on specifically to exclude certain types of remuneration for an employee's services to his employer (e. g., combat pay, agricultural labor, certain domestic service). Our task, therefore, is to determine the character of the lunch reimbursements in the light of the definition of "wages" in 3401 (a), and the Company's consequent obligation to withhold under 3402 (a).

Seems clear to me - wages are income, but not all income is wages. Wages are even defined as "remuneration for services".

So, I ask again, exactly how are wages not compensation for services?
 
Yeah, tough ain't it? how the dishonest and purposeful misuse of a word twists its meaning 180 degrees. "It's true!" :)
That's a resourseful argument.


Sure, but the people you'd have believe your total lies...they'd go to the big house for taking your sage advice wouldn't they? You are a liar. You've had the case law shoved in your face numerous times but still say "Show me the law!" Your arguments are simply not worth my "sacred time" to read.

What lie did I tell? What advice did I give? I have had case law shoved in my face alright but it doesn't say what you are trying to say it says. 26 USC 206 doesn't support your claim, 26 USC 7201 doesn't support your claim. So what law is it you are referring to?

My argument aren't worth your time becuse you don't know how to intelligently respond to them. All you can say is you are a liar. So more specifically, where did I lie and Show me the law.
 
Don't you just love selective quoting? The case you cite here quite effectively makes my point. You see, it says that wages are not equivalent to income as income includes not only wages, but other sources of income as well.

Here is the case: http://caselaw.lp.findlaw.com/scripts/getcase.pl?court=us&vol=435&invol=21

The case is actually about the treatment of lunch allowances. But here is a quote for you:



Seems clear to me - wages are income, but not all income is wages. Wages are even defined as "remuneration for services".

So, I ask again, exactly how are wages not compensation for services?

I believe I posted about 10 or so cases, you defeated one of them, I'll give you that, but what about the others I posted. Isn't that selective quoting also?
 
What lie did I tell? What advice did I give? I have had case law shoved in my face alright but it doesn't say what you are trying to say it says.

Did you miss the immediately previous quote? From Central Illinois[/i (footnotes omitted):

The income tax is imposed on taxable income. Generally, this is gross income minus allowable deductions. Section 61 (a) defines as gross income "all income from whatever source derived" including, under 61 (a) (1), "[c]ompensation for services." [...] Wages usually are income.

Game, set, match.

Or prove yourself a liar.
 
Doesn't matter. The 16th Amendment says that "The Congress shall have power to lay and collect taxes on incomes, from whatever source derived, without apportionment among the several States, and without regard to any census or enumeration."

So the statement that taxes must be apportioned or indirect is no longer true, when we're speaking of the income tax.

[FONT=Verdana, Times New Roman, Times, serif]1916: Stanton v. Baltic Mining, 240 U.S. 103. Declared that the 16th Amendment conferred no new powers of taxation to the U.S. government, but simply prevented income taxes from being taken out of the category of indirect (excise) taxes to which they inherently belonged.[/FONT]


[FONT=Verdana, Times New Roman, Times, serif]And again[/FONT]


[FONT=Verdana, Times New Roman, Times, serif]1918: Peck v. Lowe, 247 U.S. 165. Stated that the 16th Amendment does not extend the taxing power to new or excepted subjects, but removed the need to apportion direct taxes on income.

Read those for me, they are Supreme Court rulings saying the 16th amendment offers no new forms of taxation therefore apportioned and indirect are still the only forms of taxation allowed, unless of course the Supreme Court is null and void because the IRS says so.
[/FONT]
 
I believe I posted about 10 or so cases, you defeated one of them, I'll give you that, but what about the others I posted. Isn't that selective quoting also?
I think I see part of the problem - an inability to count. You posted 5 cases in your reply to me, the first four of which seem to be dealing with the 16th amendment rather than whether wages are income or whether wages can be considered "compensation for services".

So, not really selective quoting - more like irrelevant quoting.

Again, you haven't answered how wages are not compensation for services. If the employer is not giving you money in exchange for the labour services you provide, why are they giving it to you?
 
You are correct, but my associates in the Tax Honesty Movement are CPA's, tax lawyers, and former IRS agents.

Tax Honesty Movement is anything but. It's a bunch of conspiracy theory nonsense. Have fun, Scooby Doo.

All rhetoric, no law cited.

I suspect you wouldn't know a statute if it bit you on the ass. I did cite law. That's what the United States Code is. As for the law that requires you to report your wages as income on your tax return, I suspect you know damn well where it is. It's the one cited numerous times here that defines "income," and the numerous other sections of what is informally referred to as the tax code. Yes, I'm well aware that the statutory definition of "income" in the US is circular. It always has been. Deal with it.

Maybe you don't get it, if the IRS is right then there should be a law that says wages are taxable. How do you convict someone from breaking a non-law?

What you don't get is that I'm not about to engage in a dishonest strawman "debate" with a conspiracy theorist. I've heard the sophomoric, unsophisticated arguments before. I've actually tried a four-day complicated tax fraud case before the U.S. Tax Court. I spent two years on it. My client was a "tax protestor" and subscribed to the same stupid arguments you are making. He gave me quite an education and insight into your brand of nonsense. No, thank you.

Have fun.

AS
 
1916: Stanton v. Baltic Mining, 240 U.S. 103....

And again

1918: Peck v. Lowe, 247 U.S. 165....
WOR,

You aren't trying to pass off someone else's words as your own, now, are you?

I'm guessing you copy/pasted that text from somewhere and just forgot to put it in a QUOTE box and just forgot the proper attribution. Am I correct on that?

By the way, have you taken over for oahuoahu? Just wondering how that reading of the US Constitution is going.
 
Reading tax protester arguments reminds me of when I discovered masturbation.

I was very young, and utterly convinced that I was the first person in all of existence to have discovered something so incredible. The fact that I was a few thousand years late off that mark, and that practically the entirety of humanity had already been there, done that, and gotten the proverbial t-shirt (or hand towel?) never occurred to me. I was the first of the Enlightened, and no one could POSSIBLY have come up with this idea before.

But this breaks down at a point, like all analogies. Masturbation, unlike a tax protester argument, is actually useful for something.
 
Wouldn't the Government close this loophole if it existed? Simply add the words 'wages and salaries received for labor' or something to that effect. They strike and add clauses to the tax code every year, why wouldn't they fix that, if they thought it was a problem.
 
WOR, you got my basic explanation to the simpleton, you got the appropriate law cited to you chapter and verse by genuine certified US legal folks, you go the case law showing it applied consistently and constantly by the same folks...

GAME OVER, I'd say.
 
I trade 800 dollars of labor for 800 dollars.

800 - 800 = 0

No you don't. Your labour (or services) is measured in time. (or maybe kilowatt hours if you want to get geeky about it.)

1 hour of your time (labouring to perfoming a service) is worth $x to your employer.

Your argument makes about as much sense as saying "I used 200 volts of energy on the exercycle today, so i've lost 30 joules of weight..."

I kind of get what you're trying to say though - I just thought of an analogy: If I buy a pack of marshmellows for $1.95 and then sell it to someone for $1.95 do I have to pay income tax? I haven't made any profit...

You're still wrong tho.

Actually - Do I? It's income, but i haven't made any profit, I'm selling at cost...

ETA: Actually not a great analogy - your time isn't worth the exact amount you get paid. Figure, the cost of food you need to eat to perform the work, and overheads - power, rent/mortgage, gas (car etc). so you actually have (at least) a little left over to invest, save, recreate (movies and weekend activities etc.). So even by your really lame logic, you are making a profit. You might be spending it all, but you earn more than you need to do the work.
 
Last edited:
Where in these chapters does it define income as wages or labor? These are just about deductions from people who are required to pay income tax, these are not laws stating you have to pay income tax. Where are these chapters and sections?
So, you didn't bother to read them?

U.S.C. Title 26 §63 defines taxable income as gross income minus certain deductions.

U.S.C. Title 26 §1 imposes a tax on taxable income.

You have been shown the law. If you are too frightened to read it or too stupid to understand it, that is your problem.

---

You will notice that the definition of taxable income depends on gross income rather than net income.

So even if you are dumb enough to count doing $1000 dollars worth of work as the loss of $1000 of money, your gross income is the amount of money you got paid for doing the work.

Of course in the real world the value of your work isn't substracted in a calculation of your net income, because accountants usually aren't ******* insane. But even if it was, taxable income is calculated from gross income.
 
It boggles my mind that we are on page 6 and we have people repeating stuff I already answered on page 2. I've already cited the laws in question. I've already cited the court cases that disagree with this ridiculous interpretation numerous times.

At some point you are just staring at reality and lying to yourself about what you see. I can't help that.

There is very obviously a law that imposes a tax on "taxable income". Wages, as has been repeatedly, exhaustively, specifically, and conclusively stated by the courts.. fall into that catagory.

[I]United States v. Connor[/I] said:
Every court which has ever considered the issue has unequivocally rejected the argument that wages are not income.
 
Last edited:
admittedly, I could only get through 1/3 of page three but, if I may, I suggest that we ALL just discourage such tripe as that in the original post by just asking to let us know how his/her theory turns out when put into practice...see the last paragraph.

Reading the opening post brought be back 5 years, near the transition from newsgroups to internet forums, when woo-style libertarianism was still the rage (I actually bought into some of it...but not for long) and tax protesters were actually winning arguments that the 16th amendment was not even legal or in force...and that the IRS was not even a part of the government!

Just let these go and focus and those that actually deserve/need rebuke: tax protesters no longer do -- it's too-too old news.

Encourage him/her to do what they think best. They won't go to jail, (especially a 19 y/o) but the fines will serve as a great lesson your responses (because they will NOT be really read) will not have.

That's all...

Rob the Lister out.
 
Last edited:


Well the argument is good enough for some jurys. Consider:
U.S. District Court, Western District of Tennessee (Memphis) # 03-CR-20111, USA v. Kuglin.


The jury didn't decide Kuglin doesn't have to pay taxes. All the jury decided was that Kuglin is not guilty of the criminal offense of "willful failure" to pay taxes. Needless to say, she still (a) had to pay her taxes, and (b) with interest and penalties, to boot:

A little more than a year later, she entered into a settlement with the IRS in Tax Court in which she agreed to pay a total of $296,302.00 in tax for the years 1996 through 2001, $221,265.73 in fraudulent failure to file penalties under section 6651(f) for those years, and $14,350.21 in estimated tax penalties under section 6654 for those years, for a total of $531,917.94 plus interest.

http://www.quatloos.com/Tax-Forums/...t=kuglin&sid=3d4baf30b6c73bc27fa99110e9396014

In other words, the jury didn't decide she didn't have to pay taxes (and, for that matter, this question was never for them to decide). All the jury decided was that, in this particular case, she really, honestly didn't believe she had to pay taxes, and thus is not guilty of the criminal offense of "willful failure" to file.
 
26 USC 206 doesn't support your claim, 26 USC 7201 doesn't support your claim.

Yes it does. But, of course, you will simply dismiss every and any laws you are shown as "not relevant" or "not supporting" what you don't want to believe is the case.
 
Skeptic said:
Yes it does. But, of course, you will simply dismiss every and any laws you are shown as "not relevant" or "not supporting" what you don't want to believe is the case.
I considered posting a second reply to Without Rights, but came to the same conclusion.

In addition to the many well written posts above, I would like to highlight Dr Adequate's at #214 for his point about gross vs. net income which tax "protesters" often misunderstand or willfully ignore.

Dr Adequate said:
You will notice that the definition of taxable income depends on gross income rather than net income.

So even if you are dumb enough to count doing $1000 dollars worth of work as the loss of $1000 of money, your gross income is the amount of money you got paid for doing the work.

Of course in the real world the value of your work isn't substracted in a calculation of your net income, because accountants usually aren't ******* insane. But even if it was, taxable income is calculated from gross income.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom