[Ed.]What requires that I pay the income tax?

But it also lists a whole bunch of things that are included in gross income, including "compensation for services" (which I have been harping on) which wages are a part of.

The problem with reliance on the list in IRC §61 is that if an item listed there is not income as defined by the courts, its presence in section 61 does not make it income.
 
It's time to come clean and tell Without Rights and oahuoahu the truth.

You guys are correct. There's is no law requiring you to pay your taxes.

All the real posters on the board have been taken to a secret prison and replaced with IRS agents and sympathizers. We're here to shore up the conspiracy to over tax every American. The money collected from income tax goes to our secret bank accounts in the the Bahama's.

So here's the deal. You two guys don't have to pay any more. If you are questioned by anyone from the federal government, tell them you're covered by Secret Action #432. Unless they're very new to their job they'll know what that means and leave you alone.

If you happen to be questioned by some new guy and get arrested, just tell the judge that "you know where he lives" and he'll take care of you.
 
The problem with reliance on the list in IRC §61 is that if an item listed there is not income as defined by the courts, its presence in section 61 does not make it income.
On what do you base this? Unless legal interpretation is flipped completely on its head in the US, it's presence in the list in 61 certainly does make it income whether or not a court has said it is so. The court's job is to interpret the statute - if the statute says, for example, that dividends are income, then the court cannot say that dividends are not income.
 
It's time to come clean and tell Without Rights and oahuoahu the truth.

You guys are correct. There's is no law requiring you to pay your taxes.
I no longer believe that. I now know that I am required to pay the income tax even on salaries and wages.

I thought before this thread that all laws were to be interpreted as they were written and if definitions of terms were not written they could not be used within context of law, but anti-sophist explained to me how the constitution gives the Judicial branch (the courts basically) the power to determine the meaning of written law and the meaning of terms when dealing with written law and their determinations can be used without them being written into law. Period end of discussion. So if the courts say salaries and wages are income, then salaries and wages are income.

Sure, there are some cases i've found where jury decisions are thrown out because they were biased. But there are also many jury decisions that go against the law and are not thrown out. If your jury decision is thrown out, then you just end up getting a new jury and the process repeats itself. Or maybe you end up going to the supreme court where a bunch of judges (justices) that are basically just another form of a jury decide your fate.

Regardless my point is that the courts have the power to determine what written law means, even if its the opposite of what is written down in the law it doesn't matter because the constitution gives the judicial branch that kind of power, and then a Jury which represents the general will of public society is above the law and decides your fate and determines if the law is good for society or bad for society and the jury determines if you are guilty or not guilty then sometimes the jury determined if you get punished or dont get punished. The jury trial concept formed through habeas corpus and the magna carta gave rise to the ideology that the general will of public society should have the power to be the ultimate deciders and sculptors of civil law within society, by having the power to set people free if they felt like it, and the founding fathers had that idea of jury trials and the magna carta and habeas corpus within them while writing the constitution.

The courts have determined that labor has a value of (I think) 5150 dollars per year because that amount of a persons income is not taxed per year. So all money you make after that is taxed. Because the courts have determined this, all those laws requiring you to pay an income tax on your corporate activity now require you to pay an income tax on your wages and salaries, and if you dont do it and the government finds out and decides to prosecute you the jury then decides your fate.

Posted this explanation for the without rights dude who says he doesn't have to pay the income tax.
 
... then a Jury which represents the general will of public society is above the law and decides your fate and determines if the law is good for society or bad for society ...

So you have gone from being confused about the income tax to being confused about the role of the jury. I guess that's progress.

The courts have determined that labor has a value of (I think) 5150 dollars per year because that amount of a persons income is not taxed per year.

Could you cite the case or cases in which the courts have communicated that determination? Since the value of labor is irrelevant in computing income, except occasionally barter income, I doubt the courts have ever made that determination.
 
I no longer believe that. I now know that I am required to pay the income tax even on salaries and wages.

I thought before this thread that all laws were to be interpreted as they were written and if definitions of terms were not written they could not be used within context of law, but anti-sophist explained to me how the constitution gives the Judicial branch (the courts basically) the power to determine the meaning of written law and the meaning of terms when dealing with written law and their determinations can be used without them being written into law. Period end of discussion. So if the courts say salaries and wages are income, then salaries and wages are income.

Sure, there are some cases i've found where jury decisions are thrown out because they were biased. But there are also many jury decisions that go against the law and are not thrown out. If your jury decision is thrown out, then you just end up getting a new jury and the process repeats itself. Or maybe you end up going to the supreme court where a bunch of judges (justices) that are basically just another form of a jury decide your fate.

Regardless my point is that the courts have the power to determine what written law means, even if its the opposite of what is written down in the law it doesn't matter because the constitution gives the judicial branch that kind of power, and then a Jury which represents the general will of public society is above the law and decides your fate and determines if the law is good for society or bad for society and the jury determines if you are guilty or not guilty then sometimes the jury determined if you get punished or dont get punished. The jury trial concept formed through habeas corpus and the magna carta gave rise to the ideology that the general will of public society should have the power to be the ultimate deciders and sculptors of civil law within society, by having the power to set people free if they felt like it, and the founding fathers had that idea of jury trials and the magna carta and habeas corpus within them while writing the constitution.

The courts have determined that labor has a value of (I think) 5150 dollars per year because that amount of a persons income is not taxed per year. So all money you make after that is taxed. Because the courts have determined this, all those laws requiring you to pay an income tax on your corporate activity now require you to pay an income tax on your wages and salaries, and if you dont do it and the government finds out and decides to prosecute you the jury then decides your fate.

Posted this explanation for the without rights dude who says he doesn't have to pay the income tax.

Pity that nearly every word of it is incorrect (but at least you admit now that your wages are taxable). You appear to be very confused about the binding effect of statutory law, about what role judge-made law plays, and about the functions of judges and juries in general. You are also confused about the distinctions between criminal and civil cases, and about a lot more too.

AS
 
I think I see part of the problem - an inability to count. You posted 5 cases in your reply to me, the first four of which seem to be dealing with the 16th amendment rather than whether wages are income or whether wages can be considered "compensation for services".

You are not the only one I posted to. The 16th amendment is the amendment that the IRS says allows them to tax wages so of course they deal with 16th amendment, what part of the Constitution would you like to talk about, freedom of press maybe? How stupid of you.

So, not really selective quoting - more like irrelevant quoting.

The 16th amendment is irrelevant to taxes, hahahahoho. What a moron.

Again, you haven't answered how wages are not compensation for services. If the employer is not giving you money in exchange for the labour services you provide, why are they giving it to you?

So employees provide services to thier employer. Whos ass did you pull that out of. I have never ever heard in my entire life. Services are provided by companies to customers who then compensate the company. The employee offers labor, not services. If I dig a hole for my employer it is not a service, it is labor. There is a distinction even if you don't think so.
 
Pity that nearly every word of it is incorrect (but at least you admit now that your wages are taxable). You appear to be very confused about the binding effect of statutory law, about what role judge-made law plays, and about the functions of judges and juries in general. You are also confused about the distinctions between criminal and civil cases, and about a lot more too.

AS
I'm inclined to cut him some slack. What first appeared to be another rabid woo has turned out to be a sentient, thinking human...and one that is willing and able to say, "Hey, I was wrong before."

He may not ready for the Bar exam, but few of us are.
 
The dictionary definition of "gross income" is not the meaning of "gross income" as that phrase is defined in the IRC. "Gross income" is specifically defined as "all income from whatever source derived" unless otherwise provided in Subtitle A. As I noted before, Congress, when debating the 1913 tax act, discussed defining the word "income" in the act. They decided not to define income because any definition would be too broad or too narrow. They did include various examples of income sources as a starting point, but left the definition of income to the courts.

Gross income as defined in the Random House Unabridged Dictionary, which is the source for dictionary.com's definition is not really relevant to this discussion at all.



Income, as defined by the courts, is revenue minus the costs of goods sold (and maybe the direct costs of providing a service*). Laborers have few, if any, direct costs of providing labor, so for wages, there is seldom any difference between revenue and income.



* A series of cases in the 1940's involving the deductability of direct costs in excess of wartime wage caps left the question unresolved.

Gross income is not the issue, taxable income is the issue. Apportioned or indirect is constitutional a a unapportioned direct tax is unconstitutional no matter what the IRC says. IRS doesn't write laws, they are supposed to follw them.
 
I know you have, and I am well aware of that. Nevertheless, the term "wages" is not used in Section 61's definition. It's in a large body of case law. That omission, deliberate as it was and is, is what has allowed tax protestors to claim with a delusional sincerity (in some cases sincere, anyway) that wages are not income. Sure, courts have consistently held that at least in civil tax cases that argument simply cannot be made in good faith. It doesn't stop tax protestor nuts from claiming it.

Also, please note that in a previous post (not the one you responded to), I mention that Section 61 enumerates several types of income, and that "compensation for services" is the very first one.

AS

It is left out deliberately because it does not follow the Constitutional provisions of taxation. That being apportioned or indirect.
 
I'm inclined to cut him some slack. What first appeared to be another rabid woo has turned out to be a sentient, thinking human...and one that is willing and able to say, "Hey, I was wrong before."

I am too, of course, prepared to offer him some slack, but he seemed to take it upon himself to try to educate the other dude and spouted off a lot of nonsense about the law. Getting it a little wrong is OK by me, but missing it by a country mile and passing it off as educating someone else is not.

He may not ready for the Bar exam, but few of us are.

True, and I didn't mean to come off as a snob about it. For that, I apologize.

AS
 
It is left out deliberately because it does not follow the Constitutional provisions of taxation. That being apportioned or indirect.

Wrong again. Please stop reading or listening to tax protestor arguments. They will not aid you in understanding tax law or theory. The deliberate omission has nothing to do with the applicable constitutional provisions, especially not the apportioned or indirect part. That part refers to apportionment among the various states due to their differences in respective populations, and it means that the federal government cannot treat taxpayers in different states differently depending on the size of the state. The federal income tax is uniform across the states. It has nothing to do with defining "income" in the sense which we have been discussing it.

AS
 
Originally Posted by Quixote
The problem with reliance on the list in IRC §61 is that if an item listed there is not income as defined by the courts, its presence in section 61 does not make it income.

On what do you base this? Unless legal interpretation is flipped completely on its head in the US, it's presence in the list in 61 certainly does make it income whether or not a court has said it is so. The court's job is to interpret the statute - if the statute says, for example, that dividends are income, then the court cannot say that dividends are not income.

The court also interprets the Constitution. The 16th Amendment removed the apportionment requirement from direct taxes on income. If Congress attempts to tax something that is not income as that word is used in the 16th Amendment, the exclusion does not apply. If the tax in question were a direct tax, it would have to be apportioned among the states based on the latest census figures, a political and administrative nightmare. (The case law which seem to say that there is no such thing as a direct income tax is not a model of clarity.)
 
The whole thing may be void. Maybe it was never legally ratified.

HOW SOME STATES DID NOT LEGALLY
RATIFY THE 16TH AMENDMENT

Ha ha. That link goes to a page of the website of "We the People," a tax protestor organization. Read about their "projects."

These nuts will never give up, and they continue to offer the same stupid, bogus arguments over and over. The alleged "illegality" of the Sixteenth Amendment is one of their favorties. They continue to lose, lose, lose in the courts.

AS
 
Gross income is not the issue, taxable income is the issue.

No, gross income was the issue being discussed in that post. I would have thought that was obvious. Gross income may not be of interest to you, but the world does not revolve around you.

Apportioned or indirect is constitutional a a unapportioned direct tax is unconstitutional no matter what the IRC says.

The IRC is silent on the subject, so I guess there's no problem.

IRS doesn't write laws,

I'm glad you've got that straight. I assume that you will no longer refer to the imaginary "IRS code".

they are supposed to follw them.

These words are added to satisfy the character counting thingy.
 
The employee offers labor, not services. If I dig a hole for my employer it is not a service, it is labor. There is a distinction even if you don't think so.

So if a customer hires you to spend an hour digging a hole and pays you $20 to dig it, you're providing a service (and apparently digging the hole without doing any labor). But if you boss pays you $20 an hour, and sends you out to dig the same hole for $20, you're not providing a service and now it takes labor to dig the hole.

So what's the distinction?
 
The whole thing may be void. Maybe it was never legally ratified.

HOW SOME STATES DID NOT LEGALLY
RATIFY THE 16TH AMENDMENT

From that article:

In Kentucky, the legislature acted on the amendment without even having received it from the governor (the governor of each state was to transmit the proposed amendment to the state legislature). The version of the amendment that the Kentucky legislature made up and acted upon omitted the words "on income" from the text, so they weren't even voting on an income tax! When they straightened that out (with the help of the governor), the Kentucky senate rejected the amendment. Yet Philander Knox counted Kentucky as approving it!

Assume for the sake of argument that everything in that paragraph is true. Put yourself in the shoes of a Kentucky legislator. Wouldn't it irritate you a tad that Knox had misrepresented the legilature's decision? Wouldn't you mention it to, oh say, the newspapers, or in a speech on the floor of the Kentucky House? And wouldn't your like minded colleagues, who make up the majority of the Kentucky House, do the same?

So why were Kentuckians so silent? Oh, I know. It's because Benson is an idiot or a liar and Kentucky actually ratified the amendment, just as Knox reported.
 
This only validates his point. Labor belongs to the person doing the labor, if he wants to waste it digging a hole for nothing that is his desision. If he wants to sell his labor to survive this is not income, it is one commodity being traded for another.

And if you spend 8 hrs digging a hole for no reason you did lose money, you could be digging a hole for someone who needs a hole dug instead of digging for no reason.

That is NOT a loss. It is not a gain. I should have known better than to respond.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom